Open Source Plant Breeding Forum

General Category => Nightshades => Plant Breeding => Tomatoes => Topic started by: Justin Jardinier on 2024-03-18, 07:12:09 AM

Title: South American Heirlooms
Post by: Justin Jardinier on 2024-03-18, 07:12:09 AM
Quote from: William Schlegel on 2024-03-17, 09:42:46 PMhttps://academic.oup.com/aob/article/100/5/1085/136832 (https://academic.oup.com/aob/article/100/5/1085/136832) This article says the same thing but it cites five papers including the one above that extend to 2000.

Just going through this paper.
QuoteTwo hypotheses have been advanced for the original place of tomato domestication, one Peruvian and the other Mexican. Although definite proof for the time and place of domestication is lacking, Mexico is presumed to be the most probable region of domestication, with Peru as the centre of diversity for wild relatives (Larry and Joanne, 2007). Solanum lycopersicum cerasiforme is thought to be the ancestor of cultivated tomato, based on its wide presence in Central America and the presence of a shorten style length in the flower (Cox, 2000). However, recent genetic investigations have shown that the plants known as 'cerasiforme' are a mixture of wild and cultivated tomatoes rather than being 'ancestral' to the cultivated tomatoes (Nesbitt and Tanksley, 2002).

To me now, it looks pretty conclusive that cerasiforme (going by the modern concept of that classification given in the recent papers I reference below) is actually the original cultivated tomato, domesticated in or around Ecuador, and that it was either domesticated directly from pimpinellifolium, or possibly from some populations that folks might argue were in between what are now considered pimpinellifolium, and cerasiforme. And that since the devastation of colonialism, many cerasiforme have crossed back with pimpinellifolium in the wild, but some populations remain distinct (for example populations found in Sucúa, Ecuador).

It also seems to me that pre-Columbian South American agriculture was not as black and white with regard to the 'wild' vs 'human' realms as they have been in European and Asian agriculture (I gave some references to that in the 'currant tomato' thread from 'The Dawn of Everything' - https://opensourceplantbreeding.org/forum/index.php/topic,933.msg15411.html#msg15411 ), the lines between the two being more blurred (and possibly thereby far more sustainable and less destructive environmentally), and that that difference has helped modern academics hold on to the original (perhaps misinformed) assumption that tomatoes were domesticated in Mexico (where European tomatoes were originally sourced from and therefore the tomatoes that look most like the tomatoes Europeans are used to, which I suggest has led to this bias), leading to the in my opinion peculiar argument that the tomatoes bred and cultivated in pre-Columbian South America are either 'pre-domesticated' - a strange concept in my opinion, and I have doubts as to whether this idea would ever be subscribed to had the belief that they had first been domesticated in Mexico not been already established before all of this recent work on genetics and closer examination of South American populations, and greater understanding of the history of pre-Columbian South American civilisations; or, as this paper seems to be saying, a mere 'mixture' (disproven by more recent work).

Here are some papers to support what I just claimed. In them you may still see the tendency to conceptualise the South American cerasiforme as 'pre-domesticated' but in my personal opinion so far, I see this interpretation as likely due to the momentum of prior academic opinion rather than objective analysis of the evidence these papers cover. I may be wrong, but I'd suggest looking at the data and holding that particular interpretive conclusion on pause before deciding:
- Genomic Evidence for Complex Domestication History of the Cultivated Tomato in Latin America - Hamid Razifard - 2020
- Exploiting the diversity of tomato- The development of phenotypically and genetically detailed germplasm collection - Estefanía Mata-Nicolás et al. - 2020
- Mining QTL for fruit weight quality traits in uncharacterized tomato germplasm - Alexis Ramos - Thesis - 2015
- Unraveling the genetics of tomato fruit weight during crop domestication and diversification  Lara Pereira et al. 2021
- Variation Revealed by SNP Genotyping and Morphology Provides Insight into the Origin of the Tomato  -Jose Blanca et al.- 2012
- Genomic variation in tomato, from wild ancestors to contemporary breeding accessions - José Blanca et al. - 2015
- Genomic inference of complex domestication histories in three Solanaceae species - Stéphanie Arnoux et al. - 2020

Regarding what the paper https://academic.oup.com/aob/article/100/5/1085/136832 (which you just shared William) says about tomato domestication syndrome, so far as I understand we see the increased seed size in cerasiforme already, and increased fruit size. Also it states:
QuoteAn obvious feature of tomato domestication is the massive increase in fruit size. Wild tomato species have tiny fruits made to propagate the species and not to feed human beings. Domestication has transformed the once small wild tomato into the present-day cultivars.
[...]
By crossing a wild and a cultivated tomato, mutations in about six QTLs seem to have been responsible for transforming the small berries of wild tomatoes to the extremely large fruit now associated with modern cultivars (Fig. 1, reviewed in Tanksley, 2004). One of these QTLs is fruit weight 2·2 (fw2·2) that changes fruit weight by up to 30%. It is believed that mutation(s) in the fw2·2 locus was the first step on the road to domestication and responsible for a key transition during tomato domestication (Alpert et al., 1995; Frary et al., 2000).

Now here's an extract from Mining QTL for fruit weight quality traits in uncharacterized tomato germplasm - Alexis Ramos - Thesis - 2015:
QuoteWe found new sources of variation in fruit size quality traits that were not explained by the major fruit weight genes FW2.2 (CNR), FW3.2 (KLUH), FW11.3 (CSR), LC (WUSCHEL), and FAS (CLV3), providing evidence supporting that genes were either left behind during domestication, or made it to modern germplasm but have not be cloned yet. Our study also supports a two-step domestication process in tomato, but phenotypically we found some discrepancies not reported previously. Also, we show that most fruit area measurements are the best predictors of fruit weight. Furthermore, we found that the increase in fruit weight from Solanum pimpinellifolium (SP) to Solanum lycopersicum var. cerasiforme (SLL) was accompanied by an increase in percentage water content, and a disproportional increase in columella to fruit area ratio, suggesting that the central part of the fruits enlarged more than the remainder of the fruit during domestication.

Firstly they seem to have accidentally written 'SLL' when meaning 'SLC' in that last part I put in bold. Anyway, if we ignore for a moment their subscription to the 'two step' idea of 'pre-domestication' then 'domestication', and just look at the data, then going by the idea of domestication syndrome, we can see the fruit size increase from SP to SLC. This may also bring into question fw2·2 being the first step, and again that might be a bias due to focus on studying Mexican tomatoes and their derivatives rather than early South American tomatoes. Furthermore, we have this:
QuoteWhen accessions were classified based on the allele combinations of CNR, SlKLUH, CSR, LC, and FAS, the observed phenotypic variation suggested the presence of additional loci controlling weight in tomato (Supplementary Table S2.3, Supplementary figures S2.17-S2.24). Within the groups that carried the same allele for all five genes, large weight and weight related trait differences were observed. For example, 58 accessions that carried the wild allele at all five loci carried fruit of up to 14.95 g.

That's pretty interesting. SP having fruits of 1g weight, we have here 15g fruits which would clearly fit the 'domestication syndrome' idea, yet having none of the identified domestic fruit size genes of European tomatoes, derived as they are from Mexican tomatoes. The 3 cerasiforme populations with largest size (13.3g, 14.7g, and 15g) in that study that have none of those 5 previously identified domestic fruit size alleles, all come from Tena, Ecuador, and the largest cerasiforme lacking fw2·2 (18.7g) is from Cuzco, Peru. There's also an SLL from Guatemala lacking fw2·2 weighing 55.1g. Also the one from Tena weighing 14.7g comes in at 21g in the paper Unraveling the genetics of tomato fruit weight during crop domestication and diversification - Lara Pereira et al. 2021

From the abstract of that latter paper:
QuoteKey Message Six novel fruit weight QTLs were identified in tomato using multiple bi-parental populations developed from ancestral accessions. Beneficial alleles at these loci arose in semi-domesticated subpopulations and were likely left behind. This study paves the way to introgress these alleles into breeding programs.
[...]
A subset of populations was targeted for QTL-seq, leading to the identification of six uncloned fruit weight QTLs. Three QTLs, located on chromosomes 1, 2 and 3, were subsequently validated by progeny testing. By exploring the segregation of the known fruit weight genes and the identified QTLs, we estimated that most beneficial alleles in the newly identified loci arose in semi-domesticated subpopulations from South America and were not likely transmitted to fully domesticated landraces. Therefore, these alleles could be incorporated into breeding programs using the germplasm and genetic resources identified in this study.

I share this since it's potentially useful in the context of breeding for diversity as this topic is about. But also to show what to me seems the clear discrepancy between the data showing 'domestication syndrome' in or around Ecuador (increase in seed size and at least a 21-fold increase in fruit size, amongst other things); and the remaining subscription to the old idea that tomatoes were domesticated in Mexico. I wonder that the old idea might have weight in many people's minds simply because even 21g seems small relative to European tomatoes, so if they take the tomatoes they are familiar with as definitive, then that bias might lead them to think the 21g tomatoes are merely 'pre-domesticated' or 'semi-domesticated' because they are not similar enough to the crops they are accustomed to. However, using that principle, someone used to the 1kg (2lb) fruits in contemporary Europe or the US etc., might similarly look at Mexican SLL (lycopersicum var. lycopersicum) and, seeing how much smaller they are, consider them 'pre-domesticated'. Hence such an approach seems, to me at this moment at least, irrational. Both would seem to ignore the already explicit subscription to the concept of 'domestication syndrome', as well as their actual use as cultivated crops in well established pre-colonial agricultural societies.

The most recent genetic analysis that I am aware of, Genomic inference of complex domestication histories in three Solanaceae species - Stéphanie Arnoux et al. - 2020, indicates that 2 bottlenecks occurred in the ancestors of our modern tomatoes, 9,900–19,040 years ago (which if I am understanding the paper correctly is representing splitting from pimpinellifolium) and then another bottleneck 4,410–8,480 years ago (which seems to be the movement of domesticated cerasiforme from South America to Mesoamerica). The article https://www.science.org/content/article/were-humans-living-mexican-cave-during-last-ice-age on the basis of archaeological evidence from Mexico, claims "people must have entered the Americas 32,000 years ago or more", which fits well with the hypothesis that humans domesticated tomatoes in South America within that initial range of 9,900–19,040. The former article further supports this, stating:
Quotethe first area cultivation records for maize in Peru ~ 6,600 ya (Grobman et al., 2012) and in Mexico ~ 7,300 ya (Pohl et al., 2007).

I think it is safe to assume that the earliest records post-date the first occurrence, and the initial shift, particularly considering the nature of ancient South American agriculture, would have been gradual. Also just to note, they state:
QuoteThe tomato domestication centre is located in Peru (Blanca et al., 2012), even though it was imported into Mexico, further increasing the bottleneck effect due to cultivation.
[...]
Further sampling in Peru would be needed to evaluate if the geographic origin of the first domestication event occurred in Peru or in Mexico.

I find it plausible that if they widened their analysis to include enough cerasiforme accessions, they might find Ecuador to be the centre of domestication rather than Peru.

Also note that this estimate for the time of the split contradicts earlier estimates, and here's a quote from the paper on that:
QuoteSurprisingly, our estimate of split time (9,900–19,040 ya) is largely in disagreement with the ∂a∂i estimate of ~ 78,000 ya in Razifard et al. (2020), which resemble more to a speciation event, as it predates the human presence in South America.

The former estimate of 78,000 years ago would make it seem cerasiforme is a wild species, so this more recent analysis really does back up the hypothesis of cerasiforme being domesticated by South Americans directly from pimpinellifolium.