https://permies.com/t/170703/Tomatoes-seed-zone-colder
Over on permies.com someone started a thread today which I have responded to.
The question is: can we breed tomatoes that just reseed themselves and reliably volunteer.
I've noticed they tend to dissappear over a few years. This might be habitat dependant. For instance dry streams seem like a tomato habitat. Given proper habitat do tomatoes volunteer reliably?
Or is it just a matter of time? With a few more generations of direct seeding would tomatoes volunteer reliably? Maybe a few more crosses?
What do you think?
My strain of Solanum pimpinellifolium has been reliably volunteering in my community for decades.
It does not reliably volunteer in my garden. I haven't tried to analyze why it succeeds for my neighbors, but fails for me. I have a huge population of tomato flea beetles. Perhaps my tiling practices interfere. My field is 300 feet higher in elevation (colder). Different weeds or soil?
I received a report last year of an F1 pimpinellifolium hybrid volunteering in a neighbor's garden. It was a small cherry tomato instead of a current tomato.
Tomatillos reliably volunteer in my garden, and in gardens throughout my community.
This fall, I gathered tomato vines, with lots of fruit, and threw them into the badlands. Just an experiment to see if any of them can learn to grow, and volunteer in the non-irrigated badlands.
I reckon badlands tend to have seasonally dry stream beds and gulches. I think that is habitat for tomatoes based on what I have seen of wildland volunteer tomatoes.
Those tomato flea beetles that stop you from direct seeding have me intrigued by these Arthopod resistant populations of habrochaites especially LA2329 and galapagense of which Andrew sent me LA1410 which seems a likely candidate. The berries are little fur balls on both but it seems reasonable. I haven't noticed any hybridization yet in LA2329 itself it all seemed fairly true to type but there has been fairly extreme selection just for individuals that can ripen a berry in the two years I've been growing it. I have a small pile if seed packets from the 2021 crossing block though I wish I had included one plant of R18. I just had poor seedling survival on it so I thought the six or so survivors too precious. However if any of the elite promiscuous project plants managed to cross with LA2329 or if exserted tiger, big hill, or MMS did it should be a fun cross. Same with the reverse if LA2329 ever manages to pick up genes from the promiscuous ptoject. Also just excited to see any hybrids from that experiment. Can't wait to start spreading those seeds in trays.
Will definitely put R18 in that mix next year. Too little observation but I saw bumble bees being too faithful in my opinion to species. I feel like R18 flowers look more like habrochaites flowers to me so maybe they'll fool the bees too. Also some deliberate crosses are in order but I am slow on those. I do have LA1410 galapagense sprouted in my winter pots but it is little still.
I have enough LA1410 seed to surround one exserted plant with galapagense seedlings in 2022 and intend to do so.
I grew LA2329 this summer. It was one clump in a field of Solanum habrochaites, and (purported) Solanum habrochaites back-crosses. It managed to produce a few super fuzzy fruits. The flowers sure were pretty.
I didn't keep it separate while harvesting, but I haven't processed the fruits yet, so could pull them out before extracting seeds. I tend to work as a lumper, rather than a splitter. It simplifies record keeping and seed saving for me.
Might be worth pulling out a few of the extra fuzzy berries seeds in a separate packet. Your strain now has actually had two generations to potentially cross with your other habrochaites because it was within easy bee striking range of one of your back cross habrochaites strains in 2020 in my garden. As well as a giant direct seeded row of BH x W4 that was all virtually wild type. If any crosses occurred we could expect some real segregation from it as early as next year. If not no big deal I can keep it separate for both of us. Definitely hoping for some back crossing into it next year if I can find any hybrids!
Also apparently I have gradually accumulated 195 tomato accessions according to the numbering I did in my excel spreadsheet. Which might make me a splitter. Though I calculate about fifty of those I could lump into two. Segregating reds and segregating yellows.
I know at least one person a bit of a distance from me who tossed some cherry tomato seeds along the side of their house, they've been self-seeding and harvesting for several years without re-sowing. I believe it's under the eaves, -5C sort of winter climate, long cool summers.
The pigs turned under my tomato trial site this year when I was done with it, I'm curious to see what self-seeds from the trial with that kind of pretty intense cultivation.
My experience in every climate I've tried has been that tomato volunteers ripen right at the end of the season when it's cold enough that they're tasteless anyhow so I've never saved seed from them or encouraged them in any way previously. This year if nothing else I'm going to leave my sweet cheriette pot full of mummies to go again on my deck.
By the time I finish processing fruits, I'm on track to have saved 29 packets of tomato seeds in the 2021 growing season. That's about equal to what I have stored from previous years.
8 packets with seeds from only one mother plant.
One packet each for 5 pure wild species.
3 packets for solanum habrochaites.
4 packets that are manually crossed F1 hybrids between wild species and self-incompatible elite lines.
4 packets that are purely domestic inbred varieties.
1 packet of seeds selected for a possible xenia effect.
The rest of the packets are composites, grouped by similar traits.
The largest packet is for Wildling, which is for semi-elite lines that don't meet the project archetype for one reason or another. I culled most of the red-fruited tomatoes that showed up in the Beautifully Promiscuous and Tasty Tomato project. Even though Wildling is for the seconds, I still want it to be continuously improving, which means minimizing red-fruited genetics.
I've had volunteers here from outdoor grows, and in greenhouses too, but never in the compost pile.
Our coldest winter temps would be around -20 C but we usually are not that cold and we have a lot of thaws.
The most efficient for me is to expand the compost for have a maximum of volunteers at a correct density.