Anybody else working toward perennial corn?

Started by Carter Phillips, 2023-06-24, 09:48:13 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

reed

I've grown a lot of different kinds of corn, and I don't know that I have ever seen any that did not have at least some aerial roots. The perennial teosinte that I grew had massive amounts of them. It was just one plant, but it tillered a lot with the roots going way up the stalks. It looked like it wanted to fall over and spread by rooting down, I had to tie it up to keep it from doing that. The idea that the ariel roots and that gelatinous stuff that oozes off them is nitrogen fixing sounds nice, but I don't know if it's true or not.

Carter Phillips

Quote from: Steve1 on 2025-02-14, 05:02:35 AMHi Carter, have been working on perennial maize for about 5 yrs now. Working with diploperennis x mays. Was a PITA to get it all lined up though. In a warmer place than you though at 9A/9B. 

Hello Steve, what kind of progress or results have you observed in your work? What kind of strategy are you employing? It would be great to share our results to improve our projects.

Quote from: Carter Phillips on 2024-11-12, 09:41:37 PMIn the next few days I will describe my efforts to hybridize Z. mays and Z. dip (very minor success), and my future plans to continue what I have started and to widen the scope of the project further.

It took me a while to get around to posting it but with the next planting season coming up I figure I should give an update. As I mentioned last time I did win a small victory in hybridizing Z. mays with Z. dip, with the result being 10 seeds that I am certain are hybrids (picture below). I am going to allow these plants to cross with each other and see what range of phenotypes I'm dealing with. Given the historical record of high rates of attrition for Z. dip seeds I've started indoors, I'm worried that starting these indoors will incur unnecessary risk, but I'm probably going to go that route anyway.

Having tilled new earth in a few areas to dedicate to the project, I will be able to maintain multiple isolated populations that are not at risk of contaminating each other. My current plan, subject to change, is to:
1. Grow out the meager yield I eked out of the 87/13 Z. dip/Z. mays population in harvest 2024, allowing plants to freely cross
2. Grow out more pure Z. dip plants and pollinate them with corn pollen from various corn cultivars; I intend on recording the identity of the pollen provider for each pollination so I can track the traits provided by the fathers. Growing Z. dip plants in large pots and keeping the pots near monocultures of the respective fathers would be a good way to do this.
3. Establish more eastern gamagrass; waiting for this grass to seed is proving to be a major drag on the project. My attempt to establish a patch of gamagrass failed last year, with only a dozen or so plants surviving. Once I have a mature population I will attempt to cross it with Z. dip and Z. dip/Z. mays. After reading some papers critical of past attempts to hybridize zea species and gamagrass I am less inclined to hope on this front but I will persist nonetheless.
4. As mentioned previously, grow the 10 hybrid seeds I produced last year and see what they do. If they display traits similar to both maize and Z. dip then I'll at least have confirmation that these are hybrids. Perhaps I will use some as mothers and pollinate them with pollen from the 87/13 hybrids, producing a plant that will certainly have Z. dip cytoplasm (potentially important for expression of perenniality) while hopefully retaining important maize traits especially related to ears and seeds.


Steve1

I am harvesting F2 seed at the moment whilst battling some mice and parrots. Have about 40 f2's in the ground Good amount of seed in the bag.I have a mix of self pollinated F2 and backcrossed to my dryland flour project parent mix. Segregation is occurring for seed husk in this generation amongst other things. Rudimentary cobs are about 3 inches long. I'll try and pop in some images later. Those white teosinte seeds in your pic IME are not fertile. 

Steve1

Quote from: reed on 2025-02-15, 04:30:29 AMI've grown a lot of different kinds of corn, and I don't know that I have ever seen any that did not have at least some aerial roots. The perennial teosinte that I grew had massive amounts of them. It was just one plant, but it tillered a lot with the roots going way up the stalks. It looked like it wanted to fall over and spread by rooting down, I had to tie it up to keep it from doing that. The idea that the ariel roots and that gelatinous stuff that oozes off them is nitrogen fixing sounds nice, but I don't know if it's true or not.
Interesting Reed, the pure diploperrenis will occasionally bend and grow roots but the accession I have isn't interested in aerial roots otherwise. I grow it pretty much without additional inputs and it grows well in ground that will not grow standard maize, I've seen the odd drop of goo on aerial roots of one F1 plant but they were diverse crosses. I have come to conclude after discussion with Shane Simonsen (whether right or wrong) that the process of N fixing endophytes in the goo has likely been occurring (underground) since time immemorial and that we have only noted it (above ground) since because we have been looking at some of the low input maize more closely. The biology can probably piggyback off pollen as it is likely an endophyte throughout the plant not just on the root surface, It is likely similiar biologicaly to other analogues that occur in many plants that grow in the wild and may explain African maize x teosinte lines with significantly more adaption (yeild) to low inputs. But selecting to grow with inputs simplifies the microbiome and you could put forward a good arguement that the only place you could see this expressed is in places where the wild species teosinte co-exists with low or no input agriculture maize.           

Carter Phillips

It's been a while since I posted so I figured I would provide an update. Unfortunately, 2025 was a tumultuous year and I was unable to expand the project in the way I intended to, though I gained valuable experience in some key areas. Some bullet points describing the methods/results compared to my optimistic plans I laid out on 3/18/25:

1)I grew out the 87/13 Z. diploperennis/Z. mays hybrids and harvested a decent crop of seeds. I even observed one or two plants throwing new shoots well after the main shoot had thrown an ear and senesced late in the season, perhaps indicating perenniality or traits that contribute to perenniality. I dug one up and kept it in a pot on my windowsill but it died after some time. Hard to say if it would've lived had I left it in the soil and temperatures stayed warm. Digging a plant up is traumatic and can kill a plant which would otherwise be perennial. Picture of the plant below.

2) I grew out some pure Z. dip plants and about a dozen varieties of corn to provide pollen so I could make some hybrids. I planted thirty Z. dip plants in small pots and transplanted the nine most vigorous plants to larger pots. The pots were placed on a pallet which I could roll in and out of a garage, making it much easier to put the plants in a simulated nighttime condition to induce flowering (picture below). Some of the corn varieties used include "Hopi pink" (flour, known for cold hardiness), "Appalachian purple" (dent, known for having some N-fixing root traits while being adapted to the mid-Atlantic, bred by Kevin Bane of Philadelphia, TN), "glass gem" (pop, known for its beautiful variety of kernel colors), "Chires baby" (pop, known for prolific tillering and number of cobs), and "japonica" (flint, known for its beautiful variegated leaves). Due to a slow start in getting the Z. dip to flower, I wasn't able to pollinate Z. dip with the other varieties, which had finished tasseling before Z. dip flowered. Nonetheless I was able to produce ten seeds with "Chires" as the father, three with "Glass Gem" as the father, and one with "Japonica" as the father. Many other seeds were produced, but they were white in coloration or shriveled. These are indicators of inviability.

One of the Z. dip seeds I planted in 2025 was apparently a new hybrid seed which made it into my pure Z. dip harvest in 2024. This either happened via fertilization by nearby 87/13 hybrids, making the new hybrid 93.5% Z. dip and 6.5% Z. mays, or as a result of my manual pollination of Z. dip flowers with yellow dent maize pollen. I pollinated several flowers with yellow dent pollen in 2024 but the Z. dip in the garden soil grew out of control, with hundreds of flowers, and I culled most of the garden Z. dip flowers I pollinated. From then on I favored manual pollination of more controllable potted Z. dip plants in 2024, resulting in the 10 aforementioned seeds. The hybrid plant was pollinated by "Blue Clarage" dent corn before its distinctive spikelets gave away its hybrid status, making its offspring either 53.25% or 75% maize, depending on the parentage. The hybrid was brought inside and lived all winter on my windowsill, surviving into spring. It is now sending up new shoots. Spikelet and hybrid pictured below.

3) I was unable to attempt any gamagrass establishment in 2025. I did acquire plenty of "Pete" diploid gamagrass (also see PMK24) to attempt hybridization in the future.

4) I did not grow out the 10 putative hybrid seeds harvested in 2024. I intend to plant them for the 2026 growing season.

Carter Phillips

Now that I have updated you all on the 2025 results, I will lay out my plans and predictions for 2026:

1) I will be growing the 87/13 hybrids again and hopefully achieve a better yield than previous years. Ideally I will be able to place numbered tags on each plant and bag seed from each plant separately. After screening plants for the regrowth trait I noticed in 2025 I can selectively promote these traits.

2) I acquired some seeds from Maize GDB that have a complete maize genome with one additional Tripsacum dactyloides (gamagrass) chromosome. (The accessions I acquired are: [T940I Tr9],[ 220B ws3 lg1 gl2; Alien Addition T2-Tripsacum], [T940J A158 with T. Fla, chr9], [T940H Tr5], and [T940G A158 with T. Fla. chr4]). This is a valuable resource which will give me a new avenue for the introduction of gamagrass genetics into maize. Hopefully I can use these plants as pollen providers to fertilize Z. dip. The seeds look like regular yellow dent corn seeds, except for one strain with a few reddish kernels.

3) I am growing Z. dip in pots mounted on rolling pallets as I did in 2025. This year I'll be initiating the simulated short days earlier to hopefully better match up Z. dip flowering with maize tasselling. I'll be planting several varieties of maize to provide pollen as I did in 2025. (My plans aren't set in stone but I may be planting Appalachian Purple, Bloody Butcher, Blue Clarage, Chapalote, Chire's Baby, Glass Gem, Hopi Pink, Jaguar Priest, Japonica, Ki:kam Hu:n, Montana Cudu, Strubbe's Green [erroneously Oaxacan green], and Waimonolo Orange.) I'm going to plant in two garden plots two or three weeks apart so hopefully at least one plant will be producing pollen to coincide with the flowering of Z. dip.

4) I am going to grow out the hybrid seed produced in 2024 and 2025 and see what phenotypes I can observe. I intend to grow plants in pots on rolling pallets so I can pull the short day trick and take them inside for the winter easier. It's been observed that the cobs of Z.m./Z.d. hybrids can change phenotype depending on where they're grown, e.g. in a greenhouse or in the field, so I might plant a few in the garden to see what they look like. (This phenomenon, along with the likelihood of a Z.m./Z.d. F1 regrowing, is discussed in the paper "The Genetics and Genome-Wide Screening of Regrowth Loci, a Key Component of Perennialism in Zea diploperennis". Picture from that paper below).

5) I'll be establishing a plot of diploid gamagrass (Pete) this year for future hybridization attempts. I may attempt to establish tetraploid gamagrass as well. I'm worried that pollinating gamagrass with maize/teosinte pollen and vice versa will be more difficult than I originally imagined. Does anybody on this board have experience with this cross?

Claytonfsmith

Carter,

I've been interested in gamagrass for years. I gather seed from wild grass here in Georgia and plant it on my farm for livestock grazing. I'm curious what traits of corn could be added to gamagrass to make it bigger or faster to establish while keeping it perennial.