Direct Seeded Tomato Project

Started by William Schlegel, 2018-10-13, 09:10:08 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Adrian

Hy william,
At placements or we expand compost we have often volunteers tomato plants and they are often more strong than plants sow at home.

William Schlegel

Direct seeding tomatoes has worked well for me now for 6 years. Volunteers have been a little more sporadic, but I think perhaps now they are becoming more reliable. Though I also thought that might be the case a few years ago!
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Cathy A

The challenge I've had with direct-seeded volunteers is that if they fruit at all, it's at the very end of the season. It might work for me if the varieties were very early, like Sweet Cherriette or Sub-Arctic Plenty.

William Schlegel

It was volunteers doing that in 2016 that inspired me. Then it wasn't that hard here in zone 6A western Montana. It's definitely a later crop though.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Adrian

#79
 Two volunteers  are give mature fruits at this moment for me:san marzano lungo and marmande.
On san marzano lungo all the fruits get mature in same time.Unfortunately as is grow with the melons i think that he has a potasium deficiency.it too late for put fertiliser at the maturation of the fruits?
costoluto and andine cornue volunteers have fruits in formation at this moment.

I have never tryed bloody butcher as volunteer he has the earliness but i din't know if he is sufficiently vigorous for have a fast grow and if he is sufficiently tolerant at the bads conditions.Her grow look like start slowly.

At a period i was grow a tomato with some characteristics of solanum cheesmannii as volunteer.The fruit was small, long and orange.A small sign on some plants the sepals was closed on the fruit.

William Schlegel

#80
Getting fruit from my direct seeded and volunteers now. From now till frost will be the maximum tomato harvest as the short season transplants continue to produce, the long season transplants finally bear fruit, and the direct seeded come into production more and more.

Edit: just found aome fruits / seed for a couple that segregated out in 2019 and I seed saved then and then just this year decided to add back into the direct seeded seed mix. A super pale yellow and a yellow / blue tiger striped tomato.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Kadence Luneman

Any thoughts on the direct seeded tomatoes  for 2022 to wrap it up? I was curious how the harvest was being closer to your expected frost date.

I have 19 seeds from you for Panamorous Direct Seeded 2022. I am considering putting them over in the field with the squash. Depends on timing probably.


William Schlegel

#82
If you wish to keep direct seeding them, I advise you to plant those 19 seeds around one foot a part in soil where there isn't too much perennial grass where you can weed around them. Plant them as early as 20 days before your last expected frost right up to your last expected frost or to your last actual frost if you get a late one. They are descended from seeds Joseph direct seeded in 2021.

I had two direct seeded areas in 2022 and a couple patches of volunteers.

There was a section of volunteer exserted tiger in the corn near the panamorous direct seeded area. These were ok but the colors and stripes weren't great- that could be that they included a few F1's. None of the other genetics from the 2021 mix direct seeded there were apparent, but ET is definitely a tomato of my garden with a lot of years of direct seeding.

There were some volunteers in the SW garden in my sorghum which I weeded out to protect The One x Mission Mountain block then I transplanted them into the main garden at the end of the direct seeded row where they didn't end up producing in poor soil. Exserted Orange produced a couple volunteers one of which even bloomed but I weeded them out as that was my isolation garden for "The One".

The panamorous direct seeded project did ok. Flavor wise I thought I had some rejects then came back with some taste testers and we failed to re-detect a true reject plant. It showed a lot of Brad characteristics though notably not potato leaf.

The other direct seeded row which was sort of a remix of some of the highlights from 2019 plus some promiscuous project seed including a fun "Salmon" plant from 2021 was crowded heavily on the south end by volunteers from 2021 when it was a promiscuous project row. I got some seed packets back from it but never did a big collection of it. It was also notable because if seedlings are too thick, they outcompete each other. I also had a small patch like that in 2021 where I just seeded some seed too thick to finish off a direct seeding mix. Another element of note to it is that it was attacked heavily by Colorado potato beetles as it is mixed with their preferred host an annual nightshade. I suspect their could be a little arthropod resistance there.

In 2023 I hope to use that area to test arthropod resistance genetics so the arthropod resistance project will switch gardens.

I won't have my usual capacity for growing lots of tomato seedlings in 2023. I may grow just 72 pots of tomatoes plus a few trays looking for regular leaf seedlings from crossing blocks. Therefore, I may direct seed more, or direct seeding may be a more important part of the mix in 2023.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

reed

I might try direct seeding tomatoes. I've never done it before because all my life starting tomatoes for transplant was just how we did it. I think a long time ago it was sort of a competition to see who could get the first tomato of the season.

I have jillions of volunteers, so I'll have to be careful not to get the ones I planted mixed up with the ones I didn't. And I wonder, will a stored seed, direct planted sprout and grow the same as one that laid in the ground all winter.

One reason that maybe I should give it a try is I've noticed that when I set out a tomato, say six inches tall and a volunteer sprouts nearby it isn't long till the volunteer catches up in size.  Maybe starting tomatoes to transplant is just a completely unnecessary springtime ritual.

Cathy A

Quote from: reed on 2023-01-12, 03:55:08 AMI think a long time ago it was sort of a competition to see who could get the first tomato of the season.

One reason that maybe I should give it a try is I've noticed that when I set out a tomato, say six inches tall and a volunteer sprouts nearby it isn't long till the volunteer catches up in size.  Maybe starting tomatoes to transplant is just a completely unnecessary springtime ritual.

Well, the first tomato of the season is probably the one you will enjoy the most that season!  One of my tomato breeding goals is to get a reasonable supply of fresh eating tomatoes earlier.

I agree that if the process of starting the transplant isn't done under nearly ideal conditions, plants started from seed could potentially catch up under good growing conditions. In some years, I have started plants from seed, transplanted them out when very small, and had them produce almost nothing. Other transplants that were much farther along when transplanted grew rapidly, and produce a lot of tomatoes.

To get the benefit of transplants in short-season climates, you really need your transplants to be rock-solid at the time of transplanting.

William Schlegel

I find that stored seeds direct seeded and volunteer seeds sprout about the same.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

reed

Quote from: William Schlegel on 2023-01-12, 06:29:12 PMI find that stored seeds direct seeded and volunteer seeds sprout about the same.
That's good to know, I may give it a try this year, but start some for transplant as well, for insurance. I'll do them all at the same time, put some in the cold frame and some in the ground. Those in the cold frame will sprout first I'm sure but if the others do just as well in the end, then I'll know I can skip the transplant step in the future.

Still will need the cold frame of course, for some to sell. People like and will pay more per, for bigger plants, even if they are really no better. Who am I to argue?

William Schlegel

In my garden I've discovered a few details that seem important. You can plant pretty closely in a row and still get good production up to a point. Last year I had some leftover seed at the end and instead of putting it away I seeded it really thickly on a small portion of a row. That small portion of the row failed badly because it exceeded some limit of density after which they compete too much with each other. Same thing happened this year when the volunteers came up too thick in one of the direct seeded rows where I had direct seeded the year before. I eventually got a few, but it would have been better thinner. I reckon you could thin down to one every square foot or so in a grid, or one every six inches along a row and be fine. You could even rip out a few from a thick part and stick them back in somewhere they didn't come up good and probably get some fruit.

I do think the direct seeded ones start producing later. I think the only year I was really disappointed was 2018 the second year I did it. I planted all the seeds of Blue Ambrosia looking for hybrids. I had gotten some seed back when it froze, but if it could have waited a few weeks I would have had a much better harvest.

Frost always ends my year though- never disease. I reckon if disease ends your year, it might cut things too short for direct seeding.

Volunteering has been a little inconsistent. I'm sort of hopeful that the volunteers from 2021 that came back in 2022 might be a sign that Joseph's promiscuous project will produce better volunteering results. However, it is also very possible that certain soil properties might make one spot better for volunteering than others and the year might matter too.

Also, just because something volunteers well one year, doesn't always mean it will keep coming back. Amurski Tigr volunteered ok in 2017 but didn't come back in 2018. One patch of 2018's volunteered in 2019 but most of the field did not come back on its own. So until something starts coming back year after year, I don't think I'll ever be able to rely on volunteers alone.

Germinating rain might be a part of it. A one-inch storm or equivalent irrigation right around the last date of frost will really help things germinate. A one-inch storm is very important for wildflowers down in California to get going. Seems to work with tomato seed too.

There is a book https://www.amazon.com/Ruth-Stout-No-Work-Garden-Book/dp/1927458366/ by Ruth Stout and Richard Clemence and one of the stories in it Richard explains how he direct seeded tomatoes. He always used the now old heirloom variety Ponderosa https://victoryseeds.com/products/ponderosa-tomato and he would bury a few tomatoes next to a wood stake in his mulch. Then in the spring dig up those seeds, pull back the mulch along a row to expose the soil, seed them, let the plants grow, thin or whatever, and then as they got big enough, pull the mulch back in around them. I haven't tried it, but it does seem interesting that the tomato seed can just be stored in the garden like that.

In my garden the old tomatoes rot partially and often can be found as little mummified balls in the spring. If I dig into them with my fingernails I can usually find and extract seeds sometimes a bit dried out and sometimes nicely moist depending on if the clump of seeds had good soil moisture contact or was up on a little dry spot. A few years ago, I temporarily lost my Payette seed and because the year before I had grown it in an isolation field I just walked over and grabbed a few tomato mummies, opened them up and used it to plant with- in a pot. Still, I think the principle is sound. I'm sure tomatoes decompose better with more water and warmth but as long as there are some seeds around or you mark a spot where you buried them, you should be able to find and replant them.

We had a lot come back from compost a couple years ago also.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

reed

I don't think disease has ever really ended my tomato season, but I think it and weather work together to reduce the daily harvest. I don't really care much at that point as we do all of our canning from the first flush of fruiting. I always leave a few to harvest mostly as green tomatoes which we like fried and harvest them up until frost, but I often end a lot of them myself to make room to plant something else after the canning is done.

I get tons of those mummies on the cherry types, sometimes if left alone they will hang on the vine all winter. Before they freeze/thaw and dry/rehydrate, too many times they are pretty tasty. After a while though, I guess they ferment or rot inside, not so good after that.

William Schlegel

Sounds like a good possibility!
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days