Blossom End Rot Resistant Tomatoes

Started by Cathy A, 2023-11-25, 09:41:55 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Cathy A

It's surprising that breeders haven't spread anti-blossom-rot genetics through the whole domestic tomato population.

William Schlegel

#1
Quote from: Cathy A on 2023-11-25, 09:41:55 AMIt's surprising that breeders haven't spread anti-blossom-rot genetics through the whole domestic tomato population.

Do such genetics exist? I thought I might dabble in a Roma type and in summer of this year 23' I crossed Fisher's Earliest Paste a MT bred tomato originally from Fisher's in Belgrade MT with a cross I made in 22 between Mission Mountain Sunrise and Brad's Atomic Grape. Roma types in general are awful for blossom end rot here and Fisher's Earliest Paste is no exception. Though I don't remember if Brad's Atomic Grape had it too bad. The MMM x BAG F1 was kind of a Roma shaped cherry and didn't have any.

Seems like they do:

https://www.reimerseeds.com/Departments/Vegetables/Tomato/Disease-Resistant-Tomatoes/BER-Blossom-End-Rot-Resistant-Tomatoes.aspx

https://www.tomatodirt.com/blossom-end-rot-in-tomatoes.html#:~:text=Choose%20varieties%20that%20are%20resistant%20to%20blossom%20end,Manapal%2C%20Mountain%20Pride%2C%20Pik%20Red%2C%20Sunny%2C%20and%20Winter.

http://ipm.illinois.edu/diseases/series900/rpd906/

My next questions are: Is it ok to breed with these, and what is the nature of this resistance?

Saucy is a 1993 OSU introduction from Jim Myer's predecessor James Baggett. Should be fine to breed with. Ropreco is an Italian heirloom and should be fine to breed with. Still wonder what is the nature of their resistance though? Also, how good is it? 
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Ferdzy

I have no idea about the genetics, but there have been at least a couple of tomatoes that came into my garden with a tendency to get blossom end rot, which was greatly reduced just by careful selection, ie seeds saved only from plants that had none.

Adrian

#3
Blossom end rot is very influenced by the nutrients of the soil and the climatics conditions.
High nitrogen and potasium rate and long days increase the speed of fatness of the fruit and reduce the calcium rate in the soil.
More the fruit get fat fast more it consummed calcium.
If you have a miss of calcium when the fruit get fat the cellules be necrosis.Its the reason who provoqued it blossom end rot.
It seem at the symptoms of a cancer but on a tomato.
What action can we tried?
-We can selected a fruit who get fat more slowly but with a big size.
-We can selected a more small fruit
-We can improve the capacity of the plant to absorbated the nutrients
-We can selected plant with good sinergy with mychorizes for reduce the fertilisers consomption
-We can selected plant with good balance fruits - leaf -root
-We also can improve the soil and the grow conditions.

I don't explain this phenomene but since some years i have make a cutting on a plantet of andine cornue extremly sensitive at the blossom end rot.The most part of the fruits was touched by the ber on the plant feom seedling in fullground.However the fruits of the cutting was without ber.The potting soil of my planter was probably more balanced or the rate leaf, root, fruit was more balanced in the planter.
On a plant of seedling you get the fruits after the 9th internode.
On a cutting a fruit can appeard largely before the 9th internode.
I think that balance root - fruits - leaf is very different on a cutting than a seedling.The nutrients in the plant are also differents.I also think that a plant who grow too fast cas also have nutrients disorder (too light, too hot, too fertiliser)
Picture of the cutting


Joseph Lofthouse

#4
I believe that breeders have not focused on eliminating blossom end rot because of brainwashing to believe that it's  due to a defect in the farmer or ecosystem, instead of in the genetics of the plant.

I approach blossom end rot as a genetic problem. For more than a decade I culled any tomato that  grew even one fruit with blossom end rot. Therefore, it doesn't exist in my garden.

Adrian

#5
You totally right Joseph its well a proven genetic disorder however with some care we can significatively reduce the expression of thoses ber.

For sum-up my last post i think that thoses varietys are mainly sensitives at nutrients disorders.Above-all excess of nitrogen and potassium in the soil.
My question: What can give thoses varietys in a soil poor in nitrogen and potasium?
Tolerants varietys of ber are probably more adapted at high nitrogen and potasium rate but what can they give in a poor soil in theses nutrient?


I have noted a thing with my F1 between canestrino di lucca x andine cornue: The fruits was differents forms.The nutrient availlable in the soil when the fruit get fat can have an influence on the morphology when the fruit get fat.

Kadence Luneman

My roma and San Marzano last year had lots of blossom end rot. I felt like I pulled more little rotten end 'babies' than I did anything else to the tomatoes.
This year was a mess but I had several volunteers. All had BER. I decided to just pull them than pull so many duds for the chance of some good tomatoes.
Then at the end of October I found a late volunteer, big and sprawling. But the sheep were about to graze there and of course these things pop up when you don't have time to mess with them. There was some developing tomatoes and didn't see any BER. But it was frosting not long after that and they never would have made it anyway. Could have been because it came up at the corner of the sheep shed where the bedding pushed out and it was lovely, dark, rich there lol.

I have saved seed from them (last years) and have considered direct seeding them just to cull them out for BER. But I have so much other seeds and things I want to do. At best I may grow a couple of each and crowd them, thin to the best single plant, and try some crosses with Big Hill, etc. But again, so many other options.

Does roma type just mean shape?

William Schlegel

To me Roma types are the sausage shaped ones most commonly used for sauce and canners. They've always seemed more prone to blossom end rot. Joseph, as I recollect, weeded out that shape. However here in the above lists are a couple prospects with that shape and supposed blossom end rot resistance. Intriguing!
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Kadence Luneman

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2023-11-25, 10:30:34 PMTo me Roma types are the sausage shaped ones most commonly used for sauce and canners. They've always seemed more prone to blossom end rot. Joseph, as I recollect, weeded out that shape. However here in the above lists are a couple prospects with that shape and supposed blossom end rot resistance. Intriguing!

Hmm very interesting. I have unintentionally not gotten any other seed for long/sausage shape.

Perhaps the goal isn't to root out BER from prone varieties? Though a good goal in itself. But maybe we could do more by routing it altogether? Select for the wanted traits and always cull for BER?
Why roma according to internet search: "smooth and thick skin houses meaty flesh with few seeds, high sugar and acid levels, and low moisture content".

High sugar.. brix testing
High acid.. digital acidity testing
Low moisture content.. I'm not sure what the simple/not expensive test would be for selecting that? Isn't lower seeds = lower moisture for tomatoes like as a rule?

This seems doable and yet people flock to the same old roma/etc varieties that are terrible for BER.

Adrian

#9
lower seeds = lower moisture for tomatoes like as a rule?Difficult to answer at your question Kadence Luneman.On my F1 between canestrino di lucca and andine cornue, the fruits polinisated when the weather was bad was the mosts longs and pointed and sometimes without seeds and very dry.The fruits polinisated in good conditions was more large and courts but with more seeds and less dry.

Roma and san marzano and andine cornue are terrible for the ber.The most important on my point of view is to understand the reasons of apparition of the ber and why some varietys give long fruits.
Used varietys sensitives at ber in breedind project is not so bad.

For me the plant must be able to adapted the form and structure of her fruit in term of the nutrients availlables in the soil.I see the long form as a possibility among a lot of differents forms.
I think that its the better thing than we can do. Thealine problem with my solution is to give  differents forms of fruits on the same plant probably little adapted for commercial conditions.
I will selected for that

Nutrient availlable in the soil are mainly influenced by rhe weather, the t°, the light and the apports of the farmer and nutrients in the soil.

I think that long and thin form is adapted when you have low nutrients rate (N,K) but a lot of calcium.Give the possibility at the fruit to be more large and more court if you have more nutrients availlable in the soil (N,K) but less calcium is for me is a solution.You can see here a extreme exemple of  form variability in the same plant.
The problem appeard mainly when the fruit get fat for me.Theses two photos was took on the same plant


Adrian

#10
Remove thoses varietys is also a solution for remove the BER.This solution make the job but you dont understand why.
je work with thoses varietys and they sometimes can very surprising heterosis effect crossed with the goods parents.
That why i think that totaly remove all the varietys with long form is not the better solution.
In my f2 2/4 fruits was more sensitives at ber but all the f2 was globaly less sensitives that the less tolerant parent.The F1was almost perfect.