Intergeneric - Interfamilial Solanaceae hybrids

Started by Garrett Schantz, 2021-07-05, 10:24:31 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Garrett Schantz

Figured I would make a thread about general Solanaceae hybrids.

It has been pointed out that Goji berries and Tomatoes can hybridize through embryo rescue.

Tomatoes can also hybridize with Litchi tomatoes - again using Embryo rescue.

"Stamens of the hybrid were equal as long as styles (Figs. 9, 10) and usually free (as in S. sisymbriifolium), however with more loose arrangement than in paternal flowers (Fig. 10e). Only in few of observed hybrid flowers the stamens were fused together and formed a tube which surrounded the styles and stigma similarly to the tomato flowers. The stamens morphology of hybrids was similar to the S. lycopersicum and S. sisymbriifolium ones with the intermediate length. The hybrid stamens were usually yellow (Fig. 10d) as in S. sisymbriifolium https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10681-019-2358-9 Seems like this hybrid would be really nice in the "Beautifully Promiscuous" portion of the tasty tomato project...

The pollination with tomato pollen was unsuccessful, however cross-pollination of hybrids with S. sisymbriifolium resulted at very low fruit set (fruits morphologically similar to S. sisymbriifolium). Interestingly, in some of the produced mature fruits, only globular embryos were present. These results indicated that hybrid progeny is partially female-fertile.

S. sisymbriifolium was used as the male parent, could attempt to save seed from these male-sterile early hybrids - grow the seeds out again and cross them with a plant with restored fertility. Could end up with a large Litchi tomato if nothing else.

I would try using S. sisymbriifolium as a female parent if at all possible. Might be able to backcross to tomatoes rather than S. sisymbriifolium.

S. sisymbriifolium hybrid images:
https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10681-019-2358-9/figures/5
https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10681-019-2358-9/figures/6
https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10681-019-2358-9/figures/7
https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10681-019-2358-9/figures/9
https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10681-019-2358-9/figures/10

Eggplants (S. melongena in particular) can be hybridized with S. torvum, S. elaeagnifolium, S. insanum

Mention of a dwarf determinate intergeneric cross eggplant: https://twitter.com/SOLbreedCOMAV/status/1356265631952347136

Other interesting Eggplants related things:
https://twitter.com/MoticPathEU/status/1321430972131409922?s=20
https://twitter.com/SOLbreedCOMAV/status/1388394517821280265?s=20

There are of course some species that cross readily without Embryo rescue, tomato / relatives for example can be easily hybridized (Excluding S. peruvianum and a few others).

All of these can hybridize quite easily - a lot of them without embryo rescue, though the offspring is usually sterile for the most part(Also depends on specific accessions in certain cases):

Naranjilla(S. quitoense), Cocona (S. sessiliflorum), Indian nightshade - Hairy-fruited eggplant (S. lasiocarpum / ferox), S. pseudolulo, S. stramoniifolium

Cocona is spineless, Indian nightshade is from Asia - whereas the other species are from South America, this makes it a great resource for genes that would enable other species to be cultivated elsewhere as well as added disease/pest tolerances.


Going to mention some other Solanaceae species, mention some possible benefits for adding into other cultivated species.

Tamarillo Cyphomandra betacea(Not calling it Solanum, this is basically a small tree - seems to be in a group with a bunch of other species)

Cyphomandra corymbiflora - Hardy to 15F

Pepino S. muricatum - Can hybridize with some wild relatives like S. caripense(which has a bunch of variants - vining - bush).
There are many varieties of Pepino found outside of the U.S. - Europe. There are purple fruited varieties.

Somatic hybrids with tomatoes have been produced in the past: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24221316/
Probably wouldn't hurt to attempt embryo rescue with Pepino / Tomatoes

Solanum pachyandrum

Solanum alternopinatum

Solanum aethiopicum

Solanum macrocarpon

Solanum centrale

Solanum laciniatum

Solanum aviculare

Solanum retroflexum - Solanum nigrum: Either of these two would pretty much be great if someone wanted decent tasting anthocyanin filled tomatoes. Fruit  / Seed size would cause a lot of issues - ploidy could be different from tomatoes as well. Seed / Embryo size could be dealt with by using some wild tomato hybrids.

Jaltomata

Capsicum: Hot peppers might be interesting mixed with some of the new fruity tomatoes. Otherwise, I would say such a cross sounds rather disgusting. Sweet peppers might be fine.

Physalis (Has some very cold hardy species, but they are a pain to hybridize with one another, can't imagine how difficult outside crosses would be)

Lycium - This has already been mentioned on this forum: http://opensourceplantbreeding.org/forum/index.php?topic=231.0


There are probably a bunch of other edible Solanaceae that could be mentioned here as well.


There are articles / documents of successful hybrids between a lot of different species mentioned here, from the 1990s and earlier. So, the question is - If these were successful, why aren't there any new research papers or anything else popping up?

My best guess is that due to most labs being privately owned, once they realized that they had new crops / great hybrids that they blocked off research from the public to prevent other countries from making the same hybrids, "stealing" methods. Such hybrids would probably only be known to certain research groups that share information with each other.


Now the potential problems: (Using tomatoes as examples)

If such crops are in the works, they will almost surely be patented for quite some time - a lot of money would go into these projects.

Imagine a perennial tomato - all fine until the prices of tomatoes go down due to reduced labor costs. Then people growing the annual non-patented types can't really turn a profit.

Same thing could happen with Physalis - Tomato hybrids. The fruits would last a lot longer on shelves, being a Intergeneric hybrid - it could be patented.
Fruits with a few weeks added to their shelf life would pretty much wipe out any other commercial varieties sold to supermarkets - for the most part, a lot of people may not be pleased with "GMOS" or hybrids.

If disease resistances from other species are brought over, regular tomatoes would most likely be decimated after some time. Again, these could possibly be patented as well - incorporating traits from them into standard tomatoes would be a crime until the patents run out.


Some of this may not happen. But the threat of having these things happen worries me enough that we should start making our own Intergeneric - Interfamilial Solanaceae hybrids. This could apply to perennial - cold hardy beans, other species as well.

Plus the possibilities here are quite nice. Softer high shelf life perennial tomatoes - or just cold hardier types. Also, completely non-bitter eggplants.

I may try out some embryo rescue / culture next year if I get the resources. Afterwards I would send out the offspring to anyone who wants seed.

I will be growing out some species mentioned here in pots this year, they will be cycled outdoors in the pots next year.

reed

Goji berries have gone feral at my house. I started with two little bushes and now there are 1/2 a dozen or more that have come up nearby. That would be really cool if someone crossed them to tomatoes but it's a little beyond my skill level I think.

I got a new plant this year, I think it is German blackberry or Schwartzbeeren. I looked it up and came up with Solanum nigrum. Someone gave me a bunch of seeds and they sprouted very easily but the plants are not doing all that well. I think flea beetles are about to kill them off although a couple are holding on better than others.  Reading about them it sounds like they actually originated in Russia rather than Germany. Maybe a good prospect to cross to tomatoes, looking for a new fruit with cold tolerance? Again well above my skill set.

Garrett Schantz

I am also quite interested in Solanum lycocarpum. No idea of where to find seeds though. Would need to be grown in a pot.

It is eaten by the Maned Wolf (Chrysocyon brachyurus), which isn't closely related to any other living Canids. Found in large portions of the wolves diet - thought to kill off parasitic worms in their intestines and also lower their cholesterol.

Humans have used it for medicinal purposes as well.

Could be interesting if crossed with one of the edible Australian solanum species. Unsure of how all of the steroidal compounds would mix together though. Could be some toxic mixtures.


Any potential crosses could have toxins that aren't detectable by taste. Most glycoalkaloids have unpleasant tastes.

Garrett Schantz

Quote from: reed on 2021-07-06, 08:36:18 AM

I got a new plant this year, I think it is German blackberry or Schwartzbeeren. I looked it up and came up with Solanum nigrum. Someone gave me a bunch of seeds and they sprouted very easily but the plants are not doing all that well. I think flea beetles are about to kill them off although a couple are holding on better than others.  Reading about them it sounds like they actually originated in Russia rather than Germany. Maybe a good prospect to cross to tomatoes, looking for a new fruit with cold tolerance? Again well above my skill set.

Solanum retroflexum survived flea beetles for me here.

Solanum villosum and S. nigrum are destroyed by the flea beetles here. There arent even any feral / wild nightshades other than Physalis species here.

Jeremy Weiss

Quote from: Garrett Schantz on 2021-07-07, 12:06:58 AM
I am also quite interested in Solanum lycocarpum. No idea of where to find seeds though. Would need to be grown in a pot.

It is eaten by the Maned Wolf (Chrysocyon brachyurus), which isn't closely related to any other living Canids. Found in large portions of the wolves diet - thought to kill off parasitic worms in their intestines and also lower their cholesterol.

Humans have used it for medicinal purposes as well.

Could be interesting if crossed with one of the edible Australian solanum species. Unsure of how all of the steroidal compounds would mix together though. Could be some toxic mixtures.


Any potential crosses could have toxins that aren't detectable by taste. Most glycoalkaloids have unpleasant tastes.

You might want to check with http://sacredsucculents.com/. They do a lot of seed collecting in South Amrica, and I THINK they will do requested searches.

On the Australian species I think it might be interesting to try and cross Solaum opacum with something to make the fruits bigger. As they stand now, they are too small, (and not numerous enough) to make them worth much.

Garrett Schantz

Solanum laciniatum, S. sisymbriifolium, S. retroflexum and a Perennial Physalis species are all beginning to flower / form buds.

I might post flower comparisons or dissect a few flowers to note structural differences.

Garrett Schantz

Posted an outside look of some flowers.

Physalis species are pretty far removed from Solanum species. Jaltomata crosses could be attempted, I suppose. Some species have similar flower structures  / sizes - fruit size - foliage type - growth type. Both species have some tasty fruits as well. I posted an image of a perennial Physalis species that I found growing outside last year.


S. sisymbriifolium has currant - cherry sized fruits depending on the variety. It is difficult to find named varieties in the U.S. - seed banks are the best choice if someone wants to explore the species.

For tomato hybridization, I would try selecting for pimpnellifoium sized seeds / fruit. Embryo rescue is probably needed here as well. The flower structure seems more similar to some wild tomato species rather than domestic types. So, selecting towards something with a similar - outer / inner flower structure may work out well. "Natural" pollination attempts appear to abort due to incompatible flower structures - using wild flower types could result in a hybrid, wouldn't hurt to attempt it this way.

I added a habrochaites flower to the S. sisymbriifolium image, just to show how large the flowers are.


Wonderberries have very small white flowers. The fruits are also quite small, they also have smaller seeds than domestic tomatoes - pimpnellifoium.

For hybridization attempts to be successful, I would probably need to select for the "Pea-Sized" pimpnellifoium / neorickii / penneli fruits, along with the flower size of of neorickii or chmielewskii. Seed size would be a focus here as well. Some other species may be needed to have the inner parts of the flowers match up well. Embryo rescue would probably still be needed, but the offspring would probably be much better off - less chances of failure.

Garrett Schantz

One of the Kangaroo apples are flowering.

Once both species begin to flower, I will dissect them along with other solanum species, just to look at possible incompatibilities in flower structures.

Garrett Schantz

Solanum retroflexum and S. pimpinellifolium fruit comparison.


I am using the Wild Currant Tomato From Peru type from HRseeds as a comparison - the fruits are pea sized, close to the Wonderberry(S. retroflexum).

Alberto Shatters and Wild Currant Tomato From Peru appear to be nearly identical. Both show a bit of exsertion from time to time.

Ideally I would have a exserted S. pimpinellifolium - small seeds, flowers and fruit. I would probably need to do the cross in a lab setting, exsertion might not matter - could be nice for potential backcrosses though.

This website has a nice list of chromosome counts for S. retroflexum:

https://phytokeys.pensoft.net/article/21991/

Notable species:

S. retroflexum (Wonderberry) (2n=4x=48)

S. villosum (Hairy / Wooly Nightshade) (2n=4x=48)

S. scabrum (Garden Huckleberry) (2n=6x=72)

S. nigrum (European Black Nightshade) (2n=6x=72)

S. americanum (American Black Nightshade) (2n=2x=24)

Different websites will give different chromosome counts. Each species is variable - hybrids are also possible.

Crosses / backcrosses have been made with potatoes

https://www.wur.nl/en/Publication-details.htm?publicationId=publication-way-313039333238


S. lycopersicon(Tomato) 2n=2x=24

All of the "wild tomato species" appear to have the same chromosome count. Some tomato varieties have different counts though, probably due to chemicals being used to facilitate certain crosses with the wild relatives.

https://www.researchgate.net/publication/237187251_A_new_diploid_chromosome_number_for_tomato_Lycopersicon_esculentum

Preliminary meiotic examination of the variety 'Flora-Dade' (2n = 26 mitotic chromosomes) sometimes revealed 12 associations of chromosomes and sometimes 13 associations.

'Sunny' (2n = 25 mitotic chromosomes) revealed what appeared to be 12 bivalents.

Centric fission may account for the numerical variation of the diploid chromosome number of tomatoes.

One commercial hybrid variety, revealed 25 mitotic chromosomes. This variety, as well as the varieties with 26 chromosomes, appeared to be fully fertile. Different chromosome numbers did not appear to be associated with any morphological differences between the varieties examined.

I can only find seeds for Flora-Dade - nothing on "Sunny", the other varieties aren't mentioned - perhaps if I requested the full PDF, they would be mentioned.


S. americanum includes some former species in it as well. Some sources used to call it S. nigrum - seed sellers sometimes sell S. nigrum as S. americanum.

S. americanum seems like it would work well in a potential cross. Though, there are toxicity issues even with ripe berries - varieties matter as well. I really want an antho trait that doesn't require sun-exposure to show up.

If I can't find any good S. americanum lines, I will attempt to cross them with larger fruited / more edible species. Wonderberries taste decent enough to me - better than tomatoes.


Jaltomata species would be interesting to work with as well - I am not currently growing any right now, I will be next year. General information - including chromosome counts are lacking, most species are relatively "new".

Garrett Schantz

#9
My main reasoning for not attempting Jaltomata - Solanum species (At least at the moment) is that they appear to be more closely related to Physalis species than things in the Solanum genus. Physalis species also have trouble hybridizing with each other - mostly due to differing chromosome counts, there are discussions of Physalis breeding on other forums. Jaltomata species have troubles hybridizing with species in the same genus even with the same chromosome counts.

Most of the Morelloid clade - (Also know as the S. nigrum complex - Black nightshades) is described here: https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/1541-4337.12756

Certain species can hybridize pretty easily - having the same seed / fruit size, other qualities probably helps.

S. americanum, S. palitans, S. triflorum, S. pygmaeum(usually), S. nitidibaccatum are diploids - these are from the Americas.

S. sarrachoides and S. chenopodioides from Africa are diploids as well. These two species could potentially be used to bridge African and American species together without use of embryo rescue.

Edit: (Seems these aren't from Africa! My bad!)

Most of the clade is at least somewhat edible, I would still be careful.


As I mentioned before, what I really want is to take the Antho gene from this complex and move it to tomatoes. This group has different genes responsible for producing Anthocyanins than the genes responsible in tomatoes.

https://www.mdpi.com/1420-3049/22/6/876
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32054115/

I would say that the genes from the Lycopersicon genus are inferior to the Morelloid clade's. The Antho-Morelloid species have a much higher Anthocyanin content than what is found in any of the "wild tomatoes" along with hybrids. The Antho-Morelloid also contain the anthocyanin inside of their fruit - tomatoes only contain it on the peel. And of course, the Antho-Morelloid species do not require sunlight exposure in order to express the anthocyanin.

There has already been mention of the Snapdragon Antho genes being inserted into tomatoes - these are classified as GMOs, due to actual genes being inserted. These will need to be tested in trials before the general public tastes them.

The snapdragon antho gene was mentioned here, there is also some fun related discussion there as well (http://opensourceplantbreeding.org/forum/index.php?topic=548.msg7177#msg7177)

The overexpression of other MYB-type TFs, both endogenous, such as SlANT1 (Mathews et al., 2003), and heterologous, such as AtPAP1 (Zuluaga et al., 2008), led to the first partial successes with tomatoes characterized by an anthocyanin-spotted fruit peel. Finally, anthocyanin-enriched tomatoes were produced when Butelli et al. (2008) overexpressed the regulatory genes Delila (Del; bHLH) and Rosea1 (Ros1; R2R3 MYB) from snapdragon (Antirrhinum majus) under the control of the tomato fruit-specific E8 promoter, resulting in completely purple fruits not only in the peel but also in the flesh (Fig. 2). Del and Ros1 were able to activate not only LBGs but also EBGs, such as Phe ammonia-lyase and CHI (Butelli et al., 2008), strongly promoting flavonoid biosynthesis. The anthocyanin content was comparable to the levels found in blackberries and blueberries (>2 mg gāˆ’1 fresh weight; Butelli et al., 2008). https://academic.oup.com/plphys/article/182/4/1841/6116463

In short - the gene from Snapdragon is superior to the pre-existing Lycopersicon Antho traits - the Snapdragon trait has blueberry levels of Anthocyanin - found in the peel and flesh. There are some photographs of the fruit in the academic article.


I am unsure of how well an Antho-Morelloid x Lycopersicon would compare to the Snapdragon gene - Lycopericon in terms of Anthocyanin content.

At the very least, we would be able to share seed for the Antho-Morelloid x Lycopersicon. The GMO would probably has a patent - which I'm not against entirely as they spend a lot of money on these things.

There would probably be "muddy" lines in the beginning as well.



This will once again probably still require embryo rescue, which I do not have a setup for.

What I can do however, is attempt to hybridize African - American Morelloid species, selecting for diploids, larger flowers, taste, along with disease resistance.

Diseases that evolved independently are currently present in related host crops, brought over from different continents. Having a bunch of species from Africa and the Americas could be quite nice.

Of course I would be doing the same thing with the Lycopersicon clade/genus, selecting for smaller flowers, seed size for embryo compatibility, I would probably need to study the pistils as well. Fruit size could be an issue as well - it probably isn't noticed as much with the crosses in the Lycopersicon clade because everything else lines up well enough.

It would be a waste to only select for Anthocyanin if I were to attempt a cross with tomatoes in the future.

Garrett Schantz

Next year I will be growing a lot of Solanaceae species. I can get away with starting most of the tropical / subtropical species in January, others need grown indoors. The species that need started indoors will be started as soon as possible. Some of these, I have grown before and saved seed - others are new to me.

Capsiceae:

Lycianthes moziniana – Tlanoxtle

Capsicum annuum

C. chinense

C. chinense x annuum

C. flexuosum

C. rhomboideum

C. baccatum

C. pubescens

C. praetermissum

C. lanceolatum (Possibly)

C. exile (Possibly)

The peppers include a few different varieties depending on the species. I may not grow every single species here as some of them take over 1 - 2 years before they begin to flower. I am starting to amass quite the collection. Hopefully next year I can start some pepper breeding threads.


Morelloid clade:

Solanum retroflexum

Solanum nigrum

Solanum villosum

Solanum melanocerasum (https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6070582/ This may not be a species - could be a subspecies, should still fit into the Morelloid)


Archaesolanum subgenus: Kangaroo apples / some Leptostemonum species as well - Australian species

Solanum aviculare

Solanum linearifolium x aviculare

Solanum vescum x aviculare

Solanum laciniatum

Solanum lasiophyllum

Solanum sturtianum

(If anyone is able to send other solanum Bush Tucker species - or Solanum plastisexum - Solanum jobsonii, I would be interested in trading seed)


Subgenus Leptostemonum Listing these separately from the Australian species

Solanum candidum

Solanum stramoniifolium

Solanum quitoense

Solanum pachyandrum

Solanum sisymbriifolium

Solanum abutiloides

A lot of these species fit into different clades in the Leptostemonum subgenus, I might edit this in the future to separate them


Cyphomandra Genus/Clade:

Cyphomandra corymbiflora

Cyphomandra beataceae


Jaltomata Genus:

J. bohsiana

J. ventricosa


Lycopersicon-Potatoe Subgenus/Clade:

Lycopersicon Hybrids

L. peruvianum

L. corneliomulleri

L. habrochaites

L. neorickii

L. pimpinellifolium

L. galapagense

L. cheesmanii

L. chmielewskii

L. lycopersicum

S. caripense

S. muricatum (https://bohs.biology.utah.edu/PDFs/Lynn/Bohs-2005.pdf - https://homepages.uc.edu/~tepeej/EricTepe/Research-Solanum.html)

I am probably going to end up growing more Lycopersicon species than what I listed. This "clade" is still being made, genetic tests and everything else are needed to piece everything together.




I will probably just plant closely related species closer together and see what happens. This is my first time growing most of these species, so I will get a feel for them before I try anything. I did use a phytosanitary to import a lot of these species - so diseases shouldn't be an issue.


Garrett Schantz

I checked Nindethana, they have some interesting seeds but they aren't doing international orders at the moment.

I will check the others later - thanks for the links.

whwoz

Garrett, there maybe ways around this if you want some seed.  Let me know

Garrett Schantz

I should be fine for now. Probably shouldn't try cramming anything else into the grow room.

It appears that Edibleoz only ships to Australia. Still some interesting stuff on there.


Fairdnkumseeds is quite nice, wide selection of seeds. They also have non-Solanaceae species that I want. A lot of things are out of stock there, so I will need to wait anyways.

Fairdnkumseeds has what they believe to be S. sarrachoides - if the identification is correct, this should be a diploid species.

They also sell Solanum nigrum, Solanum scabrum and S. opacum - which aren't diploids - probably wouldn't merge into a diploid very easily either. Still interesting finds.


Fairdnkumseeds also sells "Tzimbalo African Pepino Solanum Caripense". The species shown there could actually be S. canense

S. caripense is thought to be the wild ancestor of S. muricatum(Pepino) - and they should be able to form hybrids easily. I grew both of them from Bakercreek a while back, noticed the flowers(Size, number of flowers per bract etc), leaves and some other things were different from each other.

Eventually, I read about the species on this website: http://unusualediblesandtheirwildrelatives.blogspot.com/2018/07/rare-pepino-cousins-solanum-sect.html

The S. caripense sold online is probably a misidentification.


I ended up ordering this S. caripense type, just due to the "blue flowers" - normally the flowers are pure white. This could be a rare flower variation, or a pepino crossed into a wild species at some point.
https://www.rarepalmseeds.com/solanum-caripense-reptans?