Micro Dwarf Characterization

Started by KaguyaCloud, 2024-03-04, 08:28:49 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

KaguyaCloud

After growing 4 different types of micro dwarf varieties (Orange Hat, Vilma, Jochalos, Micro Tina), I have characterized the leaflet numbers, and flowering patterns of the micro dwarf plants I have grown in this diagram. Due note that I grew the micro dwarf varieties under at least 40,000 lux on the top of the canopy for 15 hours per day, as leaflet number does change with light levels:

https://i.imgur.com/0mIVOVz.png

From what I've observed so far, micro dwarfs immediately terminate at 2 flower trusses after growing a set number of leaves. There is no alternating between leaf and flowering truss before terminating like in regular determinates, which may be one way of selection in the F2 generation.

I have also noticed that micro dwarf tomatoes with a 1/3/5 pattern in the first 5 leaves tend to be much smaller than micro dwarf varieties with a 3/5/7 pattern. However, despite the difference in size, the early termination of the main stem is the same. Side shoots, however, behave like the flower and leaf pattern of a regular determinate, with the exception being that the axillary shoots grows 1-3 leaves before alternating in flowers and leaf trusses.

So there seems to be several genes governing micro-dwarf tomato morphology:

The determinate gene(sp), a recessive gene which causes termination of the main stem by ending the last shoot in a flower truss. Located in chromosome 6.

The dwarf gene(d), a recessive gene which causes shortened internodes and dark green rugose leaves due to a mutation that causes less brassinosteroid hormone from being produced. Located in chromosome 2.

The combination of both does not equate to a micro dwarf unfortunately, as there are tomato varieties that have both and grow 2-4ft(0.6-1.2m) tall.

Then we have a list of unknown phenotypes that are currently in progress of being characterized. Due note that these characteristics could be phenotypes that work in conjunction of the dwarf gene, the determinate sp gene, or each other:

Early termination gene: This causes the main stem to terminate into 2 flower trusses after growing a set number of leaves. Based off of this article, it seems that this gene may be co-dominant as the F1 shows an intermediate flowering characteristics of Micro-Tom and the determinate cultivar M82 in figure 2:
https://www.plantbreedbio.org/journal/view.html?uid=731&&vmd=Full

Internode shortening: It is unknown what causes the extreme stature of micro dwarf tomatoes. However, when Micro-Tom is introgressed with the non-dwarf D gene, it still remains around 14 inches tall. So there seems to be something that is causing a shortened stature, which may be connected to repressed secondary leaflet growth on the leaves: https://www.esalq.usp.br/tomato/Dwarf.pdf

A leaf reducing gene: Based off the F1 cross I am growing, this is a recessive gene. This causes the leaf pattern to reduce from a 3/5/7 pattern to a 1/3/5 pattern in the first 5 or so leaves. This characteristic is not necessary to make a micro dwarf, but it does make it considerably smaller and compact in size. This might be a means of classifying different micro dwarf plants.




Sledgehammer Potato

Micro tomatoes sure have some interesting genetics and are fun to use in breeding projects and for teaching.  There are at least three genes needed for a tomato to be a micro dwarf, you seemed to have missed one. 

Quote from: KaguyaCloud on 2024-03-04, 08:28:49 PMHowever, when Micro-Tom is introgressed with the non-dwarf D gene, it still remains around 14 inches tall.

I am not sure the parentage you used for your crosses to get this result.  I have crossed Micro Tom with a regular size tomato a number of times, the F1 were usually about 5 feet tall under field conditions.  I tend to use Micro Tom as the seed parent because I am a little clumsy and it is easy to cull early if the cross didn't work. 

I may be wrong, but believe Micro Tom has the dwarfing gene d, with a slight mutation.  From what I have read it has the self pruning gene which is responsible for creating determinate tomato plants, which as you mentioned is most likely sp. 

What you seem to have missed is that Micro Tom, and all micro dwarf tomatoes, also have the sun dwarf gene.  This creates extremely short internodes under high light intensities, it is most likely sd. 

When homozygous for all three you get micro dwarf tomatoes.  Other than that you end up with regular dwarf, or even full size plants. 

KaguyaCloud

#2
Quote from: Sledgehammer Potato on 2024-03-07, 07:48:23 PMI am not sure the parentage you used for your crosses to get this result.  I have crossed Micro Tom with a regular size tomato a number of times, the F1 were usually about 5 feet tall under field conditions.  I tend to use Micro Tom as the seed parent because I am a little clumsy and it is easy to cull early if the cross didn't work. 

I used micro-dwarf Jochalos and indeterminate Rosella Cherry as parents.

Several articles indicate that crossing a micro with a determinate leads to a 1:27 ratio of showing micro phenotype in the F2 generation:
https://plantmethods.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/1746-4811-6-23
https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/pdf/10.1046/j.1365-313x.1997.12061465.x

This leads to the possibility of 2 recessive traits + 2 dominant traits.


Ah, introgression means that you select one trait in the F1/F2, then backcrossed with the original parent for several generations until it's statistically 99% likely that the progeny has the original genes except the one you selected for. There is a website that shows micro-tom introgressed with other genes and this is what it looks like with the dominant D:
https://www.esalq.usp.br/tomato/Dwarf.pdf
Full website here: https://www.esalq.usp.br/tomato/

At the moment, I've grown the F1 cross at 13 days and it's already showing flower buds. Based off my observations, leaf reduction is incompletely dominant and internode length is strongly dominant. The F1 height is 9cm tall and showing flower buds. Compared to Jochalos(7.5cm) and Rosella Cherry(25cm) growing at that height with flower buds. Although measuring height for an indeterminate is quite difficult to determine, as they don't really have a limit as long as conditions do not kill them. At the moment, I'm measuring just the height to the first set of flowers as reference.


This is what I've found for Sun Dwarf:
Select for the sun dwarf gene under "Locus Name" https://tgrc-mvc.plantsciences.ucdavis.edu/Genes/search
"heterozygote is intermediate, but sometimes difficult to distinguish from +"

I'm unsure if it's the sun dwarf gene that is making micro-dwarfs compact. Do we have any scientific articles proving that this is the case?

Sledgehammer Potato

It seems rather odd that you used rosella cherry as a parent yet only had 16 inch tall plants in the F1.  Are you certain about the parentage and that there was no possibility of stray pollen getting in? 

All the F1 crosses I grew reached about 5 feet tall, it wasn't until F2 that there were any dwarf or micro dwarf showing segregating out from the population. 

This paper https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16687436/ mentions Micro Tom having a mutated form of dwarf (d) as well self pruning (sp). 

I note some of your research has determined that "an unidentified miniature recessive gene" is responsible for shortened internode leaf length.  Micro Tom carries sd, it was used to breed all micro dwarf tomatoes so would stand to reason that sun dwarf is likely the recessive gene making all the other micro dwarfs so compact. 

Without using anything from work and getting myself in trouble, it appears there is not a lot of publicly available information on sun dwarf anymore.  One of the universities, UC Davis I think, used to have a fair bit of information, from memory a few others did too, but that has all disappeared from the internet for some reason. 
 
I googled and found this on sun dwarf:
Appeared in cultures of G. C. Hanna. Of special interest is the complete dependence of sd upon the environment for its expression. Throughout the late fall, winter, and early spring, growth is entirely normal. The following phenotype is exhibited by sd/sd during the rest of the year, reaching its greatest extreme in early and midsummer. Exposed stems greatly stunted, internodes often being less than 1 cm in length. Stems somewhat constricted above the nodes, showing here a brownish discoloration at first, scar tissue later. New shoots from base of plant grow normally until they break through the chick canopy of foliage. Net effect on whole plant is general stunting and extremely compact growth. All exploratory tests to date indicate that expression of sd is limited by intensity of light within the range of the visible spectrum. Additive and subtractive tests with UV and infrared seem to have no effect. Normal fertility and fruitfulness. Heterozygote intermediate but sometimes difficult to distinguish from+, sd thus being best managed as a recessive. F2 seg. 251+ : 95 sd. Classification good in the proper environment.

KaguyaCloud

#4
I'm using Rosella Cherry as the parent and only getting 9cm(3.5 inch) F1 plants that are at the beginning stages of flowering at 13 days since the cotyledons opened up from the soil.

There'no doubt that the F1 will grow taller since it should be heterozygous for the indeterminate gene. I'm very sure there's almost no chance of stray pollen causing an unintentional cross, as I am growing and crossing these plants indoors and Rosella Cherry is my only regular leaf tomato. The rest of my varieties are determinate micro dwarfs. In addition, I used Jochalos as the seed parent to indicate a successful cross.

The Jochalos x Rosella F1 has regular, non rugose leaves and the leaves have the same chocolate-like aroma in the leaves like Rosella Cherry with slight hints of the citrus aroma from Jochalos. However, they have very short internodes and intermediate leaflets numbers between the parents. I have also taken pictures and documented the whole process of crossing, obtaining fruit and growing out the F1. But I will need to compile everything first.

If all that is needed is being homozygous for all 3 recessive genes, then there should be a 1 in 64 chance that a micro phenotype. However, 5+ articles I've read about F2 crosses,  it seems that the 1:27 ratio keeps popping up or referenced multiple times.

https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/pdf/10.1046/j.1365-313x.1997.12061465.x
QuoteMicro-Tom was crossed with UC82, a determinate cultivar...Six out of 176 F2 plants analysed were clearly of the Micro-Tom type.

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0168945204002079
QuoteIt was observed that the hypocotyls length was a good indicator of the dwarfism in Micro-Tom. Thirty one out of 861 seedlings were selected based on hypocotyl length. These figures represent a 1:27 proportion (or a 1/28 ratio), which may be attributed to the requirement of two recessive and two dominant genes (1/4 × 1/4 × 3/4 × 3/4) to produce the Micro-Tom phenotype.

That's really strange that sun dwarf related articles just disappeared from the internet. Or maybe it's the search function that's not working well. If the sun dwarf gene is as you say, then hopefully selection is easier. I am growing under grow lights after all.

Maf

The full text of the same paper referenced above that investigated d and sp in Micro Tom, Genetic and physiological characterization of tomato cv. Micro-Tom suggests that miniature (mnt) is believed to be one of the genes contributing to the micro size, but this was not proven in the article.
QuoteIt has been suggested, based on its pedigree, that the phenotype of Micro-Tom is the result of two major recessive mutations: dwarf (d) and miniature (mnt) (Meissner et al., 1997).
QuoteIn summary, the phenotype of Micro-Tom plants is due to at least three mutations. The characterization of two of them, sp (producing a determinate phenotype) and d (reducing internode length and producing smaller, rugose, and dark-green leaves as a result of reduced BR content), has been carried out in this work. In addition, Micro-Tom has another mutation (putative mnt), still uncharacterized and that does not affect GA metabolism but which is likely to be associated with GA signalling.

KaguyaCloud

Luckily I had this thread cached in my computer, so I will post lost data as of 41 hours ago.

KaguyaCloud

QuoteThe full text of the same paper referenced above that investigated d and sp in Micro Tom, Genetic and physiological characterization of tomato cv. Micro-Tom suggests that miniature (mnt) is believed to be one of the genes contributing to the micro size, but this was not proven in the article.

Correct. There only really seems to be mentions of "putative mnt" without really much detail. As of now, I cannot find much evidence in what exactly determines the micro-phenotype. I'm hoping selecting and recording the F2 generation personally will at least determine something. And in most of the crosses I have seen in these research articles, sp doesn't seem to be a common variable, as the majority of the crosses are already with the sp gene.

This is the only article I can find about researching the genetics of micro tom:
https://academic.oup.com/pcp/article/55/2/445/1860269
Quote
The dwarf mutation was identified in the DWARF gene (Solyc02g089160) that encodes Cyt P450 protein, or deoxocastasterone oxidase, as a single base substitution in the 3′ end of intron 8 (Marti et al. 2006). The corresponding locus, SL2.40ch02:45624583, is a T in 'Micro-Tom' and an A in 'Heinz 1706' (Supplementary Table S1). The self-pruning mutation was identified in the SELF-PRUNING gene (Solyc06g074350) as a non-synonymous single base substitution (Pnueli et al. 1998). The corresponding locus, SL2.40ch06:42362242, is a T in 'Micro-Tom' and a C in indeterminate cultivars (Pnueli et al. 1998). In 'Heinz 1706', this locus is a T, since 'Heinz 1706' also carries the self-pruning mutation.

Which means that the sp gene that micro tom has is pretty much similar to the normal sp gene. All the crosses I've referenced seemed to be a cross between a micro and a determinate, so I'm wondering if sp could even be counted as a factor that causes dwarfing. Although, it does aid in terminating the main stem, which leads to shorter overall stature.

KaguyaCloud

MAF responded:
"Yes, clearly sp is not directly causing any miniaturisation in terms of internode length or size of parts. What it is contributing is the compact habit (less leaf nodes per flower cluster) that is obviously very useful in a micro.

Several articles reference mnt in Micro-Tom, so would consider it a fairly safe bet, maybe?

I don't like the idea of sun dwarf, sounds more like a defect to be avoided rather than a useful trait.

When growing "full sized" indeterminate tomatoes pruned to a single stem in the greenhouse it is clear that different varieties have different internode lengths that may vary by 5, 10 or 20%. Mutations which have a large effect on internode length such as brachytic (br) (~50% reduction) have been researched and documented, but it is possible that there are some (many?) undocumented mutations that have a lesser effect on height. They may be fairly insignificant by themselves and so would tend to fly under the radar. Who knows how many such minor mutations have made their way into micro tomatoes?" 

KaguyaCloud

#9
QuoteSeveral articles reference mnt in Micro-Tom, so would consider it a fairly safe bet, maybe?

They may be fairly insignificant by themselves and so would tend to fly under the radar. Who knows how many such minor mutations have made their way into micro tomatoes?

The issue with mnt is that this gene is putative, meaning that it is believed to exist. Here's an article from 2016 stating that it has yet to be characterized:
https://www.nature.com/articles/srep20454
QuoteBased on its pedigree, the phenotype of Micro-Tom plants is due to at least three mutations: self-pruning (sp), dwarf (d) and miniature (putative mnt)29,30. The characterization of one of them, putative mnt, has still been not clarified.

I found something interesting on one side of the Micro-Tom's parentage.
https://www.academia.edu/56664919/Comprehensive_Resources_for_Tomato_Functional_Genomics_Based_on_the_Miniature_Model_Tomato_Micro_Tom
QuoteThe miniature and dwarf S. lycopersicum cultivar Micro-Tom (TGRC accession # LA3911) was bred for home gardening purposes by crossing cv. Florida Basket and Ohio4013-3 [46].

https://tombreeding.ifas.ufl.edu/pdf/Accomp98.pdf
Quote
Quote"-Florida Basket were the first dwarf(d gene) cultivars released by the Univ. of Florida."

Someone kindly took progress images of growing the variety "Florida Basket":
https://www.gardentags.com/profile/abbeyj/solanum-lycopersicum-florida-basket/624309

Based on the structure of the mainstem, it seems that Florida Basket has the dwarf gene. However, it does not terminate early, as the main stem produced more leaves and another truss of flowers like a normal determinate would. That being said, the stature is still quite compact. It's possible that Florida Basket contributed the dwarf gene. However, it did not contribute a gene that causes the main stem to terminate into 2 flower trusses. This would suggest that early flower termination may be independent of the  dwarf gene and the sp gene.

Oh this is very interesting. I found an article on Micro-Tom and Micro-Gold, which described the parentage of Florida-Basket and the Ohio 4013-3 lines.
https://eurekamag.com/research/002/159/002159940.php
Quote
Micro-Tom, tested as Fla.7191, was developed by increasing seed in the F12 generation from a cross between Florida Basket (which segregates for Fusarium resistance) and Ohio 4013-3 (the source of diminutive leaf and fruit characters). Micro-Tom is short, compact and dwarf with small leaflets, and a more prostrate growth habit than other dwarf tomatoes making it suitable for growth in hanging baskets.

https://journals.ashs.org/hortsci/view/journals/hortsci/30/3/article-p643.xml?tab_body=pdf
Quote
QuoteBoth parents have closely related Ohio lines (Ohio 4014-4 and Ohio 4013-3) in their background, which provided the miniature plant, leaf, and fruit sizes. The dwarf character of the parent lines was derived from 'Florida Petite' or 'Florida Basket', which were earlier dwarf tomato releases from the Univ. of Florida.
There it is, the confirmation on the origins of the micro trait. The Ohio lines seem to provide the further unknown miniature traits that are independent of the dwarf gene and also provide reduced leaf and fruit size as well. It's possible Ohio 4013-3 has the genes for early flower termination and leaf reduction.

Found another article explaining the characteristics by searching for "Fla.7191" instead of Micro Tom on page 8:
https://swfrec.ifas.ufl.edu/docs/pdf/veg-hort/tomato-institute/proceedings/ti86_proceedings.pdf
Quote
QuoteFlorida 7191 is the number we assigned to this miniature dwarf tomato. Not only does it have the short internodes and reduced growth rate characteristics of dwarf tomatoes, but leaf and fruit size have also been reduced.

KaguyaCloud

#10
MAF responded:
QuoteThe issue with mnt is that this gene is putative, meaning that it is believed to exist
The author of the quoted paper is using putative in this context to indicate that it is supposed or commonly accepted (but not 100% proven) that "based on its pedigree" mnt is the extra size reduction factor in Micro-Tom, not that there is any doubt over whether mnt exists or not. TGRC have it listed and mapped to the long arm of chromosome 11. While it is true there are no modern studies explaining exactly how mnt works, there can be no doubt that it actually exists.

KaguyaCloud

That's a good catch, I must've missed that important detail while going through the Meissner article. If Ohio-4013-3 or Florida Basket did have lineage towards a cultivar with the currently known mnt gene, it cannot be ruled out as a possibility. Reading through the TGRC description of the gene, the mnt gene in chromosome 11 does seem to line up with the smaller micro varieties I have grown. They seem to have a tendency to not produce axillary buds until after they set flowers.

If it is the case that mnt may be one, then we can actually construct the potential 4 theoretical genes that make up the micro-dwarf phenotype that is characterized in Micro-Tom:

Dwarf(d): Compact growth habit, rugose leaves
Miniature(mnt): Reduced branching, short internodes

Leaf reduction: Reduces leaflet number by 2 leaflet nodes in the first 5 leaves. This gene can exist independently as the micro-dwarf variety Vilma has minimal leaf reduction but early termination of the main stem.
Early termination: After a certain number of leaves, the main stem ends in 2 flower trusses. This gene may be co-dependent with self-pruning in order to function.

KaguyaCloud

#12
MAF responded:
Also, I meant to add that the TGRC page for Micro-Tom says in the comments "May contain the gene mnt (miniature)."

It is a shame that the original 1989 paper/article about Micro-Tom by the breeders does not seem to be available on the internet.

KaguyaCloud

I swear the internet has everything about Micro-Tom except for the 1989 paper that everyone seems to be referencing. The following links have more descriptions and even quotes from the original breeders. However there isn't anything new other than the the breeders of Micro-Tom stating that it was the smallest variety they've known and the reduced leaf characteristics.

1989 news article on Micro-Tom: https://ufdc.ufl.edu/UF00028309/03398/images/2
1991 news article on Micro-Tom: https://ufdc.ufl.edu/UF00028309/03463/images/4

KaguyaCloud

#14
Had to pay $30 to have someone scan it, but I finally got access to the original document for "Micro-Tom. A miniature dwarf tomato" overall it's brief, but interesting. I'm posting it for free because, I feel that the internet should have this:
https://files.catbox.moe/7p01cd.pdf

So it seems like Micro-Tom, while not the first small dwarf variety, is the first known variety with proportional characteristics in terms of fruit, leaf, and stature. I find it amusing that Micro-Tom is called a miniature tomato, while Red Robin is just classified as a dwarf with short internodes. It seems that the classification Micro-dwarf might've been derived from the characteristics of Micro-Tom originally, but has been loosened over time to refer to smaller tomato varieties with the dwarf gene.

For the time being, I cannot say for certain that micro-dwarf varieties have a firm definition now even after reading through the article. At the very least, we can be very sure that tomato varieties expressing reduced leaflet counts and early stem termination are indeed micro-dwarfs to start with. For breeding micro varieties, this may make it easier to discern between the different phenotypes expressed in the F2 generation. Sub-classifications could be used to define different types of Micro dwarfs.