https://academic.oup.com/jhered/article/94/6/449/2187396
I am interested in blue tomatoes like a lot of people. I was given samples of OSU Blue P20 way back around 2008 or 2010 or something like that. And they were very interesting. That breeding line from Oregon State University eventually turned into what we know as today as 'Indigo Rose' and have spawned many breeding lines and projects (especially on tomato only forums). While the 'Indigo Rose' variety isn't terrible i think it can be greatly improved.
I've actually started growing LA1996 a pre-bred line which was used to breed 'Indigo Rose' and i find it to be excellent even just as it is! It does not have the recessive "atv" genes from Solanum cheesmaniae that help to combine and give a double dose of anthocyanin expression, but it does have the "Aft" gene for blue fruit. I have affectionately been calling this variety 'AFT' instead of LA1996. It is sort of odd in the fact that the blue fruit color is somewhat muted without the 'atv' genes. It sort of looks like a diseased red tomato with blue-ish spots on top. To a regular consumer this might present a problem as it makes the fruit look diseased when it is not. But i found them to be an excellent variety for my garden, with my soils and conditions and found it to thrive when so many other tomatoes just die here. Not only did it do well it was determinate and had a decent amount of mid-to-large sized red tomatoes. Productive in my environment and productive considering it is a short determinate plant. A winner on all fronts.
That doesn't mean i don't want to use it in breeding projects and see if i can improve it, because i do. One cross i want to do is with my favorite tasting variety 'Anasazi' which also does well in my environment and has dark brown tomatoes with the "green shoulders" gene that helps to contribute to it's good flavor. This variety is indeterminate and is very prone to cracking. A fusion between the two could produce something really worth while, if only to my tastes.
Having the blue skin trait and good taste is something I am also trying for in my domestic tomatoes. I also want mine to be so short season I can direct seed them.
For good flavor which often means yellow colored I like the following:
Some plants of Blue Ambrosia
Coyote
Amethyst Cream
Yellow Pear
Some plants of Brad x Yellow Pear
Big Hill
Sungold
Many on this list are nearly short season enough and two have the blue gene at least partially.
My plan is to use two of these that already have the blue trait as the base, and make crosses with other either good tasting or early varieties until I have good tasting, blue, and early plants.
My first real tomato of the year was blue skinned bicolor F2. Semi promising.
The most vigorous and early variety in my tomato bed this year is Brad Gates' 'Black Beauty'. Thick trunks and heavy trusses, currently knocking spots off everything else. Slightly exerted stigma too, if I'm not mistaken.
@ William S
I trialled 18 yellow tomatoes for good production on my poor, clay soil. It was a summer that included drought and heat. Most died or produced poorly. Indigo Pear was outstanding, great taste and produced thru the heat and drought.
Probably widely available, I got my seed from Pinetree.
My original mother was slightly exserted and I pulled it from a JL landrance. The F1 was slightly exserted. The whole F2 growout has not been much exserted. Though I suspect stigmas are at the tip of the anther tube and not way up in there. The appearance of bicolor flesh suggests perhaps Blue Gold as the unknown grandfather. If so showing up this early suggests a huge improvement in earliness. Flavor seemed good.
The F3 of the Blue Gold? X unk Lofthouse Potato Leaf was good, going to advance the line with the best blue color. I think I will name it Mission Mountain Sunrise for the colors and local mountain range. Have an ounce of seed ordered and so will be growing it for seed this year. So there will be an isolation block with just it.
Future plans are to cross it with Big Hill and from there maybe with the promiscuous descendents of Big Hill. Then will allow that to cross with the extra hairy habrochaites line. Though it may not be that straightforward.
What I may do is plant four Big Hill seeds. Then surround one of those with Mission Mountain Sunrise. Then do this right next to the direct seeded row of promiscuous to hopefully varying degrees bicolors. Then plant the row of extra hairy habrochaites adjacent to the row of promiscuous bicolors. Add two one from each packet of the special 2020 Joseph selections from the promiscuous project and maybe a little block of the tomato I suspect was the exserted F1 of S. Pimpinillifolium x Golden Tressette and that may be my slushy tomato block this year.
William: That extra hairy habrochaites is also extra smelly. I don't have a clue which trait confers insect resistance. Perhaps both/and.
Quote from: Joseph Lofthouse on 2021-03-09, 01:44:30 AM
William: That extra hairy habrochaites is also extra smelly. I don't have a clue which trait confers insect resistance. Perhaps both/and.
I think the chemistry has been implicated. Though also the trichomes.
https://uknowledge.uky.edu/pss_etds/114/
My thought is to try to develop a promiscuous woolly blue bicolor with habrochaites cytoplasm.
Quote from: Joseph Lofthouse on 2021-03-09, 01:44:30 AM
William: That extra hairy habrochaites is also extra smelly. I don't have a clue which trait confers insect resistance. Perhaps both/and.
Does this mean you have started some seeds? I will start seeds next week during spring break.
I'm doing a small winter grow in my bedroom window.
Seeds that William sent.
Cuttings from the elites from last summer. I'm hoping just to keep them alive for another two months. The crosses are a bonus.
Continuing the experiment to grow one habrochaites, one peruvianum, and a bunch of pennellii. The seeds from the peruvianum mother flowered, and I spread pollen between different plants. They didn't set fruits. The flowers looked like regular peruvianum flowers. The pennelli phenotype was not obvious in the flowers or leaves of the offspring. If anything, the leaves look more like habrochaites with the repetitive leaflet pattern of large, tiny, medium, tiny, large.
Germination of the seeds was low from both the habrochaites and peruvianum mother (20%).
I don't remember if I reported that I grew one peruvianum plant in a field with 108 of the BHxW elite population. It did not set fruit.
Joseph I love that photo of a pot full of generation two of LA2329. Only two plants or so of the ten or so plants in generation one set any seed and I don't know why. They all flowered. The hab cytoplasm plants you sent were in the next row and set huge amounts of seed by comparison. Hopefully these G2 plants have gotten some pollen from others.
Quote from: Joseph Lofthouse on 2021-03-09, 01:44:30 AM
That extra hairy habrochaites is also extra smelly. I don't have a clue which trait confers insect resistance. Perhaps both/and.
I am not concerned about insects eating my tomatoes, but I'd love to develop some plants that deer will avoid. They don't eat squash plants because of the rough leaves, but don't mind all scented plants - they regularly eat my garlic leaves during the winter.
Deer leave my tomatoes alone fairly well probably mostly due to my neighbors roaming dogs but they did sneak attack the exserted orange last year.
I'm growing a few blue tomatoes this year for this purpose.
Taste depends on whoever is eating the tomato, so I'm going for what I like.
I don't like red tomatoes - "tangy" also isn't ideal to me. Lycopene appears to be my main dislike.
White tomatoes are fine - so are orange types, - yellow varieties are ok but it depends on other factors of the tomato.
Fruity types that are mostly sweet pair well with white - cream - orange varieties.
This is all in my opinion. Others here appear to share the same taste, which is nice for breeding purposes. A lot of people seem to just want red.
Some blue tomatoes I am growing this year:
Black Bumblebee Trial from J&L Gardens - I got this as a sample seed, not too sure about the tangy description but I will try it out. Bosque Blue is a parent, the description mentions that Black Bumblebee is 60 days from maturity when transplanting out. Which is rather early.
Wagner Blue Green from Bakercreek - I bought this last year and ended up with cherry tomato sized fruit - completely round as well. Bakercreek no longer sells this tomato, unsure what happened there. Could be that the variety has some different variants floating around or that they sold the variant? It tasted fine. Still using seed from last year, so I will probably get cherry tomato types again.
Blue Cream Berries from Bakercreek (Wild boar farms) - Another variety that I bought last year, this one dampened off - unsure of how it tastes. Reviews say super sweet, good flavor. There is also mention of splitting issues when ripe. Some reviews mention that they are bland, which could be due to lacking some typical tomato flavors. Won't know until I try it. The seeds also look quite small, seeds look almost identical to habrochaites / peruvianum or other wilds in appearance. Probably a recent cross.
Woolly Kate - Can't remember where I bought this from, seeds are in a plastic bag from maybe two years ago? These I remember died off because I had to go somewhere after transplanting them, and there was a heat wave which killed them. Anyways, the fruit, branches and leaves all apparently have "hairs". Different hairs from habrochaites, they still might work for bug resistance. This variety might work well as a base for a woolly blue tomato when adding habrochaties cytoplasm.
Most of these I am just using for breeding, or they are older seed I had laying around. Also note that some of these are Tom Wagner, Wild Boar, J&L - all sorts of different breeders made these varieties which may have a good bit of diversity. Different people may select for different traits after all.
Some of these might be planted around my Habrochaites x Pimpinellifolium F2 - hopefully some are exerted. Or they might go towards one of the promiscuous saladette types.
I would prefer to work on the flavor before crossing them to a larger type, cherry tomatoes are easier for me to grow during the winter.
OSU released a new blue tomato fairly recently. It's a roma. I wonder if the anthocyanin shows up when canned.
Midnight Roma: https://www.row7seeds.com/products/midnight-roma-tomato
A decent amount of seeds on the website say "We kindly request that those wishing to propagate or breed with these seeds for commercial purposes obtain a license from the breeder."
The section talking about their seeds says they never sell utility planted seed.
I would email and ask about anything that you purchase.
The blue would not be visible in the sauce but it does add some anthocyanin. Part of the reason Jim Myer's lab breeds blue tomatoes or promotes them is this nutritional benefit. Basically we eat a lot of tomatoes so adding some anthocyanin packs a nutritional punch. Roma is a traditional sauce tomato so this makes sense as an OSU introduction.
So I have a tomato line I am calling Mission Mountain Sunrise that is a small early blue bicolor. I just dropped the paper OSSI registration form in the mail yesterday. So eventually it will be OSSI registered. It is a fun tomato.
One thing though I suspect it probably is determinate and that is part of where it gets its earliness. If determinate tomatoes really don't taste as good as indeterminate and dwarf tomatoes, it might make sense to make a cross with a dwarf. Wonder what happens when you cross a dwarf and a determinate? I don't think it is safe to say that dwarf, determinate, and indeterminate are alleles.
Figured that I would post an image or so of early - cold stressed antho fruit.
The plant itself is still purple - not noticing any new growth either. Was surprised to see flowers.
I had these marked down as Blue Cream Berries - there are some Wooly Kates that seem permanently stunted as well - no flowers / new growth on those plants.
I had regular plants that were cold stressed - but still recovered. The anthocyanin showing up after exposure to cold temperatures is interesting.
Purple Smudge seems the same.
Unsure if cold tolerant projects would interfere with Anthocyanin tomato projects. I will do a few tests next year.
On the flip side - these tomatoes are covered up by weeds and still showing decent amounts of anthocyanin in the fruits.
https://www.edp24.co.uk/things-to-do/food-reviews/john-innes-centre-purple-tomatoes-heading-for-usa-8553956
GMO blue tomato seeds may be available in the U.S. soon. As well as actual fruit in stores?
May or may not be patented over here. Article doesn't mention. I would assume so, but this is still pretty interesting.
Isn't it encouraging to see countries co-operating in the name of progress?
One country says 'We've got a brilliant idea, but our population is DEEPLY unsure about it. Please can we try it out on your population?'
The other country says 'Sure. ... use our population as guinea pigs.'
Now all we need is the same self sacrificing responses to Climate Change.
I wonder whether anyone in Norwich has tasted them fresh?
If they did, I wonder what special precautions were taken regarding processing those peoples subsequent bowel movements!!
Tim DH
Quote from: Garrett Schantz on 2021-12-14, 01:29:59 AM
https://www.edp24.co.uk/things-to-do/food-reviews/john-innes-centre-purple-tomatoes-heading-for-usa-8553956
GMO blue tomato seeds may be available in the U.S. soon. As well as actual fruit in stores?
May or may not be patented over here. Article doesn't mention. I would assume so, but this is still pretty interesting.
"If approved, it was possible that seeds of the purple tomato varieties might be available to gardeners and growers in the American market from the early spring, she said."
Whoa no one ever releases GMO to home gardeners. Always keep it patented and under wraps. Here come the snap dragon genes?
I poked around a little on the websites of John Innes Centre and BigPurpleTomato and found no confirmation of the above quote from the article. They did say in older materials that they would produce juice only with no seed sold to keep the GMO genetics controlled. Regulatory approval to sell seed to home gardeners would be very different. If they sell fresh fruit with seed in it they might as well sell seed packets.
I'm not entirely opposed to the idea. Would be lovely if they could prove it safe, then extra lovely if they would just release it without patents. Then I could breed with it!
In a similar vein the GMO version of resistant American Chestnuts might be released soon and that is intended for release into the wild.
Speaking of the wild- I wonder how long before wild tomato populations would be contaminated by the gmo tomato and what if any impact that would have?
I like that it isn't GMO for herbicide or pesticide resistance.
Snapdragon genes is a little weird to me though because I don't typically look at my snapdragon plants and think of food. Wonder how they inserted the transgenes also. I like the potential of the new gene editing technology. I would have the least qualms about them gene editing a tomato with the genes for all the way through purple fruit from a tomatillo. Vs. old school insertion of rando snapdragon genes but still it might be an ok thing. Better than that escaped roundup resistant Agrostis.
I wonder if targeted mutation could activate the pathways for purple flesh in tomato. It is just possible that this same effect could be found in a natural way.
Found an older article talking about this particular team.
http://www.norfolkplantsciences.com/bbc-news-purple-tomato-may-boost-health/
Quote from: William S. on 2021-12-14, 09:09:00 AM
Whoa no one ever releases GMO to home gardeners. Always keep it patented and under wraps. Here come the snap dragon genes?
I'm not entirely opposed to the idea. Would be lovely if they could prove it safe, then extra lovely if they would just release it without patents. Then I could breed with it!
In a similar vein the GMO version of resistant American Chestnuts might be released soon and that is intended for release into the wild.
Speaking of the wild- I wonder how long before wild tomato populations would be contaminated by the gmo tomato and what if any impact that would have?
I like that it isn't GMO for herbicide or pesticide resistance.
Snapdragon genes is a little weird to me though because I don't typically look at my snapdragon plants and think of food. Wonder how they inserted the transgenes also. I like the potential of the new gene editing technology. I would have the least qualms about them gene editing a tomato with the genes for all the way through purple fruit from a tomatillo. Vs. old school insertion of rando snapdragon genes but still it might be an ok thing. Better than that escaped roundup resistant Agrostis.
I wonder if targeted mutation could activate the pathways for purple flesh in tomato. It is just possible that this same effect could be found in a natural way.
https://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-25885756
"The purple pigment is the result of the transfer of a gene from a snapdragon plant - the modification triggers a process within the tomato plant allowing the anthocyanin to develop."
Hopefully a mutation could cause something similar, like you said.
I do feel like copying the Antho genes from black nightshade or something similar would be more welcomed by consumers.
Seems like they don't want to let seeds out, in order to prevent "contamination". Or, they don't want to lose money on something that they have tested / put a lot of money into.
I would really like to work with this tomato if seeds ever become available. Also makes me wonder if existing antho genes in some S. peruvianum accessions - other tomatoes, would increase the anthocyanin levels even more.
I'm also unsure of what tomato was used as a base for this. The main goal appears to be higher nutritional value / anti-cancer.
The Flavr Savr had a weak "parent", apparently didn't taste good. I would hope that these researchers can look back at that for example.
Yeah with Flavr savr the story I heard from at least one of my profs at Oregon state if I recall right is that they chose a bad flavored tomato to do the modification to. However there is a practical reason for that. Some varieties work better in tissue culture than others and it constrains work that has to be done in tissue culture.
The transgenic purple tomato websites I was looking at earlier did say they've been working on the conventional breeding side of it. That's an important part of it! Also precisely what sunk the flavr savr. If you or I or they could take that original flavr savr genetics and cross it with something tastier it could still be bred into a better product.
I wonder if blue cream berries and amethyst cream are the same?
Amethyst cream and Brad Gate's blue bicolors actually taste good. I found one plant of a segretating blue Indigo Kumquat F3? Mike sent that was good.
I bet exserted orange would be tasty with some blue on it if crossed to say my MMS line which I think tastes like a normal bicolor as do Brad Gates blue bicolors.
Quote from: Garrett Schantz on 2021-12-14, 01:29:59 AM
https://www.edp24.co.uk/things-to-do/food-reviews/john-innes-centre-purple-tomatoes-heading-for-usa-8553956
GMO blue tomato seeds may be available in the U.S. soon. As well as actual fruit in stores?
May or may not be patented over here. Article doesn't mention. I would assume so, but this is still pretty interesting.
https://www.newscientist.com/article/2309346-purple-superfood-tomato-could-finally-go-on-sale-in-the-us/amp/
Another article same thing.