Ideal outdoor tomato for cool cloudy farming?

Started by Justin Jardinier, 2024-01-29, 04:32:04 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Justin Jardinier

I would love to hear people's opinion of an ideal tomato for outdoor growing for small farms or market gardens in cool cloudy northerly environments. In particular, whether that would be determinate; indeterminate; or dwarf, whether rugose or any other form of dwarf. (I'm not really thinking of mechanised harvesting, though welcome to speak up if you think I should be considering that).

I've heard best for outside is determinate, since they are shorter and don't require much de-suckering or support, that indeterminates are more suited to high tunnels (such as in the video of the late blight breeding professor's talk I shared recently). And I've been wondering that dwarfs might cover those advantages, while being indeterminate. Then also, a friend in such conditions said indeterminates are better than determinates (we did not mention dwarfs in the conversation) because of disease, and that they will replace damage leaves with more growth. Though, when thinking of an 'ideal' tomato, I am really thinking of one with high disease resistance - basically, trying to breed what would be ideal, so, I don't know whether that would apply if we can get good enough disease resistance.

So far I have been using all 3 types in my crosses, but perhaps a bit more focus could be beneficial, or that's what I am starting to wonder anyway.

Any other input on this topic of an ideal tomato would also be most welcome. Including suggestions for the best balance of larger size with enough earliness to be used for increasing size and earliness for interspecific hybrids under these conditions as a method for moving towards this ideal.

Thanks!

William Schlegel

#1
My mom strongly rejects determinates, she likes the big end of the season harvest of green tomatoes that will slowly ripen. It is an important gardening tradition for her.

I've expanded to all three traits, and I was very pleased with Krainy Sever a determinate dwarf I grew in 2017. It did well direct seeded and kept its fruit off the ground nicely. I finally made a cross with it in 2023. I no longer think that all dwarfs are equal in this potential to keep fruit off the ground nicely. Some do though!

I do think indeterminates may retain some robustness of growth that could be important. You can get earliness with any combination of the three traits.

I think my odd thin topsoil over a clay accumulation layer and short season makes smaller plants fairly desirable. I think Mission Mountain Sunrise may be genetically small. Likewise, I think many of the tomatoes out of past regional tomato breeding programs in Idaho, North Dakota, and Alberta may have produced genetically small plants. The few Montana bred varieties I found and tried in 2023 also seemed small and at least one of them was a cross with the regionally bred varieties. Though this may be confounded by my soil which keeps plants small.

I do grow a few plants inside the backyard greenhouse and if indeterminate those can get huge. Though I grow all three types outside. I would say that there are some early indeterminates and those may be worth seeking out.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Steph S

I only grew one dwarf - Al Kuffah. (It was indeterminate and required as much support as any). It was early in my greenhouse and production on par with determinates and indeterminates.  But in the field trial at the farm, which included determinate and indeterminate earlies as well, it performed worst of all due to much slower ripening in the cooler temperatures. I got the impression that dwarf metabolism is slower and that can mean slower ripening in the cool, so I steered away from them. Obviously I missed out on some much earlier dwarfs like Krainy Sever. But I have heard other growers comment that they found dwarfs too slow for their climate as well, so if you do dwarfs, choose carefully or expect to select hard for a speedier metabolism.  I grew a micro too - Red Dwarf - both indoors and out - and while I loved the sturdy self-supporting growth habit it was obviously too small to be much of a producer.
All of my plants, both determinate and indeterminate, are more compact and sturdy outdoors.  However the outdoor environment is windy as well as cool, and all tomatoes benefit from (or need) some kind of support. At the field trial at the farm, we used small cages for all types, and was more or less adequate.

Ultimately I think the choice of growth habit depends on the support structure preferred by the farmer and whether or how much shelter is required.  Single stem indeterminates make the best use of vertical space, where high tunnel or greenhouse space is expensive therefore limited and must be tuned for maximum output.

Determinates are my preference because they are the 'no pruning' option, and with the thought that a less expensive structure could be designed to provide a bit of shelter and season extension. 

Ferdzy

I grow tomatoes outside only. While we may have cloudy weather much of the rest of the year, summers are usually clear not to say droughty.

However, I will note that I prefer indeterminates, the larger and leggier the better. That's because we get septoria leaf spot, a fungus which starts at the bottom of the plant and works its way up. Nothing seems to be resistant to it; it's out-grow it or bust. It is of course worse in cool, cloudy (which is to say rainy) summers as it gets splashed up onto the leaves more.

Justin Jardinier

#4
Quote from: William Schlegel on 2024-01-29, 05:53:38 AMMy mom strongly rejects determinates, she likes the big end of the season harvest of green tomatoes that will slowly ripen. It is an important gardening tradition for her.

That's interesting. For farming I guess that could mean to have some lines for such purpose. Makes sense to grow different types so can supply the market through a longer overall season. I have also been wondering about 'longkeepers'. When I was looking into Tim Peters I noticed he had made some, like Golden Treasure and Winter Gold, which sounded interesting, though no idea how they would do in this kind of climate.

Interesting about Krainy Sever. I suppose crossing large fruited dwarfs with wilds might potentially end up with something similar in some respects to that small fruited dwarf perhaps.
[Edit: That university page gets its information from seed catalogues, hence claiming Stupice is resistant against late blight when that resistance seems pretty irrelevant by now, plus they have loads of F1s under 'heirloom' category so I guess all in all that is not a reliable list, sorry about that.]

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2024-01-29, 05:53:38 AMI think my odd thin topsoil over a clay accumulation layer and short season makes smaller plants fairly desirable.

Do you get much rain? I guess I am wondering if this is still the case in cloudy rainy places. Especially with the habits of stripping off all the lower leaves. I wonder how easy it would be to breed enough disease resistance to not need to do that. Though having said that, last year I let all my wilds do exactly what they wanted to, densely planted, and I didn't even remove any lower leaves of my domestics, and hardly did much sucker removal on most of them either, and aside from late blight there didn't seem to be much issues - the wilds all did fine aside from the loss of one or two peruvianums, and the domestics mostly did well aside from some browning of some leaves more on some than others. But maybe this changes from season to season.

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2024-01-29, 05:53:38 AMI do grow a few plants inside the backyard greenhouse and if indeterminate those can get huge.

Do you water those? I wonder if to water or not to water might be critical to this question. My aim really was to make tomatoes to never be watered aside from when initially planting out. So maybe I should think about height and manageability in terms of that specific condition, though that could be fairly variable from year to year and month to month with weather patterns and local microclimates, and soil types.

Quote from: Steph S on 2024-01-29, 07:21:02 AMI only grew one dwarf - Al Kuffah. (It was indeterminate and required as much support as any). It was early in my greenhouse and production on par with determinates and indeterminates.  But in the field trial at the farm, which included determinate and indeterminate earlies as well, it performed worst of all due to much slower ripening in the cooler temperatures. I got the impression that dwarf metabolism is slower and that can mean slower ripening in the cool, so I steered away from them.

I wonder if that might be related to it coming from Iraq? Though from what you said about other reports, maybe a general dwarf thing. I will be curious to see how Uluru Ochre performs in terms of earliness with size reduction in cross. Earliness is so important here though, so, it will be key to see what potential dwarfism can have with earliness or not. Thanks for that.

Quote from: Steph S on 2024-01-29, 07:21:02 AMAll of my plants, both determinate and indeterminate, are more compact and sturdy outdoors.  However the outdoor environment is windy as well as cool, and all tomatoes benefit from (or need) some kind of support. At the field trial at the farm, we used small cages for all types, and was more or less adequate.

In the big farms, don't they just grow them straight on the ground? I think I have seen that from China, Italy, in the US also. Huge fields of them. Like this:



Though I did wonder if that can only suit rather dry areas?

Cages sound like a lot of work and money. I wonder how profitable that can be for a farm. I guess I'm thinking that maybe commercial tomatoes are bred to not need cages, just no support or support in a single line like I also see in some farms? For example:


Also, I was thinking that for short enough sturdy enough tomatoes even if they need support, perhaps a single stake each could be enough? Or those lines similar to a fence where they weave the stalks up through a few horizontal strings. I wonder perhaps the latter would be less work than individual stakes, and I wonder then, perhaps such support is necessary where the weather is not dry enough for none?

What you say about determinates not needing pruning, I guess maybe that is a major reason why they're preferred in farms by the sounds of it.

Has anyone actually grown any commercial tomato before? It would seem silly maybe because they must be quite inferior as fruits. I would be interested to grow some though, just as comparison in terms of their growth habit, yield performance etc.

Ferdzy thanks about septoria. I read Geranium Kiss has resistance against it. It's one I intend to cross with. There are a few on this list:
https://www.vegetables.cornell.edu/pest-management/disease-factsheets/disease-resistant-vegetable-varieties/disease-resistant-tomato-varieties/

Did you ever try any of those claimed to be resistant? I'd be curious if any said there to be resistant are sufficient or not in practice.

reed

#5
Quote from: Justin Jardinier on 2024-01-29, 08:59:22 AMThere are a few on this list:
https://www.vegetables.cornell.edu/pest-management/disease-factsheets/disease-resistant-vegetable-varieties/disease-resistant-tomato-varieties/

That's the same list I have used as reference, but as someone mentioned earlier it is just information from catalog descriptions rather than from them doing trials and so, pretty worthless. I am a bit curious about Garden Peach, it says LB resistant and if I remember right it is supposed to be fuzzy. I'm guessing fuzzy means it might have some wild genes still lurking around. I have grown some that are on that list and no, they were not resistant, to anything, that I noticed, except for Cherokee Purple which I already grew anyway.

Interesting that not many years ago they had a much shorter list of heirlooms with no F1s included, and my favored Mr. Stripy was on that shorter list, but it isn't on this one.

Justin Jardinier

Quote from: Justin Jardinier on 2024-01-29, 08:59:22 AMFerdzy thanks about septoria. I read Geranium Kiss has resistance against it. It's one I intend to cross with. There are a few on this list:
https://www.vegetables.cornell.edu/pest-management/disease-factsheets/disease-resistant-vegetable-varieties/disease-resistant-tomato-varieties/

Sorry I now realise that seems to be a really unreliable list. Also strange it puts so many F1's in the 'heirloom' category!

I hear Dr Martha Mutschler-Chu, a tomato breeder at Cornell University released breeding lines but maybe nothing to the public. Someone was saying Brandywise was good but was taken off the market, did that work for you? I also hear some habrochaites and peruvianum accessions are resistant:
QuoteA collection of 124 accessions was initially evaluated under greenhouse conditions. Ten accessions
were highly resistance (HR), whereas 33 were classified as having a resistant (R) response to S. lycopersici
isolates. Field evaluation was also conducted with a sub-set of accessions identified as either HR or R in the
greenhouse experiment. This field evaluation confirmed greenhouse tests and indicated the presence of some
potential sources of rate-reducing resistance. One highly resistant and eight resistant S. habrochaites accessions
were identified as being resistant under both conditions, confirming that this wild species is one of the most
promising sources of resistance to S. lycopersici. Five new sources with high levels of resistance were found in
S. peruvianum accessions (PI-306811, CNPH-1036, LA-1910, LA-1984 and LA-2744). One accession derived
from an interspecific cross between S. lycopersicum and S. peruvianum was also found to be highly resistant
and might be useful to introgress resistance factors from this wild species into cultivated tomato germplasm

Source: Resistance to Septoria lycopersici in Solanum (section Lycopersicon) species and in progenies of S. lycopersicum × S. peruvianum - Jaqueson Ferreira Satelis et al. - 2010

I also see:
QuoteAmong the accessions expressing the highest resistance level were several lines derived from the three-genomic hybrid (Isogenic line gf - Lycopersicon chilense LA 460 – L. peruvianum var. humifusum PI 127829) and the wild species L. pimpinellifolium LA 0722.
RESISTANCE COMPONENTS TO SEPTORIA LYCOPERSICI IN TOMATO - 2009

Quote from: reed on 2024-01-29, 09:58:13 AMThat's the same list I have used as reference, but as someone mentioned earlier it is just information from catalog descriptions rather than from them doing trials and so, pretty worthless.

Yes, sorry about that. I was just waiting to do more research before posting this in case I could find more details for septoria but I'll post it now.

Ferdzy

Of the tomatoes listed, I have grown:

Bellestar (correct spelling but hardly anyone does), Black Cherry, Cherokee Purple, Cosmonaut Volkov, Garden Peach, Great White, Green Zebra, Jaune Flammé, Matt's Wild, Mortgage Lifter, Stupice, and Wapsipinicon Peach (I think).

Lots of other tomatoes not listed. So far while all the tomatoes grown from the list have been healthy plants generally, the septoria marched up all of them at pretty much the exact same rate. Matt's Wild may have been slightly better than average but it's been a while and it didn't stand out very strongly.

I loved Bellestar, by the way. An early, productive determinate canning tomato bred for my climate exactly. But we can't grow it because it is too short and all the leaves get munged before the tomatoes have a chance to ripen. We first got some when a local farmer abandoned his mucky field of them because we had been having torrential downpours and he just couldn't get in to pick them. I don't think he thought they would be very good, but once we sloshed in there, pulled them out, and washed them, they were fine.

Justin Jardinier

Regarding septoria, this paper Resistance to Septoria lycopersici in Solanum (section Lycopersicon) species and in progenies of S. lycopersicum × S. peruvianum, the accession with 3rd highest resistance they say is peruvianum but it's actually arcanum, LA1984. And there's interesting info on that on the TGRC:
QuoteAccording to several informants = "CHAMBRAC", some say used as a flavor or tea, others claimed no use except feed for animals.


Roland

My ideal tomato can be grown in the field without support. Ripens early, is firm for mechanical harvesting but has plenty of soft flesh for texture. These plants will have to be extremely resistant and the fruits should not rot in the moist soil. The fruits contain little to no seeds and have a good taste. The skin is easy to peel and the core should be very narrow so that there is minimal pulp loss. And of course the plants also have to be extremely productive. Since insect populations are declining significantly, the flowers must also be self-pollinated by the wind.
Netherlands

William Schlegel

#10
I don't get much rain and I usually water my tomatoes inside and out. Except I stop and let the fruit ripen in the hottest driest months because tomatoes can handle being starved for water.

I experimented once with not watering and it did work- that year.

I am close enough to the pacific Northwest that varieties bred or recommended there do fine. Far enough away that some other climate tomatoes like Joseph's or those bred in North Dakota also do fine. I get occasional cool cloudy years but most are warmer and sunnier.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Justin Jardinier

Roland would the skin be thick then? I.e. to make it not rot on the ground, and be easy for peeling? Also, what is the destination for your ideal tomato? Some kind of processing?

Steph S

Justin, there's just no equivalency between my climate and the ones you mentioned. For one thing it's one of the windiest inhabited places on earth.  Also cool and wet, with a very short window of tomato optimal temperatures on the order of a couple of weeks.   Even with the climate change summers increasing that window to as much as 8 weeks, no one will ever grow rows of tomatoes in ground on a massive scale as shown in your image for mechanical harvest.  Tomatoes grown for the local market here are always in tunnels, as the risk of zero harvest outdoors is pretty close to 100%.
Our field trial was at an organic market garden farm (mixed vegetables) and amounted to one double row X 50 ft using black plastic mulch for maximum soil warmth and minimum splashing, using some cages that were on hand, having being used for determinates in greenhouse by the previous farmer, so least effort required for the experiment. 
I think a better choice for an outdoor tomato crop that is easy and doable would be to pound some stakes and put a roll of wire fencing up to tie the plants to, as they do for peas on this farm.  I doubt single stakes would be adequate.    It would also be possible to clip row cover onto the top of the wire, in case of catastrophic frost - which is never out of the question here, in any month of the year.
Larger scales and mechanical harvest are just not in the picture for us, but YMMV in the UK and maybe it's possible.

Justin Jardinier

Wow, so windy! No wonder the cages were used.

Quote from: Steph S on 2024-01-30, 07:28:31 AMI think a better choice for an outdoor tomato crop that is easy and doable would be to pound some stakes and put a roll of wire fencing up to tie the plants to, as they do for peas on this farm.  I doubt single stakes would be adequate. 

Thanks, yes that's what I was thinking might be best, unless he unsupported method might work here if disease resistance were strong enough. That thought has triggered me into looking more into strong septoria resistance and considering trying to integrate that into my populations. I guess I will try to keep both growing methods in mind as objectives.

Your climate sounds so extreme, I would guess maybe what tomatoes do well for you should do very well in the climate I described too!? What are the biggest nice tomatoes that you can grow there?

Jeremy Weiss

Just cloudy, or actually really rainy?

I ask because, when the question of tomatoes and heavy constant rains comes up, mention is usually made of the benefits of Nagcarlang, a black tomato from the Philippines that apparently has flowers that actively shed water (and so don't rot or fall off in heavy rain.) 

That tomato is for HOT humid weather, but, if you live somewhere rainy, it might be of used as a source for water resistant blossom genes to breed into a more cold tolerant one.