Open Source Tomato Magic

Started by William Schlegel, 2026-10-17, 06:49:22 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

William Schlegel

So I was Googling about what it might take for us independent tomato breeders to reach parity with South American domestic and currant tomatoes. Google returns AI answers now. Got an interesting suggestion. Use the Multi-Parent Advanced Generation Inter-Cross or MAGIC breeding system to develop a highly diverse tomato population. Here is a example:

https://www.mdpi.com/2073-4395/9/3/119

In my quick read of the suggestion you would essentially intercross about eight diverse accessions. This is done to study traits. Though in the example it became a basis for a participatory plant breeding effort.

Last year one of my crosses was between a wild accession and an indigenous south American accession. So to create an aggregate you would need about four distinct crosses like that. Eventually crossing them all together. Additionally I think it might be nice to include some OSSI and OSS parentage. I have a few crosses already made along those lines.

Technically it's difficult to cross currant to currant- that could be a hold up. Though I do think I have at least a few indigenous or potentially indigenous (never went to Europe and came back) lines. Maybe a few other lines that are already close to this level of crossing. Though perhaps too many of them have the same parents. Have to think about that a bit. Still I think I might have part of the necessary work done for building this type of gene pool. Though I'm also uncertain how different it would be from the gene pool I'm currently building. In this you concentrate at least eight accessions into a single gene pool. In my current breeding I have many more lines but each of them has a smaller subset of the overall genetics. I think the key differences are that wiyh MAGIC you would have equal amounts of each accession and lots of diversity retained in each cross by using pollen from lots of pollen parents. I'd like to do things but it might not be practicable for me to change course at this point in my project.

Still Theoretically with eight accessions you could grow eight rows, collect lots of pollen from lots of individuals, make the crosses multiple times, then repeat over several years until its all in one germplasm accession maintained with large population size.

I wonder how that might differ strategically and at the genetic level from just physically combining seed from many different lines and growing that as a grex?

In my current scheme I might have say 75 lines but growing in one garden. Which would mean a certain level of natural outcrossing would also happen each generation.

One big advantage of the MAGIC system is that it combats what I've been thinking of as the dilution effect. I was recently contemplating a failed cross that would have combined some 10 crosses and several different projects but all at different levels. One conclusion was that it really belonged primarily to the most recent cross so was a Brown Rugose Fruit Virus project potential primarily. However using the MAGIC scheme that same accession would preserve the potential for all three projects and keep all the accessions germplasm and potentially traits in the population.

Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Steph S

This concept with the catchy acronym is similar to approach pioneered by Tom Wagner, that is of using crosses between unstable lines to maximize the diversity captured in their F1.
TBH, for me, the best tip of all from breeders who commented at Tomatoville back in the day.

Is there anything mathematically or genetically special about the 8 parent formula for MAGIC?  Just wondering if it is a real advance or just a gimmick.

Joseph Lofthouse

#2
I sorta do MAGIC-like plant breeding, primarily with natural bee-assisted cross-pollination instead of manual crosses. I bring together genetics from multiple wild and domesticated tomato species, then encourage them to cross freely and adapt to local growing conditions. Rather than developing uniform inbred lines, I favor genetically diverse populations that continue evolving through promiscuous pollination.

This shows the genealogy of the 4 new varieties I send to Experimental Farm Network this fall.

tomato-magic.jpg


Kadence Luneman

This sounds like composit breeding with livestock. Polypay are an American breed that was started with 4 breeds crossing and the idea that you keep the first crosses that each breed is evenly represented and select for all the good qualities that each initial breed was selected for. I imagine there's nothing special about starting with 8 parents except that more wide genetic start is a wider net cast?

William Schlegel

#4
The researchers were conducting some genetic studies and then the use of the populations in breeding was perhaps secondary. I don't know why they did eight founding populations. Might have been funding limits on the genetic testing somewhat unrelated to the population. I suppose that practicality and population size do limit the number of accessions.

My problem is I actually have 75 or so populations that meet my 50% wild and or indigenous standard. They represent about a dozen wild and indigenous accessions. That could mean that I might need to pick just a dozen starting crosses so that the germplasm is evenly represented.

I do think Joseph has been doing something like this- and so have I given the prevalence of common genetics for increased crossing rates in our two gardens.

Joseph- your development of self incompatible lines of the promiscuous project could be a tool that could allow us to combine many populations into one in a relatively short amount of time without hand crossing. Though another tool might simply be the flower architecture that goes with. A third might be easy seedling marker traits like potato leaf and rugose dwarf vs regular leaf.

For instance if we wanted to combine my #339 12.5% wild descendent of your promisuous project with your SI promiscuous strain it might be enough to plant them together in two parallel rows. Then in year two three parallel rows with the third row being the rl seedlings. In the third year potato leaf seedlings would be segregating out of the rl seedlings. Eventually the two populations would be a completely merged mixed breeding system population. You could then plant its potato leaf or regular leaf descendants next to most any tomato accession and expect natural hybridization you could track. Then if you managed those hybridization efforts in an even way you should in theory be able to equalize the populations genetics with a broad genetic base like in MAGIC.

I don't think I want to adopt this MAGIC plan but I do really like how the resulting unselected germplasm population has an even distribution of all the founding populations genetics. That's something to aspire to.

One method I could employ is that I have three crosses with 339 and more with 303 that should segregate back to potato leaf next year. If potato leaf lines were interspersed evenly with regular leaf lines I think the resulting regular leaf off spring from potato leaves might be a really good basis for founding a relatively even subset from a dozen lines or from 75 lines since no hand crosses are required. If you repeated the experiment over a few years it might have a pretty good chance of collapsing even 75 lines into one. You could also supplement that with some hand crosses. Another factor is bumblebees and this year was a beepocalypse for them but other years have been great for them.

2% outcrossing it might take 250 years for 75 lines to mix, at 5% that would be less than half. With super tight spacing and high bumblebee activity you might get something like 20% (according to Google AI), and of course with self Incompatibility the SI plants would approach 100% though that would vary in a mixed population. My populations almost universally have some exserted stigma ancestry so I'm probably not at 2%

Though even 250 years isn't really that long in the mostly unwritten history of tomato breeding. Though the AI thought we could get it down to a few by intervening.

Another thought with the 75 lines is to physically mix them before creating between group crossing blocks depending on which germplasm ancestor or even trait group is represented. To get down to maybe just four or so breeding purposes. Like late blight, brown rugose virus, arthropod resistance, exserted stigma, general diversity, and combinations of the above that have already been made. Like 303 is 50% exserted stigma 25% late blight and 25% brown rugose fruit breeding intent.

I have F2 seed for I think 14 crosses with LA 0410 the exserted stigma South American domestic I got a few years back. Just within those 14 most all of the subprojects are likely represented.

I'll post more thoughts on combining populations in my Montana tomato thread since I think I am getting a bit far from the MAGIC system here.

Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days