Potato onion flowering and seeds

Started by Cathy A, 2022-08-09, 09:05:07 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Cathy A

Potato onions normally propagate by cloning, seldom producing seeds. This makes it difficult to breed a better potato onion. On the other hand, when seeds do form, the resulting plants show great variety. There appears to be a lot of breeding potential locked up in the genetics, despite the uniformity of the clones.

My potato onions flowered on three plants this year. I am hoping they will produce seeds, but the stalks are dying back in the usual late summer pattern, and I fear the flowers may shrivel before forming actual seeds. We'll have to wait and see.

Has anyone here successfully produced potato onion seeds and propagated it for selection?

reed

I'm not 100% sure that what I have are real potato onions, but they readily make lots of seeds.

I also have walking onions and garlic, some of which both bloomed instead of making top sets this year. It looks like I have lots of seeds but in both the onions and the garlic, those I've dissected and examined under magnification are empty. There is nothing there except a little black shell. I'm going to plant them anyway in hopes there are a few that grow. 

Greenie DeS

Someone at the experimental farm network was doing a project on this. I got seeds from EFN and they're growing, too early to know if they'll set seed or not.

whwoz

Look up Green Mountain Potato Onion/ Kelly Winterton is someone who has had success with this

nathanp

#4
I have had potato onions flower and produce seed, though not this year.  It has been too dry.  Picture one here is of some of my potato onions in flower from 2021.  Picture two is the bulbs from the this year's seedlings out of those 2021 flowers.  My original seed source was Bill Whitson, who had mass crossed as many potato onion sources as he could get his hands on.  Green Mountain was in the mix, but tends to be rather uniform in color. 2/3 to 3/4 of what I have are yellow onions, with the remainder pink to red.  I had a single white onion bulb in 2020 but have since eliminated that from the genepool.

I had one seedling that produced a divided bulb, the remainder of them produced single bulbs as seedlings.  It is in year 2 when planted from bulbs that they should be expected to divide.

I believe the key to getting them to flower is to plant them in the fall.  The ones that overwinter have a much higher likelihood of flowering.  I saw this last year when I planted half in the fall and half in the spring.  I did lose some during the winter, but those that survived all flowered.  Those that were spring planted did not flower.

Here is a link to Bill's guide to growing them. 
https://www.cultivariable.com/instructions/root-crops/how-to-grow-potato-onion/

nathanp

Also, if the plants are dying back, you can cut the flower stalks and keep them in a vase or jar outdoors.  This will allow the flowers to remain alive for a few more weeks, and may allow more flowers to set viable seeds.  I have done this with both potato onions and garlic flowers successfully. 

I found potato onions rather easy to get to flower when fall planted.

Cathy A

I usually plant mine in the fall, which gives them a head start in spring despite my snowy Zone 4b climate.

I wasn't able to get any seeds out of the heads. I think the seed heads were a fake without actuall producing seeds. ;-)

nathanp

I did not get seeds this year either, but is probably the result of a drought and the plants all dying back in late June.