A diverse patch of shallots

Started by Steph S, 2019-11-13, 04:31:52 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Steph S

It seems that there is a lot of diversity in the Allium cepa var aggregatum group of shallots, which iirc is the conclusion made about taxonomy in the tropical populations of shallots.
Just reading through my notes before making decisions about the seed sowing, got these two interesting papers about diversity in shallots.  This one from Vietnam looked at the difference in populations grown in the south, central and northern regions.
https://www.jstage.jst.go.jp/article/jjshs/75/3/75_3_236/_pdf
Genetic Variation of Shallot (Allium cepa L. Aggregatum Group) in Vietnam
Pham Thi Minh Phuong, Shiro Isshiki and Yosuke Tashiro
"Morphological  and  physiological  differences  were detected between the strains of the northern region and those  of  the  central  and  southern  regions.  The  former had spreading dark green leaves, and bolted late; their bulb  skin  color  was  white  during  development,  but  it turned brown after harvest (Fig. 3). ..Whereas, the latter had semi-spreading young yellow green leaves, which turned  dark  green  at  maturity;  they  bolted  early.  The young bulb skin was pink but became red after harvest.
...In Saga,  the  short  day  length and/or  low  temperature  during  autumn  and  winter supposed to stimulate the bolting of both types of shallot,  and  the  South  type  of  shallot  might  have  higher sensitivity than the North type (About 60 days and 120 days were necessary for bolting, respectively). Besides the change in bolting, the bulb size also had altered in Saga. Both types form almost the same size of bulbs in Vietnam,  but  in  Saga  the  North  type  entered  bulbing earlier and produced bigger bulbs than the South type.
It seems that early bolting and continuous flower stalk formation resulted in the small size of bulbs in the South type.
"
60 vs 120 days to induce bolting is a huge spread.
This study in Ethiopia also reported a great diversity of traits in the cultivars grown there.
https://scialert.net/fulltextmobile/?doi=ijar.2011.517.536
"Shallot grown in Ethiopia is diverse and includes: bolters and non-bolters, spreading and compact types, those with various bulb shapes, sizes and colors ...
Bulb dry weight had negative and significant association with number of leaves per plant, number of bulb splits per plant, unmarketable yield per plant and harvest index at genotypic level suggesting that an increase in bulb dry weight could result from decrease in all these traits....
High magnitude and maximum positive direct effects on bulb yield was exerted by bulb dry weight (1.782) followed by leaf length (1.359), leaf sheath diameter (1.108), number of bulb splits per plant (0.988),.
...."

Steph S

Ferdzy, I am thinking back on your first comments, and I'm wondering if growing some seed out for sets would be a way to select for bulbing vs staying green and producing more shoots than bulbs.  You mentioned keeping them in the flat until you're able to tell which color is present, are they starting to bulb by then?  If they were left longer in confined space as when growing sets, I wonder if I would then see that some bulb and some don't, and be able to select for bulbing on that basis. I guess I'll find out if I try it.   

I haven't grown sets before, but the basic method is to sow very densely, don't apply N ferts, and lift or loosen them with a fork early so they start to dry out.  (Rain protection may be needed here as well).  This manual describes the process for growing onion sets in ground:
https://naldc.nal.usda.gov/download/ORC00000286/PDF  It seems like a convenient way to maximize selection opportunities for space. Or at least to make up for the fact that I don't have a single bed prepped to put shallots into, and not sure how much space I can wiggle out for them. :-[
For onions, the sets 2 cm diameter or less are recommended so that they don't bolt when planted the following season.
I'm trying to decide what container depth might be adequate to grow that size of sets. 

Ferdzy

A comment for Doro; potato onions in general were widely regarded as not producing seeds. It was a break-through in the 1990s that Dutch breeders were able to cross potato onions with regular onions, thus creating the present "hybrid shallot seed" situation. So not surprised that yours aren't.

triffid, that's interesting. I'll be trying to compare the Ste Anne's to Diane's we-think-they're-oschaninii in the spring/summer and see how close they are.

Steph, the "set" growing to weed out the non-bulbers might be worth a try. I don't grow mine in the flat until they bulb (cough, cough), just long enough that the bases start to thicken a bit and change colour (or not, as the case may be). I cannot tell at that stage whether they are liable to be splitters or not. Worth noting; some years everything divides at least in half, if not 4 to 6 bulbs; this (past) season not a single bulb split. I cut them in the kitchen and see they were thinking about it, but no splits in the garden. That was weather, because it's been the same seed batch for the last 4 or 5 years.


Steph S

 :) I had a couple of neglected seedlings that didn't get planted the first year - they made little bulbs less than a cm across in a half full cell (72 cell size).   :o But when I continued to neglect them, and it got rainy, they unbulbed and divided instead!  ::)  I guess they used the bulb to do it.  Anyway they have lived on in their little cell, I brought them in this fall and I still have em somewhere in the greenhouse.  Talk about (cough cough) attentive gardening....  ;D  These things are tough.   But the weather cues, definitely seem to play a big role.  Tx for the advice.

Steph S

Well here it is the end of April 2020, and just today the snowbank has shrunk past the last post of the old shallot bed.   They were up as soon as the snow receded past them, and looks like they survived no problem in their third year - possible exception(s) and I'll be looking to assess that survivorship but overall I think the word "perennial" duly applies.   
Another important note is that animals are nipping these poor things like crazy.  Could be hares.  Almost nothing else is up and green, so I guess they are putting up with onion flavor - they really don't bother garlic.   I took wire off garlic beds and a beat-down frame and rigged up the cover to stop that heavy browsing.
I really like the fact that these are "self mulching".   Their own leaves when died back form a tight little skin over the ground, which is just the right thickness for their own spiky leaves to penetrate.   
It's nice to be able to see the shoots and their colors while small...   I will get a better look at them soon.  There are certainly clear differences in both the thickness and color of shoots.   My plan is to take these all up from the shallow and half shaded bed where they've been, set out offshoots as starts with the right spacing to make bulbs, and put the perennial keeper clumps in a permanent place.
If offshoots of perennial clumps can be set out to bulb successfully, that would be the perfect solution for me...   
I haven't started from seed yet, I will be trying to make sets from seed for 2021. 

whwoz

Like it and good luck dealing with the hares

Ferdzy

Innnteresting. They continue to be so different from any other domestic allium I've ever grown. The seeds you sent me are up, by the way and doing nicely, although they are about a third the size of any of the other seedlings.

I wonder if they are even allium cepa? Could they be some other species of onion? But if so, what? I've looked at a bunch on line, and although I see some similarities with other species I don't find one that seems like a clear match.

Steph S

I got some seeds of a "French shallot" from Annapolis Seeds - they are more rounded than these seeds, and look more like an onion seed.
Overall these definitely have slender leaves compared to other onions or leek seedlings for that matter.   My original seedlings were small but not so small as a third of other allium seedling size!  Are they short as well?
I measured a clothespin and then used that for scale to take a few allium pics in my "late winter" yard for comparison.  The pin end is about 1 cm:  gripper hole is 1/2 cm across at its widest and the small round hole is 2 mm across.  The egyptian onions are in similar conditions to the shallots, not the best  or deepest topsoil nor the sunniest spot.   Looks llke the larger end of shallot shoots are about the same size as them, they are coming up around 1/2 cm diameter. 
By comparison the smallest of all 'shallot' (which might actually be a cross with A. canadense or something), those shoots are about 1 mm diam!  Tiny. 
It is way easier this time of year to see which plant is producing bigger shoots.  Maybe not all the tallest plants either (some were up to 55 cm in height).  So I will be very curious to see if the thicker shoots also produce larger bulbs.   



Ferdzy

I've grown that "French shallot" offered by Annapolis, although I got mine elsewhere. It's a reasonably available variety, also known as Banana shallots ( a modern name), cuisse de poulet de Poitou, and Zebrune. It is in fact one of the parents of the seed-grown shallot line I've been growing for the last 5 or 6 years. It's a good one.

I'll try and take a photo of the seedlings in the next couple of days to give a sense of how different they are from other alliums we're growing this year. I'd say they are half the size of the others, shorter but also much more slender. However, they appear to be quite healthy and are growing steadily.

If you did have a cross with A. canadense, that would be surprising to me and quite interesting.

Steph S

I've heard that Zebrune is "a cross between an onion and a shallot" - that might explain the seed looking more like an onion!     I definitely think it would be interesting to cross some of the multipliers with a good onion, and develop the best of both worlds.  It does seem like the 'multiplier' aspect does well to be reined in a bit, for the more reliable bulbing that the onion provides.  :)

Re: possible cross with A. canadense.  Two plants unlike the others, with smaller, mostly flat leaves and pale green color.   One very small - that's the one shown and generally referred to as "tuft".  The shoots are really tiny.   Both of them had strange flowers that were mostly petals and  missing many of reproductive parts.    Flower pic below is from 'tuft's' larger sibling but they were basically the same with flat, almost lime green leaves, great number of tiny shoots, messed up flowers.   Tuft produced no seeds, the sibling produced 8 seeds.
A. canadense is my best guess from trolling alliums on the internet - we don't have them here so I have never seen one in person.  But I believe the leaves are flat, and I figured it could be common enough in other parts of Canada, to have crossed with the shallot in someone's garden, if the bees were making it happen.
Then again it could be some wild thing in the shallot gene pool - just a crazy outlier.  I guess? 
I looked at some tropical things but nothing stood out to me.



reed

I tried crossing A. canadense to other onions last year but didn't work out. I only had I think, six plants and flowering didn't sync with the other onions, managed to not save any seeds.

Right now I have two nice little patches of the A. canadense, one that I planted from bulbils and one that must be from bulbils that got lost. I also have a patch of onions from the top sets of some shallots / potato onions that made both seed and sets last year. They all are growing bloom stalks in perfect synchronization right now. I'll keep a close eye to make I collect any seeds even though from what I understand crossing is unlikely.

They are all pretty small and seems to me the blooming is a little earlier than I would have thought. Flavor of both is amazing delicious.

Steph S

Good to hear delicious!  I must admit nothing like a bulbil appeared on these.   I will be looking for little underground bulbs if any, when I dig to move them.

Reed if you have bumblebees I would guess it ups your chances.   Unlike honeybees they don't stick to the same type of flower, so by random visiting and their delicate pollination tricks, things can happen that are harder to do on purpose.   I would say best bet is to collect every seed you get from that patch, grow them all out and look for strange ones.

reed

#42
I don't know how to describe flavor but they are very very good and mild,hard to resist just eating them all. We have lots of bumblebees and I notice a lot of much smaller bees and a small very triangular looking fly are common on onion flowers here.  I'll pool all the seeds and just plant them together, also will mix up any bulbils that come from them both all into a new patch. They are all small, the wild ones are about the size of a dime at best but they are hardy which is a primary goal of mine. I have lots more than expected so if that holds maybe next year I will have a big enough patch to start eating them.

They don't look like those in your picture, I'll post some pictures later, it's raining right now. I hope this link works, mine look very much like those in the big picture to the right except I don't remember them being that purple.

https://www.google.com/search?q=Allium+canadense&tbm=isch&ved=2ahUKEwiQjfTZ9pDpAhVRYK0KHXUjC4cQ2-cCegQIABAA&oq=Allium+canadense&gs_lcp=CgNpbWcQDDICCAAyAggAMgIIADICCAAyAggAMgIIADICCAAyAggAMgIIADICCAA6BAgAEB5QhNECWPP0AmCWiANoAHAAeACAAekFiAGKF5IBCzItMS4xLjIuMS4xmAEAoAEBqgELZ3dzLXdpei1pbWc&sclient=img&ei=uiyrXpDID9HAtQX1xqy4CA&bih=657&biw=1024&rlz=1C1GGGE_enUS445US454#imgrc=WRArjm_JD2kTPM

triffid

Busy times for the alliums in my allotment.
Besides the bolting softneck garlic, today I discovered all of the Ouddorpse Bruine 'shallots' have grown scapes. These are a vigorous old-fashioned variety (1943) from the Netherlands - round, bronze skin, look like onions. It is my first year growing them and I do not know whether it is normal for them to flower, or whether these flowers are fertile. But it's exciting to see nonetheless. Each bulb division has a scape, and most have divided a dozen times.
I was saddened to find this evening that many of the seedlings from your seed, Steph, perished in the very dry weather we are experiencing. :( A few made it through but I'll re-sow in midsummer, and hopefully get some to form sets.
Zone 9a - brown calcareous earth, high natural fertility base-rich loam - coastal maritime climate

Steph S

That's too bad about the seedlings Triffid - not to worry about seeds I can always send you more if you need them.   Good to know they didn't fare well in dry weather, we certainly had none of it here and they are vigorous as can be in spite of really cold weather and lots of rain.
I would love to see a pic of your Bruine shallots when they flower, if you allow them to do so.  :)

The shallot patch here had 100% survival after all.  A few were later coming up but all are intact now.  In general these were up before garlic and they outpaced even the chives as well.  Here is a pic of the patch, with nearby chives and lovage in the upper right for comparison of how far along they are in this very late spring.

It is much easier to see the differences in traits while the plants are small.  The growth habit differences seem to be what the authors refer to in tropical shallots, as 'spreading' or curvy vs upright leaves.    The curvy ones have almost a tausled appearance at this stage and are kind of cute, so I plan to move a few of those to their own location and see if they isolate for these traits more or less, at the distances available in my garden.   Then there is another group that have slender very upright shoots with no sign of spreading or any attempt to bulb, which I will separate to another spot, and designate for spring salads.   Shoots are very tender and nice, and the different colors are pretty too.  Some of the 'spreading' looks like a growth stage to me, as much as a growth habit.   They look like they wanted or were ready to bulb but didn't quite manage it.

I went through and identified 20 plants with the largest shoots, about 1/2 cm diameter.  So these will be planted out as single starts in hopes to produce bulbs, but I will keep a few shoots of each and keep them as perennials in their own location.   I was interested to see that not all of them were the ones identified last year as tallest, but there are a few that scored on both measures, which might correlate with bulb size.