Blight Resistance in Potatoes and Tomatoes

Started by William Schlegel, 2018-11-04, 09:45:44 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

nathanp

Quote from: Garrett Schantz on 2020-12-07, 06:05:12 PM
Some of the unknown resistances on the heirlooms could be one of the known resistant traits, but tests probably haven't been done to confirm them.


The specific heirloom varieties mentioned in the paper I linked to above, tested without Ph2 and Ph3.  Pruden's Purple and Wapsipinicon Peach both had resistance roughly equal to the best of the LB varieties, but neither one has those resistance genes.  That was tested for.
Quote
Still a possibility that some of these just have different ways to resist late blight.

It seems so.  So there is something else going on in them that provides roughly equal resistance.

atilgan

#91
There are also Mountaineer Delight and Mountaineer Pride by West Virginia University. Both OP. Which genes involved are not mentioned.

Roland

Mountaineer Delight and Mountaineer Pride are both homozygous for ph2 because they come from the West Virginia 63 x Iron Lady cross. Unfortunately, they probably didn't inherit Iron Lady's ph3 gene.
Netherlands

ThomatoGarden

Hello, i am Thomas i'm new here
i'm from Germany/Münsterland near the Netherlands zone 7a with much rain.

i grow Tomatoes forever but was allways annoied by Late Blight, so i did a trial last year.
Late Blight was really bad this year :-(, but a good test :-)

for me the best Varities in 2021 were (Rating 0-10, 10 best)
- Primabella                Rating: 9
- Mountain Magic F1    Rating: 9
- Rondobella               Rating: 8
- Sunviva                   Rating: 7
- Vivagrande              Rating: 6
- Mountain Merrit F1   Rating: 5

Tomato Varities tested:
- Mr. Stripey               Rating: 4 
- Prudens Purple         Rating: 3 
- Mountain Magic F1    Rating: 9
- Mountain Merrit F1    Rating: 5
- Legend                    Rating: 1
- Sunviva                   Rating: 7
- Vivagrande              Rating: 7
- Philovita F1             Rating: 2
- Dorenia                   Rating: 2
- Gelbe Johannisbeere  Rating: 3   (yellow currant)
- Rote Murmel            Rating: 3
- Rote Zora                Rating: 4
- Cerise Red               Rating: 1  ?
- Primabella               Rating: 9 
- Matina                    Rating: 1 (but early so some yield)
- Fantasio F1             Rating: 0
- Rondobella              Rating: 8

? maybe some Varities were not original seeds, bought them online. So there is allways a piece of doubt.

this year i want to test:

- Matt's Wild Cherry
- Lemon Drop
- Wapsipinicon Peach
- Resi Gold
- Trip-L-Crop
- Rutgers
- Verna Orange
- Mr. Stripey (new Source)
- Prudens Purple (new Source)
- Mountain Merrit F1
- Resibella


Ar there any other Tomatoes i should test?


(Videos on Youtube: Thomato Garden)


nathanp

If you are interested in testing a few others, these four that are not known for having LB resistance did well in a research paper trial.  It is unknown what the source of the resistance might be.

Ailsa Craig
Amai
Bella Rosa
Matina

https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=&ved=2ahUKEwjh96--vrDtAhVfFVkFHRUmBzUQFjAFegQIBxAC&url=https%3A%2F%2Fresearch.bangor.ac.uk%2Fportal%2Ffiles%2F20580359%2Fnull&usg=AOvVaw1Z33V1p5OPTTn63oQLYgHI

ThomatoGarden

Hi, thanks for your proposals

Matina was in my 2021 test, it has early yield before LB hits , but otherwise not good.
i will look for the other ones.

Greetings Thomas

ThomatoGarden

Ok

now as i remember this :-)
i will plant Matina in my early grow test

Thanks :-)

Tim DH

Hi Thomas,
   That's an impressive list of cultivars you trialed.

   You might want to add some of the 'Crimson' series, which appear to have come out of the Bangor breeding programme referenced on this thread, and the tomato one.

   This year I'm going to try 'Crimson Cherry'.

   Apart from that I'd   REALLY   like to try Purple Zebra, but Territorial Seeds have suspended international shipping and AP Whaley don't respond to emails or web enquiries on the matter. .... Does anyone know of another supplier????

Tim DH

ThomatoGarden

Hi, Tim

Ok , but i could only find Crimson Crush here in Germany.

Added it to my list.

Thanks

Mikkel ImGrimm

The culinaris varieties, e.g. Rondobella, have not done so well for me. Mountain Magic did.

Tim DH

Hi Thomas,
There are four Crimsons available in England.

Crimson Crush is the most widely available. (One catalogue lists it as resistant to Blight Pink 6 and Blight Blue 13, whatever that means!)
Crimson Blush (A Beefsteak)
Crimson Plum
Crimson Cherry

(Confusingly, there are a few other varieties with Crimson in their name which are not part of the series.)

Tim DH

ThomatoGarden

Hello, i got Crimson Crush F1
couldn't get the other's UK vendors seem not to send to Germany any more.

Blight Resistance Outdoor Test 2022:

- Crimson Crush F1
- Matt's Wild Cherry
- Lemon Drop
- Wapsipinicon Peach
- Resi Gold
- Trip-L-Crop
- Rutgers
- Verna Orange
- Mr. Stripey (new Source)
- Prudens Purple (new Source)
- Mountain Magic F2
- Primabella
- Resibella
- Vivaroma
- Buffalosun F1
- Rondobella     
- Vivagrande     
- Mountain Merrit F2

I think thats ebough for this year :)

(not including varities for the Glasshouse!)

Hello, ImGrimmer what Area are you from ? Was Blight that bad ?

Mikkel ImGrimm

#102
I am near Hamburg.
last year the infection was very strong, almost all varieties that were resistant in recent years have failed.
Among them all culinarissorten and the Crimson Crush.
Only my own landrace and BH seedlings from Joseph Lofthouse were resistant.
In previous years, the culinaris were fairly tolerant of LB, but Mountain Magic was always the healthiest.
MM F2 and F3 seedlings are not all resistant, but many are and if you select enough you will find them.

ThomatoGarden

Wow,

LB was really bad here near Münster, but not that level. H... S... .

I hope you selected some good ones at this super hard test year.

Greetings

(Maybe sometimes i can get some samples :) .)


William Schlegel

#104
ImGrimmer when you say BH from Joseph Lofthouse I assume not the original Big Hill HX-9 but rather the more variable descendents of wild crosses such as BH x W4? Or? Also how does your strain taste if is the more variable descendents? Do you plant your own landrace in easy bee pollination range of the BH material and have you been able to detect any crosses yet? Do you have bees in the genus Bombus there that buzz pollinate? Are your tomato flowers on both your land race and the BH material mechanically suited to cross pollination now?

In my own garden where blight has not occurred since I've been breeding tomatoes the more tomato like post BH x W4 wild crosses from Joseph were still such a novelty in 2020 I don't think I was very selective. Then in 2021 I got picky about the flower mechanics and the flavor. Both good flavor and good mechanics with open pollen pollen cones and exserted stigma seemed rare.

Back when we were on the Alan Bishop proboards homegrown goodness forum some time ago. There was a fellow in the upper Midwest who wrote of bad blight problems and his own tomato landrace/grex. He shared photos of some stigmas that were very exserted that he claimed had been developed rather naturally over time in the population. Then there was a bit of a falling out and he left the group and deleted his posts because it seemed he did not believe in climate change which made him a bit of a pariah and seemed inconsistent but it is a very strong subculture here.  Nonetheless it was sort of an interesting story he told. My own tomato populations have gotten better flower mechanics over time but I have heavily reselected for the trait which in my case came originally from the varieties Big Hill HX-9 and Blue Ambrosia as well as probably now the wild species Solanum habrochaites and Solanum penellii through Joseph's promiscuous project including Andrews penellii admixture to it.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days