Fruit size possibilities crossing with small fruited wilds?

Started by Justin Jardinier, 2023-11-22, 06:50:25 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Joseph Lofthouse

#30
I also worked on a population which was Brad X yellow pear. They recovered the Brad size readily. I grew that this year, but didn't save seeds. Decided that I don't like it. I released it as "Chariot" and the next year as "Yellow Chariot", and other people grow seed for them now. The fruity flavors from the promiscuous project spoiled my taste buds.

Chariot:
chariot_640.jpg

Yellow Chariot:
chariot-3.jpg

Here's a photo of my F1 hybrids between domestic and habrochaites.

F1-fruits-domestic-X-habrochaites.jpg

And the F2 hybrids. The parent varieties were about 3-5 ounce fruits (Brad, Silvery Fir tree, Black Prince, No-ID landrace).

domestic-x-habrochaites-F2_640.jpg

The above F2 plants were then crossed with Big Hill (a 10 ounce tomato).

The current size of some families approximates the size of Big Hill, the largest-fruited ancestor. I consider fruit-size a low priority trait, because I select primarily for flower type. This population traveled to other gardens, where the stewards selected for large fruits, and returned seeds to me.






Justin Jardinier

#31
Thanks for the photos Joseph! I just took some too, for @Nicholas for the conversation about a pimp F1, but they relate to this topic maybe a bit more:
 pimpx-yc-pimpxpen-pimpxchm--pen - 2.jpg

pimpx-yc-pimpxpen-pimpxchm--pen.jpg

Top is pennellii, not the same one used in the cross, and rather old neglected fruits, but very similar to the one used in the cross. Bottom row, left is a pimp x lyc. I was hoping it was a pimp x arc but knew probably wasn't when saw so many seeds inside, 1 or 2 would be as lucky as I have ever got! Sure enough, turns out to be a pimp x lyc by all indications, but I just don't know which lyc. Right is pimp x chm, these fruits are about the same size as pimp, some possibly fractionally larger towards chm size. Middle is pimp x pen. As I mentioned, these are way bigger than pimp (14.5mm diameter at widest part of these I have ready for seed processing, not sure if any previous ones might have been larger), still not really sure if some of the larger ones might be a big bigger than their father or not (I'll try to measure when the next pen fruits are ripe), though TAXONOMY OF WILD TOMATOES AND THEIR RELATIVES (SOLANUM SECT. LYCOPERSICOIDES, SECT. JUGLANDIFOLIA, SECT. LYCOPERSICON; SOLANACEAE) - Iris E. Peralta - 2008 does state for pennellii: "Fruit 1–1.3 cm in diameter" so maybe my suspicion about size increase was right.

Knowing what was in the room when I made the accidental pimp x lyc, I know it was nothing particularly large. The largest father it might have had was Black Sea Ma but it could have been something smaller than that.

The callipers measure in cm on the bottom side, sun on the top side - don't be thinking they are inches! Also, the pimps used in each cross were all different accessions.

So I was thinking 2 things about this.
1) @Nicholas (or anyone else for that matter), is the red too small for a 'cherry tomato'? They're exactly 2cm wide and almost perfectly spherical. I'm not planning to a pimp x lyc F1 for wide use but, just curious since it came up.

2) I found it so curious that the pen cross was so large. I really never studied about size genetics. But, I know pen is a strange one, maybe the most distant of all the Lycopersicon species to the others? And odd behaviour like SC accessions pollinating SI species. So I wonder, perhaps the size genes are... more powerful somehow? I'd be curious to know, whether that might occur in reverse, like, is it harder to increase size in F2 onwards for lyc x pen than it is for lyc x pimp/che/gal?

reed

Quote from: Justin Jardinier on 2023-11-28, 03:22:30 PMI was hoping it was a pimp x arc but knew probably wasn't when saw so many seeds inside, 1 or 2 would be as lucky as I have ever got! Sure enough, turns out to be a pimp x lyc by all indications, but I just don't know which lyc.

That's interesting an F1 of pimp x lyc yields such few seeds. Now I wonder where my little tomatoes came from. I assumed they were just that, pimp x lyc, but it doesn't make sense that a very few seeds yielded two volunteers that just by chance didn't get weeded out the next year.

My original pimps look like those on the right in your photo, only orange. Those first two off-types looked like those on the left, only maybe a little smaller. Now I wonder, but I suppose will never know because I keep awful records but years ago, I had another Lofthouse tomato that I called Captain Crunch. It came to me, I think, about 2014 in a mix he called, early, all kinds. Here is a photo of it. It had very good fruity tasting tomatoes but had terrible disease problems, still it made a lot of tomatoes, I sent its seed to other people but dropped growing it myself.

Maybe it is what crossed with my pimp but if so, the children inherited none of its disease problems. And maybe it too was just an another lyc, but it didn't really taste like one. I wonder if anyone else kept growing it.
 
Captain-Crunch.jpg

Are those little yellow tomatoes in your photo good? Some that look just like those in the middle showed up in my garden this year and they are very, very good.

Justin Jardinier

Quote from: reed on 2023-11-28, 06:40:55 PMThat's interesting an F1 of pimp x lyc yields such few seeds.

No I meant if it were pimp x arc (S. arcanum) then in my experience almost all fruits give no seeds, just embryos with no endosperm nor seedcoat; but some might give one or two seeds, that's the most I ever got. I don't remember how many seeds there were but perhaps 12 or something - I'm guessing that there might have been some unintended pollen on the spoon I had used for the arc pollen on that occasion. At first I had though it may have selfed (but grew some seeds out just in case it really was arc), but the fruits show it to have a lyc father. I don't remember specifically about the pimp x lyc crosses I made and I might not even grow them out since the pimps I used are LB susceptible, but I would expect them to give a full set of seeds.

Quote from: reed on 2023-11-28, 06:40:55 PMAre those little yellow tomatoes good? Some that look just like those in the middle showed up in my garden this year and they are very, very good.

The pimp x chm I do like. It is hard to be objective though, it's possible that I like them because I grew them and am excited about them, but perhaps if a stranger offered them to me I might not, hard to tell! But I anyway enjoy them. Nicely sweet. But I would expect the F2 to be more interesting - the above 3 crosses are all F1. Gal is delicious in F2 and a wonderful bright orange colour even with a red parent. Che I recently realised I do not like the taste of in fact, particularly a certain aftertaste I find in the accessions I have grown, which I first noticed and came to dislike in a hybrid someone bred which might have only 25% che in. However, I recently ate my first lyc x che I crossed, and there was none of that taste, plus the skin was not as thick as lyc x gal and the flesh was thicker. So, I maintain interest in the coming F2 of both those types of cross. And to me the size of those two at F1 seems already a pleasant size for a... cherry tomato. I keep hesitating with that expression since I have never had any habit to purchase such small tomatoes. But am now finding these delicious ones nice to snack on, even if slowly as I process their precious seeds. Not sure about production though, I'll see in the F2 but I guess pimp has the advantage of many flowers per ... per whatever it's called.

The pimp x pen (pennellii), in the middle, I also like. I ate about 7 of them this evening after removing the seeds for processing. Not as sweet perhaps, but nice (refer to above caveat!) But quite different texture - thicker flesh and softer texture but not grainy. Also very interesting skin, not hard like pimp or how lyc can be, rather, softer and a bit elastic. I've be dealing mostly with lyc, che, gal, pimp, per, chil, and arc. Pen is quite different to all of those to me, it stands apart. Also from hab though I spend little time with hab. I would be quite interested to see what could come of lyc x pen over several generations - I wonder if a tasty 50% pen could be made over several generations, with the interesting textures of pen preserved.