Is cold hardy perennial tomato possible thanks to s. habrochaites ?

Started by Nicolas, 2022-11-26, 07:54:56 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Nicolas

Just starting this thread to give it little more visibility.

Some times ago William talked about some work from Tim Peters to breed some perennial tomato.

I've found some ref to this work from Tim Peters on Homegrown goodness board :

https://alanbishop.proboards.com/post/22338/thread
Quote...the hirsutum I was working with had a unique chemisry that I wanted to move into the average tomato, it could regenerate from root tissue (but had a nasty flavor I was trying to escape)... It was/is possible to create a perennial tomato... one that can come back from root in a cold climate. ...I had thousands of F2's, 3's, in that one project when it got terminated. ...

UnicornEmily


Nicolas

Ah some more observation from Tim Peters :

Quote... my hirsutum selection that showed root regen and exceptional disease resistance was a typicum, exceeding hairy. ....and in case you thought the crosses came easy, think again, ...it took me 2 years and hundreds of diverse attempts to get a few hundred F1's . ...All the F1's were more like the hursutum than anything...Seed was collected in mass from the F1's ....(maybe a misery of 1000-1500 seed), ...and hundreds of crosses and backcrosses were made with the F1's.
...a number of plants in the following generation showed ability to make shoots from roots but none ever captured the rot-out resistance of the hirsutum parent, ...and i was not able to pursue my work with that material any to much further. ....some of the hirsutum-esculentum crosses brought together hairiness upon hairiness... some were like cotton balls ! ...the poor anthers were so hairy they kept the pollen from getting to the pistil!!!


Garrett Schantz

I'm restarting breeding on cold tolerant / frost hardy tomatoes and things to some extent.

Redoing lot of breeding projects from scratch - unless there's really interesting things I already created.


Mainly because a lot of my lines, I didn't save enough seed from earlier on, and some things weren't setting fruit.


I have a fuzzy leaved litchi tomato that's taken a bunch of frosts.

Elephant ears, canna lilies, other solanums are all mostly dead - brown / black leaves.

Litchi tomato has bright green leaves still. Quite interested in hybrids using that species in particular.


A perennial tomato doesn't sound entirely favorable to me. This, is for a simple reason of most species simply being vulnerable to disease if they were perennials in my opinion. And being disease vectors - tomatoes seem to produce less after two years or so.

Granted, two years would be great, save a lot of money. Outcrossing tomatoes would probably help out a lot too.


I'm more interested in trying out tomatoes that can handle a lot of cold, maybe a short period of frost.

I'm now in zone 8, perennial tomatoes seem viable without much threat of diseases or things popping up.

I also have a long enough growing season to work with all sorts of species / relatives outdoors.

Most frosts here don't go very deep even when they do hit. Think I mentioned this elsewhere, but some cold hardy bananas, Elephant ears and canna lilies can grow in standing water or in the ground here and come back the following year if their bulbs aren't too far above ground.

Some mentioned habrochaites - other species have fun root growth habits, resist root rot etc.



I'm pretty sure some birds down here eat tomatoes more than back where I used to live.


Extending a season for tomatoes doesn't mean much to me as frost wipes out fruits on the plant for the most part. Cold tolerance would be the only great extender. But, a perennial could grow back without disease issues here I hope. Bit humid here, rains a lot.


Of course, I could probably send out my best hybrids out to people in other zones in a few years.


Also going to be doing something similar with peppers.

UnicornEmily

Perennial tomatoes might be interesting, for the simple ability to get tomatoes earlier in the year.  If you had a plant that could resume growing in, say, March and give you ripe fruit before the end of April, that would be way earlier than any other tomato plants you'd normally be growing.

William Schlegel

I think that Josephs promiscuous project with might have superior resprouting ability after a first fall frost. In areas of Southern California where there is sometimes only one frost in a winter that would do it.

It happened in my garden in 2020 with the first elite lines and again in 2022 with the fruity line I saved from 2021 and called the one in the garden that froze early the sw garden which is down in a frost pocket.

Otherwise I think it is probably just a matter of growing and evaluating as many Solanum habrochaites strains as possible looking for that rhizomatous trait.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Garrett Schantz

I think one of HRseeds habrochaites accessions survived a lot of frosts, roots underground were plentiful and somewhat tuberous, went deep into the clay soil.

The long tubers were a few feet long.

Top parts were soggy and dead, deeper stuff was still live.

That was in zone 6.



I'm just happy being an in area where I can probably play around with those different lines without having them mix completely into another line and losing most of its genetics.

Joseph Lofthouse

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2022-11-28, 06:51:44 PMOtherwise I think it is probably just a matter of growing and evaluating as many Solanum habrochaites strains as possible looking for that rhizomatous trait.

This fall, I pulled the polyamorous tomatoes by the roots, before frost,  to more fully harvest the fruits. The rhizomous roots were really noticeable on a few of them. I haven't paid attention before, other than to re-sprouting after frost.

William Schlegel

Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Nicolas

There are a lot of potential for selection already, excellent !

Nicolas

Root system of S. arcanum vs a tomato

LA2172_20221203_101453.jpg

I'll check if it resprout this spring

AndrewB

Wow, very interesting. I'll have to pay attention to these roots.

 One partially wild tomato I transplanted into my grow tent that had weird fruits and had tiny wild seeds died but recently is growing back from the roots. It has what appear to be habrochiates like leaves but more domestic looking.

Chance

Nicolas, your photo makes me wonder something, does a larger root system promote a better plant immune system?  It would be interesting to compare resistances in the F2s and beyond to root size.