Open Source Plant Breeding Forum

General Category => Nightshades => Plant Breeding => Tomatoes => Topic started by: William Schlegel on 2022-02-23, 07:12:48 PM

Title: GMO Blue Flesh Tomato Seeds Coming
Post by: William Schlegel on 2022-02-23, 07:12:48 PM
Message deleted
Title: Re: GMO Blue Flesh Tomato Seeds Coming
Post by: Diane Whitehead on 2022-02-23, 09:52:49 PM
I wouldn't mind growing it if the added genes were from blueberries, but they are from snapdragons, so I won't.
Title: Re: GMO Blue Flesh Tomato Seeds Coming
Post by: AndrewB on 2022-02-24, 07:41:50 AM
Quote from: Diane Whitehead on 2022-02-23, 09:52:49 PM
I wouldn't mind growing it if the added genes were from blueberries, but they are from snapdragons, so I won't.

Curious as to why that makes a difference?

Im probably not interested,  but not because its GMO, and not because I think there is a conflict with open source breeding,  or any ethical concern. I don't have any problems with those in theory.
Title: Re: GMO Blue Flesh Tomato Seeds Coming
Post by: AndrewB on 2022-02-24, 11:34:23 AM
Quote from: William S. on 2022-02-24, 08:27:54 AM
I suspect transgene engineered foods which are bred for health benefits like this one will one day get organic approval. I also suspect that methodology wise they will one day be a bit of a dinosaur given recent advances in gene editing. It seems like it is possible that this tomato will be an heirloom in another 38 years in 2058. It is funny though that it got made with snapdragon genes probably an eyeblink before a gene edit could get us the same trait in the correct place in the genome where it is in purple fleshed tomatillos using the same gene as in purple fleshed tomatillos. Which honestly might still be possible from the 14 or so species tomato complex with natural breeding.

I am curious as to precisely how it will be released in a legal sense. This curiosity is greater than normal because they are talking about releasing seeds to gardeners. I've never heard of a GMO released to gardeners though some may have been unintentionally like feral canola

When the non-GMO OSU Blue was unintentionally released it led to a flurry of breeding of blue skinned tomatoes. Even if this new GMO blue fleshed tomato is released with no patents whatsoever it wouldn't be accepted as organic nor likely by the OSSI (any time soon) though I can't speak for them. Patents though do eventually expire so eventually this will enter the public domain. Not sure when that would be!

I am bothered by the current lack of acceptance of GMOs by organic standards and would want to know what the legal framework is particularly in regard to the OSSI before I grew it or bred with it as I consider myself to be breeding for organics and OSSI and if they won't accept it I might as well not waste the time and isolation gardens on it.

If I grew it, I would need to super isolate it, maybe at my parent's place. Or I might be tempted to just buy some fruit, save the seed (if legal to do so), dry it down, seal it, and freeze it for the next couple decades to preserve the option of breeding with it later.

Also curious over how it would interact genetically. With the bicolor flesh gene would we get those kinds of spectacular patterns? How about a blue / yellow/white bicolor? Would it interact favorably with the various skin patterning genes? Wonder what the various possibilities for genetic expression are?

In terms of legal framework what would happen if you crossed it intentionally or unintentionally with an existing OSSI variety of tomato?

One future concern is that it would make tomato seed swapping (which is currently a lot of fun) just a lot more perilous in terms of contamination. The fact that I really like tomatoes with higher natural outcrossing rates doesn't help either because the contamination could quickly spread. There could easily be the same sort of breeding flurry with this as there was for the blue skinned tomato which could spread contamination even in plants not expressing the trait because as they explain on their website, they've inserted three genes for the deep purple flesh two snapdragon genes and an arabidopsis regulator gene. So you could for instance, get just the arabidopsis gene without noticing that a line was contaminated but then later genetic testing could lead to a lot of organic decertification etc.  Eventually we just might not care about that (decades from now) but I think in the near future ~20 years or so we will probably collectively care a great deal. One problem being that some will almost certainly not care about those concerns and will breed with it whatever the legal status because it is a very shiny new trait and almost impossible to regulate once you transfer it to home gardeners.

I agree with you. I don't understand why modern GE crops with increasing accuracy of targeted genes should conflict with organic or OSSI "standards". In theory they are a perfect compliment and I believe someday despite heavy pushback in the beginning that we WILL have open source or organically grown GE crops.

Im also not sure why a snapdragon gene should matter over blueberries. I can understand if it came from a fish that lives in the arctic or some other animal.

Having said that though... I will be the first to jump on board of growing a Mango tree that has the fish gene to keep it from freezing in the winter.

PaddyMc or PaddyMac has already bred tomatoes with colored flesh using natural methods! He said he would send me seeds, but must have forgot. If you can get seeds I am highly interested in that one! I love the marbled effect!

Not as deep purple as the GMO ones though.

This is the coolest tomato picture i know of named "FY 1-1" by a fellow who goes by "PaddyMc".
Lunar Eclipse - Lithium Sunset x Indigo Rose 

https://farm1.staticflickr.com/641/21820692358_189563196c_c.jpg 
http://www.tomatoville.com/showthread.php?t=34043

(https://farm1.staticflickr.com/641/21820692358_189563196c_c.jpg)

Maybe someone should replicate the Lithium Sunset x Indigo Rose cross and see if the same combo shakes out.
Title: Re: GMO Blue Flesh Tomato Seeds Coming
Post by: Steph S on 2022-02-24, 07:58:10 PM
I still don't understand the appeal or the point of jamming anthocyanins into a tomato that has a lovely spectrum of carotenoid pigments already.

The 'superfood' tag is a gimmick.   Taste will always trump high concentrations of nutrients.  We've already sampled some of those - high carotenoid carrots were gross to inedible (as rated by various tasters.) And therefore pointless, since good tasting carrots had plenty enough carotene already.  Unless the point was to reduce your food needs to one bite of carrot which makes you gag.  May as well go for a pill at that point.  :P
I do like rainbow carrots but tbh the antho I've tasted were not my fave.   IDK if carotene/antho flavors don't make the best combo for my personal taste.  The white and yellow carrots are delicious.  Meanwhile,  I certainly appreciate anthos in flowers and fruit and beans and greens and grains.  So maybe it is a carotenoid conflict.

As regards the GMO issue, it means a patent and therefore ownership issues for the seed and any crossings that picked up the specially inserted gene.  Certainly the opposite of Open Source.  Not interested in that material, personally.  I am ethically opposed to patents on DNA.   And I don't see why the organic movement should accept it.   Certainly many organic farmers are attuned to seed sovereignty issues and to growing at least some of their own seed.   Since the novelty fruit has a good chance of contaminating their OP's with patented genes, you really wouldn't want it around.
And you're right about the gardeners - many will grow it for the novelty, but what will happen to our seed swaps? 
You would not even know if your received seed was crossed until a fruit ripened purple.  By that time bees have been all over the bunch, and your season's seed is possibly contaminated.   


Title: Re: GMO Blue Flesh Tomato Seeds Coming
Post by: nathanp on 2022-02-24, 09:21:09 PM
QuoteI am bothered by the current lack of acceptance of GMOs by organic standards

I am extremely bothered by that thought that anything involving a GMO could or should ever be considered organic.  One of the reasons I grow food myself, and purchase almost entirely organic foods for my family is to avoid anything related to a GMO.  I have zero trust in the lack of transparency of the development, lack of oversight by regulators, and safety concerns that arise due to studies that are nearly all entirely funded by the developers. 

Title: Re: GMO Blue Flesh Tomato Seeds Coming
Post by: Garrett Schantz on 2022-02-25, 09:50:40 AM
It seems like this tomato has over 15 years of testing or something similar.

I do agree that their editing method is dated.

The gene that they added seems to just be an anthocyanin expression gene, doubt it has a toxicity. Even if it isn't in a great placement, it shouldn't cause problems as it has been trialed.


On William's side that GMOs with health benefits are good. I would also say that increased productivity, other traits that give more health benefits, tomatoes with longer shelf life. Could lead to less food waste.

Cold hardy miracle berries would be cool.


Anyways, if seed saving / breeding is allowed, that would be cool and I wouldn't mind using them. These anthocyanin traits are typically combined with flesh color traits, but you can't see the flesh as its covered in anthocyanin / blue color.


Title: Re: GMO Blue Flesh Tomato Seeds Coming
Post by: Garrett Schantz on 2022-02-25, 09:55:46 AM
Quote from: William S. on 2022-02-24, 08:27:54 AM

I am curious as to precisely how it will be released in a legal sense. This curiosity is greater than normal because they are talking about releasing seeds to gardeners. I've never heard of a GMO released to gardeners though some may have been unintentionally like feral canola


https://www.bigpurpletomato.com/products

Seems like they will be offering plants to home gardeners.

Purple Tomato Plants
We have made seeds of purple tomatoes bred into elite varieties suitable for backyard gardens.


I would ask on their FAQs if seeds can be saved / what happens in the case of contamination.

https://www.bigpurpletomato.com/faqs
Title: Re: GMO Blue Flesh Tomato Seeds Coming
Post by: Adrian on 2022-02-25, 10:29:59 AM
Do you think it not more  easy to cross physalis ixocarpa with solanum lycopersicum than use gmo for have blue tomato?
Title: Re: GMO Blue Flesh Tomato Seeds Coming
Post by: Garrett Schantz on 2022-02-25, 10:35:07 AM
Quote from: Adrian on 2022-02-25, 10:29:59 AM
Do you think it not more  easy to cross physalis ixocarpa than use  with solanum lycopersicum than use gmo for have blue tomato?

A physalis - solanum cross may require embryo rescue or something more complicated. Pretty sure this tomato has more anthocyanins as well. Physalis breeding, even within the same genus is difficult.
Title: Re: GMO Blue Flesh Tomato Seeds Coming
Post by: Garrett Schantz on 2022-03-03, 03:07:11 PM
Got a response to my email / question.


Dear Garrett, thank you for reaching out with this excellent question. Here is a first response, and I will work on an update to add to our website, as I expect many other purple tomato fans have similar questions in mind.
One of our drivers with the purple tomato is to show that it is not so different from any other tomato you grow - it has 3 genes added to make it purple, added on top of the 30,000 genes that all tomatoes have (and, of course, there is a lot of diversity in those genes and the total number, between varieties!). Therefore, the response should look similar to this question asked of any other varieties you grow (Celebrity, Early Girl, etc.).
Accidental crossing: This is low-probability, as tomatoes mostly self pollinate. It is possible, and the risk would be similar to other tomatoes you grow. It will not escape notice, because a contamination will result in purple fruit - if this happens undesired, these plants can be destroyed.
Saving, breeding, sharing: This is a strong tradition among many gardeners, and we support people growing the purple tomatoes in similar ways to any other tomato. There will be limits to this, and we will make them clear when we are able to share the seeds.
This answer depends on USDA granting regulatory approval.
Here's what to expect:
1) It will be illegal for the seeds to go outside of the US, as we anticipate approvals first in the US and not in many other countries.
2) We will stipulate that it is fine to save seeds, breed, grow fruit for home/community consumption. We encourage this, and look forward to learning of people's successes!
3) We will require acknowledgement that people who wish to develop commercial activities (selling fruit, selling seed, selling transplants, breeding new varieties for commercial purposes) contact us. Cathie Martin and her team invested so many years to develop this amazing tomato, and we want to make sure that she can continue to develop her vision for this tomato. We encourage this, and look forward to product commercial partnerships to bring purple tomatoes to our fans.
Thanks for your interest and best wishes,


Seems like breeding / seed saving may be allowed depending on how everything goes. Seems to be a few stipulations here.

I myself wouldn't mind contacting contacting them before selling seeds / breeding commercial varieties prior to doing anything. They put quite a bit of time and money into this.

This is a pretty big forum, it should be easy to notice any contamination, but I would be sure to keep these isolated from other varieties just to be on the safe side.

If you don't isolate these, make sure that you notify anyone else that you send seeds to that these were grown nearby to prevent any issues.

Even if the other person doesn't mind contamination, they could see purple genes pop up and send it to a friend overseas.


These are GMO traits, there are more legal problems than the standard stuff. Please don't try and be sneaky about this, you could get in a lot of trouble for sending unapproved GMO seeds elsewhere.
Title: Re: GMO Blue Flesh Tomato Seeds Coming
Post by: William Schlegel on 2022-03-13, 07:27:00 PM
https://seedworld.com/purple-tomatoes-thanks-to-red-beet-pigment/

Purple

Different GMO sounds like a research effort.
Title: Re: GMO Blue Flesh Tomato Seeds Coming
Post by: Garrett Schantz on 2022-03-13, 08:28:57 PM
That purple color seems to be betanin rather than just plain anthocyanin. It was mentioned that 7 activator traits were needed, and 3 others as well.

Would be nice to see something like this on the market.
Title: Re: GMO Blue Flesh Tomato Seeds Coming
Post by: Garrett Schantz on 2022-04-07, 03:44:32 PM
Got another email 8 days ago about the purple tomatoes - seems to have been sent to everyone who subscribed to their newsletter.


Dear Purple Tomato Enthusiasts,

First of all, thanks to the many of you who have reached out with notes of support and encouragement for our project!

We have had a lot of exciting media coverage of the purple tomato recently, and we encourage you to share our mission to develop super nutritious and tasty purple tomato varieties with your family and friends!

Wall Street Journal Video
New Scientist Article
Fast Company Article
Cornell Alliance for Science Webinar
New York Times Article

We are unfortunately still in a holding pattern on seed availability, waiting on a regulatory decision through the USDA's new framework. As a reminder, we were initially given a decision deadline of February 16th, but the USDA is apparently still finalizing their review process around the new framework and also likely slowed by Covid.
We value the regulatory process highly and believe it is worth some extra time to set the right precedents.

I apologize to those of you who were hoping to start purple tomato seeds for your garden this Spring, I know this window is closing quickly for many of you. We will share an update as soon as we have news on this front.

Wish you all healthy and happy growing,
Nathan Pumplin and the Norfolk Plant Sciences team



There is still a chance that this may not be approved. It would be a bit late to receive seeds myself, I could probably get away with starting some mid season as they have introgressed the gene into multiple varieties, some which are probably early.



Another article that I found on the tomatoes https://www.fastcompany.com/90726505/behold-the-purple-tomato-a-new-designer-super-fruit


But Martin's research found two other interesting things. Her purple tomatoes—not to be mistaken with dark varietals like black cherry tomatoes—last roughly twice as long on the shelf as a standard tomato. And mice that ate a diet of her purple tomatoes lived 30% longer than those that ate the standard red variety. A human would need to eat the equivalent of two purple tomatoes every day to reach a similar potential benefit, yet Martin believes that's actually more feasible than eating the alternative of two handfuls of blueberries a day. That's because blueberries are expensive and highly seasonal, while her tomatoes could be cooked down into pasta or pizza sauce.

Seems like some nice reported studies. Longer shelf life, increased life span of mice.

But Martin has little interest in controlling any genetic or brand IP, like Monsanto or Del Monte. In fact, her company, Norfolk Plant Sciences—founded in the U.K. alongside her colleague Jonathan Jones—leans closer to Iowa's hippy nonprofit Seed Savers Exchange than a global agriculture powerhouse. As a botanist, she first studied how to use genetics to boost the anthocyanin content in tobacco plants. The problem was that anthocyanin production worked its way into the entire plant—including the leaves and the stem—which wasted energy and stunted its growth. With her tomatoes, Martin isolated how to increase anthocyanin solely within the fruit itself, and only when the fruit was at its natural ripening state. So these tomato plants can grow under the same conditions, and with the same yield, as conventional options.

I have noticed that some of my "Antho" tomato varieties get an increase in anthocyanin all throughout the plant, which stunts it for the rest of it's life if they are exposed to any cold temperatures.


Now she imagines a surprising way forward with her tomatoes. She will give them to the market however the market wants to consume them. That means she'll sell you the seeds to grow them yourself. She'll allow farmers to grow them and sell them to stores to sell to you. She'll even turn a blind eye on you cross-pollinating these purple tomatoes with another variety in your garden. Martin isn't protective of her product; she just wants to see it grow.


We should be able to breed with these from what I am reading here. As mentioned before, don't send seeds out of the U.S. if they contain GMO traits.

It was also mentioned that these should have been approved or denied by February - now they think either by the end of March or April, it will be approved or denied.


Anti-GMO fellows probably don't want it into markets, corporation-type GMO fellows probably don't want this to pop into markets either. Other groups are working on their own purple tomatoes, a non-corporation controlled type would probably destroy the market for types that need to be re-purchased yearly and probably cost a lot more than these seeds as anyone can grow them out for seed.

So, potentially millions or billions of losses and potential gains could vanish due to this free-use GMO.


I am hoping that this tomato gets released to the public. It seems like a healthy tomato, the color shows up in canning (purple ketchup?).
Title: Re: GMO Blue Flesh Tomato Seeds Coming
Post by: Jeremy Weiss on 2022-04-07, 04:02:47 PM
Quote from: Garrett Schantz on 2022-04-07, 03:44:32 PM

I am hoping that this tomato gets released to the public. It seems like a healthy tomato, the color shows up in canning (purple ketchup?).

Of course, a big part of it would be finding out of whether the public would ACCEPT purple tomato sauce, if indeed the sauce would be purple (the lycopene in red tomatoes (which is, I assume what she started with) tend to become more orangey as they are cooked, so the sauce might just as easily come out brown.  It's sort of the same reason I long ago gave up on making ANY heated product from green when ripe tomatoes; you heat a green, you get olive khaki.

If they DON'T, well it would be about as successful as my attempts to turn people on to my green soymilk and tofu (which was green because the soybeans were green). It didn't matter HOW tasty it was, no one wanted to drink green milk.   

Title: Re: GMO Blue Flesh Tomato Seeds Coming
Post by: Garrett Schantz on 2022-04-07, 08:20:31 PM
I know of a few people that I could convince to try these.

Also aware that a lot of people will see "GMO" and shun it.

Something like this could easily "contaminate" organic exserted tomatoes as well. But, the Anthocyanin shows in the fruit the following year if there is a cross. From what I have been reading, Wild Tomatoes can pollinate other groups quite far away due to bees - pretty similar to squash in that regard.

I think that the creators of this tomato want an open source tomato that people can save seed / grow themselves and breed with. Someone on the OSSI board could try emailing them - that could open those guys up into legal troubles in the future if some court starts ruling on things. I don't know if they even have any sort of protections on the Purple Tomato from what I can tell, would need to ask them.


It would be interesting to see if this turns some people towards these types of GMO. A lot of the people I know don't like GMOs because they are used to allow for the usage of toxic chemicals on plants.

Glyphosate is more than likely toxic, some suspicious back and forth emails between the FDA and a certain chemical company were found, some of which reportedly mentioned awareness that this chemical isn't entirely safe.


I could try explaining to some people all of the GMOs currently on the market to turn them over if they really feel unsafe with this.


Here are some things on the market that are GMO:

https://www.fda.gov/food/agricultural-biotechnology/gmo-crops-animal-food-and-beyond

Some of them added things to help fight off viruses or pests, not just plain old pesticide resistances.

I believe there is a GMO pink pineapple on the market as well.


I do believe that these sorts of GMO could be really nice. A bunch of nutrient dense "superfoods" could be developed

Miraculin GMO tomatoes could prove to be interesting, especially if one of the "odd" tomato flavors from wild species was tossed in. Those will probably be GMO, and they are being developed in Japan.


There isn't a requirement to label things as GMO here in the U.S. - Purple Ketchup would probably be on the news, people would probably still buy it regardless.
Title: Re: GMO Blue Flesh Tomato Seeds Coming
Post by: Jeremy Weiss on 2022-09-13, 07:07:58 AM
Quote from: Garrett Schantz on 2022-04-07, 08:20:31 PM
Purple Ketchup would probably be on the news, people would probably still buy it regardless.

I'm not sure the ketchup would be purple. A long time ago, I did some experiments on what color tomatoes turned when you cooked them . Based on what I saw almost everything pushes itself closer to red-orange. White tomatoes cook down to yellow; yellow to orange; orange, pink and red to the reddish orange we normally associate with tomato sauce; purple and brown to a deep red (sort of the color of  Italian Madeira sauce) and green to a really ugly greenish brown (which is why I have always said that trying to create green paste tomatoes would always be of only limited use, since the only thing you could use them in would be things where you use paste tomatoes raw, like salsa and bruschetta.) So it is likely this tomato would change color as well when cooked, depending on how heat stable the anthocyanin is.

On mu side, I have been trying to find a "pure" green flesh tomato (one that has ONLY chlorophyll as a colorant, no secondary yellow xanthophylls like most have) and see what it cooks down to (I imagine it would be the same shade of green as cooked spinach.)     
Title: Re: GMO Blue Flesh Tomato Seeds Coming
Post by: Garrett Schantz on 2023-08-26, 08:03:13 PM
This hasn't been updated in awhile.

https://instagram.com/littlepurpletomato?igshid=MzRlODBiNWFlZA==

https://www.norfolkhealthyproduce.com/

The fruits can be sold, as can seeds and things.


People in the public have tried the fruits out now, in events.


So it's fully approved.


I'd give it a few months before seeds are available to the public.

Just like GMO houseplants which filter out bad stuff more efficiently, there's a chance that these may not have a ton of seed stock.


I should be notified when seed is available.


It does seem like the tomatoes will stay purple when canned.



Flavr Savr, I'm still interested in growing that out as well. Another GMO tomato. I'd love to cross the two and have a tomato with both traits.



Just figured I'd give an update.


Dunno how people here feel about breeding with GMOs.


There's been mention that they should have plenty of seed for others, and they already have the gene crossed into typical hybrids and things, cherry tomatoes and things.

Flavr Savr suffered from using a bad tasting genetic base and it wasn't all that disease resistant.



So these guys are trying to do things right.
Title: Re: GMO Blue Flesh Tomato Seeds Coming
Post by: Mica Winnower on 2023-08-26, 09:27:39 PM
My worry is that they'll do what Monsanto did to corn farmers, and start taking people to court for growing out their own saved seed of this (potentially) patented GMO crop.

I've got nothing ethically wrong with GMO production in and of itself, it's just that our profit-focused consumerist food systems are built specifically to harm us little folk and keep agency out of our own hands.
Title: Re: GMO Blue Flesh Tomato Seeds Coming
Post by: Jeremy Weiss on 2023-08-26, 11:14:28 PM
Quote from: Mica Winnower on 2023-08-26, 09:27:39 PMMy worry is that they'll do what Monsanto did to corn farmers, and start taking people to court for growing out their own saved seed of this (potentially) patented GMO crop.

I've got nothing ethically wrong with GMO production in and of itself, it's just that our profit-focused consumerist food systems are built specifically to harm us little folk and keep agency out of our own hands.

I worry about something more. Once the big companies have developed a good base of winning such cases, they could start DELIBERATELY setting up plots in places where they know the pollen will contaminate nearby crops, so THAT they can establish grounds for suits, with the ultimate goal of so saturating the environment with their modified pollen that growing crops that WON'T be contaminated will become all but impossible, leaving farmers only the options of buying their seeds and abiding by their terms or not growing the crop at all.

With their lawyer base they might even be able to convince judges that, when crops are contaminated with their pollen, those crops should de facto become their property. Then, they can claim and try to patent any novel genes THEY may have for their own use.

They could even try and claim WILD plants that get contaminated, so as to make foraging illegal as well. Ultimately, they probably COULD achieve what they have always wanted; total, complete and absolute control of the world food supply and, eventually of all life (most GMO's currently are for food or forage crops, but I see no reason someone could NOT make GMO versions of things like timber trees and medicinal plants. If there is a profit to be made, someone will eventually try and make it.)
Title: Re: GMO Blue Flesh Tomato Seeds Coming
Post by: Nicolas on 2023-08-27, 01:08:49 AM
I would love to play with the colors, but also would not eat it, so i'll pass.
Title: Re: GMO Blue Flesh Tomato Seeds Coming
Post by: Garrett Schantz on 2023-08-27, 02:36:12 AM
I believe those who made the big purple tomato have said that they have it so that anyone can breed with it.

Not just save seeds.


I may grow it indoors, they've developed some cherry tomatoes with the gene, they're breeding these into modern hybrids.



I don't want these crossing with exserted tomatoes.


The traits and things seem sound.

The flavors are probably the same as standard.

I remember seeing them mention crossing these into Sungold. I'd probably grow those seeds indoors as a potted plant.

The house has a large sunroom. Would work great to grow potted plants in.


It's been tested for long enough that I'd say it's safe.



I just know that people wouldn't want these contaminating their own tomatoes and things.

This one sure, they likely won't punish anyone for growing these out or whatever else.


Breeding these into different lines, you don't get a full purple affect either. So a first generation cross would have a tomato that's purpleish on the inside and outside.



I likely won't be able to even give away GMO tomatoes in my area.



Also, you cannot send any contaminated seed overseas.

That could grant you actual jail time. It's only approved in the United States.




The creators want a healthy tomato that can be shared and bred with - used to make even better tomatoes.



I'll likely have these indoors if I grow them.



I'd give it a few years before these get more widespread approval in different countries. Or before people go and buy GMO tomatoes.


They look very nice in terms of color. Reminds me of Wonderberry.



Flavr Savr had its patent run out if I recall. So anyone who tried growing it would be fine doing so.


This one, if they tried going back on some things, they'd run into legal issues.



Within the next few years, I can see other tomatoes with blue pigments or other things coming to market or being approved.

I'm unsure if those ones will be allowed to have seeds shared. Probably not.

So that will be an upcoming issue.


There's a ton of blue GMO tomatoes being made in different labs with different genes and things.


I'd prefer that someone crosses Solanum retroflexum or nigrum in a lab with tomatoes or Lycium ruthenicum with them.


It's not that I dislike the big purple tomato. Wonderful idea.


I just feel like it's opened up people's minds to GMO vegetables. If it's super safe and others realize it, regulators will likely decide there's already a GMO on the market and start approving more of them.


This one likely took awhile to be released, solely because some regulators know about other purple tomatoes and that these ones would screw up those plans and future marketing.

Probably why it hasn't been approved in other countries.



There aren't enough GMO laws for accidental hybrids, or introduced hybrids becoming mostly GMOs which are using non tomato traits and things for resistances.

And nobody can breed with those, or we'd have to breed our own tomatoes.



Not everyone who's aware of Flavr Savr is aware that it had more than just some added traits which made it last longer on shelves.

It also had added genes which made it immune to damage from some antibiotics.

The antibiotics were kanamycin and neomycin.


Or maybe added gene is a better term.


From my little bit of research, any progeny with the Flavr Savr genes, would also have the other added gene.

They were linked.


So, in breeding they'd dump antibiotics on seedlings. The survivors had the Flavr Savr's desired gene.

I have no idea how they still ended up releasing tomatoes which didn't have any disease resistances. Or tasted bad.



But, my point is that other new tomatoes may have that same thing going on or something similar.

Let's say other traits that act as markers or have natural insecticides that also harm bees or something are released.


Or tomatoes that fix nitrogen.


These would cause two different issues. One, would harm nature. The other would have GMO tomatoes that nobody else can grow, and anyone who grows tomatoes for sale, typically uses some fertilizer.

Anyone growing tomatoes would then be in a position where these GMO sellers could potentially sell these for cheap prices just to wash them out.



Its technically possible to make male sterile tomatoes, which still produce fruit. These would be seedless, I'd think.


There would still need to be breeding on those lines, I'd imagine. So there would probably be lines used just for breeding.



But yeah. These I may grow just as an oddity or whatever.


I'm interested as to why these haven't been mixed with Antho tomato lines which use another form of anthocyanin production.

I believe they'd do well crossed with one another. They both have the muddying issue when crossed with certain pigments and things.


Some people may be more sensitive to certain chemicals compared to others as well. But this has been tested for awhile.
Title: Re: GMO Blue Flesh Tomato Seeds Coming
Post by: Garrett Schantz on 2023-08-27, 03:09:50 AM
Added flavor traits or things like genes from miracle berry could also be added.

This would give large companies who have largely disallowed its usage, the rights to mainly distribute it

Some things are acquired tastes or things.



Beauty Berry and Sabal minor are two species which have odd flavors that I've tried recently since I've moved to Mississippi.

My first impression of Sabal minor was a odd nutty taste, different from almonds or peanuts - even without eating the seed. There's something nice about it.


American beauty berry, I tried some fresh ripe berries as well.

Some unripe ones had a slight bitterness. But, these seemed to be juicy and semi sweet. There was also another unique flavor which I hadn't tried before in it.

I tried researching the species.

I've read that it has a spiciness.


I haven't tried "Asian Five Spice."

I'm unsure of what spiciness refers to. I hate the taste of peppercorns. They don't taste spicy, they taste like death.

I have been wanting to taste Szechaun peppercorns - but those seemingly have a sort of heat or burn.

These didn't have a pepper burn or herbal taste or burn wither.


I've went out a few times and chewed or eaten some ripe berries, because these taste like something I've never had before.


I also tried eating some raw Beauty berries and raw palmetto berries. The mushy consistency was replaced with a semi soft texture when eaten together.

And some I thought it tasted good.



I'd like for whatever traits these have that make these fun chemicals to end up in a GMO. Ideally I could try and breed larger fruited beauty berries and palmetto. There's not much to work with, these barely have any flesh.

I had an odd notion of wanting to dry these and mix them, then make a powder that works as a seasoning for steak. I also had an odd notion where these had something I was missing in my diet.



But yeah. In terms of GMOs there's a lot of good you could do.

Strawberries and Sour gherkins are still at the top of my favorite fruits / vegetables.



A purple large sour gherkins would be funny to me.



Researching what can be done with GMOs is fun and all.

My point with some of this, is that different people react differently to different genes or even flavors.


Added genes need to have probably been tested for long periods of time on different groups of people.
Title: Re: GMO Blue Flesh Tomato Seeds Coming
Post by: Joseph Lofthouse on 2023-08-27, 04:22:53 AM
QuoteOr tomatoes that fix nitrogen.

My tomatoes already have that trait. I'll try to post a write up a summary of the research in the next little bit.
Title: Re: GMO Blue Flesh Tomato Seeds Coming
Post by: Roland on 2023-08-27, 07:00:20 AM
At first everyone is afraid of the unknown and GMO, later everyone is used to it and doesn't know any better.
Title: Re: GMO Blue Flesh Tomato Seeds Coming
Post by: Jeremy Weiss on 2023-08-27, 08:22:43 AM
Quote from: Garrett Schantz link=msg=13772 d<br><br><br>I have been wanting to taste Szechaun peppercorns - but those seemingly have a sort of heat or burn.<br><br>/quote]

Sichuan peppercorns don't really have a "burn", though given how often they are paired with chili peppers, you wouldn't often know this. Their flavor is more of a sort of tingling or numbing one, they may your mouth feel as if you just got it washed out with Novocain and (at least in my case) they also cause a bit of an astringent effect, so you start salivating A LOT.

I did once have a Chinese dish where they used Sichuan peppercorns and used NO chilis, and it was an odd experience.

There are technically THREE kinds out there, the Sichuan peppercorn, the Japanese member of the genus (called sansho pepper, and often used on fried things) and an Indian member that is semi-obscure (and, no, I don't know if the prickly ash tree we grow here can be used.)   
Title: Re: GMO Blue Flesh Tomato Seeds Coming
Post by: Cathy A on 2023-08-27, 01:07:23 PM
Jeremy is right. Sichuan peppercorns are numbing rather than hot, though they are often combined with chilis to produce a numbing-and-hot flavor

I routinely cook foods using Sichuan peppercorns, and also use them to make a refrigerator canned green bean. There's always a pack of the dried peppercorns in my pantry. They keep a very long time.

Title: Re: GMO Blue Flesh Tomato Seeds Coming
Post by: Garrett Schantz on 2023-08-28, 03:12:38 AM
I didn't get a numbing taste either, but that's still nice to know.

There's American species in the same genus as Sichuan peppercorns, I've been considering growing some of those out, just to see what happens.

I've heard related species in that genus cross readily.

I've also not heard of native species being used for anything but medicine.



All that I got from the Beauty berries was sweetness then an unknown flavor, I can't quite pinpoint what it is. Same goes with the Sabal species, but I can say it resembles a nutty flavor.



Anyways yeah. Having tomatoes or anything with chemicals found in these sorts of species would be nice, or having things with larger fruits.

When it comes to larger fruits, but not having any genes for larger fruits - you run into the issue of having to wait for mutants to pop up over a long period of time. These aren't very palatable due to the lack of very much flesh at all. Plus straining and other things.


Someone else mentioned elsewhere that there are larger fruited species or accessions, but they might have air pockets - but there may be genes that would make a purely fleshy larger fruited specimen.



Just figured I'd point out some GMO benefits.


They aren't all bad. But there are negatives like laws not moving fast enough or whatnot.



And yeah GMOs do mess up organic stuff.
Title: Re: GMO Blue Flesh Tomato Seeds Coming
Post by: Cathy A on 2023-11-01, 10:47:31 AM
It's just as well that no one near me grows tomatoes. Few of my neighbors have vegetable gardens at all.

I may not be 100% genetically isolated from tomatoes outside my yard, but I'm pretty close.
Title: Re: GMO Blue Flesh Tomato Seeds Coming
Post by: Garrett Schantz on 2023-11-01, 04:24:13 PM
I had two of Baker Creeks free magazines arrive today.

I'm unsure of as to why I received two of these.

I may give one to a neighbor who also buys seed from Baker Creek.


Renaissance Farms, has complained about a fruity or odd taste that comes along with anthocyanin.



This purple tomato, is said to have a fruity taste and be to be pretty sweet.


It's safe to say, that nobody here has ever had a fully purple tomato before.



As others have said here before.

Different colors of tomatoes and the like, also have different flavors or sugars attached to them.



I hate red tomatoes.

There's also different types of red, orange and other tomatoes.


Plus yellow and whatever too.



So, some people have also probably noticed a subtle tomato anthocyanin taste.


But, Purple Galaxy is full of anthocyanins.


Inside and out. Even the gel appears to be purple.


It seems like it starts out as a chocolate brown.


But yeah. Found in a group of non fully purple tomatoes. So it's a mutant of some sort.



They mentioned a plant breeder found it. I doubt it's possible to see their breeding lines.


There's also another subtle note mentioned in the catalogue.


Some of the foliage is purple or has purpling to it.


I've seen that happen when it gets too cold. Or some types just show some purple stems.

Or purple calyxes.


But, from this it's probably easy to recognize that it's probably a transponder that was messed with in some way.


Andrew mentioned purple podded peas and purple shelled peas.


This tomato is supposedly showing purpling in the leaves and fruit.




Now, back to the fruity flavors. This could be from another breeding line, adding in a fruity aftertaste.

Or, the anthocyanin being more expressed and widespread means that people eating this, will also get to experience a larger quantity of that flavor.



I've tried Otricoli Orange (Solanum nigrum). It tasted pretty awful.

Maybe the population as a whole, was just bad tasting. I've mostly only had Solanum nigrum, Garden Huckleberry and the like, from edible lines.

But, they definitely had a different flavor than Otricoli Orange. Much more different.


Some Jaltomata and things, also taste nice to me. Similar to blueberries in some cases.

But, non blue types also taste decent enough.



But either way.


I'd like to cross Sart Roloise into this tomato.


It has the fruity flavors from White Beauty, and it already has anthocyanins.


If these have different sugars or different reasons for having fruitier tastes. Then that sounds great.


It's also likey that certain sugars and things, are just anchored or attached to anthocyanin traits and things. So, the anthocyanin itself probably has more than just it's own sugars being carried along.



Either way, crossing the two sounds like a win-win. Anthocyanin and added flavors and sugars.



I'm unsure if these carry along the same sugars and flavors as Jaltomata or Solanum nigrum. They probably don't.


Anthocyanin being expressed in the leaves, is detrimental to plants.


I've heard of wild Capsicum mutants with dark leaves and fruit.


Solanum nigrum typically doesn't have dark leaves.


Some Jaltomata types, do have darker leaves.



And, it's worth noting that Solanum peruvianum's anthocyanin could also carry along different flavors or sugars. I'm pretty sure it does.

But, anthocyanin was barely expressed before this tomato popped up. So, any flavors coming over weren't really all too different I'd imagine.


Maybe this does have Peruvianum in it. Hard to say since it's from a breeding line.



It's also interesting to note, that I've heard that the GMO tomato also tastes sweet or has a berry flavor.


It could taste different from these tomatoes as well.


I would like to personally look at, and breed with the Snapdragon tomato before I eat it.



These images belong to Baker Creek. I'd recommend requesting a magazine. This is from the free catalog. This offers a better look at the fruit.

Title: Re: GMO Blue Flesh Tomato Seeds Coming
Post by: William Schlegel on 2023-11-01, 09:49:14 PM
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34177999/

Maybe this was the other GMO purple tomato I thought someone posted about. A Beet gene tomato- not anthocyanins but betalains. Look at figure five in the article link above. Or below in the phys.org popular press article. In the popular press article a figure shows the contrast between GMO anthocyanin tomatoes and the combination of both.

https://phys.org/news/2017-08-pigments-beets-boost-resistance-disease.html

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genetically_modified_tomato

According to the wikipedia page for GMO tomato there may be an Arabidopsis thaliana GMO anthocyanin version floating around somewhere.
Title: Re: GMO Blue Flesh Tomato Seeds Coming
Post by: Garrett Schantz on 2024-02-14, 11:38:50 PM
https://www.norfolkhealthyproduce.com/


The Purple tomatoes from Norfolk Healthy Produce, released on February 6th, 2024 it seems.


I was seeing mention of common varieties being bred into whatever lines.



https://www.norfolkhealthyproduce.com/product-page/purple-tomato-seeds


"The Purple Tomato is ONLY available in the USA.
Limit one order per customer, due to limited supplies.

10 seeds per packet"



"Terms and Conditions

By purchasing NHP Purple Tomato seeds, I accept the following conditions:

Seeds, fruit and plant material are only allowed in the USA.

The seeds are a patented variety and are sold to enjoy in your home garden and with your local community.

No sales of fruit, seeds or plants are permitted in this agreement, including any derived varieties.

These seeds come with no warranties.

For more information, see our website FAQs."





Firstly. I was under the impression, that we'd be able to sell the fruits or things, at the very least - in the United States.


Nope. If you plant these, you can't sell the fruit.

This likely includes canned goods.



You cannot sell the plants.


If 10 seeds germinate, you have 10 plants. Either give some away or cull the ones you don't want.



There's the mention of derivatives.



But they don't mention the whole thing of being able to breed with them.


This seems sorta awful, in my opinion.


The whole big thing of being able to save seed from these, breed with them.


You can't even sell these.



These are just for home gardeners I guess.



And they explicitly mention that it's patented.





20 USD, for 10 seeds.


They can't be traded outside of the United States, either.

Which that's due to legalities.



But seed trading. That's the only way that these will spread. Because you can't even sell the derivatives.



One big fuss, was that this was meant to be for the people - to make a healthy product, not caring about money as much.



I'm fairly sure that they do in fact have limited seed. Probably because the licensed the rest / gave it to growers.



20 USD, for 10 seeds, of which you can't sell the fruit or make anything from it.


The 20 USD, seems understandable, given what it is.


I saw a houseplant which filters out the air and break down all sorts of stuff, selling for much more. A GMO. Granted, that was a plant, not seeds.



The fact that you literally can't do anything with these, other than eat them, should be factored into the cost.


These also aren't something which needs made in labs, or prepped up like some other GMO seed.


They can be saved, like standard tomato seed.



I'll likely still get seed. I am still planning on growing it out.


I was hoping to grow a plant indoors, possibly maybe outdoors, watching the flowers / bagging them.


And doing side by side comparisons with Purple Galaxy.



But, it looks like that's not happening.



Sorta upsetting, not to have both.



But, it is what it is.



Apologies if I seek irked here. I assumed that being allowed to save seed / breed with this, would imply that we'd also be allowed to sell tomatoes or something at the very least.


Their messages they were putting out, made it seem like they weren't all into big business stuff.



Shipping is free. And I suppose that I've seen 15 USD Tomato seeds from hybrids before.


This also isn't a new GMO. It's been out for a while. It just needed approval.




It's nice being able to get seed, I guess.



I'd assume that you can't get around the rules by buying fruit at a supermarket. It's a patented variety.


Bakercreek should have no issues, selling their Tomato if or when it finally releases.


I'd also like to mention. Most people's neighbors probably won't touch a GMO tomato.

Most home gardeners aren't the type of people who grow GMOs either.


Title: Re: GMO Blue Flesh Tomato Seeds Coming
Post by: Cathy A on 2024-02-16, 07:59:26 AM
I wouldn't touch those with a ten foot pole under those restrictions. Too much risk of getting legally restricted genes into my breeding projects.

I'd suggest all the breeders here keep them out of their gardens unless this is formally clarified to not include breeding with them and selling/trade/growing out the resulting crosses.
Title: Re: GMO Blue Flesh Tomato Seeds Coming
Post by: Garrett Schantz on 2024-02-16, 10:18:08 AM
Yeah.

The legally restricted thing, sounds awful.


Not being able to trade the seed out of country is understandable, not too bad.



But, these restrictions could make it illegal to sell something which accidentally crossed over.



The first cross with a non purple tomato, would look pretty muddy as shown in their trials.




"No sales of fruit, seeds or plants are permitted in this agreement, including any derived varieties."



That's the one statement in there.



Derived varieties, would mean anything else made from these.



A lot of people here, have Promiscuous tomatoes. I've been growing them as well.




I'm unsure how the seed agreements with certain varieties, would work with something like this either.



I'd assume that a created gene would legally bypass other laws, just because it's patented and whatever else.




I agree with not touching them.



But, I'll likely still grow them indoors. If I buy them. I was mostly planning to, anyways.



I'd also recommend, not composting these, when / if they make it to markets and stores. If volunteers come up at all, I know that a lot of people like little volunteers / free plants like that.



It feels just like a normal GMO, except you can breed with them. You can't sell them.

You don't own the fruit, nor the plants.



But yeah, awful restrictions.



I'd wait for purple galaxy to come back. I'm fairly sure that it won't have nearly as many anthocyanins as the GMO.


But, the restrictions make the GMO, sort of bad to even have anywhere nearby.



I don't really plan on gorging on the fruits. I don't know anyone else who would - they're GMOs. Many people hate them in this area.



The restrictions make the GMO look even worse. I thought that being able to grow them, was supposed to make them seem more attractive to others. Help people see that not all GMOs are the same.
Title: Re: GMO Blue Flesh Tomato Seeds Coming
Post by: Adam Igra on 2024-02-16, 04:08:38 PM
Norfolk is claiming that baker creek is lying about their product and that Purple Galaxy is actually GMO. Ive seen elsewhere suggestions that it was directly stolen, but no evidence for this, beyond Norfolks vague claim that only their patented method can produce that plant (Though I cant believe this is true either, they dont own crispy cash99 but perhaps their methods patent is way more specific).
https://www.norfolkhealthyproduce.com/faqs
Title: Re: GMO Blue Flesh Tomato Seeds Coming
Post by: William Schlegel on 2024-02-16, 04:41:18 PM
Quote from: Adam Igra on 2024-02-16, 04:08:38 PMNorfolk is claiming that baker creek is lying about their product and that Purple Galaxy is actually GMO. Ive seen elsewhere suggestions that it was directly stolen, but no evidence for this, beyond Norfolks vague claim that only their patented method can produce that plant (Though I cant believe this is true either, they dont own crispy cash99 but perhaps their methods patent is way more specific).
https://www.norfolkhealthyproduce.com/faqs


"Is NHP's Purple Tomato related to the "Purple Galaxy"?

We have received many questions about the purple tomato marketed by Baker Creek as "Purple Galaxy" in their 2024 catalogs. We understand from Baker Creek that they will not be selling seeds of this variety.  Given its remarkable similarity to our purple tomato, we prompted Baker Creek to investigate their claim that Purple Galaxy was non-GMO.  We are told that laboratory testing determined that it is, in fact, bioengineered (GMO). This result supports the fact that the only reported way to produce a purple-fleshed tomato rich in anthocyanin antioxidants is with Norfolk's patented technology. We appreciate that Baker Creek tested their material, and after discovering it was a GMO, removed it from their website."

No they are claiming that Baker Creek voluntarily tested their material. Found it to be GMO and then removed it from their website. It is no longer on Baker Creeks website.

Statement from Baker Creek Below:

"BAKER CREEK DISCONTINUES PURPLE GALAXY TOMATO SEEDS

Baker Creek regrets to inform you that we will not sell seeds of the Purple Galaxy tomato, which we previewed in our 2024 catalogs. After repeated testing, we are unable to conclusively establish that the Purple Galaxy does not contain any genes that have been genetically modified. Baker Creek remains steadfast in its commitment to selling only heirloom and open-pollinated, non-Genetically Modified ("non-GM") varieties.

Baker Creek is one of nearly 400 companies that subscribe to the Safe Seed Pledge first created by the Council for Responsible Genetics in 1999. Indeed, we are one of the leaders in the movement to keep gardens free of genetically-engineered plants. In the decades before CRG wrote its Pledge, Big Ag had used genetic engineering to manipulate the DNA of seeds and, by patenting them and suing farmers to "enforce" those patent rights and avoid responsibility for GM contamination of nearby crops, Big Ag obtained significant control the world's food supply. CRG's Safe Seed Pledge explains why genetically modified seeds present a threat:

The mechanical transfer of genetic material outside of natural reproductive methods and between genera, families or kingdoms poses great biological risks as well as economic, political and cultural threats. We feel that genetically engineered varieties have been insufficiently tested prior to public release. More research and testing is necessary to further assess the potential risks of genetically engineered seeds. Further, we wish to support agricultural progress that leads to healthier soils, genetically diverse agricultural ecosystems and ultimately people and communities.

When we previewed the Purple Galaxy tomato in our 2024 catalog, we believed it was scientifically confirmed to not be a GM tomato. We sourced the seed for the Purple Galaxy from a plant breeder in Europe—where GM tomatoes are not approved—who has collected rare tomato seeds for decades and grows more than 1,000 varieties of tomatoes annually. We actively followed his attempts to breed a purple flesh tomato over the course of three years. In the beginning, using two varieties, he had a fruit that was definitely not purple; it was a purplish red with a few purple streaks. Cultivating five generations over three years, he ultimately had a beautiful tomato with purple skin and flesh. We then traveled to Europe to see the plants for ourselves.

Before we would publicly preview the tomato in our catalog, we sent samples of the Purple Galaxy to the European laboratory of one of the world's largest and most respected international laboratories. We often have used their labs in the United States. They took their time researching and then testing the tomato, and they reported that it did not contain the two genetic markers they measured for. Having monitored the development of the Purple Galaxy over three years in a country that does not allow GMO crops and should thus be free of contamination, and having examined it ourselves up close and subjected it to rigorous testing by a world-renowned lab, we were excited to preview it with you in our 2024 catalog.

But after our 2024 catalog was released, we continued to conduct testing on the Purple Galaxy some of which were inconclusive Also, we were contacted by Norfolk. At this point we decided to put production of Purple Galaxy on hold due to concerns of GMO contamination. Norfolk Healthy Produce is a subsidiary of a European GM Ag company with large, Big Ag investors. Norfolk holds the patent to (and sells) a genetically-engineered purple flesh tomato. Norfolk expressed concern that the Purple Galaxy might have been derived from its patented genetically-engineered tomato, and it suggested additional genes to test for.

Subsequent laboratory testing conducted in conjunction with Norfolk did not conclusively establish a relationship between the Purple Galaxy and Norfolk's GM purple tomato. Indeed, such contamination should be unlikely in Europe, given its approach to GM crops. But the testing also did not conclusively establish that the Purple Galaxy is truly free of any genetically-modified material. Because we believe the safest plants are those which are open pollinated and not genetically engineered, we chose not to offer the Purple Galaxy seeds for sale and to discontinue production of them. And we reiterate our commitment to refrain from knowingly selling seeds for genetically modified plants. Baker Creek continues to believe that all outdoor GMO plantings should be banned outright due to the potential for cross-pollination and patent infringement issues that are causing a loss of genetic diversity, an increase in new weeds, and have threatened the livelihood of family farmers.

For more than 25 years, Baker Creek has been a leading voice for stewarding non-GMO varieties and for mandating labels on all GM fruits and vegetables. Although we understand that you—like us—may be disappointed not to have a delicious non-GM purple flesh tomato in your garden, we are pleased that we were able to make this decision before a single seed of Purple Galaxy was made available to customers." - Baker Creek.
Title: Re: GMO Blue Flesh Tomato Seeds Coming
Post by: Adam Igra on 2024-02-16, 06:19:28 PM
A few people commented that the marketing material explicitly claimed it had been tested as non-GMO, and that one person who asked directly was also told it wasnt gmo. Perhaps they were lied to by the supplier, whoever that is, and their initial tests were not accurate. Baker Creek has before been quite openly opposed to GMO crops and insist their seeds are heirlooms. Whilst I dont think this is totally true, norfolk is claiming the only way to have made this tomato is to use their method... Thats implicitly accusatory, no?

You are right I shouldnt be accusative, scandals like this encourage a lot of aggression online. Still, on their instagram, The reason claimed even 2 hours ago for removing it was due to production issues, no comment on it not actually being GMO on their social medias since then either. Perhaps they were simply misled by their supplier, but then they shouldnt claim they already tested it.
Title: Re: GMO Blue Flesh Tomato Seeds Coming
Post by: reed on 2024-02-16, 06:45:24 PM
The catalog does say specifically that it is not GMO, but it does not specifically say that it was tested for GMO. It does say that it was discovered as a chance mutation that appeared in a patch of other tomatoes, a number of years ago and was selected by one of their plant breeders.

Maybe the breeder wasn't completely open or got sloppy. If the other company just released theirs, how did it get in that other patch, several years ago anyway?

In any event, I feel bad for Bakercreek because I don't believe they did anything wrong, at least not on purpose and they fixed the error by pulling it from their shelves.
Title: Re: GMO Blue Flesh Tomato Seeds Coming
Post by: Garrett Schantz on 2024-02-16, 07:15:48 PM
They're still claiming supply issues.

I'm inclined to maybe agree.


They've told others that they've tested their stuff.


Maybe the probability of a mutation is rare?




The seed was originally to be sold as limited stock. Baker Creek has pushed selling a new product, into further into the year, on multiple occasions.



Because of that, it could just be that they're growing out that seed which they planned to sell, and making a huge seed crop.




I've been inclined to think that they were making a breeding line, saw Norfolk's product and tried to rush this out.



That would explain the marketing, limited seed and other things.



I've asked them on their Instagram, a few times. They also gave out stories about it being found as a mutant by a breeder.


Others have asked and gotten the same response.



They got the seed tested. Genetic markers weren't found, colleges usually have those logged.


"This result supports the fact that the only reported way to produce a purple-fleshed tomato rich in anthocyanin antioxidants is with Norfolk's patented technology."



I think that someone else here mentioned that there's other antho tomatoes out there. It's also likely that researchers are aware of other antho tomatoes being made privately.


And yeah. It feels like Norfolk Healthy Produce, accused Baker Creek of using their product.





Baker creek testing their material and doing whatever. That's their claim.



They could've just removed it for production issues.




And as I've mentioned.



The existence of this tomato, would tank Norfolk Healthy Produce's antho tomato.


People could breed with it or do whatever.



Yes, they'd probably be inclined to make accusations without actually making accusations.


Force people to assume things, using their words.



That's what it feels like to me.



Nowhere have they said that they confirmed this for themselves.



Keep in mind that they've been doing their thing since 2003 or whatever. Their home country, wouldn't approve the tomato.


There's been a lot of money shoved into the GMO. They are working to mix the patented stuff into existing varieties.


They have people who have licensed the product.




If a non GMO pops up, nobody will want to license themselves with Norfolk Healthy Produce. No stores will buy their tomato, customers prefer non GMOs.


Farmers would have access to less expensive antho tomato seed.


Anyone could breed with, and make new varieties using what Baker Creek has.



Other countries who likely have scientists making antho tomatoes, would not want this to be released.


Because it could be spread to other countries.




The chances of only Norfolk Healthy Produce working on a antho GMO, are very, very low.


I'm willing to bet, that there's people making antho tomatoes which also have traits from miracle berries or other things.


Sweeteners, vitamin c. Fun flavors.


High disease resistances from other species.




We are at a point in time, where GMOs are more accepted. And large companies have political power.



Norfolk Healthy Produce, released a product which only has an antho trait - and snapdragon stuff.


Private groups probably won't leak their processes or ideas.





There's another big issue.


Lobbyists and scientists.


If some genes moved over, or other things happen - people could argue that the chance of things happening naturally as a mutation, are too low for their liking.


They could argue that CRISPR or something else was used to modify the plant - remove or move / add something.



I've seen this argument with videos recently. Footage and photos are no longer very credible. AI and people can easily fake videos, voices and pictures to the point where people can't tell that it's fake.



Many genetic engineering techniques, are cheap. They weren't always cheap. Different fellows made different techniques.



Someone working for fellows making purple tomatoes, would likely fight tooth and nail with anyone with a purple mutant.


Someone could be forced to prove that it isn't a GMO, or they could be forced to hold off on releasing a product.


It's just a theory. But, it could feasibly happen.






I'm hoping to see more of a statement come out from them. Look around anywhere online, people are bashing Baker Creek for selling a GMO and people are saying that they stole from Norfolk Healthy Produce, and shouldn't have listed the product at all / that they misled customers.


It's not just you who read it that way. Others are taking it as Baker Creek tested their material, contacted Norfolk Healthy Produce and whatever else.



I'm simply saying that we should wait on a response from Baker Creek.


If they release their product later on in the year, then that could be nice.



I know a few people who work with colleges.



Norfolk Healthy Produce shouldn't be able to leak anything, or say whatever, either. Even if they have contacts.



And yeah I was one of the people who asked them directly and was told that they had it tested in labs before it was even a stable variety.
Title: Re: GMO Blue Flesh Tomato Seeds Coming
Post by: William Schlegel on 2024-02-16, 07:38:28 PM
Topic Locked. Seems like proper courses of action were followed and speculation can be harmful.

Baker Creek came out with a statement. It is on their website and I pasted it in an above post right below Norfolk's.