Moving this conversation out of the thread on intergeneric hybrids.
Andrew Barnum wrote:
"For me, I think I am more interested in crops that can survive multiple early spring frosts more than end-of-season frosts. The two may not be the same in that a plant that survives one may not necessarily survive the other type."
I agree that the genetics to survive one may be different from the other.
Early spring frosts, if predicted, can be dealt with by covering the small plants. It's easy to cover plants that aren't much more than seedlings.
End-of-season fall frosts, on the other hand, occur when the plants (especially if indeterminate) are quite large. While I have managed to cover them and survive fall frosts, it's more difficult.
Of course, if the plant survives a fall frost but drops all of its fruit and flowers in the process, that's not very useful.
Probably the most beneficial adaption would be the ability to survive a fall frost under a light to medium row cover and retain most of its partially-ripe fruit in the process.
Regardless, I am interested in any and all tomato genotypes that have any kind of frost resistance. They are all potential inputs to breeding the ideal tomato for zones 4 and lower.
End-of-season frosts which we in the south are right on the edge of atm are made worse if one mulches around plants, even weed cover will enhance frost damage. I like to have bare soil around my frost tender plant in autumn.
Spring frost survival is of great interest to me, and so hard to quantify because there are so many variables. As Richard says, what's going on around a plant can have an effect.
We had a really cold Spring night on April 21st 2021. Two thirds of my greenhouse was planted up at the time. Some cultivars were be-headed by the experience, but they later put out new shoots lower down. Six weeks later a couple of cultivars were STILL putting up stunted leaves. The two least affected cultivars were Latah and Imur Prior Beta. These guys continued almost as if nothing had happened.
I have some other reputedly cold hardy cultivars, which missed this episode, but I'm hoping to not re-run the 2021 experience!
I'd be interested to read which cultivars others recommend. (From experience, rather than from seed merchants websites!!)
Tim DH
Yeah, it seems everyone has their own interpretation of this.
Currently I only have interest in early spring frost tolerance. I would rather plant early regardless of snow than harvest late in the year. I also don't want to cover them. I'd rather be lazy.
By the end of the season I don't really care if a plant dies and the fruit rots because by that point I'm probably sick of eating them anyway.
But, having said that, perhaps if I had tomatoes that could survive late/end-of- season, I might find a use for them.
Also, when I talk about tomatoes having frost tolerant I am referring to the PLANT and I'm not talking about the FRUIT. But it sounds like others in this thread are talking about the fruits surviving frost and not the plants. So moving forward we may need to be careful to really define what we are talking about.
Regardless, any tomato with any kind of frost tolerance would probably be useful to everyone. If we could get a tomato with all kinds of frost tolerance to some degree better than typical tomatoes then I think that would be something useful worldwide.
Imagine if we found tomatoes with early frost tolerance, other tomatoes with some late frost fruit tolerance, and still others that produced fruit fairly quickly.
Then cross them all to get one tomato that had all of these genes in the same plant.
You could transplant out 3 - 4 weeks before last frost, get fruit a month before other gardeners in the same area, and still be getting fruit through Indian Summer.
Personally, I don't get tired of tomatoes. When the garden stops producing fresh tomatoes, I start buying those bland cardboard ones in the grocery stores. :-)
This hypothetical variety could be very interesting for gardeners in cool climates, even if it didn't have spectacular taste.
https://www.nytimes.com/1977/05/14/archives/upstate-scientists-is-trying-to-breed-a-tomato-that-can-stand-the.html
I think this means I need to email someone from the New York State Agricultural Experiment Station. Looks like it is run by Cornell University. Maybe this is something Michael Mazourek can help with as he is an Associate Professor of Vegetable Breeding at Cornell University and on the OSSI board of directors.
now to find Michael Mazourek's email...
EDIT: found it digging through my emails. :)
Very interesting.
"pollen is damaged' by the cold, Dr. Robinson explained. "This is why the first flowers on the tomato plant usually don't develop. into tomatoes,"
There are some tomatoes that are parthenocarpic and don't require pollination for their first fruits. Legend, Siletz and Stupice are some that I have grown.
Maybe they would be good parents for tomatoes that survive light frost.
Siletz impressed me in 2017.
As usual, LA1777 has cold tolerance for seed germination, plant growth, and pollen germination.
Could be a good candidate, and cold tolerance selection can be easier as one can sow a lot of seeds and then let natural selection occurs early in the season.
QuoteA frost tolerant tomato.
A devastating greenhouse freeze led to one potentially valuable discovery. After 5 nights, or 40+ hours of subfreezing temperatures as low as -3.3 C a 2" seedling was found which showed no freezing injury. The survivor's pedigree is F4 (Moneymaker x Gemini x Adagio x Stupicke x Sonato x L. minutum). Later observations indicated this plant grew quite slowly, had 1 to 2 cm fruit, and leaves which wilted on sunny days. The wilting could be related to the frost tolerance, but studies need to be cone to discern why the wilting occurs and how this might relate to frost tolerance. Seed is available to those with interest.
https://tgc.ifas.ufl.edu/vol32/vol32html/main/vol32scott.htm
Wild Mountain Seeds in Colorado exposed hundreds of seedlings to freezing temperatures and are selling seeds from the survivors.
https://wildmountainseeds.com/product/heirloom-survivors-grex/
That's a very interesting idea, Diane. Even if the result is a mix of epigenetic tolerance mixed with genetic tolerance, it could be a good starting point for breeding.
It is Joseph's old methodology almost to a T. One of the things he was doing before the big addition of wild genetics. I think he said he might resume once the promiscuous project was at a certain point.
I did a little young seedling community flat frost torture and overwhelmingly the plants with the most foliage of other plants protecting them in the flat survived. I deemed it physics not genetics.
Yeah, survival of the lucky is bound to manifest in any but the most ultra controlled situations - which are way too controlled to simulate real conditions anyway.
Every frost is different too, when you think about unmeasurables.... microclimate data we really don't have, might explain the fine points of who survives or even which leaves get toasted.
From my own experience and limited space situation, I would say I can only see the broad strokes of cold tolerance genetics when comparing genetically distanced plants as a group over multiple seasons. Epigenetics does play a huge role too but you see side by side differences in different lines which have the same epigenetic treatment.
Quote from: Diane Whitehead on 2023-08-11, 10:31:52 AMWild Mountain Seeds in Colorado exposed hundreds of seedlings to freezing temperatures and are selling seeds from the survivors.
https://wildmountainseeds.com/product/heirloom-survivors-grex/
I see their site seems to be down. It was down when I checked months ago also. Though EFN have their 'Mountain Miracle XL Pink Hybrid Swarm Tomato':
https://store.experimentalfarmnetwork.org/products/mounain-miacle-xl-pink-hybrid-swarm-tomato?_pos=13&_sid=0e40e9a92&_ss=r
And their ''Mountain Spirit Bi-color' Hybrid Swarm Tomato':
https://store.experimentalfarmnetwork.org/products/mountain-spirit-bi-color-hybrid-swarm-tomato?_pos=3&_sid=0e40e9a92&_ss=r
I was a bit confused why it's called a 'hybrid swarm' since in all the photos I saw of it (on that site and some on facebook), they all looked the same to me.
But anyway, they then also have ''Oh My' Black Hybrid Swarm Tomato':
https://store.experimentalfarmnetwork.org/products/oh-my-black-hybrid-swarm-tomato?_pos=20&_sid=0e40e9a92&_ss=r
All of these mention frost tolerance. Has anyone grown any of them? I'd love to hear grow and taste reports. And do we have any idea if there's a difference in cold tolerance between them?
I'm growing 'Mountain Spirit Bi-color'. I have found it so far impossible to cross to, unfortunately. Though I've used its pollen to cross to others - none harvested so far but hopefully the crosses will work. Also I was growing it inside for much longer than usual before putting it outside, and all my tomatoes went out late due to circumstances, so I don't have a fair evaluation of it as it was already germinated way earlier than most of my other plants. But it is looking very productive.
I've repeatedly looked at their products on EFN and not purchased them. Their website works fine for me.
For me they seemed interesting as breeding partners for wild tomatoes, if they have the good traits wanted in lyc. Early, disease resistant, and big, sounds great to me for that :-)
I think there is a lot of value in making crosses and selecting from segregates. Trying and Trialing existing varieties can be an important step in even deciding if new work needs to be done (Which I learned from Carol Deppe's books), but methods of trying that erase existing variety names and rename them are annoying because then the same variety ends up with multiple names.
Last year, one of my old Skipper plants survived a fall frost that white coated and killed the upper leaves of squash and buckwheat in the beds next to it. The plant only had a couple of fruit on it, and not many leaves left. But it didn't drop the fruit and I later picked a fruit off it that ripened normally. Noting that fruit was hanging way higher than the squash leaves covered in hoar frost, I'd put it down to microclimate that the temperature around the fruit and leaves didn't drop below freezing. Soil temp was well above freezing.
The plant only lasted another week tops, in any case.
One thing I am wondering about is the tradeoff between cold tolerance and heat tolerance.
The past couple of summers have been brutal for hot and humid spells.
I think there is general 'temperature stress tolerance' in some tomatoes - Stupice comes to mind, as being able to pump out the fruit through wide temperature swings.
OTOH I see a definite difference between the two sibling lines Skipper and Rodney, where Skipper tends to be more impervious to cold but suffers in the heat, while Rodney definitely tolerates the higher temperatures better. So there may be genetics that boil down to, say specific temperatures where enzymes involved in the fruit setting process are optimal or just functional - one plant may have a narrower temperature range than another, or a slightly different range that falls lower or higher.
I like the idea of stacked types of freezing temperature tolerance. Whole plant resistance applies to early seedlings. PI120256 and Costuloto Genovese are two plants that performed well in a trial that I read. (sorry that reference isn't handy or I'd link it).
I really don't know of any work on fruit freezing tolerance, except that I've read that nearly ripe fruit are less vulnerable than the immature green.
One thing I've selected for is the ability to ripen off the vine without loss of quality. Since I'm growing for food supply, I wouldn't risk the fruit to a frost or leave it out when temperatures are not going to help it ripen. So cutting clusters of fruit and laying them out to ripen in a box is a fact of life for me. Not my favorite part, but there often is no alternative. IDK but I doubt there are genetics in the family that would cause fruit to ripen well when temperatures drop below a certain level.
Yeah, all that makes sense. I'm keeping everything labelled for now. Next year I don't expect to be growing much of anything I haven't crossed myself. I may grow some for reference. But my focus is on what I can contribute, rather than trying to find things that work well already. I just figured if I can find some that work the best already for these conditions, then I can try my best to use them to make things that are even better suited. Especially by crossing with wilds. So, I don't really have much interest in existing varieties aside from for crossing.
Quote from: William Schlegel on 2023-08-13, 08:54:18 AMTrying and Trialing existing varieties can be an important step in even deciding if new work needs to be done (Which I learned from Carol Deppe's books), but methods of trying that erase existing variety names and rename them are annoying because then the same variety ends up with multiple names.
Oh I was just pondering what you said here and it occurred to me, perhaps you are referring to Casey Piscura's method? I suppose it's possible that his various tomatoes could be heirlooms he has just renamed. I say this not implying he would have done that deliberately, but, on the basis of what you said about method. Like, from the description of ''Mountain Spirit Bi-color' Hybrid Swarm Tomato' page, in this part it would seem he was only working with crosses:
"Born by creating a hybrid swarm of popular heirlooms"
And from this part it would seem he never continued that until they were stable - 'hybrid vigour' quickly dissipates, no?:
"Wild Mountain Seeds in Carbondale, CO at 6400' have been using selection pressures such as frost, drought and late blight to find superior heirloom plants with hybrid vigor."
Plus calling it a 'hybrid swarm' would imply that it's nowhere near stable, it's come straight from thorough intermixing of a diverse population. But then, the only indications I have seen are that they're all the same.
So if it isn't really a hybrid swarm, then, maybe the population started as all crosses and he made an (at least mostly?) stable variety from it over numerous generations (or multiple ones like the 3 I linked to, all being sold as separate 'hybrid swarms'); or, maybe not even all the starting ones were hybrids? Like is that what you're warning against?
Though it would not surprise me if he maybe really did start with a hybrid swarm, and made these varieties from it, though I still find it strange that they are being sold as hybrid swarms. Unless there's something I'm missing! Though even to start with a hybrid swarm, all pollination would have to be done manually, and only those surely crossed fruits used for the next round of crossing, and no more heirlooms grown on for seed saving. I wonder if he did it like that or not....
Well anyway they look like great tomatoes! Pity I never hear about anyone growing them, maybe because of the $15 price tag.
Yeah I have some doubts about his methodologies from those and other descriptions on his website. Maybe they are unique work- but from his language I couldn't quite tell.
For example the website talks about:
"Lucid Gem of Colorado
$4.50 – $26.00
Our newest 2020 selection of this beautiful tomato originally bred by Brad Gates of Wild Boar Seeds in California. Our newest strain arose out of the 2018 frost trials and has gone through ongoing selection for fruit quality, yield, vigor and disease resistance."- Mountain Garden Seeds.
I wouldn't expect that a stable selection of Brad's would lend itself to much ongoing selection- except maybe for epigenetic change and variety maintenance.
Epigenetic change is great but it strikes me it would be better combined with a cross.
That slight doubt + that often $15 price tag causes me to not buy seeds. I'd rather say buy a F1 from one of the small but very dedicated to flavor breeding groups working with marker assisted selection like Frogsleap Farm and Mark McCasslin. Then make my own cross with that.