Tomato Cytoplasm

Started by Justin Jardinier, 2024-01-15, 06:44:46 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Justin Jardinier

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2024-01-15, 06:07:20 AMOnly cytoplasm that might be worth preserving is that of the current tomatoes.

William do you know of anything in particular we should be looking out for regarding cytoplasm? I have these now:
lyc
pimp
che
gal
arc
per

I might be getting pen (still not ripe) and might be able to get chil, I will try once my one remaining chil plant flowers. I could also try getting chm - I guess I would be more inspired to grow more chm if there was some indication it would be worth the effort of getting chm cytoplasm though so far I don't really know of any potential benefit to diverse cytoplasm, aside from some speculation that I read about maybe it being involved in some hab late blight resistance (and I'm not working much with hab, plus Joseph has already done amazing work with hab female line so I think it would be redundant of me to be doing that). I've made the others because it wasn't really much extra work to do so.

The first 4 are already edible and I have reciprocal crosses for some of those. Aside from difference in initial speed of development, in my indoor grow I'm not sure I notice any specific difference but not really sure what to look out for when it comes to outdoor growing - maybe they'd have some potential difference in disease resistance (which would be hard to know depending on which diseases would give hard pressure this year here, plus F2 will be so variable anyway) or maybe in terms of response to light or heat conditions? For those not edible yet, my main plan is just to continue with my diverse SI and UI projects and keep track of which are which cytoplasm line in case it will prove important for me or anyone later down the line, though potentially I could also try over a few generations to dilute some of them down to mostly lyc, thus able to offer basically a lyc with wild green species' cytoplasm, if that would be useful for folk. I could potentially do the same also for the 3 wild red/orange/yellow species.


William Schlegel

#1
I don't know anything more than Carol Deppe wrote about on the subject. Which in quick summary is that the more rarely used cytoplasm might be worth preserving to avoid homogeneity in the few cytoplasmic genes.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Justin Jardinier

Prompted by William, I'm looking into Breed Your Own Vegetable Varieties_ The Gardener's & Farmer's Guide to Plant Breeding & Seed Saving - Carol Deppe - 1993, 2000. Here are some quotes:

QuoteOnce in a while you can do a cross where one of the characteristics you are interested in is associated with a gene that is cytoplasmic instead of nuclear. Suppose you do a cross between a variety that has a mottled coloration pattern on the leaves and one that does not. If you cross a mottled female to a normal male, some or all of the F, plants are likely to be mottled. But if you cross a mottled male with a normal female, none of the F, plants will be mottled, nor will the offspring in any future generations.

The cytoplasm is relevant to us in additional ways. The cytoplasm of a variety and its nuclear genome have evolved to be compatible. When distant relatives are crossed, sometimes the cytoplasm and the nuclear genome of the FI or of some of the FZ progeny aren't compatible. In extreme cases lethality results. In less extreme cases the plant may be sterile or pollen-sterile. Malesterile cytoplasms have, in fact, been useful in the production of hybrids. Such cytoplasms aren't absolutely male-sterile; they are sterile only in the presence of one or more nuclear genes.

Anytime we are crossing two fairly distant relatives, we need to realize that the reciprocal crosses might be genuinely different. Both will give rise to the same nuclear genotype, but they will set it down in the middle of different cytoplasms. This could have a dramatic effect on the phenotype of the F, and subsequent generations.

These should be fairly easy to notice.

In the context of squash, she mentions:
Quote`Connecticut Field' germinates and grows better in cold weather and under low light conditions than most varieties. It is quite possible that those characteristics could involve genes in the cytoplasm. So I wanted the cytoplasm from `Connecticut Field'.

I have wondered about that, and whether some species from the South American mountains might therefore be useful for colder conditions, and conversely, whether the Galapagos species and some others might prove disadvantageous for light and temperature for Northern growers. But I guess the only way to know if there haven't been any studies, is to try.

She also mentions speculation about disease resistance but I don't see any additional info than what we had already on that.

Searching Principles of Plant Genetics and Breeding - George Acquaah - 2007, I find this which might be of interest for anyone growing potatoes from seed:
QuoteThose cultivated for a vegetative product. Important species vegetatively cultivated for a vegetative product include sweet potato, yam, cassava, sugarcane, and Irish potato. These species tend to exhibit certain reproductive abnormalities. For example, flowering is reduced, and so is fertility. Some species such as potatoes have cytoplasmic male sterility. Sometimes, flowering is retarded (e.g., by chemicals) in production (e.g., in sugarcane).

Presumably that means one could potentially still take advantage of useful genetics in a male sterile potato by using it as a pollen donor. Though it seems some potatoes have genetic male sterility, as opposed to cytoplasmic male sterility, so one ought watch out for that I guess.

Another quote:
QuoteGenetic basis of low-temperature stress tolerance

The capacity of a genotype to tolerate low temperatures has been extensively studied. Whereas it is agreed that low-temperature tolerance is a complex trait (quantitative), researchers are not unanimous on the mode of gene action governing the expression of the trait. Reports indicate recessive, additive, partial dominance, and overdominance as the modes of action that occur in nature for cold stress. The inconsistency in the results is partly blamed on the way research is often conducted. Some workers use controlled freeze tests while others use field tests. Further, various reports indicate the role of cytoplasmic factors and non-additive gene effects, even though such effects are generally believed to be minor.

That's all I cn find useful in that text. It was mostly talking about cytoplasm in the context of capitalist sterility traits, which is what I remember almost all sources only talking about the last time I tried researching this topic.

I found also this paper abstract:
Maternal and Genetic Effects on Seed Weight of Tomato, and Effects of Seed Weight on Growth of Genotypes of Tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum Mill.)
https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1111/j.1439-0523.1989.tb00343.x

QuoteA study was made on the inheritance of seed weight of tomato, and on the effect of seed weight on growth of tomato plants. Use was made of 15 parental genotypes and 105 F1s produced by diallel crossing (F1-seeds). From combining ability analysis of variance carried out for weight of F1-seeds it appeared that the weight of seeds harvested from tomato plants was mainly determined by the maternal genotype and largely independent of the genotype of the male parent. A combining ability analysis of variance for weight of seeds produced by seilfing F1's (F2-seeds) showed, however, that female and male parents contributed equally to the inheritance of seed weight and that the inheritance of seed weight is determined mainly by chromosomal additiveiy acting factors, but that also non-additive gene action occurred.

So far that has also been my experience.

This paper may be interesting to some, but it's only about lycopersicum:
INFLUENCE OF THE MATERNAL FACTOR IN THE CONTROL OF SOME
BIOLOGICAL CHARACTERS AND PRODUCTIVITY OF TOMATOES
https://ibn.idsi.md/sites/default/files/imag_file/47_50_2_2015.pdf

That's all I have had the time to find.