Grains 2022

Started by Steph S, 2022-07-01, 10:33:31 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Steph S

Planting dates, survivorship and earliness of your crop:

This year I have combined rows of different grains in a variety of beds which are out of rotation from garlic and scattered around the garden, so some variability in shade, soil quality, and microclimate from bed to bed.  I wanted to evaluate earliness and flowering times, so every bed has at least two wheats to compare.   I also used two different planting dates, and double planted some of the grains to compare their dates from staggered planting and to act as a "clock" for the partners that were only planted once.

As I mentioned last season, I'm a complete novice to grain growing.  I've been reading a lot, always learning something new, and still have everything to learn about the wheat family and other small grains.    This year I have Goldkorn spelt from a fall planting, and a spring spelt to compare.   Three bread wheats : Huron, Purple and Prelude.  Three Emmer plantings, separating short and tall variants of the "Blue Tinge" landrace from last season, plus a Black hulled Emmer.  And three species wheats:  Rivet, Militina and Zhukovsky.

After reading on experiments with early planting of spring wheats, I was looking for a day/night average of 2C for three days before I planted.  So my first date was April 16, and it was quite a warm day and above the "2C" average which unfortunately didn't turn into a warm period.  Second planting was April 22, still cool.  Realistically this is not an "early spring" planting it is a "late winter" planting, as we had many repeats of frost and snow afterwards, and a long stretch of below normal temperatures in may.  I used row cover, mainly for animal protection, on the expectation that seedlings would be fairly frost hardy.   Survivorship from both planting dates was patchy.  You could see that germination had been good, but numerous small seedlings had become crispy critters.  The only one that had 100% survival was the Spring Spelt.

Fast forward through an unusually hot June, and the earliest wheats (and Black Hulless Barley) are heading or emerging from the boot, at the same time the garlic scapes are emerging.  I find this kind of exciting because garlic, like wheat, is very much governed by the degree days.  So it is likely a very good marker for the actual earliness and crop timing expectations for our extremely variable season.  This is early for scapes, and not surprising due to the much warmer than normal temperatures since the middle of June.

The big surprise though, is that there's no difference in heading time, between the two plantings of same kinds of wheat.   I guess there were not enough wheat degree-days between them.  Prelude from both plantings began heading June 26.   Purple wheat from both plantings on June 29.    Also double planted were Huron and Rivet, which are not heading at July 1 but are afaict putting out the flag leaf at this point, and no apparent difference in the two plant date beds.

So I think I will stagger spring planting dates again next season, but also try some more dates into May.  It would be nice to improve survivorship by nailing down the best time and/or temperature conditions for the spring plantings.   It would be good to know too, just how late an early wheat can be planted and still get a crop here.  That is besides knowing the anthesis dates of the varieties and how to stagger planting for a cross I might want to make.

I would love to hear your thoughts and observations about planting dates for spring wheats.

I'm also going to continue trials with fall planted wheats, especially the spelts, but also the two Zanduri wheats and perhaps the rivet.  All three had patchy survival from spring planting similar to the spring wheats, but perhaps they would do better as a more mature seedling going into fall.


Jeremy Weiss

I actually just ended up tossing most of my old small grains into one pot (as I don't have the kind of land space to grow grains on the scale necessary to use it for food, I tend to select my grains based on attractiveness of the heads; so I can use them in dried flower arrangements. So letting them mix and cross isn't a problem for me.) I think I tossed in some einkorn, two or three kinds of emmer* (gold and black hulled), my shot wheat, a two packets of Utrecht Blue (plus their contaminants*) and one vial of the Tibetan barley that I had left after growing out the Chusi Gandruk mix Kusa Seed Society sells.

At first, I though the animals had ended up eating ALL the grains. But when I was checking today, I saw a few blades poking through, so SOMETHING must have survived.

*I originally SOWED only two emmers, the golden and the black hulled. However, when it was growing I noticed that two or three of the einkorn head were getting much bigger than the others, as well as wider. So I think either some emmer got mixed into the Einkorn packet (different from the other two) or some of the einkorn spontaneously doubled its chromosome number (which it can) and became emmer itself.

**The company I got my Utrecht Blue packets from  (Botanical Interests) seems to be having a problem with keeping the seed clean. Besides the long dark grains in each packet (which I assume is the Blue) there were five or six smaller, redder grains that looked like some sort of bread wheat, as well as one or two hulled barley grains.)   

Steph S

Glad to hear some of your seeds came, Jeremy!

Tall Emmers from the Blue Tinge Emmer landrace (Salt Spring) are also early., and will probably overlap Prelude and Purple for anthesis.
I saved and planted seed separately for the different phenos observed last year.  The tall emmers, which were at least a week later than the short ones last year, were planted on April 16th and started to head on the 28th and 29th. 
The tall emmer had several different phenotypes which are looking to be quite distinct.  The blue one is tallest of the lot, and emerged a day later than the first of the red-purple ones. Foliage on the red-purple is notably a light, bright green compared to the dark blue-green of the others. There was also a black awned one, which only a few survived but coming on a little later.  A green one with no antho and a blonde grained pheno with a fat head have only one or two smaller plants surviving.
I suspect that one may have been a stray grain from something else.  But I certainly got a mix of very different emmers in "Blue Tinge" from Salt Spring.  Next post about the short ones.
I'm really looking forward to see the heads (yes they are really pretty!) and whether they are true to the same colors seen last season.
These tall emmers are planted in a bed with Militina (Chelta Zanduri) which is far behind, just beginning the jointed stage, and one row of Rivet which is fairly far along and looking like it will come in around the same time as Huron and Black Hulled Emmer.

Steph S

The short emmer from "Blue Tinge" got planted in the back bed, in the same rows as Prelude.  It seems even shorter than last year.
These were planted on the April 22nd but this time are heading a  bit later than their tall sibs planted a week earlier.  They also are looking pretty bad - really bad.  They didn't look great last year, which we blamed on the weather since we had that snow in June etc.   
But I've been looking online for those leaf stripes and it seems like there is a major genetic susceptibility to rust in this emmer line.  The rust is probably hosted by various perennial grasses that have found their way into the background (and foreground) around the place.  So now I am regretting that I don't have a mower or whippersnipper to really keep the grass down a bit.
I don't know if these little plants can possibly produce grain, but they're trying to.
I'm suspecting that the late winter planting losses across the board may have been at least in part due to the leaf rust/stripe rust, and row cover may have made it worse by lengthening the time of condensation on the leaves.  The other plants have outgrown it but these short emmers are having a tough time.

Steph S

BTW Jeremy, I didn't plant the shot wheat afterwards.  I did some reading after your comment about pests, and found that the dwarf Indian wheat is especially susceptible to mildew - this is something we get really badly here if or when the weather turns hot and humid.  I've been struggling to control the weeds that host it the most.  So I dithered about where to put it and in the end I delayed too long - or so I thought, and gave up on finding a spot for them this season.  The plus side for this species is that they're very drought tolerant.  So a planting somewhere that doesn't get watered is not out of the question.

Jeremy Weiss

Well, I wish you better luck than I had. When I finally re-opened the packet I had made of the shot wheat for this year's planting, every grain looked like a "tombstone", and an extremely small one at that. If ANY of what comes up proves to be shot wheat, I'll be surprised.  Not that I can  be sure if it does (despite the common assumption, I really don't notice shot wheat grains as being significantly fatter than any other wheat grains.)

Since I am after "architectural wheat" (that appears to be the correct term for wheat being grown for the flower trade). I'm thinking of trying out some club wheats next time, as I like the short, stubby head shape (not Mt. Pima Club though, I have seen pictures of that, and the uneven beard lengths make it look untidy.) Poulard might also be good, if it can make it though the season her unscathed (something with that much loose hull looks like a bug trap waiting to happen.)

I DID try all of those alternate Russian types (like your Zhoukovsky) but they seem not to like it here (I think it's too wet). Plus, as far as I can tell, they LOOK more or less the same as any other wheat. Add on how hard it is to get Salt Spring to send over the border, and that's a no-go. Though I MAY try Timopheevi again at some point, if only for the extra genes (Ideally, I'd go with out and out Uratu, but I don't know of a source for that.)   

Steph S

Yes, I was reading about the club wheat or "Hedgehog"/Herisson Brun and others which look very ornamental, they are also quite early by reputation so could be an excellent spring wheat for a short and fickle season.
All of my new wheats this season came from Prairie Garden Seeds, btw, they have an amazing selection.  Will be posting pics of their beautiful heads later on, and Jeremy, if you want a few seeds of anything I'm sure it would arrive just fine from me in the post.  A lot of our local seed retailers have stopped shipping to the US and are selling only within Canada since the pandemic, and I believe that's due to the increased demand for seeds as well as the uncertainties of shipping.

I have it in mind that a fall planted grain could be the ideal rotation for garlic, insofar as it could be planted as soon as garlic is harvested, usually mid August, which is said to be the optimal winter wheat planting date here on the island.   But that may not always be possible, depending on the timing of the grain crop from the previous season.  Local ag reps who determined the parameters for winter wheat some time in the past decade have stated that it is not always possible to get grain to plant by the optimal date.  I am interested to see whether grains and garlic continue to 'sync' for degree days to harvest, and whether later plantings would still work, if necessary.

Anyway, the fall planted Goldkorn Spelt has started to emerge from the boot on July 1.   As shown in the pic, Goldkorn is the tall one on the left, followed by some rows of spring spelt that are short and bright green, with the last 5 rows of Purple Wheat, Huron, and Prelude on the right.   Obviously there's an advantage to fall planting, earliness and also tillering.  I was not sure that Goldkorn would pull through since we had just a light frost in September and then it continued to grow into the jointed stage as we experienced a very mild and frost free fall well into December 2021.   I left the row cover on it, except for one part which the wind exposed, and it made no difference to the survival as the worst patch was fully covered.   I removed the cover in late winter when the spring grains were planted, and the remaining stalks were promptly browsed to the nub by rabbits (we are having a rabbit year, I see them every day.  This is the reason for enclosures around the beds, which seems enough to deter them since there is plenty of forage out around.) It was probably for the best, as i understand browsing is not harmful to winter grains and encourages tillering, but I wasn't sure about that when the plant had already gone to the jointed stage.  I put the enclosure around afterwards, so they would have a chance to regrow.

None of this seems to have bothered the Goldkorn.  I did clean up and remove dead leaves at one point, which was probably helpful in terms of the rusts which seem to be affecting all the grains to at least a small  extent on the smaller leaves close to the ground.   It is very thick in the row and is certainly ahead of the spring spelt in terms of harvest date.  I believe the majority of spelts are fall planted and I'm really keen to trial some others as well.  Spelt is my current favorite grain for bread, so it would be great to grow our own, just aside from the superior hardiness which a grain will need to do well in this climate.



Steph S

Hmmm, it appears that different cultivars have different patterns of time to anthesis after emerging from the boot.  Both stands of Prelude were in full flower yesterday evening, after only six days.  Then this morning I saw that the Goldkorn went into anthesis in only three days from heading.   Emmers from the BT landrace and Akmolinka took about two weeks last year, which I thought to be typical.  Guess I'll be paying close attention, although I guess multi years' experience is required to judge how much of this is environmental and how much is genetic.

Greenie DeS

When I thought I'd be moving in June I tossed six seeds each of the glutinous barleys dango mugi and sumire mochi into pots on my deck when the pots were mostly thawed (still had a crust of ice).

The dango mugi seeds germinated, tillered, and are now heading up nicely. One sent up ten tillers, most have three or four (one pot seems poorly drained so what's in it is yellower and smaller) so I need to look at that. If not drainage it may be a fertility issue.

The sumire mochi did not sprout, or else they were immedately eaten by something before I noticed. I expect the former.

On June 8th I tossed some chiddham blanc wheat into a couple rows and it's looking robust and happy.

I didn't plant any other grains (with the exception of corn) this year, but I do have a plan to do some late august planting to see if anything will overwinter.

Steph S

Your corn project is really interesting!  But I'm glad you got at least one wheat coming on.
I did a lot of reading in late winter, about fall planted wheat, spelt, and rivet, and what would be ideal to trial here.  Frost tolerance, snow mold resistance, and so on.  Hoping to get at least a few new ones to trial for August planting as well. 

Greenie DeS

I do have enough seed from last year's trial that I can do an overwintering trial on a bunch of things here. I'm so curious about whether any will work. We have such low temperatures that I'm skeptical. We also have really intense vole populations in the winter - the tunnels are everywhere under the snow. So the young plants would need to be pretty well established by the time the snow came, and not seem even a little like a sprouted grain snack (I may have learned from the crows on my corn this fall).

What are you planning to try?

Steph S

According to what I've read, snow pack is good for winter wheat.  More worry the kind of winter we had last year, mostly turning to rain and then freezing with no cover.  Voles could be a problem for sure.
But the spring grains aren't designed to go through winter.  WInter grains have a vernalization requirement, which is supposed to prevent them from leaving the tillering stage until spring.  Wheat hardiness is variable depending on the stage they get to.   This is why I am thinking the Goldkorn must be adapted to spring planting, because it was definitely into the jointed stage before we finally turned frosty last season.   I think the unevenness of the stand speaks to the amount of damage suffered, which you wouldn't expect with a true winter wheat.   Some are facultative and can be planted either spring or fall - this is what I've read about the Zanduri wheats.
Your question sent me back to my notes, whew!  So much reading and much I had forgotten.  I have a list of spelts and other winter wheats that would be especially promising to trial, but for most there are no commercial sources on this side of the ocean that I could find, and my planting date is fast approaching.  So this may not be the year for a major trial of fall planted grain.   Maybe I should start another thread, just to discuss that longish list of winter grains with potential for low input organic agriculture, and work on sourcing them (or more of them) for the following year.  I will let you know if I'm able to get something for this year.

Meanwhile as of yesterday I have multiple grains in anthesis at the same time!   Prelude, Purple and Goldkorn in one bed (but Goldkorn at a distance of about 4 ft) and Huron is heading there too.   And Prelude and the short emmers in the back bed.  I wasn't expecting anything in the same ballpark as Prelude but the Purple Wheat is a nice surprise, also handsome, healthy and sturdy.  Rivet is heading in the bed with the tall emmers but is taking its time to emerge from the boot. It is also quite healthy looking and much earlier than I expected.   The weather for yesterday and today is about as good as it gets with relative humidity down to 45%, sunny but not too hot at 21C, and plenty breezy enough for pollen transfer to take place.  I don't have high hopes of any natural crossing and hadn't planned on it,  but you never know. 

Steph S

We've just had a major and much needed rainfall event today - right in the middle of heading and anthesis.   I guess it'll be a good test for how susceptible these varieties are to the FHB.
"FHB:
Fusarium infections look different depending on the plant it infects. For barley, Fusarium appears as a brown discoloration at the base of the glumes. On wheat, it appears as a pink or reddish mold on the glumes and kernels. On corn, a pink or reddish mold appears on the tip of the ears.
The environmental conditions in both soil and field that call for vomitoxin analysis include:
Temperatures between 70 to 85 F
    Humidity levels above 20%"
https://www.envirologix.com/catalog/?target=mycotoxin&mycotoxin=vomitoxin-don

That pretty much covers our summer environment, other than colder and wetter!

Bug patrol in the grain beds as of yesterday:


Steph S

It has been an exciting couple of weeks watching the different grains heading up and getting to anthesis.  The heatwave has driven me indoors so it's a good time to post some pics and what I'm thinking about these wheats so far.  Heights as noted are approximate and there may be revisions to final heights - of Zhukovsky, especially, since they are still emerging and just into anthesis.   None of these grains got any fertilizers - I have just left them to scavenge whatever is left over from the garlic (or other) last season.  There are some clear differences in height (and also head size) between the same varieties planted in different beds, and I take that to be a difference in nutrient status.  Partial shade may account for slightly later heading as well.
In the bug patrol, I've been seeing leaf hoppers on grain every day, and just recently finally spotted a couple of damsel bugs which I know are cleanup crew for pests.  Hoping they'll do the job.


Steph S

This pic showing the heights of different grains in one bed - there is a single row of Prelude on the other side of the Huron rows which isn't visible but it is a bit shorter.   We've only had one moderate wind event (by local standards) and there was some lodging but not what I would call significant.
I'll just comment on the two spelts -  major difference in size between the fall planted Goldkorn and the spring spelt (from Prairie Garden Seeds).  The spring spelt is shorter with quite a bit smaller heads than the Goldkorn, and of course less tillering which I would expect from spring vs fall planting.   The Spring Spelt was outstanding for cold tolerance in the late winter planting (April here) and was the only cultivar with 100% survival.