Now I want to grow a carob tree . . .

Started by UnicornEmily, 2022-11-19, 06:34:19 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

UnicornEmily

So, I can't grow chocolate because cacao trees are ridiculously cold sensitive -- they'll die before it even gets to freezing temperatures -- and they also die without super high humidity.  Ha ha ha ha, that's not gonna happen in Utah.

But it looks like I may be able to grow a carob tree!

Turns out they're super drought tolerant, they do well in the American southwest, they like alkaline soil, and they're even a legume, so they don't need to be fertilized.  They're only hardy to zone 9, but if I find a cheap source of a lot of seeds, I could plant them all and see if any are more cold-hardy than usual and can survive a zone 7 winter.

Now I just need to figure out where to buy seeds.



William Schlegel

When I lived in Santa Barbara California, I found one row of them growing as street trees after reading about them in a foraging book.

One caveat is that there is an insect that does feed on the fruit leaving behind some frass.

The history in the book was that during the depression era people thought to plant them as street trees to provide a free food source.

That is similar to some modern gardening movements.

Zone 9 is quite different from zone 7 though.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Jeremy Weiss

Quote from: UnicornEmily on 2022-11-19, 06:34:19 AMSo, I can't grow chocolate because cacao trees are ridiculously cold sensitive -- they'll die before it even gets to freezing temperatures -- and they also die without super high humidity.  Ha ha ha ha, that's not gonna happen in Utah.

But it looks like I may be able to grow a carob tree!

Turns out they're super drought tolerant, they do well in the American southwest, they like alkaline soil, and they're even a legume, so they don't need to be fertilized.  They're only hardy to zone 9, but if I find a cheap source of a lot of seeds, I could plant them all and see if any are more cold-hardy than usual and can survive a zone 7 winter.

Now I just need to figure out where to buy seeds.




Check around on the internet, I think there are plenty of sources ( just checked and eBay has several). Or just buy some whole carob pods from some health food or ethic grocery site; they're just sun dried, so the seeds inside are still perfectly viable (you will have to scarify them though, they are hard).

And if Carob doesn't grow for you, I think you can do a lot of the same things with the pods of honey locust, which is VERY closely related.

I also seem to recall that there is a second species of carob that is smaller and has smaller pods (thus making it less commercially attractive) but is even MORE drought tolerant. I think someone had seeds for that as well, somewhere online. 

The scientific name is Ceratonia siliqua, you may have better results using that.

UnicornEmily

Oh, interesting, the honey locust is closely related?

I've heard honey locusts are prone to suckering and have really nasty thorns.  I heard their thorny suckers described as "living caltrops."  O_o  Are there some that are thornless and not prone to suckering?  If so, it might be worth trying to grow one of those, too.

UnicornEmily

Yeah, zone 9 is a lot warmer than zone 7b.  But there's always the possibility that if I plant a LOT of seeds, I'll find one that's just barely cold hardy enough to grow here.  That requires finding a lot of seeds for cheap so that it's not a waste of money, mind you.  ;)

Jeremy Weiss

Quote from: UnicornEmily on 2022-11-21, 08:31:10 AMOh, interesting, the honey locust is closely related?

I've heard honey locusts are prone to suckering and have really nasty thorns.  I heard their thorny suckers described as "living caltrops."  O_o  Are there some that are thornless and not prone to suckering?  If so, it might be worth trying to grow one of those, too.

There ARE some that are thornless (or, at least, have reduced thorns) I think. I don't know about suckering (given how readily the seeds germinate, I'm not sure that a lack of suckering would make that much difference anyway),

If where you live is sort of wet, there is another relative called Water Locust, I think. Maybe that will be better.

Quote from: UnicornEmily on 2022-11-21, 08:32:54 AMYeah, zone 9 is a lot warmer than zone 7b.  But there's always the possibility that if I plant a LOT of seeds, I'll find one that's just barely cold hardy enough to grow here.  That requires finding a lot of seeds for cheap so that it's not a waste of money, mind you.  ;)

Sounds like how I am trying to get my rice bean landrace working, I buy bags of the stuff that looks right (by now, I can tell the kind that absolutely will NOT flower and fruit up here from the kind that might). Plant, wait, take the seed I get and keep adding until I have a decent reserve I can work from.)

Ideally, you could try and find someone who eats a lot of carob pods (or processes them) and ask them for seed. They'd be by-product to them, so you could probably get them very cheap, if not totally free.   

UnicornEmily

Ha ha ha, where I live is the opposite of wet.  It's a super arid desert, and my soil is sand.  ;)  It's cool to know that species exists, though!  I bet that would be a good fit for someone who lives in a place with lots of rain and clay soil that retains too much wet.

Oh, that's cool!  What signs do you use to identify the seeds that definitely won't flower and fruit for you?

Ooh, that's a clever idea.  Yeah, finding someone who considers them a by-product would be a great way to go.  Excellent thought.  Are there any types of restaurants that might be likely to use a lot of carob pods?


Jeremy Weiss

Quote from: UnicornEmily on 2022-11-25, 09:20:26 AMOh, that's cool!  What signs do you use to identify the seeds that definitely won't flower and fruit for you?


It's sort of a general thing. The "southern type" (the one that won't work) is smaller and a darker shade of red (basically standard azuki or kidney bean red). The "Northen type" (the one that might) is a bit bigger and the red is a somewhat lighter color (I liken it to the color of the outside of a boiled hotdog) The Southern are also shinier than the Northern. Of course, the color thing doesn't work so well when I'm using off color beans, but since they are always IN bags of one or the other I can guess those from their companions. I'm not sure WHAT I will do if I ever get my hands on any of the Southeast Asian production (where alternate color can be the DOMINANT or even EXCLUSIVE component). But so far, pretty much all my supply is Chinese (I have managed to get a few from Thailand in some black cow pea bags, and one tan one from a bag of chickpeas from India, but neither of those really "took")

Quote from: UnicornEmily on 2022-11-25, 09:20:26 AMOoh, that's a clever idea.  Yeah, finding someone who considers them a by-product would be a great way to go.  Excellent thought.  Are there any types of restaurants that might be likely to use a lot of carob pods?



My two best guesses would be either a Middle Eastern place, or a health food cafĂ© that was big into "raw" foods. With the Middle eastern, carob is usually a dessert thing, so you may want to focus on bakeries and sweet shops rather than full restaurants. I'd say simply patrol around areas where it is sold with a bunch of tissues and pick up any seeds people have spat out as they were eating, but I think only I am disgusting enough to do something like that! (funny story, once, in Manhattan I saw a public planter with a green leaf blade sticking out of it, and realized that what had happened was someone has spit a date palm stone into it, and the stone had germinated!) 

UnicornEmily

Clever!  That sounds like the kind of expertise that comes through experience.  I'm glad there are details that make it easier for you to intuit which bags you need.

Ha ha ha, I would totally do something like that.  Not during the height of a global pandemic, mind you, and maybe not during flu season either, but during a normal time, sure.  Actually, what I'd probably do is look for someone eating a pod and spitting out seeds, sit next to them and say, "Hey, would you mind spitting the seeds out into this used plastic cup?  I want to try planting them!"

I'm not particularly shy, either.  (Grin.)

Jeremy Weiss

Quote from: UnicornEmily on 2022-11-25, 10:11:22 AMClever!  That sounds like the kind of expertise that comes through experience.  I'm glad there are details that make it easier for you to intuit which bags you need.

Ha ha ha, I would totally do something like that.  Not during the height of a global pandemic, mind you, and maybe not during flu season either, but during a normal time, sure.  Actually, what I'd probably do is look for someone eating a pod and spitting out seeds, sit next to them and say, "Hey, would you mind spitting the seeds out into this used plastic cup?  I want to try planting them!"

I'm not particularly shy, either.  (Grin.)

I actually HAVE asked for the pits back for some of the fruit I've shared, if it was difficult fruit to get and I was planning to grow it. I remember doing it with the lychees I gave my English teacher, and I think I did it with my therapist when I let her have a greengage (a kind of tiny green fleshed plum found in Europe).

I've actually gone one further. Besides off color and weed seeds there is some less savory stuff that sometimes shows up in the beans packets, like insect parts and rodent droppings. The insect parts get thrown out (unless it's a whole insect and a colorful one, in which case it goes in a little screw top vial with some rubbing alcohol and becomes a preserved specimen) but there was at least ONE time I actually took apart a rodent dropping to get the seeds INSIDE of it (I could see some from the outside). Heck, I have joked more than once that, if I was at a tomato tasting by Tom Wagner (who is famous for being quite eager to let people taste his new tomatoes, but quite NOT eager to let people save any seed from them so he can maintain control I MIGHT stick some plastic Ziplocs in my pocked and take advantage of the fact tomato seeds aren't destroyed by passing through the human digestive system.

Oh, and I never mentioned, if you ever want to TRY growing rice beans, just tell me. I have a 15 lb. bag of what I think are the right kind I'm going through for the second time around (I try and do it twice in case I miss any the first time.) so I'll have plenty of plain red "leftovers". If you wanted a LOT, it might take me some time to go through that much (I can only sort in direct sunlight, since I need that to see if they have black speckles or not. most indoor lights are too yellow to see clearly in.) But a tiny amount should be no problem at short notice.

In seed saving I also had to learn to "spin slice" citrus rather than cut it the normal way (to spin slice you cut around the fruit about half way in, then twist the two halves apart. That way if there ARE any seeds, you don't slice them in half. It's good for fruits were seeds are rare, like conventional limes, Red Mandarins (a pretty recent hybrid of tangerine and blood orange, as far as I can tell, whatever kind of mandarins I am growing (the name was Japanese and started with an "M" but that's all I remember. They taste like Dekapons (Sumo Mandarins) but have the odd seed (unlike Sumos, which are completely seedless) and "true" minkans back when I could find them (those are the kind of mandarin oranges that get put in the cans. They're a lot better fresh.)

As for cups, I always have a small screw top pill container on my keychain for if I find small seeds (bigger ones are okay to just put in my pocket, since I won't lose them in there) (though the bottom half is currently missing somewhere in my room, I need to find it.) When I went to the city, I had a seed sorting and saving "kit", consisting of a takeout food container (to sort in) a ceramic blade letter opener (to slit open the bags, since people tend to get nervous if you take out an actual knife on a train) a LED flashlight (for better light, there are SOME models that produce sunlight type visual spectrums) a Ziploc to pour the leftovers into (back then I just tossed the leftovers into the first trash can I saw when I got off the train, to save the weight of carrying them home). and a small compartmented box (for the seeds I was saving). The only time I recall using and ACTUAL paper coffee cup (and it was a fresh one) was when I spotted an interesting looking legume plant (looked like a common vetch, except the flower was large, white and single as opposed to small purple and in a raceme or paired) growing out of an edge of a parking lot and dug it up (unfortunately, the lawnmower that had taken away most of the plant had also messed up the roots quite badly, so even IN a pot it didn't last long enough for the flower to turn into a pod and give me seed to work with again).

Oh yes, it is experience. By now I can actually guess the origin of a crop (which isn't always the same as is marked on the package) by the weed seeds found in it.  Those places that sell from bins instead of pre-sealed packages are a little trickier (since they can of course mix bags) but most of those play their favorites, so I can work it out by what store I am in (bins also give me the opportunity to "hunt and strike" to get a larger portion of the stuff I want than I would from a random pre-sealed bag. You look, you locate, you take a very TINY scoop to get what you see, you use the scoop to stir things around until you see something else, and repeat until you have gotten the amount you want. It takes some extra time, but that isn't something I'm short on on those trips.)     

UnicornEmily

That is so cool.  What a great way to keep your eyes open for interesting seeds.

If it's Japanese and starts with m, is it mikan?  That's the most common Japanese citrus I know of.

I like your idea about spin-slicing.  I'll keep that in mind.  Since I've decided my plan with citrus is to save seeds from any fruit I buy and then plant them outside, I like having a suggestion about how to keep from slicing them.  I figure if something survives and does well in my climate, woot!  I'd like to grow citrus, and I'd prefer to not have any trees that need helicopter-gardener coddling, so I figure the solution is to plant lots of seeds and see if I can get one that'll do well without aid.

I'd love to try rice beans!  I looked up the species, and it seems to be drought tolerant, which makes it promising for me.  What kinds of characteristics are you looking to have in your rice beans?  If I grow anything that seems promising for you, I'd be happy to send you its seeds.

Growing plants is fun, but when you throw plant breeding into the mix, it gets much, much more fun and exciting.  :D

Jeremy Weiss

Quote from: UnicornEmily on 2022-11-26, 08:39:08 AMThat is so cool.  What a great way to keep your eyes open for interesting seeds.

If it's Japanese and starts with m, is it mikan?  That's the most common Japanese citrus I know of.

I like your idea about spin-slicing.  I'll keep that in mind.  Since I've decided my plan with citrus is to save seeds from any fruit I buy and then plant them outside, I like having a suggestion about how to keep from slicing them.  I figure if something survives and does well in my climate, woot!  I'd like to grow citrus, and I'd prefer to not have any trees that need helicopter-gardener coddling, so I figure the solution is to plant lots of seeds and see if I can get one that'll do well without aid.

I'd love to try rice beans!  I looked up the species, and it seems to be drought tolerant, which makes it promising for me.  What kinds of characteristics are you looking to have in your rice beans?  If I grow anything that seems promising for you, I'd be happy to send you its seeds.

Growing plants is fun, but when you throw plant breeding into the mix, it gets much, much more fun and exciting.  :D


Can't be minkan, I already mentioned that (and those are tiny). I think it was Mu-something (I want to say Muramasa, but that isn't a citrus, it's a feudal era sword maker famous for making cursed swords.)

The many seeds thing is ESPECIALLY useful for Yuzus since, for some reason, the mixed genetics mean the seeds go all over the place when you grow them, and you get a lot of non viable ones (ones that make no leaves, or are albino, or things like that).

Bear in mind I have no idea WHAT will happen if you plant a seed you find in a conventional lime. Modern limes are triploid (which is why you see so few seeds) so any seed you DO find has probably had something happen to revert it to  being diploid. So you'd probably actually get something close to one of the modern limes ancestors, either Citrus medica (the citron, as in the stuff they candy the peel of for Italian desserts or the Etrog we Jews use on Sukkot) or Citrus aurantifolia (the Mexican, or Key lime).

Also remember that most citruses have VICIOUS thorns, so be careful when handling them.

If you wander around Etsy, you can find people offering a lot of unusual citruses in both seed, fruit and treelet forms (just only buy from within the US; customs has gotten too vigilant to count on anything from outside making it through.)

All rice beans seem to need is space. They're a field crop, so you basically just broadcast them. Eventually you'll get some seedling (the first two leaves look sort of like spear points) then the regular leaves show up. I can't give any advice about support because I still don't have a clear idea of what kind they need (I have had plants climb, plants that went bushy and plants that never got more than four or five inches tall and therfore needed no support, all from the same batches. EVENTUALLY, I'd like to get those separate, but it's harder than it sounds). Flowers are yellow, and are borne in groups of two to about five (depending on type of plant).

Pretty much anything I need I'll already have removed (i.e. all of the off color seeds, which I grow primarily because the overwhelming preference for pure red is probably driving all of the other colors to extinction. The Southeast Asian populations are stable at the moment, but with China exporting so much around the world, they could be swamped out as well.) I suppose that, if any of your plants DID go bush, saving those separately might be a good idea (bush is likely to be more attractive to large scale farmers, since they won't need outside support). That's about all I can think of. If they do well, I can always send you rarer types later (like the giant version that shows up in bags sometimes, the one that about as long as a pinto bean (rice beans aren't just shaped like grains of rice, they are about the same size. Oh and they are GROWN traditionally in the rice paddies when they are drained for the year.) 

I currently have about 1/2 and oz. of cleaned seed. When I get to a full oz. I'll contact you for the mailing address.

   

UnicornEmily

Oh, I didn't know a lot of citrus had thorns!  I know trifoliate oranges do.  Well, I guess I'll keep an eye out for thorns on any sprouts that live, then.  Thorny plants are something I'm trying hard to avoid.

That sounds great!  Yeah, I'd love to try that species.  When I grow them, what kinds of traits should I watch out for, as things that may be promising for you?

You're right, saving the bush seeds and pole seeds separately would be a good idea.  Smart thinking.  I should do that with all my bean species.  I bet that would make it a lot easier to plan out where to put things.

Let's see, so next year, I'm thinking I'll be growing common beans, lima beans, tepary beans, runner beans, cowpeas, and now rice beans.  That's quite a few species!  :D  It'll be interesting to see which ones do best.

Do you grow any crops through the winter?  I've been thinking about planting Austrian winter peas in the fall to replace all my warm weather beans.  I bought some recently to use for that purpose.  Everybody in my family likes peas.


Jeremy Weiss

AS far as I know, pretty much ALL citrus have thorns. And looking at the seedlings won't help; the thorns don't show up until the plants are older. If you are committed to thornless citrus; you're pretty much limited to the really tiny ones, like kumquats and calamondins.

Yeah, bush usually beats pole. I suspect that the only reason pole beans are still relatively common is that a lot of them were grown in small home gardens, where people could take the time to put up supports. And, of course, thew fact that the "Three sisters" method of planting that the Native Americans used meant there was a ready support (the cornstalks) already there (if corn were as small and delicate as wheat or most of the other grains, or didn't exist, I suspect the Europeans would have found few domestic beans that were not bush type.) The only other crops where pole/climbing types are tolerated tend to be those where bush types are either rare (lablab/hyacinth beans would fit this, there are bush types, but not many.) plain don't exist (peas) or are crops generally grown on a field like basis where you plant to just take the whole plants up at the end of the season and thresh them like a grain (rice beans, azukis and the other small beans and many cowpeas.)

Incidentally, I have a lot of Bambarra groundnuts (Vigna subterrenea) as well for next year, but I'm not handing any of those out until I can confirm I have some that will actually GROW and make seed this far north. Same thing with the Kersting's groundnut and the African Yam beans.


As I said, anything I send you will be pre screened for anything I would need, so you can just have fun with them. About the only thing you might see that WOULD be interesting to me is if any plants make flowers that are NOT yellow (I've heard other colors are possible, but have never seen them.) And if any seed comes back not red (or red with markings), at least let me know, so I have a better understanding of the genetics.

It's too cold here to grow anything over the winter, and too wet.

You are aware that Austrian Winter is a soup pea as opposed to a snap pea, right? The pods are going to be pretty fibrous and not taste that great. When you said your family likes peas, I'm hoping you meant they like them as pea soup or something like that.

Oh, and since I HAVE grown Austrian winter myself once, if yours happen to throw any pure black/purple seeds, please put some to the side for me. 

Garrett Schantz

https://www.seedways.org/product-page/bambaras-village-mix

Here's a page with more Bambaras.

Dunno if it's the same type or ones that you have.

They also have landrace / rare peas and other neat stuff on there.

They had a yellow fruited ashwagandha at one point too. Wish I'd gotten it.

Oh yeah, some Pawpaw relatives are decently cold hardy - same genus, not family.

Bigflower pawpaws seem easy enough to find and grow.


There are some "very" cold hardy citrus that I'm looking into. Some may become weedy in my area eventually if I let them do whatever though.

I have those marked down and will update later.


Been looking into growing a bunch of Musa, Asimina, Yucca - other neat things just to let them wildy hybridize while I select for good fruits.

Surprisingly a lot of wild Musa species will grow in zone 8. Sorta hard to find any US sources though.

Lot of them should work in zone 7 as well, but... Those are mostly not very edible.