Dark green shoulders and Uniform ripening genes

Started by Roland, 2021-08-29, 03:08:53 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Justin Jardinier

#15
Quote from: Roland on 2021-08-29, 03:08:53 PMGalahad F1 have very light green shoulders. It is heterozygous for the u gene (uniform ripening).
In the F2 I get some different phenotypes:
Very dark green shoulders

Light green shoulders

Uniform ripening.

Did you notice any specific taste difference in the uniform ripening ones compared to the others? I have seen people saying the uniform ripening trait is responsible for inferior taste. I'm curious about this especially since I have made some cheesmaniae crosses, and cheesmaniae has uniform ripening - it seems maybe that's the source of that train in the commercial tomatoes? So I am wondering if I must select against that trait in the F2.

Quote from: Andrew Barney on 2023-03-18, 11:32:01 PMThe green shoulders gene has been shown to help accumulate more sugars in the fruit from the extra chlorophyl and of the tomaotoes I have grown I have noticed those with green shoulders to taste superior. Standard supermarket tomatoes have the U uniform ripening gene which is the opposite of the green shoulders gene.

This is interesting since cheesmaniae is said to increase sweetness in crossing with lycopersicum I think, isn't it? Could it be that cheesmaniae has other genes for sugar accumulation that balance out the negative effect of merely adopting the uniform ripening gene in isolation, but commercial breeders have left out those that might balance it?

Justin Jardinier

Oh sorry Roland, now I see you have actually answered that on another thread!
Quote from: Roland on 2023-03-19, 02:01:28 PMMy 50 F2 and 80 F3 Galahad population with both green shoulders and uniform ripening shows that there is no difference in brix due to this U gene.

Roland

My Galahad F3-31-16 (2022) selection is a pink uniform ripening beef with brix 8.0. The highest of them all.
These fruits with brix 8 were super tasty.
Strangely enough, I also found fruits with Brix 5 on the same plant (these tasted less).
Because the plant ripens so late, I did not continue with this selection.
Netherlands

Justin Jardinier

#18
Quote from: Roland on 2023-12-28, 11:16:10 AMMy Galahad F3-31-16 (2022) selection is a pink uniform ripening beef with brix 8.0. The highest of them all.
These fruits with brix 8 were super tasty.
Strangely enough, I also found fruits with Brix 5 on the same plant (these tasted less).
Because the plant ripens so late, I did not continue with this selection.

I just wrote a comment in the Trying to get dark greens tomatoes thread, which may relate to this. I wonder if they ripened late due to having less chlorophyl in the fruits.

Adrian

#19
On the selection between tiny tim x green giant a lot of fruit are long to get mature but the taste is wonderful with a dark green shoulder.

I have noted on my f1 between (canestrino di lucca x andine cornue)x roman candle that the fruits was take a very progressive coloration.
1st stape:green with green shoulder to yellow with green shoulder
2nd stape:gold with yellow shoulders
3rd stape red with gold shoulders.
I think that we can pick up the fruit at differents maturity stapes.


Roland

In the publications I know they compare tasteless commercial varieties that possess the u-gene (uniform ripening) with tasty heirloom varieties that have the dominant U-gene (green shoulders).
It does not surprise me that these studies show that the u-gene appears to be related to lower brix and less flavor than the green shoulder U-gene.

A good study would be to cross 2 tasty varieties, one of which has uniform ripening u-gene and the other has green shoulders U-gene. A large F2 population will then reveal whether there is a correlation between the u gene and brix or taste?
Netherlands