F1s for the People! 2026

Started by Tim DH, 2026-01-05, 11:34:03 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Tim DH

As mentioned further up this thread. My main focus this year is recreating Craig's Gift F1.
As a sort of insurance policy, I got both parents from two different sources.
One of the supposed Lillian's Yellows didn't even get to planting out since it wasn't potato leaved.
(The same thing happened with one of the Pruden's Purples.)
Now, as the fruit ripens, one of the Cherokee Purples is also off type. Very irritating, I'd used pollen from that plant in quite a few crosses and they'll all be useless.

Still, all is not lost, I have one fruit on a plant I believe to be Lillian's Yellow, which was pollinated by a plant I believe to be Cherokee Purple. ... Here's hoping it has plenty of seed in!

A (small) Cherokee Purple on the left and an imposter on the right.P8030002_edited.jpg

Roland

I got the same, a regluar leave Lillians Yellow  :-\
Netherlands

William Schlegel

#17
That's very upsetting about the varieties not being kept true to type.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

Tim DH

Happy Days!
The first fruit of what I believe to be Lillian's Yellow. Hopefully pollinated by what I believe to be Cherokee Purple!!

Aware of Roland's warning (back in 2023) that Lillian's Yellow is not particularly seedy, I've attempted the cross twice and the other fruit is also fattening up.

SO: I should have plenty of Craig's Gift F1 seed. I'll check that both lots ARE hybrid, by doing a seedling leaf test in the Autumn. Since Lillian's is potato leaf and Cherokee Purple is regular leaf, if the seedlings are regular it will prove they are hybrid.

Tim DH

Adrian

#19
Some variety low seedy can be very seedy with crossed fruits.
The fruits of andine cornue contains at normal time between 30 and 50 seeds by fruits.
I have found 140 seeds in the crossed fruit of andine cornue between canestrino di lucca x andine cornue.
Some varietys can giving the priority at the crossed fruit.

For my cross with pineaple, The crossed fruit was the more small of the bunch.

Tim DH

Getting to the exciting part of the season now, evaluating the new F1s.

These little fellows are SunvivaXTasteofParadiseF1 (I was trialling this outdoors as hopefully Blight resistant, however we haven't seen any Blight for a couple of years!) This is a good example of why I've got interested in truss architecture. What I suspect is that, because the fruit set is placing so little demand on the plant, the hybrid vigour is being expressed as excessive vegetative growth.

SunvXToP.jpg

For comparison, at the other end of the spectrum, a determinate F1  (LatahXPolarStar) I got 6kg from one plant of this cultivar last year and here it goes again! I think here the balance might have swung the other way, not enough vegetative growth! The focus of next year's F1 project will probably be creating more early outdoor determinates.

PSXLat.jpg

Tim DH

I've made a start on crunching the numbers for this year. Greenhouse results first.

I have a new favourite hybrid cherry. Sunrise Bumblebee x Iva's Red Berry produces well flavoured fruit of around 16g each. It was a healthy plant yielding 3.46kg. Not much splitting.

Another hybrid of Iva's Red Berry, this one with Barry's Crazy Cherry, also produced well flavoured fruit, but they were a bit small (9g) and more prone to splitting. (yield 2.94kg)
Two other hybrids with Barry's Crazy Cherry had a disappointing flavour, so I'm guessing that the taste in this hybrid came mostly from Iva's Red Berry

My previous favourite hybrid cherry, Rosella x Brandy Wine Cherry, produced 2.25kg. The fruit are a bit big for a cherry (29g) They are prone to splitting and also had some greenback.

SO: Next year my hybrid cherrys will be:
Sunrise Bumblebee x Iva's Red Berry...  This year's favourite
Rosella x Brandywine Cherry...  Last year's favourite
Rosella x Iva's Red Berry... Cross made in 2025 but not yet trialled.

My parent pool for creating new F1s this year was Cherokee Purple, Lillian's Yellow, Pruden's Purple, Uluru Ochre, Goat's Tit, Imur Prior Beta, Heart of Ashgabat and Rebel Starfighter Prime. Crosses made early in the season were generally successful, those made later in the year were generally unsuccessful! I have seed for ten novel hybrids, and space to trial five next year. ....

Apart from that I remade PotemkinF1 four times (Imur Prior Beta x Latah), so I'll be getting a few friends to trial that next year.

Steph S

Nice work Tim!

I wanted to update you that I may have been unfair with my F1 taste rating, due to general boredom with red tomatoes.   I had a few runts left to ripen off the vine at the end of season, and tossed them on top of a pizza the other night - I was startled at how good they were.
Overall I was really impressed with how regular and manageable and productive the F1 turned out to be, so I am seeing what you're saying.
I have a trio of F1s to try side by side next season.  Rodney X Mazarini,  JollyBoat F4 X Mazarini, and JollyBoat F4 X Rose.   Jolly Boat is not stable of course, but it is a pink black, which means I can compare taste results for pink x pink vs red x pink.  So it will be a bit of fun.

Tim DH

Hi Steph,
   I'm all for a bit of fun. ... But using an F4 as a parent might give you headaches further down the line! What happens if you really like the F1? You can't guarantee that the remaining seeds will produce the same result in future years. Conversely what if the F1 is a dud? That doesn't mean that the rest of the seed will produce duds.

        I have considered raising variable F1s. For example crossing Mountain Magic F1 with Crimson Crush F1 would give a diverse population of plants. It might suit someone who has a field to plant and doesn't want to shell out on commercially produced F1s!

Tim DH

Here is my round-up of outdoor results. ....

Last year one of the Determinate x Determinate hybrids turned out to be Indeterminate AND very productive. So I decided to try growing one of the other Indeterminate hybrids in a cage (as if it were a determinate) just to see if I liked it. The variety I chose for this was PotemkinF1. At both outdoor sites the cage grown plant out produced the cordon grown plant by about double. (Average 8.27kg v 4.12kg) However I don't think the fruit quality was as good from the cage grown plants. Maybe a solution would be to limit the cage grown plants to, say, four leaders. But I'm not sure I want to start pruning cage grown plants.

The original Det x Det hybrid which set off this train of thought is Polar Star x Forest Fire. This year I tried growing it both as a cage and a cordon. Once again the cages easily outpaced the cordons. One cage produced 11.78kg of fruit! However I'm not a fan of this variety. The fruit is often misshapen, the flesh to pip ratio is low and the leaves are not particularly healthy. I'm thinking of treating myself to a 'Tomato Press' for Christmas, which may address the first two criticisms.

As noted above, I don't like growing Indeterminates in cages, so next year I will try raising some new early determinate hybrids to challenge the two above.

The best Determinate Hybrid I've made so far is Latah x Urbikany, which averaged 8.11kg this year. It easily out produced Latah (average 1,926kg). Sadly this F1 also suffers from misshapen fruit and a poor flesh to pip ratio.

For the third year in a row Late Blight has not been a problem here on outdoor tomatoes. However I still intend to include Blight resistance in selecting the out door hybrid parents, just in case.