fall planted grains for low input organic agriculture

Started by Steph S, 2022-07-07, 08:51:01 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Tim DH

Finally got the Wakelyn's YQ planted. I was somewhat delayed by digging a trench for the new Ground Source Heat Pump! We went for a borehole, which was drilled 15metres from the house. I thought digging a 1 metre deep trench between the two would take me five days. ... It took seven.

Anyway the WYQ  is in, not the latest date I've ever sown winter wheat. I've done half a bed, the other half is my 'usual' wheat which was, originally, just sown from a sack of organic chicken feed!

Tim DH
IMG_3136_edited.jpg

Steph S

Nice work Tim!  :) And great timing on that heat pump.

How much growth do you expect on the wheat before winter?  Or does wheat just grow more or less continuously in your climate until spring speeds it up?

Tim DH

Hi Steph,
    Apologies for the slow reply. I photo'd my grain beds a couple of days ago. The better established one was sown about October 10th. It's Rye at the top and a new (to me) Oat at the bottom.
    The Rye was 'collected' at the start of the Millennium, whilst cycling home from Genoa. I saw this field of grain I couldn't identify, so I took a few heads home to show Dad.
    The Oats are from a friend who grows it every year. I've tried Oats in the past, more than once, but never got on with it. However we use Oats so I thought I'd try again.

    The less established bed is Wheat. Wakelyn's YQ at the top, my 'chicken' corn at the bottom. Sown October 19th. I wonder if the Wakelyn's was industrially dried. (It was sold for milling rather than planting!) I think it will be OK, so long as the current warm spell doesn't go on too long. The problem with the warmth is it enables the slugs to get about, but there isn't enough day-length for the grain to do much growing! So the grain just sits there getting hammered. One good frost would be a blessing! We've got night-time temps of 11 degrees C forecast in the next week!!

Steph S

Well I see we're not the only ones having that warm fall situation.  It was so warm in September, the big threat here was grasshoppers, which just didn't go away until that first bit of frost in October.  By that time I thought it would be too late, and I got tied up with work as well,  so I didn't follow through on my fall grain plans.  All I got in was the Salish Blue, and it is at least a foot tall now, the row cover finally blew off it a couple of days ago but there don't seem to be many predators around to chew on it now, so I think I'll leave it off and hope that the plants get hardened off with the cooler weather we expect some time soon.
We have a new slug here, just the past couple of years, which turned out to be 'Black Arion' an import from Europe.  Just a voracious eater of carrot seedlings, cilantro, anything in the carrot family seems to be the favorite.  This summer was so dry though that I believe they were seriously knocked back. I haven't seen a one around lately.   Fall has been relatively dry as well.

Tim DH

   Crazy weather we are having here.... Tonight's 'low' is forecast to be 13 Celcius. Our average maximum for November is 8.47 (average minimum 3.5)
   I wouldn't normally do a slug cull on winter sown grain, but I went out tonight and got a couple of hundred (head torch & scissors).

Tim DH

We've past the Equinox now and that Autumn sown grain is starting to look happier.

WheatA is my usual and WheatB is WakelynsYQ. The Wakelyns is, so far, much flatter to the ground and a bluer green.

The Oats look OK, but the real star is the dwarf Rye. This is the grain which is most welcome in the kitchen too!

They are all in rows 9inches apart.

Tim DH

Steph S

Very nice Tim!  That's a sight for sore eyes - garden is under four feet of snow here at present.

I meant to post pics of the perennial wheat, which is the only fall sowing I managed to do this time.  It turns out that row cover is the answer to the pest question.  But with a warm fall, it also resulted in a lot of lush growth.  I uncovered it in november, and the pic in december is after a light snow that melted.  A bit crushed and browsed I believe, but not too bad the worse for wear.  We had no major snow cover until mid february, which hasn't stopped - well it has lots of snow cover now!


Tim DH

All winter my usual wheat was looking much happier than the WakelynsYQ, but now the tables have turned! The usual wheat has a lot of leaf yellowing, which I associate with rust.

The Oats look much healthier too, with some very broad leaves. The Rye is already putting up flower stems.

Tim DH

Steph S

Looking lovely, Tim!   So nice to see rust resistance in the Wakelyns.
My Salish Blue died back completely during the winter, but there are a few green bits starting to show, so I hope it won't be affected by some frosty nights we are still expecting.
I'm just now prepping to plant spring grains - nearly a month later than last year's planting.

Steph S

Heading time here, and wondering how your wheat is doing Tim.
I'm happy to say that the Salish Blue planting came back from the ground and made a strong stand.
The bigger surprise has been, well it's not (or not entirely) xTritipyrum at all... it's a huge mix of things, which I assume to be a mix of ordinary winter wheats not perennial.
I guess the good news is, I think I've figured out how to do the fall planting with row cover and then let nature take its course.  If all these wheats survived it, it must be the right way to do.
These are rain fed, and are doing well in spite of the dry.  Bed next to them is favas and a few short rows of the spring wheats to see how they panned out in a late planted/ rain fed situation. Very weak compared to the fall planting, for sure.

Tim DH

The grain is finally all winnowed and threshed, so its time for a review.

As usual the Rye was most productive. It had a good year. 560g/m

The (experimental) Oats were almost as good 545g/m. But threshing and winnowing them was an absolute pain. I'd quite like to drop it, but the wife is keen to try home oats in the kitchen, so I'll plant a bit of it just incase, by next year, she can convince me its worth the effort.

My usual Wheat had a bad year. Serious rust, only 233g/m.

The new Wheat (Wakelyns YQ) did much better 485g/m. It got off to a bad start, possibly because the commercial threshing/winnowing of the seed was more aggressive than I am! (It was sold for home milling, not as seed.) I'll be interested to see how well my saved seed from this year establishes. I was quite surprised at how little visual variation there was in the heads. Most of the heads were like the four on the left. The four on the right were much less common and the long awned head really rare. Since the outcrossing rate of Wheat is so low I guess it doesn't take many generations for uncompetitive genotypes to dwindle in a population. I don't know how long my supplier had been growing Wakelyns YQ, but I'd expect the balance of the  population to be skewed by the constraints of their growing environment.

Tim DH

Hmm, I'm sure I only attached that photo once!

Steph S

Sorry it took me so long to update, and still haven't gone through all my pics but I found the grain I'd shucked as I was cleaning up the basement today and snapped a quick pic for show and tell.

2023 was a difficult year for the wheats (among other things).  It was a very humid summer, and soon after heading I began to see fungal diseases - some fusarium head blight, some stagnospora glume blotch which I hadn't seen before, on the winter wheat patch and later on some spring wheats too.

I did an early cull of diseased heads in the Salish Blue patch hopefully selecting for resistance - several of the off type wheats were badly affected and were culled out early (the Einkorn was totally FHB susceptible) and/or late. For the most part I didn't keep culling, I left later waves of disease to better assess resistance, and omitted diseased heads at harvest time. 
Eric from Northwest Meadowscapes advised that the off types may be grains stuck in the harvester from other crops elsewhere, and not related to the Salish Blue, but that there was some phenotypic variation as well in the original sample of the accession.  I did find several phenos that were clearly xTritipyrums but not exactly Salish Blue, in addition what appeared to be bread wheats resistant enough to make it to harvest time.

The other bad scene for wheat in 2023 was the voles.  What a year.  They devastated my peas and greens seedlings, and started on the grains as soon as heads were starting to ripen.  This certainly messed up my selection plan for earliest heads (which vole got) but I did save the next earliest.  The voles also caused to me to harvest everything quite early, in most cases earlier than optimal so fingers crossed all seeds are viable. 

I decided not to leave the patch as perennial on account of the disease burden, and didn't replant immediately either, on account of the unresolved vole situation.  Did a major wheat cleanup and composted in an area of the garden where wheat won't be grown (currant bushes). 

I've been reading about seed treatments that may work in organic systems, and will also get back to my notes on that before I plant again, just to avoid any seedborne disease issues, hopefully, for the next attempt probably fall 2024.

So here's a pic of the seeds from Salish Blue (greenish antho) matching the pheno description, front row left, and a couple of heads that were a little different: some very similar heads with a few awns, and some non-antho grains which are otherwise very similar to the Salish Blue.
Awns are interesting - I've read they help to moderate intense sunlight/heat so I'm happy to see the trait turn up.
Two stray awned bread wheats in the back, the grains are quite different more like a bread wheat, so I think probably unrelated to the xTritipyrum and unlikely to be perennial.