Mid-Ohio Valley Tomatoes

Started by reed, 2023-11-27, 06:02:58 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

reed

I'm starting out a tomato project next year with some seeds that William sent me. I have seven different kinds but for space reasons, I may only plant five. Is it correct that I only need a couple F1s of each, but thirty or more for the F2s? In any event I can squeeze it all in, I think. Pretty sure I remember Carol Deppe saying you can grow F2s in a clump. I don't think I really have to do much with these this year other than watch. Some of the seeds William sent are F1s from my own varieties.

These are the tomatoes I am going to try to cross to some of my other tomatoes. And these are also the parent varieties of those I got back as F1s.

BigToms.JPG

These are my little tomatoes that I want to cross with my bigger ones. These are a few generations from a random cross between pimp and one of the tomatoes in the other photo.

SmallToms.JPG

Justin Jardinier

Wow, those in the first photo look really lovely!

Quote from: reed on 2023-11-27, 06:02:58 PMIs it correct that I only need a couple F1s of each, but thirty or more for the F2s?

From what I understand, yes, if the parents are stable. However, if one or both parents are themselves unstable, you might want to grow out more, since there will be variability in terms of what genetics they are contributing.

reed

#2
Thanks! These all grow and produce well in my garden despite the various diseases, that I believe are present, as well as the droughts and so on, but I don't really know why that is.

Two of those big yellow ones are my Mr. Stripy, the other two are the new one I got this year, Willard Wynn. Very similar except Willard Wynn makes slightly smaller fruits in clusters rather than just two or three. Their resemblance to those paintings from the 16th century European tomatoes, and that they originated in the same area around the Smoky Mountains makes me think they might have started out from one ancestor, that found its way back from Europe. I don't know what the smaller round yellow ones are but think they are probably just a mix up of seed that came with the Willard Wynn.

I want to cross Mr. Stripy and Willard Wynn with the smallest yellow ones in the bottom picture, just to see what comes out of it.   

reed

#3
I have a goofy, or what I thought was goofy idea that genes might work cooperatively in some situations. Probably a lot of situations and there are probably lots of these genetic workgroups. Some work in some conditions and some work in others. And I suspect they can be manipulated on purpose.

I'm not going to go into what my tomato project is really going to be just yet, because I haven't figured it out yet and when I do it will probably be really long.

Anyway a headline popped up to an article in the Jerusalem Post about tomatoes. Jerusalem Post Article.

And it said this.
QuoteIt turns out that fruits in the wild tend to have sets of traits that occur together, which biologists call syndromes
. Sounds good to me.





reed

#4
I finally tracked down that list from Cornel again with the disease resistant tomatoes. Cornel-Disease Resistnt List

There are several where instead of listing the specific diseases it just says "resistant to disorders" but I can't find what exactly that means. does anyone know?

Also, I've heard mention several times of Black Sea Man. Does it have any specific disease resistance? I tracked it down and see that it is potato leaf. I also found potato leaf Hillbilly, which is another Mr. Stripy - like tomato.

Since I'm not great at controlled pollination and the like I'm thinking if I use mostly potato leaf as the mothers it will be easy for me to identify crosses with normal leaf types. I have my Hoosier Rose already so if those two show any tolerance in initial trials I'll have three potato leaf types to work with.

Justin Jardinier

#5
Quote from: reed on 2023-12-07, 09:53:43 AMAlso, I've heard mention several times of Black Sea Man. Does it have any specific disease resistance?

What I've heard is that it is really great, for example a favourite of someone in North Sweden, but not disease resistant. And for sure not to LB. I made several crosses with it including to some that have some LB resistance, but no crosses to PH tomatoes since didn't have both growing at once. Except in some interspecial crosses that should be 1/4 Black Sea Man and include PH genes.

I'm also curious whether Black Sea Man is a dwarf or not. It has a fat stem and doesn't grow tall. In those respects more so than Maralinga and Large Barred Boar so far as I could tell from growing them, and those are dwarfs. So I'm a bit confused, since I haven't seen Black Sea Man listed as a dwarf.

reed

Thanks for the info. Sonds like Black Sea Man came from a place pretty different than where I am. I was mostly curious because descriptions said it was potato leaf. Now, though I have tracked down some more potato leaf varieties from closer to the area I want to stick with. Basically, eastern North America from Southern Ohio to North Georgia, straddling the mountains. I know I'm breaking all kinds of landrace rules, but I want to find and cross as many as I can within the boundaries of what I'm used to, what I like and what produces well.

I know some, aside from those I already have will do at least reasonably well. First hurdle will be to discover them among all those that won't. Second hurdle will be, do they have flowers open enough for me to work with?

I've found potato leaf Hillbilly and I've grown it before, a long time ago.  Also, both yellow and pink Brandywine, also potato leaf. And an F1 hybrid called Brandy Boy. To try to make it easier I will use the potato leaf plants as mothers. There is a problem there as I would prefer to use my old standbys as mothers but only one of them is potato leaf.

I'm thinking if can get a few fruits that I'm pretty sure are crossed then I can just plant all of the seeds from each and easily discover any regular leaf F2s.

William Schlegel

I would advise working hard to make crosses on your one old standby potato leaf. That cross I made on that one might segregate to potato leaf easier than most maybe even in the F1.

Though if it had been easy I would have made a lot more than one cross on it.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Justin Jardinier

Quote from: reed on 2023-12-07, 04:34:26 PMI was mostly curious because descriptions said it was potato leaf.
Yes it has huge potato leaves. I love how it looks. It seems it's original name is Chernomor. Here's tatiana's page on both:
https://tatianastomatobase.com/wiki/Black_Sea_Man

https://tatianastomatobase.com/wiki/Chernomor

reed

#9
Quote from: William Schlegel on 2023-12-07, 05:44:31 PMI would advise working hard to make crosses on your one old standby potato leaf. That cross I made on that one might segregate to potato leaf easier than most maybe even in the F1.

I'm going to try doing lots of crosses on my PL Hoosier Rose along with the new PL kinds. I'm going to do crosses on my RL kinds too but since I'm not very skilled at it, the RL types won't be as easily identified in the next generation. I figure, assuming I have nice flowers on the PL's I can just dump on lots of pollen from Rl types and easily find any successful F1 plants the next spring.

I don't have lot of space but plenty to make beds for hundreds of seedlings from which I can select out any obvious crosses to actually set out. With the Rl on Rl and PL on Rl, it won't be as easy.

I also gotten interested in Purple Calabash. Baker Creek says this about it.
QuoteThis variety is known to be a good representation of how tomatoes in Mexico looked and tasted before European colonization
Monticello seems to hint that Thomas Jefferson may have gotten it directly from Mexico in the late 18th or early 19th century, rather than somewhere from Europe and I can't find any refences about an origin in Europe. Plus, it looks similar to those in the 16th century paintings. So, I wonder is it possible it never made the trip across the ocean and back and is instead something closer to what the first cultivated tomatoes looked like. I might have to grow it, just to see what it really looks and tastes like and of course if it likes it here.




reed

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2023-12-10, 11:17:39 AMI sent you a small amount of seed for each and retained seed for each of the crosses. So we will both be growing the same F1s in 2024.

I didn't think to open up the packs to see how many seeds there are. I might have room to grow them all. I'm moving my sweet potatoes to newly acquired uniform pots this year and have nine 25-gallon tubs available, I think I'll use those. As I recall Carol saying that you can plant crowded to do selection, so I can just use a pot per type and that will make them easy to keep track of too.

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2023-12-10, 11:17:39 AMAlso I think to cross in some of Joseph's interesting genetics and maybe some of these modern heirloom quality resistant tomatoes like Galahad F1 and Purple Zebra F1. Towards that all the crosses I made with Reeds tomatoes have Joseph's Big Hill HX-9 as an ancestor as do most of my crosses.

I see the Purple Zebra is available at several places so may pick some up to add in. I grew Big Hill HX-9 several years ago. It had pretty serious disease issues. One that I called Utah Red Bottom came from it and I kept it a year or two because of the flavor and less disease issue. It had great Mr. Stripy like flavor and acceptable tolerance but the fruits tended to have hard green cores.

I just saw on Buffalo Seed Company site that Big Hill came from Hillbilly x Jagodka.  I remember wondering when I grew it why it had similarities to tomatoes that I was used too. It's because Hillbilly is exactly in line with the kind I like and that generally do well here. The reason I dropped it years ago in favor of Mr. Stripy is because although it makes fantastic tomatoes, it only makes a very few of them, Pineapple is like that too. They are not quite as tolerant as Mr. Stripy either. I'm bringing a potato leaf version of Hillbilly back in this year and assuming it is acceptably tolerant, want to do lots of crosses with it.





 


Joseph Lofthouse

When I lived in Ohio, Hillbilly pleased me more than any other tomato. It required a longer season than my garden in Utah can provide, so I crossed it with Jagodka, my earliest most productive tomato. I grew a huge population, and all the traits I cared about were recessive, therefore, the F2 provided one stable plant, the ancestor of Big Hill and the Promiscuous tomato project.


reed

Quote from: Joseph Lofthouse on 2023-12-12, 08:42:04 AMWhen I lived in Ohio, Hillbilly pleased me more than any other tomato. It required a longer season than my garden in Utah can provide, so I crossed it with Jagodka, my earliest most productive tomato. I grew a huge population, and all the traits I cared about were recessive, therefore, the F2 provided one stable plant, the ancestor of Big Hill and the Promiscuous tomato project.

Do you recall if the Hillbilly you grew was normal leaf or potato leaf?

I've tracked down sources of both, but I don't see how just because they have the same name, they are really the same. I don't remember the last time I grew it which it was. I went with potato leaf because it will be easy to tell the difference if crossed to a normal leaf.

First, I need to discover which of those large colorful tomatoes are happy in my garden and which aren't then I want to cross and backcross them each other and see if some even more adapted ones might show up. Also, without any reason to believe it will happen, I hope maybe they will be more productive. My biggest issue with some is, it seems only one it ten flowers actually sets a fruit. If the issue, there is pollination that might make it easy for me to do my purposeful crossing. And maybe just mixing up the genes will help resolve it in the future.

The new one I got last year called Wyllard Wynn is on par flavor wise with Mr. Stripy and Hillbilly. It also tolerated my garden, the drought, the diseases and me. What was different was it made slightly smaller fruits in clusters of four or five, instead of one or two. It's normal leaf, I'm going to use it as father on lots of potato leaf flowers. 

Joseph Lofthouse

Quote from: reed on 2023-12-12, 11:18:52 AMDo you recall if the Hillbilly you grew was normal leaf or potato leaf?

It was both!

I felt attracted to it, because with a floating phenotype like that, it meant that the population I started with contained some level of genetic diversity. I was mostly after the open flowers. That was before I knew about self-incompatibility. I sought any small crossing advantage that I could cobble together.




William Schlegel

I've added at least one of Brad Gates bicolors and Dwarf Gloria's Treat to my bicolor ancestors. Bicolors are quite frequent in my breeding considering almost everything is descended from Big Hill.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days