Self Incompatible or Obligate Outcrossing Tomatoes

Started by William Schlegel, 2023-07-08, 01:23:56 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

William Schlegel

Joseph Lofthouse a few years back came up with an intriguing idea. Self Incompatible or Obligate Outcrossing traits from certain wild tomato species such as Solanum habrochaites could be transferred to a domestic strain.

Joseph has worked tirelessly towards that goal! He recently mentioned that he might be heading towards a release of a new strain which may have achieved it.

It is very possible that the Lofthouse promiscuous tomato project has subpopulations which are mixed SI and SC. In fact when we have SI Solanum habrochaites accessions in our gardens our gardens are effectively mixed SI and SC and pollen from SI can pollinate SC domestic but not vice versa.

So how would we test an potentially SI plant or population of plants to see if it is indeed SI?

We used to look for early blossom drop- in the process we may have bred in a tendency to have early blossom drop. Exsertion is probably necessary for Self Incompatible pollination. So inserted interspecies individuals without any fruit production we thought were likely SI and unable to self.

I've been doing a thought experiment wondering how to check and one way might be to do a series of isolated crossing blocks with the candidate potentially SI populations and different accessions of Solanum habrochaites I think I have four such accessions for Solanum habrochaites. Though the same thing might be accomplished in much less space, with deliberate emasculated hand crosses and only a few plants of each accession. Perhaps even more telling than accepting habrochaites pollen but not accepting domestic might be the potential that habrochaites could accept pollen from the SI strain.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Steph S

Self incompatibility is a really useful trait for breeders of F1 hybrids. This is why this type of trait, like cytoplasmic male sterility, is important to be included in OSSI pledged material, so that the potential to breed F1s easily is not restricted by patent on those genes.  I suppose that other pathways to self incompatibility would be equally useful for making F1s, as long as they didn't affect the fruitfulness of the F1.  So a trait or set of traits that is recessive to 'freely selfing' genotype would work just as well.  Or that is my train of thought.
William, what is the role of the self incompatible tomato in, for example, a landracing project?
I mean, obviously it would generate F1s, but few fruits.
It would depend very heavily on the density of pollinator populations.  According to what I recently read in some older studies of tomato and relatives, the self incompatibility of the wild relatives is something that evolved in the subtropical regions with very high pollinator density that according to the comment we just don't have in North America.    Maybe speculation about pollinator insufficiency?  But even so, it's pretty clear that we would have to have very healthy pollinator populations unless we are using these plants specifically for deliberate crosses or ? for landrace, to produce a scanty but useful contribution of F1 seed into the population.
So if I understand correctly, if not deliberately hand crossing, you would be harvesting the less abundant fruit from the SI tomatoes specifically to seed F1 diversity into the population? 
And what is the genetic basis for the self incompatibility?  Is it a single gene, that for example if recessive would produce roughly one in four SI tomatoes in your population assuming pollinator population is healthy?  Or a combination of genes making it much more rare but still generating plants with few fruits carrying random F1's, as long as the farmer/breeder is careful to include the seed from less fruitful plants to carry forward.
Just trying to understand.


Joseph Lofthouse

Anyone that can grow tomatillos could grow self-incompatible tomatoes. It's the same breeding system. Nobody complains about meager harvests from tomatillos (unless they plant exactly one plant).

Two closely related genes of the self-incompatibility system are broken in domestic tomatoes. Restoration of either one provides some barrier to selfing. The presence of both provides full protection. Then there is a suite of genes related to flower structure that really help to attract pollinators.


Joseph Lofthouse

I asked the grower doing the over-winter grow-outs and manual pollinations to do that work, but he just couldn't understand promiscuous pollination. All he would have had to do was mail me the tags that were already hanging on the plants, where fruits failed to develop.

Steph S

Yeah we did have a fail with tomatillos at the farm here.  Cold year, lots of plants, lots of flowers, no fruits.
I guess there weren't any pollinators active.  Maybe the cold as well.
Granted I am in probably one of the most extreme climates here.  We were always highly variable but now we are getting all extremes.  Cold due to the ice from Greenland.  And then hot when the wind changes.
Last summer was very hot and dry but humid.   I went out in the garden on a blazing hot sunny day and there wasn't an insect to be seen.  Not a bumblebee, nothing.  Normally my perennial garden is hopping with every kind of bug, and especially bees.  I remember years when the sound of bumblebees would wake me in the morning.   The density of bumblebees in the garden was maybe 20-30 per a square meter on a typical day, all day long.  That has declined in the last decade although it does vary year to year. They also work the tomatoes if I have any outdoors.  Farms don't usually have that kind of insect density, afaict, unless there are honeybee hives and something flowering to feed them.


Cathy A

Like Joseph, I'm not a fan of cytoplasmic male sterility, and I plan to keep it out of my breeding populations. I can see its benefits for commercial hybrid breeders, but not for open source breeding.

Steph, we've had more uncertain weather here in Vermont as well. Late winter lasted several weeks longer than normal, but more recently we have been in a hot spell with highs around 85 - 90 F (29 - 32 C) and "abnormally dry" according to the National Weather Service.

I'm seeing an interesting range of flower structures on the Wildling Panamorous. Some have a wide central area without showing clearly exserted stigma/style, other look like a somewhat larger domestic tomato flower with open anthers and exsertion.


Steph S

Nice pics Kathy.  I had a few double anther cone flowers turn up this season too, mostly on the indeterminate extras but there is one determinate which is still producing really fat, double width anther cones and some nice looking ruffly fruits, more beef than heart shaped.  Kind of a broad and open look similar to your wildling in the second pic.

Flower structure is really interesting and all the discussion about it is thought provoking.  Like growth habit, there are a lot of genotype x environment interactions, which makes it harder to select genetically unless you have a controlled environment.  But the fun stuff happens when environment isn't controlled, and isn't what you expected.  I strongly believe that growth habit affects fruit set in multiple ways.  A sturdy plant that provides self-support for its clusters is more likely to set.  And when cold stress or heat stress is a factor putting the flowers at risk, the right growth habit is able to shelter them or tweak air flow and improve the microclimate for the delicate flowers.  So it isn't just greater tolerance for the stress, it can be better stress management by the plant that depends on structure.
So why shouldn't flower structure play a similar role.  It's entirely possible too.

Whenever you have the fas gene and cold early season weather there's a high likelihood of some strange flower structures.  Maybe in its own way the plant is struggling to express safer structures?  Or are these just developmental processes that go awry when stopped and started?  IDK.
But there are still genotypes that produce lavish and interesting flowers in 'normal' weather too.
Still more food for thought.

Mica Winnower

#7
One of my tomato plants has flowers that have long, exposed stigma and occasionally some flowers have curled anthers. Very easy to emasculate and replace with the anther cone of a different plant. I've made a few manual pollinations this way, and it seems to be working. These I'll save seeds from to grow alongside next year's other selections.

Unfortunately, I cannot remember the name of the variety, and I've lost the tag from when I bought it as a transplant. I want to say it was either red opal or pink pearl or something like that. It's a red cherry variety whose fruit are displaying those beefsteak kind of ridges, though fewer on a smaller fruit.

Whatever it is, more of the flowers that I've manually pollinated have produced on its own. It's had some difficulty self-pollinating, especially when compared to its neighbor, who I'm pretty sure is a blondkopfchen (and has provided more than a few of the anther cones for transplant).
I did a bad job keeping labels and names on things this year. I'll be better at it next year.

Mica Winnower

#8
I took some pictures to show what I mean about the flowers. Some of them stick out so far you don't even have to emasculate them to transplant an anther cone!
Unfortunately, no ripe fruit from this plant yet. The blondies have started ripening on the adjacent plant.
It doesn't seem to be a super productive variety, though that might just be issues with pollination.

Joseph Lofthouse


William Schlegel

#10
One of my 2024 experiments was a large population of mixed F2 and F3 promiscuous x LA2329 that I direct seeded. The result was zero viable seed. It set a very small amount of fruit too late for it to develop. It was also all dominated by habrochaites traits with little segregation apparent.

I think there was a narrow window for bumblebee pollination in 2024.

I'm fairly certain that in all my gardens any SI individuals were selected against in 2024. I didn't get seed back from habrochaites or habrochaites crosses that weren't already looking pretty domestic.

I started my habrochaites from transplant at the same time as my regular tomatoes and this didn't prove long enough. It's probably quite important to have at least some of your habrochaites plants quite large by planting out time. I have started them earlier in past years. Maybe breeding in early genetics is important to getting pollination at the right time when the bumblebees are most active on tomatoes.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days