Watermelon (Citrullus lanatus) x Muskmelon (Cucumis melo) Hybrid cross?

Started by Professor Porcupine, 2024-08-04, 12:05:06 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Professor Porcupine

This by all means should be impossible right?
I was reading Ivan Michurins book "Selected works" and on Page 166 came across "HYBRIDS BETWEEN MUSKMELONS, PUMPKINS
AND WATERMELONS"

https://archive.org/details/michurin-selected-works-flph-1950/page/166/mode/2up

This section kind of scared me in a good exciting way, as I was sure they couldn't cross due to being different genera (Even Cucumbers & Muskmelons can't cross despite being same genus due to different subgenera) but reading this kind of made me question that kind of thinking. 8)

Can someone explain what's going on here (From page 166) "This year a muskmelon fertilized by the pollen of a watermelon bore a fruit two sections of which had a shiny hard rind of a dark green colour, whereas the rest of it was yellow; the flavour of the pulp, unfortunately, was not altered in the least, while the seeds, although uniform in all parts of the fruit, were smaller than those of any other variety of muskmelon."

I have no idea what going on with this cross (Or what was done with it), there isn't much info on it. Is it even possible?  :o

If it is, this both scares & excites me because I'm too curious about how the fruit structure would look. Can we finally get a red fleshed muskmelon? A green Flesh watermelon that's sweet like Honeydew? Both Watermelon (Citrullus lanatus) & Muskmelon (Cucumis melo) are in the Benicaseae Tribe (Melon), along with Wintermelon (Benicasa hispida).
All being in the same tribe, does this mean I can somehow cross them too? Can I make Wintermelon sweet with Muskmelon genes?


From all the research I've read about Russian Plant Breeder Ivan Michurin, I've learned his methods on how to overcome hybridization barriers, combining methods increases chances. (which do you think he used to make watermelon x muskmelon cross?, I think he probably used multiple).

1) Mentor pollination (Mixing pollens)
Gather Pollen from same species & from as many diverse different species/genera as you can get, mix them all together & apply it to the flowers. This forces plants to accept foreign pollen along with it's own species pollen so it doesn't abort the entire fruit.

Example : Cucurbita pepo pollen mixed with Cucurbita maxima pollen applied to a Cucurbita maxima female flower. I tried this & fruit actually formed but sadly deer or someone cut it off as it was maturing (Cuz I'm Ninja gardening on land I don't own, in the suburbs).


2) Mentor Grafting (Grafting Hybird Scion onto the variety you want it to resemble)
Take a scion from a Young Hybrid Seedling (The more wide it's hybrid origin, the more plastid the young hybrid seedling is) & graft it onto the mature plant you want it to resemble. Save seeds from scion fruit. Goal is to get sap flow moving across the graft into the highly plastid hybrid scion, because through the sapflow happens Horizontal Gene Flow.

Example : 1 Year old Hybrid Pear Scion, Grafted onto a 1 year old Lemon Seedling (YES! COMPLETLY DIFFERENT FAMILY) made scion pear leaves Evergreen & Glossy. The other Hybrid pear seedlings next to it discarded their leaves but not the pear scion grafted onto lemon.

Another Example : Jerusaleum Artichoke (Helianthus tuberosus) Scion, Grafted onto Sunflower (Helianthus annuus) stock, made the scion develop aerial tubers while the stock developed secondary wood.

Another Example : Morning Glory Scion, grafted onto Sweet Potato Stock developed tuberous roots much earlier.

3) Combing Mentor Pollination with Mentor Grafting & making Reciprocal Graft Crosses.
Basic Idea is making scions trade each other stock & Vice versa (So they can get used to each others roots), then making the cross with pollen mixing.


Using these methods Ivan Michurin was able to make So many EPIC CROSSES, especially just look at his pome fruit (Tribe malinae) crosses like × Sorbaronia mitschurinii (Sorbus x Aronia) for example.

If this is all possible, why wouldn't Watermelon (Citrullus lanatus) x Muskmelon (Cucumis melo) be possible if all these methods are employed?
Lets domesticate the Wild Edibles!

Weston Adams

This is totally fascinating. I would love to conduct more work along these lines... but

Personally, I have to ask myself what the point of the cross is. Melons are good. Watermelons are good. I'm not exactly sure what would be benefited from combining the two, but perhaps there is something I'm missing.

It seems that often the most popular breeding successes are those that take a well-known crop and introduce a new trait. For example, when Black-skinned tomatoes were released they were very popular because it introduced a new twist on an already-popular fruit.

It seems that if breeders generate something entirely new -- something that people are not familiar with -- that they have to spend a lot of time "selling" their new product. Cause nobody knows what it is and it seems "weird."


Joseph Lofthouse

Watermelon are too long season for my garden, and require too much heat. But I can grow muskmelons. This project fascinates me for the possibility of getting a shorter season watermelon.

I don't expect to work on projects like this, cause they're for young people with lots of strength and enthusiasm.

Professor Porcupine

@Weston Adams I get your point but I want to make a Red Flesh Musk melon using Red Flesh Watermelons. There is however an edible Cucumis maderaspatanus that has Red Flesh, it's actually a berry! Perhaps it's the better candidate for red color than Watermelon?




Reguardless, Bottle Gourds lagenaria siceraria are actually most closely related to Citrullus lanatus within the Benenicasae tribe, so that cross would be more likely to work than Cucumis melo x Citrullus lanatus.


@Joseph Lofthouse Why can't Harvesting slightly immature watermelons For seeds make the next generation mature earlier just like how you had to with your 1st gen Squash & Melons when frost arrived? This is my plan when I get land to grow them on, will this method fail?

Have you also tried grafting watermelons on to your fastest maturing squash? I'm curious about the results in a short season climate.

Quote from: Joseph Lofthouse on 2024-08-22, 10:29:06 AMI don't expect to work on projects like this, cause they're for young people with lots of strength and enthusiasm.

Is this why you started GoingToSeed? To carry the mission further? I'm young (23 years old) & with no land. All I can do i is Forage for wild edibles, Obtain seeds from Grocery Store & Learn!
Lets domesticate the Wild Edibles!

Nicolas


Joseph Lofthouse

Seeds become viable-enough long before the fruits ripen. By selecting for plants that produce early, viable-enough seeds, we move the whole population towards earliness. With my squash and melons, 75% of varieties failed to produce any seed at all, so by the third generation, the whole population had moved strongly towards earliness.

I don't do grafting. Those techniques were not understood when I started my seed breeding career decades ago, and now I have lost ambition and strength. Some of the young farmers associated with Going to Seed, and the Open Source Plant Breeding forum have already far exceeded what I was able to accomplish.


Professor Porcupine

@Nicolas Awesome! I've seen the same chart & Indeed they look close on it. However Cucumis melo x Cucumis metuliferus is possible, despite being "further" away on that chart. It works better with a more wild Cucumis melo.

Here's the study of the Successful cross : https://www.researchgate.net/publication/288264403_Characteristics_of_progeny_from_an_interspecific_cross_of_Cucumis_melo_with_C_metuliferus

That being said, Cucumbers are actually closer phylogenically to Cucumis melo but don't cross. It has been tried many times without success, but the more phylogenically distant Kiwano (Cucumis metuliferus) has worked. I think it will be possible to Cross Cucumis melo x Cucumis maderaspatanus. I wonder how that would work out? C. maderaspatanus is a soft skin berry & C. melo has a harder skin, does that mean we get Soft Squishy Berry Melon?  or just red fleshed Muskmelon? Also the seeds of C. maderaspatanus look quite different from C. melo, tho I don't think that makes it impossible.

@Joseph Lofthouse That's awesome! I'm gonna do that with all of my crops even if frost doesn't arrive early. When I harvest Slightly Immature fruit, Is it better (For Early Maturing Selection) to let them ripen off the vine indoors or to harvest seeds immediately?

Lets domesticate the Wild Edibles!