Blight Resistance in Potatoes and Tomatoes

Started by William Schlegel, 2018-11-04, 09:45:44 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

nathanp

I just found two interesting papers, neither one of the said much about Lizzano, but they have a lot on Ph2 and Ph3 and particularly, other tomatoes.  It does confirm Lizzano has Ph2, but not any further details that I could see, though I did not read it very carefully. This first one is a gold mine of information, including that the Skykomish they tested is heterozygous for Ph2 and lacks Ph3.  But it was listed amount the most resistant tomatoes in the 2011 trial, so maybe there is something else involved, similarly to Matt's Wild Cherry, which lacks Ph2 and may not have Ph3. Also, two others of Tom Wagner's tomatoes did similarly.  Make My Day, and Grungy in the Sky.

From Tom Wagner's tatermater website:
"Grungy in the Sky:
Grungy, (Val) sent me some interesting varieties to use in breeding work. SRID6 was one of those I used quite a bit. I selected a small yellow fruited selection of this number to cross to my Skykomish. I called the hybrid Grungy in the Sky"

https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=&ved=2ahUKEwjh96--vrDtAhVfFVkFHRUmBzUQFjAFegQIBxAC&url=https%3A%2F%2Fresearch.bangor.ac.uk%2Fportal%2Ffiles%2F20580359%2Fnull&usg=AOvVaw1Z33V1p5OPTTn63oQLYgHIaaa

https://apsjournals.apsnet.org/doi/10.1094/PDIS-03-14-0263-RE?url_ver=Z39.88-2003&rfr_id=ori:rid:crossref.org&rfr_dat=cr_pub%20%200pubmed

nathanp

Oh, and there are four other named tomatoes listed that are detailed as homozygous for both Ph2 and Ph3. 
8)

Roland

This is really interesting. This weekend i will study the paper.

It seems Skykomish is heterozygous for ph2.
Netherlands

nathanp

Quote from: Roland on 2020-12-03, 03:38:08 PM


It seems Skykomish is heterozygous for ph2.

Yes, but it was still among the most resistant tomatoes, equivalent to, or greater, than if it was homozygous for ph3, which this paper says it does not have.  So there is something else that is not yet quantified, that provides similar resistance.  And Make My Day and Grungy In The Sky also appear to be similar, so they may all contain the same "whatever that is" that it has.

Roland

I guess the less resistant tomato breeds are indeterminate. The homozygous Ph3 determinate (bush) breeds produces less in the tests. Probably because the leaves can dry fast enough.

In Netherlands the resistance of Skykomish is weak.

Its also strange a Heirloom variety can be heterozygous for Ph2!
Netherlands

Dominic J

yea, I've read that Lizzano was homozygous, so I ordered some last year (or rather earlier this year, maybe). I was a bit appalled by the prices, but couldn't find any local supplier. In any case, I now have lots of seeds from my Lizzanos. They also grew well, the fruits were tasty. Might have been partly caused by insufficient light, but mine were not as dwarf as advertized.

William Schlegel

Roland Skykomish isn't heirloom it hasn't been fifty years since Tom Wagner bred it.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Garrett Schantz

The unknown resistant gene sounds like it could be interesting. Suppose you if crossed wild tomatoes just for resistance you might end up with something unknown/undocumented in terms of resistant genes.

William Schlegel

That's a possibility with wild cross breeding.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

nathanp

#84
To quote this from the 2nd paper: 

QuoteThe heirloom varieties Matt's Wild Cherry, Lemon Drop, and Mr. Stripey were all resistant to late blight in this study, and it would be interesting to identify the mechanisms underlying this resistance.

Regardless of the mechanism, the fact that several heirloom tomatoes (or varieties not known for LB resistance) did show up on the list of most resistant to LB probably means those are ones that could be worked with in future breeding.  This additional paper below also mentions Pruden's Purple and Wapsipinicon Peach as having LB resistance, despite not being known for that.

http://vegetablemdonline.ppath.cornell.edu/NewsArticles/Tomato_LB_Resistance_2014_PDMR%209%20V032-McGrath.pdf

From that paper:
QuoteJTO 1175, an experimental cultivar from Johnny's Selected Seeds, exhibited the least defoliation on 29 Sep, but this was
only significantly different from Pruden's Purple and Wapsipinicon Peach. Late blight symptoms were also not found in the non-replicated plantings
(single plots) of four varieties developed by Tom Wagner: Clackamas Blueberry, Fahrenheit Blues, Blue Pitts, and Stripe of Yore.

So four more of Tom's tomatoes with LB resistance are mentioned in the this paper, even if the mechanism is not known.

Also, just to clarify from the first paper, the four other tomatoes that were homozygous for both Ph2 and Ph3 are these, and none of these appear to be be marketed by seed sellers with LB resistance in mind.  I found sources of seed for all of these just with a quick online search:

Ailsa Craig
Amai
Bella Rosa
Matina

Chance

Could some of the mystery resistance might be polygenic?  I grew some of Joseph's Promiscuous tomatoes this year this year, super wet year with blight.  They got a touch of blight on the older leaves but it didn't effect their vigor at all.  I got to thinking about the idea of horizontal or polygenic resistance being greater in wild tomatoes if nothing except for the fact that they are much more genetically diverse.  It would seem like in promiscuous tomatoes you could naturally maintain a greater diversity and therefore polygenic resistance, even if it isn't all contained in one in any given individual.  Of course there are likely also more R genes in any given wild vs domestic.  I had a cherry seedling in the garden that didn't show any blight lesions.

Roland

Netherlands

Garrett Schantz

Some of the unknown resistances on the heirlooms could be one of the known resistant traits, but tests probably haven't been done to confirm them.
Assuming some tomato varieties just happened to already have resistant genes when new late blight strains appeared.

Still a possibility that some of these just have different ways to resist late blight.

atilgan

#88
I tried both defient and galahad. Galahad is also lb tolerant. Defient is sour tasting but galahad is very good.

Roland

I will grow 1 Galahad F1 and 20 F2 in 2021. Hope i can select a good F2 for seeds.
Netherlands