Beautifully Promiscuous and Tasty Tomato Project

Started by AndrewB, 2021-04-23, 09:42:37 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Kadence Luneman

Oh Interesting! Clearly I missed some things (or forgot them) between the threads over time. And probably lots of the minutia that wasn't posted about, well because it's minutia. And progress is more fun to post about, understandably.

Justin Jardinier

#256
Quote from: Kadence Luneman on 2024-03-15, 03:48:02 PMHmm it does seem weird that the Wildling Panamorous would produce all red fruit and quite domestic tomatoes.

I can say that I had one Wilding that had red fruit but tasted way better than the pure lycopersicum I grew. So maybe don't be too put off by the red colour. Though I don't really understand the dislike of red tomatoes - I love red tomatoes and the only orange/yellow lycopersicum I grew last year tasted very bland to me. Well, I did also grow Exserted Orange but didn't get to eat any since it died from late blight very quickly, unfortunately. I'm open to orange being good, but I love good red tomatoes.

Quote from: Kadence Luneman on 2024-03-15, 03:48:02 PMWould it be useful for someone to reinvent the wheel? To take what has been learned and start from scratch with their own promiscuous project of wild crosses? The project is built primarily from crosses with Big Hill it seems. One could start with different domestic tomatoes to bring in different traits. I really enjoy the way Joseph gardens and landraces but I'm curious to see what else could be learned by starting from scratch and doing some more record keeping and hand pollinations.

You could also start with different SI wild species. I'm in the process of making an SI population using S. arcanum as the source of SI. I'm using S. chmielewskii for a unilateral incompatible population. You could use S. pennellii as an SI source, or S. habrochaites, or perhaps another species if you use more difficult methods. I think integrating late blight resistance would be particularly useful - I'm also working on that in various ways for those populations. Starting with a huge but healthy lycopersicum and a population of habrochaites LA1777 could be an excellent way of working towards an SI population with high late blight resistance, for example, though if you are in a short season environment, you might want to do that in a greenhouse to make sure you get ripe fruits from the crosses. 


Kadence Luneman

Quote from: Justin Jardinier on 2024-03-15, 07:17:48 PMThough I don't really understand the dislike of red tomatoes

I think some are selecting away from red tomatoes because it's what Joseph is selecting, for seed that goes back and forth to further it. And some just personal preferences.

Quote from: Justin Jardinier on 2024-03-15, 07:17:48 PMYou could also start with different SI wild species.

I have Cache valley currant, Neandermato, and Improved Galapagos to work with. I have too many ideas to play with already to try adding growing more wilds to it. Plus I'm not really set on working with specifically SI tomatoes. I hope to pass on SI seed to others who are doing more work with that.

I do hope to utilize the wilds I do have. I'm curious to see where that takes me.

Cathy A

Justin,

I don't have a problem with red tomatoes. Most of the tomatoes I grow are red and lycopene flavored.

However, I grew the wildling specifically because I was excited about the idea of fruity tomatoes that had traits well outside the norm for domestic tomatoes. And I just didn't see that in the seed I had.

Kadence,

I don't have room to grow tomatoes (or anything else) on the scale that William and Joseph can. Still, I grew 2/3 of a 4x4 ft bed tightly packed with wildling, but didn't make an accurate count.

Maybe a dozen plants, give or take?

Not enough to guarantee seeing the full diversity available in the line, but enough that I should have had at least one fruity-flavored non-red plant unless those genetics were quite rare in the sample that I had.

I will be interested to hear from other wildling growers what traits they see and in roughly what % of the population .

Joseph,

Thank you so much for starting the Beautifully Promiscuous and Tasty Tomato Project. There are many different ways that breeders can take these genetic lines, and I know you can't pursue them all yourself. It gives all of a new base on which to breed tomorrow's tomatoes!

Justin Jardinier

Quote from: Cathy A on 2024-03-16, 06:31:52 AMHowever, I grew the wildling specifically because I was excited about the idea of fruity tomatoes that had traits well outside the norm for domestic tomatoes. And I just didn't see that in the seed I had.

Ah I see what you mean. I think you might be seeing that soon, some of Joseph's elites really seem to fit that criteria! Very tasty, not red, and very unusual. Size increase and disease resistance would be the next steps for that I think, but taste is definitely there in the ones I experienced. Perhaps it's there among the Wildings too but might require larger growouts? And perhaps some disease resistance is there hiding in both, if we can find it. Large growouts in areas with heavy late blight pressure would be awesome. I am guessing the elites have more chance of that.

By the way I have seen tomatoes that start orange but turn red, among the Wildings and Q series. Maybe packing them tighter even if it means only very few fruits from each, could be a good way to explore the diversity quicker? (What does one call such a tomato - red because it ends up red?)







Cathy A

Have you grown Neandermato before, or will this be the first year?

I'm more interested in selecting from the Neandermato line than from crossing it into domestics, but this will be my first year to try it on a small scale. My goals may change once I see and taste it. It may benefit from a limited infusion of genetic material from larger, sweeter tomatoes, or not.

Cathy A

I didn't see signs of diseases resistance in the limited amount of wildling that I grew. 2023 was a very bad disease year for me, so that would have been the time to spot it.

A larger grow out might have found some, but for me, the Dwarf Eagle Smiley proved more resistant than any of the wildling.

Justin Jardinier

#262
Quote from: Cathy A on 2024-03-17, 06:03:03 AMselecting from the Neandermato line than from crossing it into domestics, but this will be my first year to try it on a small scale. My goals may change once I see and taste it.
Neandermato is Joseph's population of Solanum habrochaites. It's not edible. I don't think you will be wanting to eat the fruits. Also you can't pollinate habrochaites (except some rare self compatible accessions apparently) with lycopersicum pollen, so "a limited infusion of genetic material from larger, sweeter tomatoes" isn't too easy to do - I guess to do that you'd need to use the habrochaites pollen on lycopersicum to get 50%, then cross that again with hab pollen to get 75% and maybe by that point you could use the pollen to pollinate habrochaites? I don't really know, but what I mean is, I think it's pretty hard to add a little lycopersicum to a habrochaites population and I would assume it would take at least several generations.

William Schlegel

Yeah I have some seed still for some of Joseph's back cross lines where he perhaps infused some domestic into his Neandermato line of habrochaites from about 2020 which he called BC1. Mine seemed wild type. It took him until 2023 to get a few plants with colored fruit in his putative 90% hab line.

With my LA2329 hab accession project I've been meaning to pursue both directions and may have inadvertently with bee crosses. I probably haven't been giving it enough space. 50% hab population I now have enough seed I should probably direct seed a row and let natural selection start truly adapting it to my growing season at least. Otherwise I can't start enough plants of it right now with resources at hand to get to the large population size I need to start finding elites at that percentage.

In 2019 I grew about 13 F1 seedlings of Joseph's back cross to Big Hill HX-9 so only about 25% wild 12.5% hab and 12.5% penellii None of the plants were elite all wild type. I saved every seed and direct seeded a huge population row in 2020. Their were a few semi elites but Joseph had already sent me the elite seed he found in 2019 and over the winter from the winter grow out in CA and it was so much better I didn't save the seed.

I am just a little bit ahead of where I was in the fall of 2019 with Josephs line with my 2022 new 25% line from LA2329 because the one plant that survived to fruit in 2023 just happened to have some color. So I might snag an elite line for palatibility in 2024. Though I would be shocked if it happened to have the type IV trichomes or chemistry that protects LA2329 from arthropods. For that I'll probably need to make another cross. I also went ahead and made some 12.5% wild crosses.

So Joseph's 90% hab colored line is quite an achievement that required some serious time, effort, and garden space!
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

William Schlegel

#264
Quote from: Cathy A on 2024-03-17, 06:08:00 AMI didn't see signs of diseases resistance in the limited amount of wildling that I grew. 2023 was a very bad disease year for me, so that would have been the time to spot it.

A larger grow out might have found some, but for me, the Dwarf Eagle Smiley proved more resistant than any of the wildling.

Dwarf Eagle Smiley is 50% current tomato. That can confer a lot of very practical resistance without sacrificing as much flavor potential as a cross with the unpalatable species. I made a cross with it and one of my current crosses that will also be 50% current tomato. Curious how that will segregate.

I really like my hab project but the pimp projects are nice immediate gratification projects. I'm glad I'm doing both. It occurs to me that it might matter more where these projects segregate than what wild species they are crossed with for resistances to common diseases in more disease prone areas. I don't need any particular resistance so if I let my wild species crosses segregate for 7 years while selecting for best flavor the odds of resistance will be low even if I started with something great.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Cathy A

#265
Justin,

My hope was to practice selection on Neandermato for several generations to see if something edible could be produced. My understanding (possibly wrong) is that a small amount of domestic tomato genes had already been introduced.

I was thinking of growing 8-12 plants and seeing if there is enough segregation to select plants with larger or more palatable fruits.

If it's not at all edible and cannot accept pollen from domestics, then I will grow only a tiny amount of it (perhaps 3 plants) to pollinate selected domestics.

William Schlegel

Quote from: Cathy A on 2024-03-17, 10:49:07 AMJustin,

My hope was to practice selection on Neandermato for several generations to see if something edible could be produced. My understanding (possibly wrong) is that a small amount of domestic tomato genes had already been introduced.

I was thinking of growing 8-12 plants and seeing if there is enough segregation to select plants with larger or more palatable fruits.

If it's not at all edible and cannot accept pollen from domestics, then I will grow only a tiny amounts of it (perhaps 3 plants) to pollinate selected domestics.

I would treat it as the latter. Joseph may now have a population that the former could work on but it needs seed increased and stabilized before he has enough to share. I would expect any introgression in the currently available neandermato to be more of the hey this is still wild type but with three locules sort.

If I was trying that with Neandermato I would try to grow 1000 plants and the special BC1 seeds Joseph sent me and that I seed saved.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Cathy A

Quote from: Cathy A on 2024-03-16, 06:31:52 AMMaybe a dozen plants, give or take?

I went back and checked my notes. I had 20 wildling plants.

Cathy A

#268
Thanks for the update, William. I will grow a small amount of Neandermato and use it as a pollen source for crossing.

If a wild line of any of the non-S. lyco species becomes available for moderately large-scale growout and selection, I would be interested in participating. I can't grow anything like 1,000 plants, but it's the sum of plants grown by all project participants that matters.



BTW, at one point you were actively working on Little Pumpkin, but you haven't mentioned it for some time. Are you still growing and selecting LP?

William Schlegel

#269
Quote from: Cathy A on 2024-03-17, 11:59:44 AMThanks for the update, William. I will grow a small amount of Neandermato and use it as a pollen source for crossing.

If a wild line of any of the non-S. lyco species becomes available for moderately large-scale growout and selection, I would be interested in participating. I can't grow anything like 1,000 plants, but it's the sum of plants grown by all project participants that matters.



BTW, at one point you were actively working on Little Pumpkin, but you haven't mentioned it for some time. Are you still growing and selecting LP?

Moving this back to the proper thread. So we aren't mucking up Kadence's thread.

Little pumpkins, if it survived, got merged with The One. In recognizable form it died out for lack of seed production. That is like a lot of early generation habrochaites crosses it had low reproductive viability. This could be a part of why The One is now such a segregating mess.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days