Pepo x Argyrosperma (Mixta) "Lotto"

Started by Ferdzy, 2020-06-21, 08:30:19 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Ferdzy

Hi Chance; yes, I do. Mostly own/other people's seed grexes on the theme of butternut. There's Waltham in there of course, and Nutter Butter, and Pennsylvania Neck Pumpkin, and no doubt some others. We tend to just plant seeds from a few of the squashes that kept the best and still had some good flavour and texture.

I'm not going to attempt to cross them, I don't think, but they won't be so far from each other that it isn't a possibility.

Ferdzy

Picked the first zucchini of the year from this project; also the first zucchini of the year, which is a good sign! Although realistically there was another that was no more than a day behind on the Mutabile plant.

The flavour was actually excellent! It was a little watery, but since we got 2 inches of rain a few days back I am not too worried about that. The plant is one of the largest and most robust of our zucchini, although not vining. There are 2 or 3 other plants from this project but they are all just starting to form their first fruits. There is one with green and yellow mottled fruit. Not sure who the other parent was for this specimen; it really looks a lot like the Lebanese White Bush from which it is descended.


Ferdzy

Zucchini continue to come. We have one that is plainly a cross with Tatume, but it isn't very productive or interesting so far. There's another one, a bit nondescript, and then there's a YELLOW one, which is pumping them out like crazy!

It isn't as sweet as most zucchini, and has a distinctive, almost green beany flavour; we all like it quite a lot. I have attempted to cross it with itself to see if we can't get more like it next year. It's a bush, not a vine, but a nice robust one.

The last photo shows fruits from three out of what I believe are 4 plants; along with a Tatume at the top for comparison.

Ferdzy

I picked the first 2 Reinau Gold zucchini today. They are the smaller ones in the photo. The other 2 are individuals 4 and 5 from the cross. As you can see, it is pretty certain Reinau Gold is the pollen parent of this cross. One first glance the cross is amazingly further along in productivity, but in fact I think that is not so clear. The Reinau Gold are are actually from 2 plants - I planted 2 seeds close together and didn't thin them, so they are probably holding each other back a bit.

The hybrid vigour of the cross is also not likely to continue quite so spectacularly in subsequent generations. Still, I'm kind of excited about this. I really hope the "self cross" takes.

Ferdzy

So, bad news, and goo - well, making lemonade out of lemons.

We have vine borers this year.

We are growing maximas for the first time in a few years, and the borers absolutely love them and are decimating them. Fortunately, they seem uninterested in the butternuts. The zucchini are of more intermediate interest to them. The productive yellow cross is one of the few I've found a borer int - but it wasn't in the base of the plant, but in the base of a fruit. The other plants of the cross seem untouched at the moment. The Mutabile, Rond de Nice, and Costata Romanesco seem particularly susceptible amongst the zucchini.

I'm speculating that there are two different paths for susceptibility/resistance to vine borers. Let's call the first one chemical - does the plant have a scent and flavour that attracts or repels them? And the second is physical - does the plant have tough stems (in particular) that are hard to bore into?

In general I observe that plants that are particularly attractive to humans in terms of flavour are also often particularly attractive to pests: good flavour is universally recognized. So this plant is attractive to the borers in the chemical sense. The fact that I found a borer in the fruit but the base seems untouched suggests that it has chemical attraction but at least some physical resistance.

This is all wild speculation on my part. If there is anyone who can comment on these ideas, I'd love to hear it.

Ferdzy

It's been quite a while since I reported on this project, but we have continued to work on it. Unfortunately, the fruit I was hoping to save from the yellow zucchini last mentioned fell off the plant and did not mature, so no seeds. Back to the drawing board.

We went back to the f2 last year and deliberately crossed 2 of the best of those with Reinau Gold again. They both resembled Caserta, one more viney and one more bushy. We planted 45 seeds in 15 spots, of which about 40 came up. Only 3 turned out to be yellow. None of them have as good flavour as the last batch, but they have twice as much argyrosperma in them, I reckon. I intend to back cross again to get the flavour up. There is still a wild amount of variability in the other non-yellow crosses, both in plants and fruit. We yanked anything that didn't taste at least mildly flavourful and are left with about a dozen plants. Some decisions will need to be made to cut the numbers back down.

I'm still pretty excited about the possibilities for this. We covered our regular zucchini but left these crosses to fertilize each other ad lib so still expect plenty of variability next year.

We did not see any vine borer damage. I don't know if they were resistant, or if for some reason there weren't any around. Would have expected some, given how bad they were the last 2 years but pests do seem to come and go.

Ferdzy



So! All these squash are currently sitting in my kitchen waiting for me to do something with them. The ones with the blue flags next to them are the ones we agreed we should consider saving to replant next year.



Here they are, the ones to be saved. The very large stripey fellow was on the only plant that produced 2 full sized ripe fruits.

The tiny yellow one is probably the closest to what I envisaged, and it also continue to attempt to produce fruit once it was left to ripen, and had some of the healthiest foliage while being a fairly compact plant. I think it in particular has a lot of potential.

The others stood out for us as being healthier than average plants, I believe. The roundish, greenest one at the top left was not a bush but a small vine. It looks like Tatume got in there somewhere even though Tatume was not one of the expected parents. My isolation skills obviously leave a lot to be desired.

I'm going to have so much seed. Does anyone want some seeds? I'll post another picture of the bushel of other squash, if any catch your eye I can fish them out and send you seeds.

Ferdzy

I opened up the fruits pictured above last week to save the seeds. It was interesting how variable they were, in size and quantity. I opened up a representative sample of the squash which survived being pulled for lack of flavour, but did not meet the plant quality of the 5 finalists, and decided to save seed from 2 of them as well, on the grounds that they had particularly nice seeds and that is one of the things I'd like to pursue in this project. There were what I would consider pepo-type seed cavities, with seeds embedded in lots of stringy flesh, and what I would consider argyrosperma-type cavities, with clumped plentiful seeds just held in place with a little bit of fibre. I am keeping some of both.

I am only keeping a small quantity of the 2 extra ones. I roasted most of the seeds and we ate them. One of them kind of "popped" and the seeds were medium sized, thin skinned, and plump. The other were good too but I favour the first. 

Shell hardness also varied wildly, and again I presume soft shells represent the pepo side and hard shells represent the argyrosperma side. I probably have a preference for maintaining a harder shell, but it's more open to compromise than some other traits I'm looking for.

The long little golden one, the pick of the bunch from the outside, produced 4 - count 'em, 4 - seeds of which only one looks actually good. Maybe. That's a serious bummer. I don't know if that nice shape is what it would have been or only because there were next to no seeds. Also it probably attempted to produce more fruit - one of the things that made me select it - because it knew this one was such a dud.

 
The squash on the bottom left, yellow with green stripes and bottle-shaped, was mostly there because of being a healthy plant, I didn't think the fruit looked all that great. However, it had a large quantity of good-looking seeds of the argy type, which raised it considerably in my assessment. It also had a very hard shell. Now a definite for next year.

The small rounder green striped one at top left has some resemblance to Tatume. I didn't think Tatume had gotten into this mix, but it sure looks like a little snuck in. It was the only one to produce a vine rather than a bush, but it was extremely short compared to Tatume - did not get more than 6 feet long. That may be because I left it to ripen quite early in the season but I suspect just also, it's shorter. It had a fairly hard shell, and a good number of quite small seeds, but embedded in a certain amount of sponge. Still, very interesting.

The plump yellow one in the bottom centre-left should become the focus of my desire for yellow-skinned zucchini, but it is not without problems. It had a softer rind and spongy interior. On the other hand, a good number of seeds, and there should have been more - there were a fair number of empty ones. It has the potential. Unfortunately, there have been some problems with this cross with seeds sprouting in the shells and even though I opened them relatively early after ripening, this one already had 8 seeds that were sprouting. I've kept the rest, but hmmm... this is a very undesirable quality.

The final one is the very large one on the right. It was from I think the only plant to produce 2 ripe fruits, and the other one was just as large. It had a small spongy seed cavity at the bottom, and produced relatively few seeds (about 50) that were very large and look fairly thick skinned. The shell was thick and hard. I just don't know what I think of this one, but I guess it's going in.

All of these were tested for flavour at the zucchini stage, and all of them were mild, verging on bland, but okay. We pulled about 2/3 of the ones we planted before we let them cross and form ripe fruit on the grounds that they were just tasteless.

As far as I can make out these are f3. ((Lebanese White Bush pepo x Tennessee Sweet Potato argy) x Caserta pepo) x Reinau Gold* pepo.

At this point I am somewhat reluctant to add more pepo even though I bought Goldini seed with that in mind. A question: if I grow them out and let them cross with each other next year without bringing in new genetics, they will still be counted as f4, right? I have to keep the (mathematical) percentages of each species as a separate calculation.