A newly available Tim Peters tomato

Started by William Schlegel, 2022-10-05, 06:48:39 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

UnicornEmily

Ah!  Sorry!  Yeah, I was thinking you were quoting someone here, as opposed to over there.  My apologies.  ;)

I bought seeds, too!  I'm excited to grow them.

AndrewB

Got mine!

Yes, extra tiny seeds! Must be bred from wild tomato species indeed! exciting!

UnicornEmily

Oh, do wild tomato species have smaller seeds?  I've never heard that before.  How fascinating.  Does the size affect the germination rate?

They really are tiny!

Joseph Lofthouse

Here's a photo comparing seeds of three species of tomatoes. The larger seeds of domestic tomatoes get the plant established quicker, cause there's more food reserves.

wild-tomato-seeds.jpg

William Schlegel

It is a classic R selected vs. K selected situation. Wild tomatoes produce larger numbers of smaller seeds because dispersal is more important and are R selected. Domestic tomatoes produce a smaller number of larger seeds because humans have been trained to do much of the dispersal work.

You can also think about it as a function of the size of the seed dispersing animal. Here is a similar example: Domestic apples evolved with humans and brown bear (grizzly) dispersal in Kazakhstan, wild apples evolved with bird dispersal. So apple sized tomatoes evolved with human dispersal and tiny tomatoes likely evolved with small bird dispersal.

Coevolutionary action is very important for crops. In fact, the very nature of domesticated crops may be hallmarked by the visually diverse landrace. Human protection allows visible mutations to proliferate in our domesticated populations. Only we have deviated from that norm in relatively modern times.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Diane Whitehead

The other seeds I have from Tim - Fruity Cherry and Sweet Orange II - have small seeds, though not as small as Tim's Taste of Paradise.
Victoria, British Columbia, Canada
cool mediterranean climate  warm dry summers, mild wet winters,  70 cm rain,   sandy soil

UnicornEmily

#21
I'd never thought of that, but it makes sense that bigger seeds would happen naturally in domesticated crops.  Humans would find bigger seeds easier to harvest and store than tiny seeds (which are more likely to get lost), and more food for the embryo is better for a plant's offspring anyway, so if it's not meant to be swallowed and dispersed by a tiny bird, larger seeds might easily happen even without humans deliberately selecting for it.

And of course larger seeds WOULD get deliberately selected for in species where humans want to eat the seeds -- grains like corn and legumes like beans, for instance.

Hmmmm, now I wonder if this is true of most species.  I've collected seeds from several banana species, and I've seen a lot of difference in seed size between species.  The largest seeds are from the species that is the most popular for humans to grow from seed.  I wonder if larger seeds might be, as a general principle, a sign of the plant being more domesticated?  Being able to intuit approximately how domesticated a species is just by looking at the size of its seeds compared to close relatives' seeds may be very useful.

My thinking has been that I probably want to encourage my bananas to either grow smaller seeds, so that they can be swallowed without being annoying, or bigger seeds and far fewer of them, so that they're easier to eat around.  I've been thinking I would probably prefer the latter, since bigger seeds tend to be easier to germinate, and I want that.  It sounds like that's definitely going to be the goal to shoot for, if that's the direction a more domesticated plant will prefer to go anyway.