Breeding Brassica oleracea for winter greens

Started by reed, 2019-08-26, 09:25:14 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

reed

I'v mentioned my interest in this before and have made previous attempts that failed miserably for the most part although I do have a small amount of my own seed from a cabbage, kale, Brussels sprout mix.

I also have a very large amount of other seed, cabbage, kohlrabi, Brussels sprout, broccoli cauliflower, collards and so on from commercial sources as well as a number of grexes and  mixed seed from trades. A lot of this seed is a few years old so I'm going to do a mass planting in the next day or so of all of it. I'm just going to mix it up and broadcast over the entire garden. Some areas have been prepped like a seed bed but others are still maturing other crops. I'll put more precious seed such as the one cross I mentioned in the beds bu the rest is just going be scattered to the wind over the whole area.

Goal, along with maybe some nice greens this fall and winter is to try to get something to survive to resume growing next year and make seed. I don't care what and I don't care what it crosses with. I haven't had good luck in the past with getting seed from any of these crops nor with any of the overwintering, except kale and the biggest goal and most important trait is overwintering.

I don't care if any successful seed yields something completely unrecognizable in the traditional sense.  Round balls of cabbage, kohlrabi roots, broccoli heads, I don't care if it has them or not. I don't care what it has, all I want is leaves, stalks, flower clusters, or seed pods that taste like Brassica oleracea and that can reliably overwinter and seed.

I want that so I can grow fresh food during the cooler wetter weather of fall and at least early winter and also importantly, in temps cold enough to discourage if not freeze cabbage worms to death.

Like said I'v tried and failed at this before but since some of seed is getting old and pretty much none of these crops do especially well for me if planted in spring because of weather and worms, I'm going all in this time. Planting many thousands of seed of many varieties I'm hopeful I'll get some success this time.

Raymondo

A worthy goal. Good luck with it. I've done something like it though I'm sure it's not as cold here. Broccolis, cabbages and kales seem to overwinter the best here in the open garden. At least, that's what ended up in the mix come spring. I dropped this project a few years back because we couldn't sell the mixed leaves. People just want a relatively uniform looking bunch of kale.
Ray
Mildly acidic clay loam over clay to varying depths; temperate climate modified by altitude (1000m); avg rainfall 780mm; usually wet summers and dry winters.

reed

I have on rare occasions had cabbage and Brussels sprouts overwinter to flower the next year but kale is by far the most reliable. One time I had broccoli planted in spring that never flowered and lived overwinter. That was before I was interested in breeding and I never kept it, a major screw up cause it has never happened again.

I doubt what I'm hoping for would ever be much use as a market crop but that's OK. Still it would be pretty neat if it eventually settled into something fairly uniform. Reliably producing greens in the cool/cold weather is the biggest goal, and of course seeds. 


reed

Got a nice bunch of sprouts coming up all around the garden. Mostly in the prepped areas cause I'v been watering them. Germination is way higher than I expected since much of the seed was old. The rest is just being left to sprout on it's own later.

reed

Haven't checked in and reported on this topic for a awhile. My cabbage/brussels sprout/collards/kale and so on patch is doing way better than I ever though it would. This the third, maybe fourth time I have tried this and never had much luck before but this year I have, as of now at least twenty five plants that have survived temps of around zero F, several times. Most are a little tired looking right now but definitely have survived the worst of it as I don't expect any more really cold weather.

The last round of cold was accompanied by a nice snow blanket so I imagine that helped some but I think the biggest difference between this and previous tries is I started them sooner than I had before. This time I think it was late August when I planted so they had time to get bigger before the cold hit. Now, I wonder what they will do when growth resumes. I hope that even though they never reached a mature size that they will go ahead and bloom. I hope they will mix up and give me a good amount of seed to move on with.

My kale is already winter hardy and varied so I'm not worried about it but we don't like kale all that much. I never expected such good results from the others but since I have a nice selection I'm thinking I might leave the kale out of my crossed up mix this year as I'd rather have a winter hardy population of just the others.

I think I read some where that this species of plants is an obligate out crosser, that a plant can't pollinate itself. Does anyone know for sure if that is the case?

Another question, seems like I have read it is possible to harvest a cabbage head, leaving lots of big leaves on the stalk and the plants will go ahead and grow bloom stalks. Is that true? Cause if so, assuming these plants make heads I can have my seeds and cabbage too. Also anxious to see what the Brussels sprouts do too.

I know this is completely out of the norm on how these plants are normally grown but I figure if I can get my initial crop of seeds from winter survivor plants I can go on and see what comes out form them. I would love to have them just grow sort of wild like the kale does. What ever kind of heads, sprouts or what ever they make is fine with me. I like the leaves and stalks of these plants as much as anything else.

Also fine with it and might even encourage them developing into an annual crop, I might try to mix in some broccoli to help that along.

Diane Whitehead


When I cut a cabbage head, I cut right under the head and the stalk then puts out several smaller cabbages. I don't leave any leaves on the stalk.

Overwintering cauliflowers produce heads in spring and have done so for five or more years for me.  You just have to make sure you have them planted in a perennial section of the garden which isn't going to get dug over each year.
Victoria, British Columbia, Canada
cool mediterranean climate  warm dry summers, mild wet winters,  70 cm rain,   sandy soil

Ferdzy

Kale is, I agree, very reliable for overwintering. I also agree we don't love it. I'll be growing some this year for the first time in 5 years and it's mostly because I'm impressed by how pretty the leaves are (Bear Necessities. Hope it doesn't attract bears.)

Cabbage and Brussels sprouts have been the next best for overwintering. It does depend on the variety of cabbage to some degree.

I have rarely had broccoli overwintered, but sometimes. Cauliflower overwintered exactly once. It was the variety Wallaby, sent to me by Diane. That was last spring. When I moved them to a spot where they wouldn't be in the way, they all promptly died. I intend to try again this year. I'd like to get my hands on some more Wallaby seed, but it looks like it comes from South Africa and South Africa only (other than Diane - Thanks again!)

The main factors for overwintering appear to be good snow cover and non-fluctuating temperatures. In other words, it can get quite cold, but as long as you have some snow and no freeze-thaw cycle your plants will do much better than if with less snow and periods of freezing and thawing.

I've gone out in March more years than I like and looked at various plants, ornamental and edible, and been relieved to see they survived the winter, and then by the end of April 80% of these iffy plants are generally dead. I'm terrible about covering things; I'm sure they would do better if I did.

Diane Whitehead

#7
Jennifer,

I've just checked on Wallaby, and it is just an ordinary kind, 80 days to maturity in the fall.  I don't know why I sent it to you to overwinter.

I have seeds of these overwintering cauliflowers:
Aalsmeer
Mallorquinas - from a collector in Mallorca - off the coast of Spain
North Foreland  F1
Purple Cape
Walcheren Winter 5
Winter Roscoff

I have never had success with ordinary cauliflowers.
Victoria, British Columbia, Canada
cool mediterranean climate  warm dry summers, mild wet winters,  70 cm rain,   sandy soil

Ferdzy

Diane, that might be the only overwintering cauliflower that you sent me. You sent me some crosses from Spain; none of the other names look familiar. We didn't get cauliflowers from anything we planted last year; there were a lot of problems in the garden in general and brassicas continue to hate our soil.

In midsummer we planted an assortment of cauliflowers in a side bed where they can stay all year, assuming they survive this winter. We covered them with pop bottles. I planted some Wallaby in with these, but I don't think they had a good survival rate and I am not sure how many made it into the winter.

So far, this seems like a good winter for possible survival. Temps have been steady and snow cover has been consistent. Of course as I noted earlier, it's the end of March/beginning of April that tends to be the deciding factor.

I still have about 20 Wallaby seeds; I guess I will try planting them this summer again, depending on how survival goes.

Diane Whitehead

Wallaby and Purple Cape are from South Africa.  South Africa has many very different climates - I still remember the minus 8 celsius night I froze, when the next day was plus 20. I don't know whether they grow cauliflowers there (I was looking at wildflowers).  However, Purple Cape might be a good one for you to try.

All the others are from coastal areas in Europe - more like my conditions here.
Victoria, British Columbia, Canada
cool mediterranean climate  warm dry summers, mild wet winters,  70 cm rain,   sandy soil

reed

#10
I have never had much luck at all with cauliflower, I didn't even consider including it in my mix. Yep, the temperature fluctuations are the culprit. More and more we have longer and longer periods barely below freezing but always punctuated with brief periods of very cold and usually without snow. This year the first cold spell we had was right about 0 F for couple of nights and no snow. I was surprised at how many survived that. The second spell lasted about a week and a half, just as cold but there was nice snow cover so fingers crossed I got by with it this time.

I am worried on what to do with them, would like to transplant to a seed maturing bed but afraid they might croak. Another plan is to leave them be and plant early maturing beans or cowpeas among them. Maybe the beans and the brassica seed would mature about the same time and then I could plant a late crop in the spot.

Still not out of the wood though on their survival, it's warming up into the 60s F now, they should either start growing or croak pretty soon. Fingers crossed again we don't get another bad cold spell, but can't rule it out. They have shown they are pretty tuff already but I might cover them up if another cold snap threatens.

Ferdzy

Reed, I forgot to mention that I got some kale sprouts (Br sprouts x kale) in a trade a few years back. I then let them back cross with Brussels sprouts. I was hoping to get basically a hardier Brussels sprout, at the expense of looser heads, but a fair trade-off to my mind. I'd say it was heading slowly in the right direction. However, last year we tried Early Half Tall Brussels sprouts, which we got from Adaptive seeds. They did better than any other Brussels sprout has done for us, and we've tried a lot. In addition to climate woes, our soil is sorely lacking in some minerals, and generally sandy and acidic - brassicas barely tolerate it in general.

We pulled out all the other Brussels sprouts plants in the fall and we will see if the stumps overwinter and flower. I'm hoping so.

Steph S

Reed:  "I hope that even though they never reached a mature size that they will go ahead and bloom. I hope they will mix up and give me a good amount of seed to move on with. "
I think you can be certain they will bolt once they get growing temperatures.  The downside of smaller (younger) plants is that they do tend to bolt before they get big enough to produce the kind of seed crop you'd get from a mature plant.  But you should get perfectly good seeds, just not as many.
Same goes for plants like the cabbage which you decide to harvest and then let bolt afterwards.  You will get seeds enough to have something to replant but not a huge seed crop like you would have with a full size plant with leader intact devoted to making seed.
Glad to hear your project is going well!  Hope they make it through spring.

 

reed

Thanks Steph, that sound very encouraging. I was out looking them over today and several look very good. Dangerous time right now though. If it stays warm no problem but they look to be waking up and putting on a little growth. If another cold spell hit them now it could be bad. I put some sticks around them so it will be easy to toss on some covers if need be.

I had read that savoy types were the most cold tolerant and that seems to be true but some of the red ones look really good too. Most of the cabbages have small loose heads. A couple of the savoy do not. Instead they are hugging the ground in good sized rosettes, like big wrinkled, bluish colored dandelions and appear not to even have noticed the cold. The big outer leaves are delicious, but a bit chewy.

Steph S

Ground hugging rosette certainly sounds like a great pheno for winter survival.   :)  It's always the aboveground stalks that seem hardy and put forth promising sprouts which then don't survive the punishment of spring.  ::)   The last one I lost this way was a perennial arugula.  It had developed a big branched stalk when it went to seed.  In hindsight i think I should have cut that back to the ground at the end of season, maybe possible to get it back into 'rosette' mode?   Would be worth a try.