Unexpected pear shaped tomato segregants

Started by William Schlegel, 2024-09-01, 07:39:25 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

William Schlegel

I crossed Dwarf Gloria's Treat (OSSI) with a mix of pollen from a couple current tomatoes. This year in the F2 there are a few pear shaped tomatoes. So beefsteak x current. Wondering what the genetics of that is? I've been intending to cross pear tomatoes in to my breeding projects at some point. I just didn't expect it to show up from this cross!
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Adrian

In my expérience the pear form is typical recombinaison of a long parent (ovate).

reed

My pimp cross that happened a few years ago produces pear shape and elongated cylinder-shaped fruit now and then. They are also small like the round ones. I cull them to reduce volunteers the next year because so far, they have all been far inferior in flavor to the round ones.

I never really gave it much though as to why they show up, but I have wondered if those shapes are somehow genetically connected to sub-par flavor.

William Schlegel

#3
That is good that you've observed this same phenomenon.

I kind of miss the mouth feel of the yellow pear shape. I separated out a few and saved their seed separately. All red but with any luck they'll segregate out some bicolors. Or I can cross them again.

I think a few years ago I was reading about a whole bunch of fancy new small pear shaped tomatoes. Like this one: https://www.tradewindsfruit.com/solanum-lycopersicum-blue-keyes-tomato-seeds.

Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

reed

I don't know what the original cross was in mine but am near 100% sure it was not a pear type. I think it was most likely Mr. Stripey because it was about the only yellow tomato I grew in the years before the first ones showed up. Most of the best flavored ones are yellow but the original pure pimp they came from is dark red and no bigger than a pea. 

Do those blue tomatoes taste good?

William Schlegel

I thought I had tried some of those keyes ones but they aren't on my spreadsheet that I noticed. In my experience it is relatively difficult to get the blue skin back. So matching the pretty blue skin with superior flavor is a good trick. In the pear showing up cross I made the Dwarf Glorias Treat had superior flavor but I haven't done a good job separating out offspring with good flavor. I don't think any of the pear shaped ones had it. It may be the case that if we want truly superior flavor we need to do large growouts and pursue flavor alone in most cases. Other considerations like shape, anthocyanin, and stripes can all be thought of as distractions... I thought Muddy Waters had superior flavor but I may have had my cross with it die so might need to make it again. In my garden Muddy Waters has superior flavor, stripes and anthocyanin blue skin all in one package so it can be done its just difficult not impossible. Brad's atomic grape won an award but in my garden it's just ok and I don't expect my cross with it to be superior in flavor.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

reed

There are other important factors of course but flavor is always high on the list that gets something planted again the next year in my garden.

In my entire gardening career of over sixty years, I can't quickly put my finger on a single example where award winning, most popular or any other glowing description proved true. Marketing as a rule, no matter the crop, produces poorly and tastes bad.

Steph S

Not unusual for pear shapes to turn up in crosses involving ovals.

what leaves me puzzled are the 'unstable shape' plants, that will throw all and every shape at you, like they have all the genes but no dominance or preference.

My best tasting tangerine this year is a plant that was slow to set in the greenhouse and got set outdoors.  The earliest plant that got the best greenhouse spot has beautiful uniform shapes and tastes.. like any red tomato.  the really tasty one has everything on it from round, pointy, multi locule beef, pear....
I seriously don't care what shape they are as long as they taste like they do, amazing, but can't help wondering if they'll settle down and if so what shape will I end up with selecting for taste.

I wonder how many plants from the same generation I would have to grow out, to get the great taste with a stable shape, production, disease resistance etc. 

Kadence Luneman

Why decide on one when you can do it all?!  ;D

That's really interesting that happens.

Adrian

#9
A extrem exemple with one of my croce
The fruits fecondated in bads conditions was more long