Open Source Plant Breeding Forum

General Category => Nightshades => Plant Breeding => Tomatoes => Topic started by: Nicolas on 2023-03-22, 12:23:19 AM

Title: Tomatoes with fruity flavors
Post by: Nicolas on 2023-03-22, 12:23:19 AM
I'm starting a thread about tomato with fruity flavors, as a lot of us are interested by this topic :

Title: Re: Tomatoes with fruity flavors
Post by: Nicolas on 2023-03-22, 12:27:24 AM
From TGC 65 :
(https://i.imgur.com/IPL6yO9.png)
QuoteThe above picture shows the F2 progeny of a cross between a large oxheart-type S.
lycopersicum, weighing about 300 gms (bottom left and right in the picture) and
Solanum galapagense, weighing about 1 gm, (top, middle). My original idea was to investigate the
high-solids characteristics of this species. However, it has become increasingly clear that this
species has many other interesting traits to investigate. Besides the high brix of many of
these individuals, up to 11 % (non-replicated), we noticed probable resistance to Powdery
Mildew (Leveillula taurica), Oidium powdery mildew, Cladosporium leaf mold, and tolerance
to greenhouse whiteflies. Based on the environmental conditions of the native habitat of
these accessions, we expect them to be tolerant to drought and salinity. The flavor is also
interesting, with many individuals having complex flavor with "fruity and floral" notes
(however, watch out for the tomatine).

Important in this discussion is that fact that S.galapagense crosses easily with cultivated
tomato, and segregation is normal.
Title: Re: Tomatoes with fruity flavors
Post by: William Schlegel on 2023-03-22, 04:34:05 AM
Here is an attempt to list some fruity tomatoes we have spoken about:

Wild Species that may be a source of fruity flavors:

Solanum cheesemaniae
Solanum galapagense
Solanum pennellii
Solanum habrochaites


Hybrids:

Sungold F1
    Dehybridizations: Ambrosia line from Lee Goodwin, Big Sungold Select from Brad Gates

Sunsugar F1

Segregating Populations:

Fruity Mix from Tim Peters
    Selection from that: Tim's Taste of Paradise

Lofthouse promiscuous tomato project
    S35, S36, S37
          The One

Open Pollinated:

Terrior Seeds Yellow Galapagos tomato

Sunviva- European Sister Org of OSSI

Santiam Sunrise- Adaptive Seeds OSSI

Dwarf Eagle Smiley - OSSI Dwarf Tomato Project

Title: Re: Tomatoes with fruity flavors
Post by: Steph S on 2023-03-22, 06:56:33 AM
Those galapagense crosses would be worth growing for the disease resistances alone. 

I was thinking about this the other day and wondering whether the fruity flavors typically found in yellows could also be expressed in pink or red tomatoes.
Complex fruity yellows, includes  Galinas Yellow, Medovaya Kaplya
But there are simple fruit notes in many tomatoes.
Zolotoy Zapas, iirc tangerine tt, has notes of canteloupe.
Anna Russian, pink heart, tastes like watermelon.
Oaxaca Jewel PL, bicolor, is peachy.

I'm a fan of fruity tastes in tomatoes! 
Title: Re: Tomatoes with fruity flavors
Post by: Cathy A on 2023-03-23, 05:55:32 PM
What exactly do we mean when we talk about fruity flavors in tomatoes?
Title: Re: Tomatoes with fruity flavors
Post by: Jeremy Weiss on 2023-03-23, 06:26:56 PM
I lost it due to holding the seed to long, but I had a white cherry tomato that tasted so much like a grape it really DIDN'T belong in a salad (only time I ever regretted adding vinegar). No idea what kind (it was just two cherries sitting on top of a punnet of mixed heirlooms I got at a gourmet market,) but I remember it was the most transparent tomato I had ever seen, so clear that not only could you see the veins in the fruit through the skin, but the seeds as well (for those that ask, I have tried "Transparent" and "Gummi Bear", those aren't it). 
Title: Re: Tomatoes with fruity flavors
Post by: Garrett Schantz on 2023-03-23, 08:11:56 PM
White Currant maybe?

Those things have a decent flavor.

Everglades tomato sized, can see vein things on them.
Title: Re: Tomatoes with fruity flavors
Post by: Joseph Lofthouse on 2023-03-23, 08:18:02 PM
Quote from: Cathy A on 2023-03-23, 05:55:32 PMWhat exactly do we mean when we talk about fruity flavors in tomatoes?

A group of chefs described the first taste testing of The Beautifully Promiscuous and Tasty Tomatoes project like this.

taste-testing.png
Title: Re: Tomatoes with fruity flavors
Post by: Joseph Lofthouse on 2023-03-23, 08:23:57 PM
As an anecdotal story, we were doing a taste testing at a farm in Idaho that grew several hundred plants from The Beautifully Promiscuous and Tasty Tomato Project. I was serving fruits to the local farmers, and they were keeping notes.

I also picked a regular domestic tomato, and included it among the many. After it was served, the host went to the kitchen, and got a rag, so that we could wash the cutting board, and not contaminate the rest of the taste testing. Bwah, ha, ha.



Title: Re: Tomatoes with fruity flavors
Post by: Jeremy Weiss on 2023-03-24, 12:33:06 AM
Quote from: Garrett Schantz on 2023-03-23, 08:11:56 PMWhite Currant maybe?

Those things have a decent flavor.

Everglades tomato sized, can see vein things on them.
No, they were too big to be those. At the time, I referred to them as "eyeball" tomatoes. 

Since a lot of those hyper-mixed supermarket supplies are from people who don't take particular care to keep their types discrete, it is entirely possible they belonged to no named variety. The people who buy those mixes generally just want "heirloom tomatoes", not any specific one. I've long since given up on identifying the specific types that show up in the ones I get from the Farmer's market stand now, or from the commercial mixes either, for that matter.   
Title: Re: Tomatoes with fruity flavors
Post by: Cathy A on 2023-03-24, 07:06:54 AM
Mango, honeydew/melon, lime, citrus - wow!

It would be very popular to have a mango-flavired, stabilized variety of tomato. We could grow it where we couldn't possibly grow mangoes.

Though I wonder if some of the desirable flavors require heterozygosity at one or more locations, and therefore could only be maintained in a landrace, never stabilized.

Given that repeated attempts have failed to stabilize the Sungold F1 while maintaining all its desired traits, I suspect it requires heterozygosity at multiple sites.
Title: Re: Tomatoes with fruity flavors
Post by: Garrett Schantz on 2023-03-24, 07:56:06 AM
White currants are about the width of a penny, smaller than cherry tomatoes. Anything smaller would be considered those "pea tomatoes".

I can keep looking. White Beauty also has fruity flavors.

Lot of the white ones do for whatever reason.
Title: Re: Tomatoes with fruity flavors
Post by: Vesa Tee on 2023-03-24, 09:15:18 AM
Quote from: Jeremy Weiss on 2023-03-23, 06:26:56 PMI lost it due to holding the seed to long, but I had a white cherry tomato that tasted so much like a grape it really DIDN'T belong in a salad (only time I ever regretted adding vinegar). No idea what kind (it was just two cherries sitting on top of a punnet of mixed heirlooms I got at a gourmet market,) but I remember it was the most transparent tomato I had ever seen, so clear that not only could you see the veins in the fruit through the skin, but the seeds as well (for those that ask, I have tried "Transparent" and "Gummi Bear", those aren't it). 

By the description, what comes to my mind is Dr. Carolyn (https://tatianastomatobase.com/wiki/Dr._Carolyn). Never tasted that myself but related Green Doctors (https://tatianastomatobase.com/wiki/Green_Doctors) and Green Doctors Frosted (https://tatianastomatobase.com/wiki/Green_Doctors_Frosted) are insanely sweet.
Title: Re: Tomatoes with fruity flavors
Post by: Steph S on 2023-03-24, 11:23:22 AM
Those taste descriptions are great, hahaha.   8)
Vocabulary of taste, well it's bound to use tastes we know to compare.. otherwise, where are the words?  I find myself really grasping to describe tastes of green vegetables.
Thank goodness that tomatoes can be compared to fruit!

Anything 'mango' or 'tropical fruit' is bound to be a favorite in my camp.
Title: Re: Tomatoes with fruity flavors
Post by: William Schlegel on 2023-03-24, 04:39:17 PM
I described the original "The One" plant as something akin to Fuyu persimmon. My wife said "that's a tomato?" However it took me growing a huge number of Joseph's wild crossed tomatoes to really experience an really exciting one. I still haven't tasted a cantaloupe one. Though I am not that excited about Cantaloupe.
Title: Re: Tomatoes with fruity flavors
Post by: AndrewB on 2023-03-24, 06:25:23 PM
It seems like there might be a correlation between fruity flavors and light colored tomatoes. White, yellow, orange, tangerine? Maybe just coincidence?

I wonder if crosses with these fruity flavored types with varieties with extra high sugar contents could create something closer to real fruit such as peaches, plums, or cherries. I would love to have a tomato someday that can pass as a cherry for flavor. But I'll settle for persimmon or melon if they taste good. 😀

I'll be trying some seeds from William for "the one". Hoping it lives up to the hype. William do you know if these flavors are true breeding or stabilized?
Title: Re: Tomatoes with fruity flavors
Post by: William Schlegel on 2023-03-24, 07:32:26 PM
Nope definitely not stable yet. 2022 generation varied from almost as good as the 2021 plant to pretty normal tomato.
Title: Re: Tomatoes with fruity flavors
Post by: Joseph Lofthouse on 2023-03-24, 11:27:44 PM
Quote from: Andrew Barney on 2023-03-24, 06:25:23 PMIt seems like there might be a correlation between fruity flavors and light colored tomatoes. White, yellow, orange, tangerine? Maybe just coincidence?

I dislike the bitter taste of red lycopene. Therefore, I select strongly against it my breeding projects for both tomatoes and watermelon.
Title: Re: Tomatoes with fruity flavors
Post by: Nicolas on 2023-03-25, 01:31:13 AM
Quote from: Andrew Barney on 2023-03-24, 06:25:23 PMI wonder if crosses with these fruity flavored types with varieties with extra high sugar contents could create something closer to real fruit such as peaches, plums, or cherries. I would love to have a tomato someday that can pass as a cherry for flavor. But I'll settle for persimmon or melon if they taste good. 😀

Maybe it is worth playing with genes that gives different types of sugar accumulation (sucrose, fructose ...)
Title: Re: Tomatoes with fruity flavors
Post by: Nicolas on 2023-03-25, 01:47:05 AM
taste labels for tomatoes

(https://opensourceplantbreeding.org/forum/index.php?action=dlattach;attach=1127;image)

Here we're aiming at the "Floral, woody, sweet, fruity, berry, tropical, beeswax" category
Title: Re: Tomatoes with fruity flavors
Post by: AndrewB on 2023-03-25, 11:29:59 AM
Quote from: Nicolas on 2023-03-25, 01:31:13 AMMaybe it is worth playing with genes that gives different types of sugar accumulation (sucrose, fructose ...)

Yes, I think so. I seem to remember that TGRC had some very interesting lines that had extra high levels of Sweet sugars. I think they came from the wild species S. chmielewskii. I remember requesting one at one point but didn't notice anything extra sweet or special. Maybe I should grow that line out to check again if I still have it. I tried growing seed for S. chmielewskii last year. Niticed in one batch of seed saved for Big Hill there are a few tiny wild sized seeds, which indicates crossing with something wild-ish.

LA4104   sucr from S. chmielewskii
LA4453   sucr from S. chmielewskii
LA4454   sucr from S. chmielewskii

https://tgrc.ucdavis.edu/miscellaneous
Title: Re: Tomatoes with fruity flavors
Post by: William Schlegel on 2023-03-25, 12:26:12 PM
Andrew you shared LA4454 with me I grew it in 2019. Still have seed for it. I wasn't that impressed, but it likely does have the sucrose gene.

Fairly common for folks to include genes like that in their varieties. Some tomatoes are very sweet. I feel like it would help the right flavor to pop but on its own it just makes for a one-dimensional sweet tomato. I thought it was Isis Candy that I noticed that about last year- sure is sweet I said and moved on. Could be a fun variable to play with.
Title: Re: Tomatoes with fruity flavors
Post by: AndrewB on 2023-03-25, 12:54:02 PM
Yeah, my thoughts exactly, on both your points.

I think once some lines are identified with really unique fruity or fruit-like flavors but perhaps aren't tasty enough they could be crossed with super sweet varieties that lack flavor.

The resulting progeny could be very interesting if they get the best of both.
Title: Re: Tomatoes with fruity flavors
Post by: Nicolas on 2023-05-22, 10:54:20 AM
Tropical sunset is said to have fruity flavor
Title: Re: Tomatoes with fruity flavors
Post by: Diane Whitehead on 2023-05-22, 11:02:52 AM
I did a search for the term "fruity" in my database of hundreds of tomato seeds I have.

I've included the name of the developer (if known) at the end of the description.

Fruity Orange   strongly sweet, slightly different flavours at different stages   Tim Peters               
Fruity Mix - red            Tim Peters                  
Fruity Mix - yellow         Tim Peters               
Sweet Orange II   advanced generation of the original Fruity Mix  vigorous indet fruity sweet, deer zero in on, crack resistant  Good till mid March   Tim Peters                  
Tim's Taste of Paradise   re-introduction from Tim Peters Fruity Mix - intensely fruity, has the elusive umami flavor      Wild Boar      Tim Peters   

Oaxacan Jewel   wonderfully intense, lingering fruity flavor.DELICIOUS Exceptional! Bicolored, medium to large size      

Q-series Panamorous   Brad, Jagodka & Big Hill x habrochaites or pennellii - tasty, super-early, and dwarf/determinate,  red or orange. Orange taste best - fruity melon  Joseph Lofthouse   

Rose Quartz Multiflora     deep pink, iridescent color and the same aromatic, fruity flavor. Large clusters of more than 100 tomatoes each. 

SunGold F1   large plant, long clusters of very sweet bright orange cherries, delicious fruity taste   Tokita Co, Japan

SunSugar F1                  

Venus   micro-dwarf   Sweet fruity small orange cherries   Thompson & Morgan   
Title: Re: Tomatoes with fruity flavors
Post by: Joseph Lofthouse on 2023-05-22, 12:12:29 PM
I would strike OSU Blue P20 from that list.

And add SunSugar F1
Title: Re: Tomatoes with fruity flavors
Post by: Cathy A on 2023-05-22, 12:31:34 PM
Now I'm wondering if my own idea of a fruity tomato is one that is not only sweet, but lacks lycopene flavor.

While I don't object to lycopene flavor, I would not call it fruity.

I'm looking forward to tasting the fruit of the Wildling Panamorous bed.
Title: Re: Tomatoes with fruity flavors
Post by: Jeremy Weiss on 2023-05-22, 03:56:13 PM
Quote from: Andrew Barney on 2023-03-24, 06:25:23 PMIt seems like there might be a correlation between fruity flavors and light colored tomatoes. White, yellow, orange, tangerine? Maybe just coincidence?

I wonder if crosses with these fruity flavored types with varieties with extra high sugar contents could create something closer to real fruit such as peaches, plums, or cherries. I would love to have a tomato someday that can pass as a cherry for flavor. But I'll settle for persimmon or melon if they taste good. 😀

I'll be trying some seeds from William for "the one". Hoping it lives up to the hype. William do you know if these flavors are true breeding or stabilized?

Well, I've told you of the one I found and lost that tasted like a grape. So a cherry is certainly possible (assuming those compounds that make a cherry fruit taste like a cherry are available in the tomato genome).

Since there are several other members of the Solanaceae that can pass for melons in flavor, that seems possible as well.
Title: Re: Tomatoes with fruity flavors
Post by: AndrewB on 2023-05-22, 08:01:38 PM
Great... now I'll might need to do a fruity tomato trial next year....
Title: Re: Tomatoes with fruity flavors
Post by: AndrewB on 2023-05-22, 08:48:10 PM
Forgot I bought seeds for Tim's Taste of Paradise! Guess I'll grow them next year! They have extra tiny seeds indicative of wild tomato species!
Title: Re: Tomatoes with fruity flavors
Post by: Steph S on 2023-05-23, 01:53:16 PM
It's funny but I started out liking a good bold 'tomato' flavor with umami, lycopene, etc. but the more I grew and sampled different OP's/heirlooms, the more I gravitated away from 'tomato' taste.
At this point the smell of a room full of ripe tomatoes is disgusting to me.  I have to move em out to the people I'm growing for.
And I don't relish the smell of the foliage either, except maybe early in the season it's okay.  One reason for breeding determinates is to avoid the gross amount of foliage and foliage smells that go with pruning and keeping large plants in a tiny greenhouse.
Every now and then I don't mind a classic red tomato taste, if I haven't had any for a longish while.
I sometimes use tomato paste in cooking but the taste of it grosses me out.  The homemade sauce is so much better.

My Skipper Pink I would describe as plummy, sweet and floral.  I can eat or smell them any day and like it.
Rodney is very similar but occasionally throws sweet or spicy notes which may be environmental IDK. They haven't turned into different tasting lines, but instead the basic taste notes are stable.
I really think of Rodney as a basis for breeding early determinate beefs, with a decent sweetness and taste and plant health profile for the climate, and the 'locule number' and reduced point shape genetics.  I guess the bicolor Rumpus and other crosses being tested now will tell whether it is a good parent for that as I hope.

Title: Re: Tomatoes with fruity flavors
Post by: AndrewB on 2023-05-24, 10:09:44 AM
Quote from: Steph S on 2023-05-23, 01:53:16 PMAnd I don't relish the smell of the foliage either, except maybe early in the season it's okay.  One reason for breeding determinates is to avoid the gross amount of foliage and foliage smells that go with pruning and keeping large plants in a tiny greenhouse.



I think with the wild tomato species I've smelled about 4 or 5 different foliage smells that are different than typical domestic tomatoes. In general tomato plant smell is ok but not great in large quantities.

For the wild galapagense smells gross almost like bug repellant

But some of the others and hybrids smell great! One hybrid I kept over winter smells fantastic! I'm really excited about the wild tomato breeding in terms of flavors and smells.