Shortest season tomatoes

Started by William Schlegel, 2022-01-04, 04:20:46 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

William Schlegel

"Wilford
Vegetables / The Tomato Family (Solanaceae) / Tomato
Red cherry tomato. Very early and extremely productive. Slight concentric cracking. Fruit average 1-1.5 in diameter, 0.8oz. Average flavor. Determinate; 12-18 tall; potato leaf; inserted flower stigmas. Given to SSE by John Rahart (NM RA J) who obtained this variety in 1981 while living in Wyoming. It was from a local rancher in Wyoming named Wilford who bred the variety for cold tolerance and the short growing season. SSE Accession # 121649" Seed Savers Exchange Description of Wilford which I just got in the mail.

Looks like the germination test is from 2011, yikes hope it was frozen that is 12 years old and tomato seeds live about 14 years. So I guess I should grow it. Impressed it is from Wyoming. Curious because there are so many other very early red potato leaved tomatoes like Matina and Bloody Butcher.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

William Schlegel

https://underwoodgardens.com/wild-galapagos-tomato/

https://store.underwoodgardens.com/Wild-Galapagos-Tomato-Solanum-cheesmaniae/productinfo/V1182/

A similar case in terms of current tomatoes crossing with domestics is these galapagos tomatoes from Terrior seeds. Andrew Barney sent me my start and what he noted was that they seem to be a stable hybrid with a size far greater than other accessions. However, they also seem to be extremely early. It is also possible that they did originate on the islands and that the putative hybridization occurred there.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Tim DH

   Wilford is an interesting find. Most Potato Leaf earlies are Indeterminate, and, as noted on the 'Back Crossing Latah' thread, the classic Potato Leaf mutation is strongly linked to the Indeterminate gene. I wonder if Wilford is related to Glacier (another PL Determinate) or if its something completely different.
   Wilford is available on this side of the pond. I've half a mind (one year) to cross all my PLs. Since it is a recessive characteristic, that would tell me how many different PL mutations I have. ALSO it should give me some PL F1s. I don't think I've ever seen one of those!!!

Tim DH

William Schlegel

#18
I wonder what the odds are that it's simply the case that Glacier = Wilford. Renamed by seed savers who lost the original name. Or maybe there are distinct differences between the two.

"Glacier
Vegetables / The Tomato Family (Solanaceae) / Tomato
1-2.5 round fruits on 2-3' plants. Sets fruits in cool weather. SSE Accession # 122048 CV SIB" SSE'S description for Glacier.

So twice as tall with a bit larger fruit. That sounds distinct. Other sources call Glacier semi-determinate. Still, could be a parent if Glacier showed up early enough.

Glacier is one of the local favorites, I feel like I should breed with those but haven't gotten around to it yet. Acquired Wilford because it is a reportedly regional variety.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

William Schlegel

Influences on earliness in Tomato.

1.   Disturbance such as plowing: Some tomatoes especially Solanum pimpinillifolium and Solanum peruvianum are corn field weeds. Though some other species seem to be associated with dry wash type habitats so it might be wider than just the two species.

2.   Cold moist habitats like coastal Solanum pimpinillifolium and higher elevation accessions of some habitats.

3.   Deserts: Drought avoidance can mean setting seed as fast as possible.

4.   Small fruit size seems correlated with earliness.

5.   Small plant size seems correlated with earliness.

6.   Fast growth up to a point seems correlated with earliness.

A question I have: How much causal variation in earliness is there at the genetic level?
   If there is variation, that is multiple different genetic influences on earliness we might be able to make even earlier tomatoes.
   
Thoughts on how to breed an even earlier tomato starting with Sweet Cherriette:

1.   Cross sweet Cherriette with even smaller fruited such as Solanum pimpinillifolium, Solanum cheesemaniae, and Solanum galapagense.
2.   Cross sweet Cherriette with desert tomatoes like Coyote, 42 days, and interior forms of Solanum pimpinillifolium.
3.   Cross sweet Cherriette with coastal tomatoes like coastal accessions of Solanum pimpinillifolium, Solanum galapagense, and Solanum cheesemaniae.
4.   Cross sweet Cherriette with a high elevation Solanum habrochaites.
5.   Cross sweet Cherriette with a small micro dwarf tomato.
6.   Cross sweet Cherriette with other ultra-early tomatoes to see if any have different modes of action such as Forest Fire, 42 days, and Anmore Dewdrop.
I don't think I'll make any of those crosses anytime soon but I will continue to cross Mission Mountain Morning with more tomatoes and this may give me a sense of what is possible. I crossed it with Sweet Cherriette and two Solanum pimpinillifolium accessions last year. All three crosses should in theory increase the potential for earliness. 
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Cathy A

Quote from: Tim DH on 2023-01-30, 07:25:14 AMIn my environment a Calendar Early variety has to have the ability to make progress in cool weather.
   A Stopwatch Early variety would be one which has the shortest generation time (seed to seed) until optimal conditions.

That's a good insight, Tim. I am far more interested in Calendar Earliness than Stopwatch Earliness.

In a greenhouse setting, Stopwatch Earliness would be more important than in my own garden. I am always looking for tomatoes that can make good progress under cool conditions.

Adrian

#21
5.   Small plant size seems correlated with earliness.
Not obvious fot this thing.Tiny tim is more late than a tall tomato plant but it look more tolerant at cold.

Probably some f2 (PL) of my cross between canestrino di lucca x andine cornue can give early fruits. I will see if something on thoses f2 can be more early than bloody butcher.
It worth it a cross tiny tim x bloody butcher?

William Schlegel

Quote from: Cathy A on 2023-02-03, 10:23:53 AMThat's a good insight, Tim. I am far more interested in Calendar Earliness than Stopwatch Earliness.

In a greenhouse setting, Stopwatch Earliness would be more important than in my own garden. I am always looking for tomatoes that can make good progress under cool conditions.

I see a potential relationship here between say coastal or high elevation pimpinillifolium tolerance to cool moist conditions and the ability to grow, set, and ripen early. Hmm a testable hypothesis?
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

William Schlegel

Quote from: Adrian on 2023-02-03, 11:42:49 AM5.  Small plant size seems correlated with earliness.
Not obvious fot this thing.Tiny tim is more late than a tall tomato plant but it look more tolerant at cold.

Probably some f2 (PL) of my cross between canestrino di lucca x andine cornue can give early fruits. I will see if something on thoses f2 can be more early than bloody butcher.
It worth it a cross tiny tim x bloody butcher?

Tiny Tim x Bloody Butcher would be an interesting segregation in the F2. Would some of them be earlier than their parents? Would be my questions and reason for making the cross.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Adrian

#24
I think that it possible.Sometimes we have goods surprises on the f2.

I will also sow this f2 between canestrino di lucca x andine cornue.
This f2 was also very more early than the two parents.

Photo take the 28th october for a seedling mid-august. Probably tried others f2 for saw if others f2 can give interested thing.

Steph S

I've also had cases where the offspring were earlier than either parent.
Earliness is certainly a complex trait, especially calendar earliness which requires all the cold tolerance genetics as well. 
In order to maintain the absolute earliest line you have to select for earliness in every generation.
However where the variation in earliness is a matter of 3-5 days, and variation in other qualities especially taste is present, well I admit I soon forgot about which one is earliest of all.  Earliest seedlings always get the best locations in the grow plan, but they don't always turn out to be 'best' all round.
Even in stable OP's, there is often variation in earliness.  One seedling will just be a bit more vigorous and will beat out the others in absolute terms.  I always pick that one to save seeds from in case it's heritable but I'm not sure.  I think there will always be individual variation in seedlings, which is enough to give you a couple of days' difference.


William Schlegel

#26
Quote from: William Schlegel on 2023-01-29, 09:02:36 PMI managed to grow out the F1 of my cross with sweet cherriette in 2022 Mission Mountain Morning x Sweet Cherriette. So I have some F2 seed to grow in 2023. I have more F1 seed I could plant as well.

I sort of wonder where else to go with earliness. Maybe I should cross in a larger early tomato.

One early I have recently acquired seed for is Farthest North from Victory Seed. https://victoryseeds.com/products/farthest-north-tomato

Its story parallels that of Sweet Cherriette a presumed cross between domestic and currant tomatoes Tim Peters made. I learned from the Livingston and the tomato book that currant tomatoes have been available since the 1800's and Yeager released Farthest North in 1934. Assuming it took seven years to stabilize the cross, Yeager would have made it in 1927.

I suspect a lot of the earliest have some recent Solanum pimpinillifolium ancestors.

It will be interesting to see how early the segregates from my two 2022 Solanum piminillifolium crosses become. Mission Mountain Morning the mother has some early parents. The three lines all with the same mother might end up really similar in days to maturity.

Farthest North has been blooming early and prolifically. Used it in some crossing attempts from early on. Very curious how many other earlies have substantial pimpinillifolium genetics. Also how related they are. Farthest North was so early a release that potentially many could be descendant varieties. It will be curious to see how my own pimpinillifolium crosses next year segregate for earliness. Though they have early ancestors on the domestic side as well.

I was wondering last weekend if a cluster of early fruits on a potato leafed MMM x Sweet Cherriette F2 had made the color change from pale green that precedes first blush. Will be interesting to see which variety or segregating population grabs 2023 earliest this year. This is the first year since 2017 I haven't planted Sweet cherriette as a standard for earliness.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

AndrewB

Can some of you growing these extra early varieties start taking quantitative statistics on them?

Like earliest vs fruit size? Then we can choose which is best for breeding.

I also think you do need to reselect for earliness in every generation too.

Cathy A

I'm keeping detailed notes. I'll know fruit size, number of fruit on plant, date of first ripe fruit, and so on.

At this point, most of the varieties I am growing have flowered, _except_ Uluru Ochre. I have three Uluru Ochre plants, none in flower.

I would definitely avoid Uluru Ochre if short season is the goal! I am unlikely to grow it again.

On the other hand, Glacier appears to be the first variety to produce a (green) fruit, plus one additional flower. The plant is tiny, smaller even than the dwarves around it, and probably isn't going to produce much more.

So I would rate Glacier as having potential for crossing, bringing in its early genes, but not for fruit production as it is today.

Tim DH

I'm curious about the various comments regarding Uluru Ochre being shy about flowering. Mine isn't! It's also set some fruit. (Of course, there is always the chance that my plant isn't actually pure UO.)

In terms of earliest. UO isn't even close to Latah, my first fruiter for the last three seasons, but that is hardly a fair comparison. At the moment I'm guessing UO will be mid-season, so not bad for a beefsteak/heritage variety.