Using Arctic chloroplasts to increase cold tolerance?

Started by Justin Jardinier, 2023-07-22, 02:24:16 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Justin Jardinier

I put this in the nightshade category since I'm working on tomatoes and peppers but this could apply to other crops. I just came across the paper 'Chloroplasts of cold-tolerant plants'.
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/336215137_Chloroplasts_of_cold-tolerant_plants

I'm wondering about the potential for mentor grafts for transferring the chloroplasts to food crops. Such wide hybrids might require an interscion such as Nicotiana benthamiana as an intermediary in between (see paper 'Scientists find an enzyme that facilitates grafting between different family species')?

Here are some extracts:

QuoteThe chloroplasts of cold-tolerant plants are characterized by high level of plasticity. In all species, chloroplasts are forming stromules, which can enlarge surface of contacts between neighbouring cellular organelles or the cytoplasm. Such characteristics of the organelles can point out tight cooperation and intense metabolic processes, which may be defining for development of coldtolerant plants in severe conditions of environment. It correlates with a high level of effective quantum yield of photochemical energy conversion, which indicates the existence of a link between structural changes in chloroplasts and the peculiarities of the photosynthetic apparatus functioning.

QuoteAmong the 2200 species of vascular plants found in the Arctic (5), only two species could naturally colonize the Antarctic coastal areas, namely Deschampsia antarctica Desv. (Poaceae) and Colobanthus quitensis (Kunth) Bartl. (Caryophyllaceae) (6). Studies have shown that Antarctic plants really differ from other coldtolerant plants with the ability to exist at low temperatures throughout the year, since they should grow and reproduce at constant low temperatures (from 5 to 7ºC), although the photosynthesis of their leaves is active, even at zero temperatures (7).

Those 2 are pretty small, so, maybe not suitable for grafts.

They also mention Geum montanum L., Geum reptans L., Oxyria digyna, Ranunculus glacialis L., and Galanthus nivalis L. Maybe some of these would be suitable? Looking at photos while searching these species, it looks like maybe Ranunculus glacialis has the largest stem?

What do you think, useful idea?

William Schlegel

#1
I wonder if the chloroplast transfer could be done in tissue culture. Rather than in a graft callus. Also if you would really need Arctic plants.

Oxyria digyna could be obtained by hiking to the alpine here. Though any of the above could be in the alpine plant trade.

Over long time, wide chloroplast and mitochondrial transfers naturally occur over graft unions. It created problems with early genetic taxonomies that were done with mitochondrial or chloroplast DNA before it was practical to sequence the much longer nuclear genomes.

If this could be done in tissue culture for chloroplasts and mitochondria it could also be an end run around maternal effects of crosses that are difficult in a given direction.

Though I think the broader possibility of say transferring chloroplasts and mitochondria from oh say a perennial like Solanum dulcamera might be intriguing. As might the possibility of making the transfer broadly across plant families. I woder if closeness of plant family would matter at all. If it did something in the same order like Convolvulis arvensis might be interesting.

Technically similar the book "Plants from Test tubes" suggests that the technique of creating fused cells of different plant species may have been under explored by mainstream science and abandoned due to advancements in genetic engineering and might be a fruitful area for amateur tissue culturists to explore.

In this case you wouldn't need full cell fusion it might be enough to enduce callus formation in both species. Break up some callus clumps. Mix the two species. Then grow awhile mixed and regenerate shoots and roots. Though identifying any plants with a chloroplast or mitochondrial transfer might be difficult. This is definitely something that a amateur plant tissue culturist might achieve as callus formation is a fairly standard tissue culture method.

Similarly but on a very divergent note I wonder if any of the plant tissue culture outfits sell a chemical that might be used to get pollen to stick to young stigmas. Some will mix a custom tissue culture media for a special species like say Cypripedium orchids and might be willing to prepare something else. Though perhaps not affordable. 
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Justin Jardinier

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2023-07-22, 06:19:03 AMAlso if you would really need Arctic plants.
Hi William! Yeah, sorry my title was misleading. Also it's not clear to me from the paper whether it would be sufficient to merely use the species mentioned, or, plants from specific populations of them adapted to specifically cold conditions. Here are some extracts, I will add bold:

QuoteThe study of plants constantly growing in arctic conditions helps to identify mechanisms of adaptation to low temperatures. Numerous studies of plants originating from the Arctic and Antarctica have shown a higher level of metabolic activity in their cells in comparison with plants from regions with temperate climate; plants from extremely cold environments use a larger span of temperatures, where photosynthesis, respiration and most enzymes work (4). Among the 2200 species of vascular plants found in the Arctic (5), only two species could naturally colonize the Antarctic coastal areas, namely Deschampsia antarctica Desv. (Poaceae) and Colobanthus quitensis (Kunth) Bartl. (Caryophyllaceae) (6). Studies have shown that Antarctic plants really differ from other cold-tolerant plants with the ability to exist at low temperatures throughout the year, since they should grow and reproduce at constant low temperatures (from 5 to 7ºC), although the photosynthesis of their leaves is active, even at zero temperatures (7).

QuoteDeformed surfaces of chloroplasts were observed in ultrastructural research of the mesophyll cells of C. quitensis plants collected in Antarctica. The deformations had the form of invaginations closely surrounded by single mitochondria, or long stromal protuberants called stromules. Chloroplasts of C. quitensis also contained small starch grains and numerous plastoglobuli (10).

Similar spaces in chloroplasts included only stroma (stromules) were observed in several species of plants, namely, Geum montanum L., Geum reptans L., Oxyria digyna (L.) Hill. and Ranunculus glacialis L., which grew in polar and alpine regions (4, 11, 12). In the analyzed species, various specific protrusions, which had equal width or were wider at the terminal zones, were formed in chloroplasts (Fig. 1A). In C. alpinum and C. quitensis, narrow long protrusions included thylakoids and membranes were also noticed. Lutz and Engel (12) studied in the details cytological characteristics of foliar cells in six high-alpine plants. The species included plants of subalpine/alpine Geum montanum, alpine Geum reptans, Poa alpina var. vivipara, Oxyria digyna, and nival Cerastium uniflorum and Ranunculus glacialis. Numerous protrusions in chloroplasts were found in O. digyna and, to a less extent, in G. reptans; however, the others demonstrated only an infrequent formation of such chloroplast substructures. In leaves of G. montanum and O. digyna plants, which grew at about 50 m above sea level, such a pattern of structural changes was rare. In O. digyna chloroplasts of foliar cells, it was shown that the protrusions could be formed as broad long outgrowths of chloroplast envelope, which had form of pocket-like structures, where microbodies and mitochondria were spatially close to the chloroplast and/or to each other. The authors suggested that formation of such chloroplast outgrowths in some high-alpine plants may ensure fast exchange of molecules between plastid and cytoplasm as an adaptation mechanism allowing to survive and to develop during short vegetation period in the Alps, although other species may have formed another patterns of changes, which are not expressed in the plastids at the ultrastructural level (12).

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2023-07-22, 06:19:03 AMOxyria digyna could be obtained by hiking to the alpine here. Though any of the above could be in the alpine plant trade.

If they would have this adaptation, that sounds very promising!

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2023-07-22, 06:19:03 AMThough I think the broader possibility of say transferring chloroplasts and mitochondria from oh say a perennial like Solanum dulcamera might be intriguing.

I looked that one up, and found:
QuoteClimbing nightshade tolerates dormant-season temperatures below freezing

But I could not find about it nor the other you mentioned actually growing in low temperatures - they're good at that? Are they better at that than, for example, Capsicum flexuosum from Paraguay? I wonder if flexuosum could be useful for this kind of idea too, for both tomatoes and peppers, if staying closely related is important. Though these special chloroplasts in the paper still sound especially exciting.

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2023-07-22, 06:19:03 AMOver long time, wide chloroplast and mitochondrial transfers naturally occur over graft unions.
Do you think it would take a long time even with mentor grafts? I thought maybe using a seedling with only 2~4 true leaves for a mentor graft might make it... relatively speedy? Though, what are we talking about when we say long time? I was thinking of a way such as, mentor graft, get flowers, pollinate them as usual, then the plants from those seeds would hopefully have the cool chloroplasts. I only tried 4 mentor grafts (lyc. to wild tomatoes), all failed - I used superglue since I couldn't find the little grafts slips small enough, and I did not spend enough effort in controlling humidity well, but I could try harder. When looking up tissue culture it looks like maybe could be more challenging than mentor grafts, in terms of sterility requirements for example? And when you say:
QuoteBreak up some callus clumps. Mix the two species. Then grow awhile mixed and regenerate shoots and roots.
I'm guessing that that requires sterile medium etc.? I previously found an instructional video for making one of those things that blows non-turbulent air for sterile work, but right now I don't have enough space in my home for that kind of work unfortunately. Maybe in future.

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2023-07-22, 06:19:03 AMTechnically similar the book "Plants from Test tubes" suggests that the technique of creating fused cells of different plant species may have been under explored by mainstream science and abandoned due to advancements in genetic engineering and might be a fruitful area for amateur tissue culturists to explore.
Cool, thanks for the tip, just downloaded that book.

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2023-07-22, 06:19:03 AMSimilarly but on a very divergent note I wonder if any of the plant tissue culture outfits sell a chemical that might be used to get pollen to stick to young stigmas. Some will mix a custom tissue culture media for a special species like say Cypripedium orchids and might be willing to prepare something else. Though perhaps not affordable. 
I heard folk talk about walnut oil. Though I never really heard of people having success. I made some attempts but poor record keeping, too much to keep track of, plus, failure could be for many reasons so, would be hard to discount that element even with failure for usually impossible interspecific crosses.

Hmm... now this might be a silly idea, but, I wonder if crushing some Nicotiana benthamiana and rubbing that on the stigma, might help? I don't know if this principle is related to the principle of pollen getting into stigmas, but here's a quote from the paper on that species I mentioned in the OP:
QuoteThey analyzed transcriptomes at graft junctions between Nicotiana and Arabidopsis and hypothesized that the expression of β-1,4 glucanases secreted into the extracellular region is involved in cell wall digestion. In further experiments, when β-1,4 glucanases were overexpressed in Arabidopsis, the adhesion property of the grafts was enhanced. Thus, they concluded that the expression of β-1,4 glucanases is a key in facilitating tissue adhesion of the grafts.

Also in case you aren't familiar with that paper, here's another quote which made me think it might help in transferring the chloroplasts through such a wide graft:
QuoteThe team focused on Nicotiana in the Solanaceae family, because a previous study had shown that its scion can be grafted onto the rootstock of Arabidopsis thaliana in the mustard family. The team conducted grafting experiments using plants of seven Nicotiana species and their partners from 84 species in 42 families. The results showed that Nicotiana, used as either scion or rootstock, succeeded in maintaining grafts for more than a month with 73 species in 38 families.

[...]

In addition, they conducted experiments to see whether Nicotiana can act as an intermediary in the grafting of different family species, by using a tomato scion and the rootstock of Florist's daisy, a garden plant resistant to environmental stress. About three months later, the tomato plant successfully produced a small fruit.

"Using Nicotiana as an intermediate, we also achieved other grafts in which the scion, interscion, and rootstock all belonged to different plant families," says Nagoya University bioscientist Michitaka Notaguchi, the corresponding author of this study.