C.pepo as winter squash. What makes a good Yankee pie pumpkin?

Started by Plantman, 2021-01-27, 05:44:45 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Plantman

Hello everyone.
When I grew up we had mainly c.max pumpkin/jarradale and c.moschata/Kent or butternut.

They used to call C.pepo marrow, and it wasn't in fashion back then.
We had larger zuchinni in markets and started to see smaller courgette and button type summer squash appear a bit later.
About 10 years ago we started to see cow pumpkins for carving appear around Halloween.
I've never seen a new England pie type pumpkin here, ever. Not even at a farmers' market.
I have a cushaw I eat as squash, so don't grow any zuchinni/Pepo.
Just got a nice moschata from Yunnan to try as a squash next session.

I decided to try a pepo pumpkin so bought some spookie seed.
It had ok storage and was an eating type.
Since then I noticed the winter luxery pie and also bought three packs of Nantucket long pumpkin for next season.

My question is, what am I actually looking for in this type of pumpkin?

Compared to the other types they don't last as well, and have a less complex taste.
We eat pumpkin mainly as soup or baked/roasted here, also in curry or as croquettes.
As a flour substitute as well, like pumpkin scones.


William Schlegel

Not sure, most commercial pumpkin pie filling in North America is the dixon melon a moschata. I think pepo types are best for summer squash. I like maxima pies fine.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Plantman

#2
Thanks for reply.
Maybe I should of posted the thread as c.pepo as winter squash.
If they have to be baked and frozen because they don't last long, it's probably from being too high sugar and not enough starch.
The spookie is bred from Connecticut field, and the long pumkin takes a couple of month to change colour n ripen in storage ( transform starch to sugar?)
I'm guessing the long storing type will also be most complex taste.
I only grew the spookie as a curiosity. They are more vigorous and tougher than I expected. If they store well and taste good, then I'll grow them again.

William Schlegel

#3
Long Pie Pumpkin is grown by the local small seed company nearest me and is a revival from the older closed local seed company and originally from New England but I haven't personally grown it. Would be interested to do so. It's multi purpose. Generally though that can mean bad at everything as well as good at everything a summer and winter squash.  Essentially a marrow in the British usage.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Ferdzy

My impression is that the New England ("Yankee") pumpkin pie was traditionally made with pepo squash because those were the squash already being grown locally when European settlers arrived. They aren't necessarily  the ideal squash for pie. But in general you want a squash that's dense, well flavoured, and smooth in texture - a moschata in other words. I don't think most people use the so-called pie pumpkin any more.

One of the things that was typically done to improve pepo squash for pie was to cook it slowly in a cast-iron skillet until it was dried down and slightly caramelized.

Plantman

#5
@William S
Good work you are preserving that pumpkin.
It's a good plant to get people interested in gardening.

I don't see spookie winning the taste tests, it's selling point was more you can slowly but surely eat your ornamental pumpkin stash.
The winter luxery starts to go funny by Thanksgiving, so that's definitely not a good storer
The long pumpkin probably the best of that lot.

Plantman

#6
Quote from: Ferdzy on 2021-01-28, 11:54:06 AM
My impression is that the New England ("Yankee") pumpkin pie was traditionally made with pepo squash because those were the squash already being grown locally when European settlers arrived. They aren't necessarily  the ideal squash for pie. But in general you want a squash that's dense, well flavoured, and smooth in texture - a moschata in other words. I don't think most people use the so-called pie pumpkin any more.

One of the things that was typically done to improve pepo squash for pie was to cook it slowly in a cast-iron skillet until it was dried down and slightly caramelized.


You make a couple of good points, thank you.
The pepo was used traditionally because that is what was there.
Moschata is superior.

If the pepo pumpkin still takes 100 days, then a 90 day maxi like a baby blue/moranga will easily store longer.
And a moschata will beat it for quality.
Hard to justify planting pepo instead of the other species

William Schlegel

I edited my possessive to clarify, I am meerly a customer of the local seed company. I'd join them as a grower but they require organic certification and that comes with paperwork. So am currently growing for the next seed coop over.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Plantman

No worries WS.
Good job someone is preserving it.
It's an interesting pumpkin.

Garrett Schantz

Red kuri - a maxima, tastes pretty good in pies. Rather small, but quite flavorful.
Also trying Marina Di Chiogga this year, from the reviews and traits I am assuming it would do pretty well as a pie pumpkin.

Most moschatas do pretty well as pies. Musquee De Maroc apparently tastes pretty good, will be trialing it for pie usage when I grow it.

New England, other types of pepo pie pumpkins are fine, some varieties are pretty good. Not many storage - good tasting types though.

Plantman

Thanks Garrett.
Any suggestion on the good tasting type pepo pumpkins?

Plantman

Quote from: Ferdzy on 2021-01-28, 11:54:06 AM
One of the things that was typically done to improve pepo squash for pie was to cook it slowly in a cast-iron skillet until it was dried down and slightly caramelized.
If they need to be reduced and the sugars condensed that again points to a fruit bred too high moisture content/ too low dry matter and a simple sugar profile over starch.
The South African gem squash can store for 6 months, and makes a nice dense pumpkin when matured.
And the kiwi kamo kumi can store for 6 months also, with some being a bit stringy.
These should go well with the Nantucket long.
Sweet dumpling looks ok, but maybe doesn't have the endurance.
Any other great tasting and good storing c.pepo out there?

Plantman

Bit of an update on the spookie.
Three weeks ago a cyclone tail went through and gave about 3 inches of rain in two days.
The spookie patch has died back from powdery and downy mildew.
Cushaw, Jarradale and musk from Provence all totally uneffected.
I have no other Pepo, so can't compare the spookie to its like.

The fruit I have from the spookie all look ok, I'll leave them 21 days to ripen before opening one.
They have a nice strong skin. Slight cosmetic damage only from snails, but none got inside
The spookie vines have really fine thorns, and need to be handled with gloves.

I'll use the spookie to breed to Nantucket next season.
They are worth going on with.