semi-determinate habit and its genetic basis

Started by joe, 2025-09-17, 12:56:49 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

joe

I have had a hunch for a while that semi-determinate habit could be advantageous trait for practical reasons (space, ease of trellising with a simple stake an weave system, and consolidated ripening).

I came across this paper when looking into the genetic basis for this trait, and found it very interesting in regards to other advantages I had not considered http://www.lcb.esalq.usp.br/publications/articles/2015/2015jpfv177n1p11-19.pdf

Some conclusions for the paper:

- Indeterminate habit plants have a higher brix then determinate habit. I guess this is kind of obvious when you think about it as they have a higher foliage to fruit ratio, and it explains why there are few if any determinate habit varieties which can match the flavor of the many high quality indeterminate varieties on the market.

- Semi-determinate habit plants have higher brix then determinate habit plants as well. In addition they by far have the highest brix to yield ratio. In other words they strike a balance between yield and brix due to their balanced growth habit.

- Semi-determinate habit plants have the best Water-use efficiency. "determined as g of fruit dry mass
produced per kg of water transpired over a period"

I'm interested in working on a paste tomato with a semi-determinate habit. I have grown determinate paste tomatoes for years. I am tired of how wimpy the plants can be, and how lacking they can be as far as flavor when compared with something like a san marzano (which has it's own issues for me which make it not as practical as a roma type for example).

I also found this paper on the genetics of semi-determinate habit. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/279674718_Genetics_of_Semideterminate_Growth_Habit_in_Tomato

Basically I am confused, as there seem to be many sources for this trait. And also a general misuse of the term "semi-determinate", as it is also applied to many varieties which are indeterminate but have a sort internode length or a growth habit that puts it in between a determinate and an indeterminate (an indeterminate with a more reproductive leaning rather then vegetative?).

The first paper indicates that semi-determinate habit can come from two sources
1. "sft Heterozygous (sft/+) and sp/sp"
2. "Well (Water economy locus in Lycopersicon)"

The other paper indicates a single recessive gene "sdt" along with sp/sp.

Does anyone have experience in this area or additional resources?


William Schlegel

https://www.adaptiveseeds.com/seed-tag/semi-determinate-tomatoes/

https://www.fruitionseeds.com/shop/product-category/vegetables/tomatoes/semi-determinate/

Correctly or not some sellers are putting some iconic tomatoes in the semi determinate category.

Ten fingers of Naples, Stupice, and Ararat Flame, I've grown. I think I have an as yet unplanted packet of Sasha's Altai.

You may be on to something as there are some very well loved Pacific Northwest tomatoes on those lists.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

joe

#2
Yes there certainly are some great ones!

I think there is a difference between what the scientific community calls semi-determinate and what the seed companies label as semi-determinate. In these scientific papers they define it as a determinate tomato with delayed shoot termination. More leaf nodes before the terminal flower cluster. The seed companies basically use it as a bucket for anything that does not quite grow like an indeterminate, but is larger/more vigorous then a determinate.

I'm kind of more interested in improving a determinate paste tomato by adding the delayed terminal flower cluster trait. Not sure where I can find a source of this trait. I guess I need to grow out some of the tomatoes advertised as semi-determinate and see if they have a terminal flower cluster to know for sure.

joe

#3
William do you remember the growth habit of Ten fingers of Naples? Did terminate it's growth like a determinate plant would, or did it behave more like a indeterminate?

William Schlegel

It was a few years and thousands of tomato plants ago. I grew it quite badly in a dense row and like all the others it was very small and I didn't manage a cross with it and probably saved a few seeds.
Western Montana garden, glacial lake Missoula sediment lacustrian parent material and shallow 7" silty clay loam mollisoil topsoil sometimes with added sand in places. Zone 6A with 100 to 130 frost free days

joe

Some more research turns up yet another definition which also makes sense.

This publication from Organic Seed Alliance defines a semi-determinate as indeterminate with two leaf nodes between inflorescences.

This also makes total sense, as it would lean the plant to have a lower leaf to fruit ratio compared to what they define as three leaf nodes for indeterminate. thus a middle ground between indeterminate and determinate. Probably there are also varieties that exist with a single leaf node between flower clusters like a determinate, but without terminal buds.

Between the combinations of leaf node to flower cluster ratios, self pruning behaviors, and internode lengths there is a crazy amount of diversity available and multiple ways to reach what is labeled as semi-determinate. Not surprising really!

I'll have to do a grow out next year to find some good parents for a vigorous, yet not TOO vigorous paste tomato with better fruit quality then the common determinates. It will be interesting to see how many of these growth controlling genes I can find by looking at the actual plants. It is basically impossible to categorize these things from the limited info online.

Steph S

There's definitely lots of growth habit variety among existing OP's.
You can get semi-determinate types (with the loose definition of not terminating but not having the three sets of leaves between clusters that indeterminates always do) from any cross between a determinate and an indeterminate, in my experience.
I do recall one semideterminate OP (whose name I've forgotten, it was a yellow tangerine) with exactly the two leaves between clusters and repeating indefinitely.
But I've also seen 'true determinates' that make an axillary shoot at the terminal tip and then go on to repeat their entire pattern from basal leaves through termination.  And then repeat that again ad infinitum, or more truly til resources or season runs out.
Not sure whether the SDT/single gene possibility is doing the repeats differently, without ever making a terminal tip.   

I have to say that the (medium sized, vigorous) determinates I've bred are very sweet fruited.  IDK whether the fruit to shoot ratio strictly limits sweetness as has been suggested.  Some recent crosses with larger fruit seem to have higher yield potential without loss of the sweetness and taste qualities.  Then again maybe I haven't focused on yield, and if I weighed non sweet determinates vs my own faves I would find them more productive...  it could be.
 

joe

Good stuff Steph.

Yes the initial study I linked is pretty limited. Definitely there should be avenues to breed determinate plants with high brix. They just studied one cultivar, and introgressed the genes for the other plant habits. If the general hypnosis is that fruit to leaf ratio is the limiting factor for high sugar then there are other knobs that can be used to increase brix in a determinate. limiting the number of fruits per cluster, more vegetative growth, longer DTM, larger leaf surface area etc.

I started down this rabbit hole because I really just want a bigger plant habit (without needing 8ft stakes etc..) and a longer more spread out harvest window for a high quality paste. I don't like canning, or managing a jungle of plants. So that is why a semi-determinate seems attractive to me. If brix could be improved as a result of a more vegetative habit that would be icing on top.

I saved seed from Paisano f1 this year to dip my toes into tomato breeding. I did a trial of a few varieties last year, and I thought Paisano was the best to use in the kitchen. It cooks down so quick, and produces somewhat larger fruits. The plants however are always kind of sad looking with plenty of foliar issues, spindly leafs, and small stature. It is one of those tomatoes that looks like it is fruit and nothing else. It kind of pumps out the fruit despite all of that and keeps on trucking on. I'm going to see if the f2s are promising and look at more vigorous parents to improve those aspects.

I'm wondering if this variety is going to be dropped as it has been out of stock for a while now. I figure having a shot at dehybridizing it seems useful at least.

Steph S

joe, you're definitely on the right track to start with something that has at least some of the traits you wanted, and go for tailoring a growth habit to your environment.
It's totally doable, just takes some patience and willingness to stir the pot by crossing in more parents with the missing traits for your perfect stack.

Since I didn't start any tomatoes this spring I ended up with a lineup of gifted plants from friends, oddly several of them were parent lines that I hadn't grown for years.  It was a useful reminder of why I started breeding in the first place.  At the moment I have a Black Cherry plant still lurking in the greenhouse, with literally yards of vine, at least ten feet of vine per pound or even half pound of cherries.
My growing environment in the greenhouse really promotes vegetative growth.  And may be why I've seen so many weird growth habits emerging.  The effects of environment on growth habit expression are very confounding, so much so that I gave up trying to track any kind of pure genetic basis for different cluster patterns and so on.  Even with plants that are completely stable and had consistent patterns of growth for years, you can still have an odd season that brings out variation for environmental reasons alone.
Maybe that's part of the reason that intermediate habits are so poorly defined.

joe

Thanks for the encouragement! I had a similar experience with black cherry in my greenhouse. Definitely a vigorous plant, mine eventually created multiple mega-clusters with 100s of cherries per cluster which ripened almost in unison. I frequently see cherries in the greenhouse send out new leaders from the ends of flower trusses and side shoots coming out of the ground around the plant which I can't say I see as often outdoors. The environment definitely effects their growth drastically.

Breeding a greenhouse specific variety is something I have considered for a project as well, but the space is kind of too precious to waste for me with potentially poor performing plants vs outside space. There are very few OP varieties marketed as "Greenhouse Tomatoes", and the hybrids breed specifically for that environment are very pricy. I have tried some of those greenhouse hybrids, and it is not a gimmick IMO. It was hitting the top of my 9ft tall hightunnel by the beginning of july, had little to no side shots the whole season, and was generally pretty disappointed that I wasn't feeding it nutrients constantly. Not sure I really want that as a grower and have not grown those again, but it seems like there would be a market for growers that don't want to shell out $2 or more a seed and need to maximize the space.