Mid-Ohio Valley Tomatoes

Started by reed, 2023-11-27, 06:02:58 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

reed

#165
I don't know, I've never bothered trying to specifically identify them. I've grown tomatoes in the same small garden area for nearly thirty years, so I think I have pretty much all of them. There is curly brown leaf disease, they always get it later in the season but it's mostly just the old leaves and doesn't hurt anything. If it does go farther up to newer leaves I cull the plant. Then there is leaf spots disease that sometimes leads to little holes or leaves falling off, but it isn't too bad either. I've seen on trials of new varieties stem and leaf rot disease; I cull them too and think it is related to moon crater disease. Moon crater disease is round sunken, fuzzy spots on the fruits, one small one and the flavor of the whole fruit is ruined.

As long as I get a nice harvest I don't care if the vines look a little worn down. My own tomatoes, mostly just old heirlooms grown from my own seed over those thirty years, in that same small area do fine, but most new trials fail. I compost old vines or use them as mulch, no matter their condition, always have.

This has been a bad year weather wise. It didn't rain for six weeks, and I only watered them once. Then it poured rain from three or four days. That's when a lot of the new ones got sick. A lot of the others cracked but most of them healed up and taste fine. I've already taken out all of the new ones except the crosses William did with mine. Production has slowed but we have plenty canned and plenty to eat fresh till end of season. 


William Schlegel

https://vegpath.plantpath.wisc.edu/diseases/tomato-septoria-leaf-spot/#:~:text=Tomato%20septoria%20leaf%20spot%20is,lesions%2C%20but%20are%20often%20darker.

I wonder if one of your diseases could just be this Septoria?

I think Cream of The Crop tomatoes is working on some new resistance to it.

It makes sense that the F1 hybrids with your proven winners would also be resistant to whatever you have. The F2 should be more variable which will probably involve some culling but some new winners should emerge as well.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

reed

#167
The pictures in that link do look a bit familiar and it says it can be on the fruits too, so maybe it is moon crater disease, but I don't really want to know. I have this weird, irrational, superstitious feeling that knowing for sure will make it worse or that I'll be tempted to do something specific about it. Doing something specific about one specific thing feels dangerous to me since there many other specific things and right now it all seems to be in a balance of sorts, and I don't want to upset that.

I was actually a bit surprised at how poorly the F1s Galahad and Hot Streak did. They are both described as having strong resistance to about everything, but they were badly affected. Hot Streak at least, continued maturing nice fruits even after the vines were mostly defoliated enough so that, I plan to grow its F2 seeds.

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2024-08-16, 05:30:23 AMIt makes sense that the F1 hybrids with your proven winners would also be resistant to whatever you have. The F2 should be more variable which will probably involve some culling but some new winners should emerge as well.

I've already decided ;D  that somewhere in the F2 or F3 or maybe F4 there will be plants that keep the early fruiting, the disease and drought tolerance but also have even better flavor. All I have to do is grow lots of them for the next few years.

reed

I thought I was about done saving tomato seeds this year, but I have another plant that has caught my interest. It is from the off-type plant that came from the big sauce tomato I call Utha Heart. The off type in the UH patch had smaller more spherical red fruits. This plant is very late to mature fruits and is full of medium sized tomatoes that are starting to turn yellow. It's got some draw backs, being so late and a bit more disease than I like but it has a lot of fruits on it that seem to be ripening just fine. Another few days and I'll know how they taste. If it is a cross, I wonder what it might be. Fruit is too big I think to have been a pimp and I don't know how color is inherited but I guess in might have been Mr. Stripey or Willard Winn.

reed

My tomato seed saving is about done for the year. We have plenty put up for winter and due mostly to drought but also some disease I've already removed most of the plants to the compost pile. I've left one particular pimp descended plant to keep snacking on and a couple bigger beefsteaks for fried green tomatoes.

I have way too many kinds to plant them all next year, so I'm going through and tagging then now before I forget what I didn't like about them.

Strike thru means I won't be growing them.
** Means I definitely will be growing them
Just listed, means I might be growing them.

- Purple Calabash just awful, fruits didn't look like the pictures

- Dwarf Early Girl F2 liked the growth habit, poor production, poor flavor

- Mr. Stripy x Mr. Stripey x (MMM x PZ) mix of types would like to explore them all, but not enough room

- **** Mr. Stripey x (MMM x PZ) large yellow disease and drought resistance, very early, good flavor very productive

- **Hot Streak F2 no great disease resistance, produced a lot of good tomatoes anyway

- **Eary Girl F2 productive, like the flavor

- **Big red/pink from farm market very good, very large, and local, worth a try

- **Child of Hoosier Heart good flavor, stayed true to size, very late
 
- Patsy's Red Grape flavor not on par with others

- Cherokee Purple an old favorite, not great production, no room for it next year


- Pineapple an old favorite, not great production, no room for it next year

- Brandywine OTV ok flavor, horrible production

- *Garden Gate Volunteer very good solid beefsteak, don't know where it came from

- **Hoosier Rose x Rose x (MMM x LA1375) interesting but not as much as the Mr. Stripy cross

- **Pale Yellow Cherry very sweet, odd whitish color

- *Hillbilly PL fine tomato but long time to ripening

- ***Plum Regal F2 renewing my goal of a tomato for sun drying

- ***Patsy's Best Hoosier Rose she declared this plant to have superior flavor, it also tolerated the drought a little better

- ***Hoosier Heart formerly Utah Heart - reliable canning tomato

- ***Willard Wynn great flavor, great production, replacing Mr. Stripy

- Red & Yellow pimp mix too unpredictable for space available

- *Yellow Brandywine PL

- *Super Sauce F2

- Galahad F2 poor production, bad flavor

- ****Best Ever - sweet red cherry sweet all the time, time of day, temp, degree of ripness




 


reed

Trying to wrap my head around the lineage of the Mr. Stripy x (MMM x PZ). Going over some of Williams other posts I found that:

Mission Mountain Morning (MMM) is (Mission Mountain Sunrise (MMS) x Big Hill or XH9).

XH9 is - 1/4 Brad, 1/4 Blue Gold, 1/4 Jagodka and 1/4 rl Hillbilly

MMM was crossed with Purple Zebra and PZ is itself an F1

So, the seeds William sent back to me are:

1/2 Mr. Stripy - 1/4 Purple Zebra F1 - 1/4 all those other things in whatever proportions survived selection

No wonder more than one phenotype showed up in the F1 generation. I suppose there is no guessing how many more will show up next year but based on overall performance of the F1, I suspect there are lots of really great ones waiting to be found. I wonder if the distant ancestor of Hillbilly helped account for the larger yellow fruits of one of the plants. It is the one I have chosen to grow a lot of next year. I would love to have that same cross done with Willard Wynn. :D

Now to the Hoosier Rose x (MMM x LA1375). I guess it is similar except instead of Purple Zebra the MMM is crossed with a late blight resistant current tomato, so it is:

1/2 Hoosier Rose - 1/4 MMM and 1/4 LA1375. The F1 of this also produced multiple phenotypes, produced very well and had good flavor. Although Hoosier Pose is a very large tomato the fruits were in the range of a Ping pong ball size, maybe some a little bigger. I guess that is probably due to the 1/4 LA1375 influence. I wasn't as impressed with it as with the Mr. Stripy cross but I'm rethinking that now and will probably do a big grow of it next year too.



 








William Schlegel

MMM is - 1/4 Brad, 1/4 Blue Gold, 1/4 Jagodka and 1/4 rl Hillbilly as it is 1/2 MMS and 1/2 HX-9

HX-9 is 1/2 Jagodka and 1/2 Hillbilly

MMS is 1/2 Brad and 1/2 Blue Gold

Mr Stripey x (MMM x PZ) is thus 1/4 purple zebra f1, 1/4 MMM, and 1/2 Mr stripey and from the 1/4 MMM it is 1/16 each of Brad, Blue Gold, jagodka, and Hillbilly
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

reed

I'm officially giving up on following the pedigrees. I'll may actually I have gotten it all wrong. I may have to get out the packs you set them in to see what they really are. I'm just going to call them:

Mr. Stripy x William's - larger, yellow, early, productive, conditions tolerant, good flavor or MSxW-lyepctgf for short. 

and

Hoosier Rose x William's smaller red with green jell, early, productive, conditions tolerant, good flavor or HRxW-srggepcttgf for short.

Seriously, looking back over the season these things were great. They produced more than enough all year. There have to be some really great ones to show up in coming years.

As far as I can tell there isn't anything in there other than domestic except maybe a bit of current and one of the ancestors, Hillbilly, is exactly the type of tomato that I like and that apparently likes my corner of Indiana, as is Mr. Stripy. Rather than being less tolerant of conditions, they were just as or more so than most others I grew this year.

I find that interesting and wonder how much is due to them being my own 1/2 MrS or 1/2 HR, and how much is a result of hybrid vigor or specific genetics coming together. With four or five phenotypes from four or five plants, and that they all did similarly well makes me think there is a good chance that whatever came together for the good this year is likely here to stay in most offspring.

If XH-9 is Jagodka and Hillbilly, I have to wonder what doing that cross over but replacing Hillbilly with Willard Wynn might yield. WW is very comparable to HB in every way except it is earlier and more productive. It is the most productive of the large regional heirlooms I've found. Some of those same crosses with it might be really, really interesting, hint, hint. We could call it the Montiana Tomato Project.  :D


William Schlegel

#173
I think you were fine on the pedigree just I didn't make it clear enough which tomato I was talking about when I gave the four quarters. So I clarified. I like crossing with the current tomato accessions it is easy and fun. I'm not dropping the harder to work with unpalatable wild species though but I may dilute them more and faster and get more of my wild genes from the palatable current tomatoes.

I think next year I need to cut back on tomatoes and gardening quite a bit so I don't think I can help with more crosses next year. Maybe just what fits in the greenhouse for crossing with for starting from transplant and that will have to prioritize the arthropod resistance project. Gotta direct seed something though! Though there is always the year after next.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

reed

I'm not nearly as studied on this as you but I'm starting to suspect that pretty much all of the commonly discussed little tomatoes are descended from current. Matt's Wild Cherry, Sungold, all of them. Just looking at all the different colors, shapes, sizes and flavors that keep showing up in my garden from that two original off type plants I found several years ago, it's amazing how may there can be. And that is just from that one original little red current, I didn't know until recently that there were lots of different types of current like the Lb resistant one you cross with.

I don't even allow the tiny red ones to grow in the garden anymore, they just live in the weedy area at the edge of the yard now. This year though some tiny yellow showed up. I hadn't seen the tiny fruits in the garden volunteers for a while and never yellow ones. They are quite good but not as good as some of the others so I'm exiling them to the weeds too.

I was never all that interested in breeding tomatoes, just no real reason to as I've never had much problem with growing all the good tomatoes we want. Now I'm getting the itch for it, especially after seeing how those you crossed for me are doing. I'm pretty picky about tomatoes, but these have potential to replace my old favorites, as they are earlier and more productive. Not quite as tasty, but not far behind, maybe a future segregation will fix that on its own or maybe I will get better at the hand pollinating thing.


William Schlegel

Not all little tomatoes are from current crosses but they are so hard to tell apart that they lumped all cherries as variety cerasiforme until relatively recently. Currents and cherries from South America have more diversity at the genetic level but on the surface most are just plain red tomatoes. Though I've really enjoyed the two current crosses I made in 2022 but it leads to a lot of cherry tomatoes which is part of why I back crossed a lot of them to larger tomatoes last year. Next year the Hoosier Rose x (MMM x LA1375) cross being one of those back crosses to larger tomatoes might produce some decent size tomatoes in the segregating F2 with only 1/4 current genetics. The F2 generation on all those crosses will be pretty exciting. You might find some new favorites and some you don't want to save any seed from.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

William Schlegel

Found a nice F1 fruit of Mr Stripey x (MMM x Purple Zebra) that seemed to get stripes and anthocyanin both of which can be codominant with lower expression. With any luck some next year will be very nice looking and hopefully tasty.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

reed

I saw where you were thinking of downsizing a bit next year. I'm thinking that too, overall, not just tomatoes. The weather is just getting too weird, and I think I might be better off more intensively caring for a smaller space. I might abandon the back garden all together. I'm also forgetting the "grow lots of different things", practice and focus on a lot each of the few things that have consistently done pretty well.

With tomatoes, I think the F2s of the Mr. Stripy and Hoosier Rose crosses will be enough to keep me going for a long time. Thank you so much for that.



William Schlegel

Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Cathy A

Quote from: reed on 2024-10-02, 06:32:49 PMI think I might be better off more intensively caring for a smaller space.

This is what I do for all of my gardening, and it's very effective.