Breeding Brassica oleracea for winter greens

Started by reed, 2019-08-26, 09:25:14 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

reed

#45
Here is a picture of what they make to eat. This harvest was after flowering started but before the worms arrived this year. I didn't know at the time how many shoots a single plant would make or that harvesting just encourages more. I think harvest can start almost immediately on when growth resumes, even while frost or even freeze is still happening. Plants were pretty good sized already this year when a late hard freeze happened in March but it didn't hurt them at all.

I though I might get winter greens from this project but instead got abundance of these (what ever you call it) starting about February lasting in to May. No worms, no slugs, no bugs at all. They snap off the plant right at the point the tender part ends, kind of like asparagus and you have to be careful cooking them. A full minute in steam is overcooked, their best dropped in a dish at the last second or stirred around in some hot butter after the heat is turned off. Or just graze on them straight from the plant.

Kadence Luneman

Reed did you end up doing anything further with this project or the seed you collected? I'm east of you and it was interesting to read about what winter survival you had. Brassicas are in my many project ideas. The unreliable winter conditions will definitely make any regular open garden overwinter survival difficult.

reed

#47
Quote from: Kadence Luneman on 2022-07-28, 02:41:54 AM
Reed did you end up doing anything further with this project or the seed you collected? I'm east of you and it was interesting to read about what winter survival you had. Brassicas are in my many project ideas. The unreliable winter conditions will definitely make any regular open garden overwinter survival difficult.
Yes, this project is ongoing and doing pretty well, better than I expected in fact. I got an 8-oz bottle of seed in late spring, early summer of 2021. I planted some of that seed in fall of 2021 but later than the year before, so plants were smaller as they went into winter. More than 90% of the smaller plants were winter killed but I still had a few live through to make seed this summer. I actually take that as a good thing since it helped establish a proper planting time for the crop which is I think right about now. (early to mid-August)

So, I have spot where some early beans are drying down and in next few days will be sowing seed from both years. It has gone so well that I think next year I can start selecting pretty heavily for the best tasting plants. There are no bad tasting plants, but some are just a little better.

It appears that in my climate brassica oleracea is an annual not a bi-annual. It does require the cold period to bloom but its entire life cycle runs from late-July / early-August with harvest period (depending on weather) from early March through May.

The whole tops of the plants are the harvest, flower clusters, young leaves and stems. It seems like the stems though are the bulk of it. Anything roughly up to the size of a pencil or sometimes a little bigger, snaps off easily right at the spot where it's good to eat, a lot like asparagus does. They can be lightly steamed or chopped up into little chunks and warmed up in a little bit of butter or sliced up and added to a salad raw.

Planted in summer the plants are subject to the cabbage worms before frost, but it doesn't hurt them too much. After harvest the next year the worms are back on the leaves but don't hurt the seeds. There are no worms at all during the harvest period.

I'm hopeful that with further selection and adaptation the harvest can be extended even farther back into winter, maybe eventually starting in February or even during any warm spell over winter.



UnicornEmily

#48
I'm stoked that this is working well for you, because I've been hoping to do the very same thing.  If it works for you in zone 6a with seesaw weather, hopefully it'll work well for me in zone 7b with a lot of snow cover!

Right now, I have five brussels sprouts plants out in the garden.  I'm hoping they'll perennialize, but I can live with it if they only survive one season and produce seeds.  (I'll be bummed if they die.)  I also have a few smallish cabbage and broccoli plants.  All but one were transplants.  That one grew in spring from a seed I planted last year, not one of the hundreds I planted this year.  So . . . maybe a bunch more will sprout for me in spring?  I would like that.

Oh, and I may have twelve kohlrabis.  My next door neighbor ripped them out of her garden to throw them away because they'd gotten too big to be tasty, and I was like, "Can I have those?" and happily planted them in mine.  If they survive having been ripped out of the ground and thrown into a garbage pile, and then rescued a day later, only to be hit by the first snow the next day, maybe they'll give me seeds next year.  ;)

I planted something like 500 brassica seeds in June, another 500 in July, and another 500 in August.  None of them have come up yet.  Not one single one.  I added about 1,000 more a few days ago, in the wistful hope that this time some might grow.

Maybe they'll all germinate in the spring.  That would be okay.

I wonder if midsummer is the wrong time of year for me to plant brassicas.  The optimal temperature for germination of brassica seeds is supposed to be between 50-85 degrees F, and we don't get temperatures that low until . . . October.  Yeah.  It's 90-100 degrees during the day and 60-80 degrees at night here for pretty much all of May, June, July, and August.

I'm really hoping I can have a successful winter garden filled with overwintering brassicas with leaves I can harvest, and probably lots of lettuces and peas to munch, too.  And Jerusalem artichokes I can dig when the ground isn't frozen solid.  But let's not kid ourselves!  I mostly want brassicas.

Hey, all three species of brassica: please perennialize and self-sow and turn into delicious, feral weeds all over my garden!  Please!  :D




UnicornEmily

#49
In happy news, I have sprouts now!  Tiny brassica sprouts in all of my garden beds!  Yay!

In . . . November.  Just in time for a deluge of rain, snow, and seesawing temperatures that freeze at night and not during the day.  That sounds ideal for brand new plants.  ;)

I way oversowed on purpose, in an attempt to make sure some survive the winter, so I won't thin them at all.  I'll let the weather thin out anything that's too weak to live here.  Or, in the best case scenario, they'll all thrive and I'll have to thin some by eating them for dinner in December and January.  I sure wouldn't mind that idea!

UnicornEmily

By the way, should I harvest the sprouts off my brussels sprouts over the winter, or should I leave them intact if I want more flowers in spring?  If harvesting the sprouts won't diminish the number of flowers, I'd love to eat the sprouts over the winter (because yum).  But if it's best to leave the tall brussels sprouts plants intact, I will.