Domesticating shepherds purse

Started by A Horn, 2024-01-10, 05:42:13 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

A Horn

Capsella bursa-pastoris Seems to be most of the way to being domesticated already. It tastes similar to cress and is commonly eaten in japan china and korea, it grows rapidly on any disturbed ground and grows much larger when fertilized, and its seeds even eat nematodes!
But I can't find any listed cultivars

Steph S

I wonder how different the asian varieties are from our wild ones - looks pretty lush in the picture, sold as 'JiCai' seed:
https://www.etsy.com/ca/listing/1354224739/1000-shepherds-purse-seeds-ji-cai-jicai
There's a Korean sourced seed in the top row of links as well, which shows some very plump nice looking roots.
I would think there's been quite a bit of selection for agronomic traits, even if they don't have named varieties.   Recipes online look really good too. 
I admit I've never tasted it - our local ones are pretty scrawny.  I always thought it was a medicine more than a food.

Ferdzy

Now you guys have me going down the Shepherd's Purse rabbit hole. I've never tried it, although I've noted how good it smells, even as I pull it out and put it on the compost.

Here's a page with some info on it; I don't think it refers back to the recipe but I found it while looking at their recipe for Shepherd's Purse Tofu Soup. Chinese Vegetables: Leafy Greens You will need to scroll down to get to the part on Shepherd's purse.

The bit I particularly noted:
QuoteNowadays, shepherd's purse is cultivated, and it seems that everyone in Shanghai over 50 years old says the cultivated varieties don't come close to the strong aromatic flavors of the wild varieties they used to eat.

It sounds like a lot of work has happened in the last 50 years to develop it, but it also sounds like there is room for more. And also that like many things, as the plants become bigger and more tender, you may lose some flavour. Of course, lots of people prefer milder vegetables anyway, and the nostalgia for stronger ones may fade as the people who are more accustomed to it become fewer.

A Horn

Wow! So there is a lot being done to shepherd purse as a crop that I didn't know about. I will have to try growing those varieties and see what I think of them

Steph S

Well!  It would be hard to make a meal (or a crop) of the ones I've seen here, so bigger and tender would be good.  I guess the reduction in flavor can be plus or minus, depending on how strong they are to begin with, or whether it's used as a spice vs an actual bulky vegetable.
If they're following the old recipes with a less tasty bulkier plant, makes sense they would complain.

I think I'll have to sample whatever comes up in my garden this year.  I hadn't noticed a smell....
Definitely interested in a comparison with the cultivated varieties too, so keep me posted if anyone gets seeds to try.
There could certainly be room for some crossing to restore flavor to a larger cultivar.

Ciel Joiry

Quote from: Steph S on 2024-01-10, 06:35:34 PMI wonder how different the asian varieties are from our wild ones - looks pretty lush in the picture, sold as 'JiCai' seed:
https://www.etsy.com/ca/listing/1354224739/1000-shepherds-purse-seeds-ji-cai-jicai
There's a Korean sourced seed in the top row of links as well, which shows some very plump nice looking roots.
I would think there's been quite a bit of selection for agronomic traits, even if they don't have named varieties.  Recipes online look really good too. 
I admit I've never tasted it - our local ones are pretty scrawny.  I always thought it was a medicine more than a food.

Ever since I found a place that sold frozen Chinese dumplings that were filled with pork and shepherds purse, I've loved the flavor. For some reason, I can't find shepherd's purse sold fresh at Asian markets. Or maybe it's there, but I don't even realize I'm looking at it. So I ordered a pack of seeds from that Esty seller, and from the Kimchimari shop, for growing this season. I've never quite been able to forage any before it goes to seed (and becomes too tough to eat). But if I do, I'll definitely compare the flavor. Maybe cross them with the ones I grew from seed too.